Appellate Division
Sohel Rana v The State and others
Criminal Appeal(A) 92/2023 · Decided 6 February 2024
The High Court Division had stayed proceedings in a criminal case pending before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Cumilla on an application under section 561A of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The appellant, then the Chief Judicial Magistrate, proceeded with the case despite knowing of the stay, fixing dates for charge hearing, pressing the accused, framing charge and fixing the case for evidence. The High Court Division found him guilty of contempt and sentenced him to 30 days' simple imprisonment and a fine of Tk. 5,000. On appeal, the Appellate Division found his conduct deliberate and contumacious, noting that he was an experienced officer and did not claim the order was unclear. However, he tendered an unconditional and unqualified apology, it was his first offence and he promised not to repeat such conduct. The Appellate Division accepted the apology, absolved him with a strong admonition and a warning, disposed of the appeal and set aside the High Court Division's judgment.
- Q1
Whether a Chief Judicial Magistrate who proceeded with a criminal case and framed charge in defiance of a High Court Division stay order was guilty of contempt.
- Q2
Whether, on his unconditional apology, the contemnor's conviction and sentence should stand.
- A subordinate judicial officer who, knowing of a High Court Division stay order, proceeds with the case and frames charge acts in wanton disregard and disobedience of that order, which is contumacious conduct.
- Where the contemnor does not claim the order was unclear or ambiguous, he cannot rely on any misunderstanding of it.
- The sanctity of judicial orders requires the Appellate Division to respond resolutely where a subordinate judge intentionally disobeys an order of the Supreme Court.
- On an unconditional and unqualified apology for a first offence, with a promise not to repeat it, the contemnor may be absolved with a stern admonition and warning, and the conviction set aside.
this Division delivers a stern admonishment to serve as both a reminder and a warning.
In the court’s own words.
Criminal Appeal(A) 92/2023, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 8 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
APPELLATE DIVISION
PRESENT:
Mr. Justice Obaidul Hassan, Chief Justice
Mr. Justice M. Enayetur Rahim
Mr. Justice Md. Ashfaqul Islam
Mr. Justice Abu Zafor Siddique
Mr. Justice Jahangir Hossain
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 92 OF 2023
2(From the Judgment and order dated 12.10.2023 Passed by High Court Division in Contempt Rule No. 53467 of 2023) Mr. Sohel Rana ….Appellant
3-Versus- The state and others ….Respondents For the Appellants : Mr. Probir Neogi, Senior Advocate
with Mr. Shah Monjurul Hoque,
Senior Advocate instructed by Ms.
Shahanara Begum, Advocate-on-
record
4For Respondent No. 1 : Mr. Mohammad Saiful Alam, AAG
(appearing with the leave of the
Court)
5For Respondent Nos. : Not represented 2-3 Date of Hearing : 05.12.2023 and 06.12.2023 Date of Judgment : 06.02.2024
JUDGMENT
6Md. Ashfaqul Islam, J: This criminal appeal is preferred against the judgment and order dated 12.10.2023 passed by the High Court Division in Contempt Rule No. 53467 of 2023 making the Rule absolute, convicting the appellant for Contempt of Court and thereby sentencing him to suffer simple imprisonment for 30 (thirty) days and to pay a fine of taka
5,000/- (five thousand) in default, to suffer simple imprisonment for 30(thirty) days more.
7Facts, in short, are that upon an application under Section 561A of the Code of Criminal Procedure the proceeding of Kotwali Police Station Case No. 87 dated 27.03.2017 corresponding to G.R No. 320 of 2017 (Kotwali), pending in the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Cumilla was challenged before the High Court Division. Upon hearing the High Court Division issued Rule and at the same time stayed all further proceedings of the aforesaid criminal case for a period of 06 (six) months. Subsequently, the order of stay was extended till disposal of the Rule.
8The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Cumilla, appellant herein defying the order of stay passed by the High Court Division proceeded with the said case and framed charge against the accused petitioners.
9After noting the aforementioned facts and finding the appellant's explanation unsatisfactory, the High Court Division proceeded to issue a contempt rule against him.
10The High Court Division found contemnor, Mr. Sohel Rana guilty of gross contempt of Court and made the Rule absolute by convicting and sentencing him as aforesaid.
11It is noted that knowing fully about the order of stay of the High Court Division the appellant proceeded with the aforesaid case pending before him, fixed dates, one after another, for charge hearing, took hajira (appearance) of the accused and gave undue pressure upon the accused to bring the result of the Rule pending before the High Court Division and lastly, framed charge against the accused petitioner and at the same time declared another accused fugitive and then fixed the case for recording evidence. All those seemingly overzealous orders were undoubtedly prejudicial to the accused of the case and were passed in clear violation of order of stay of the High Court Division.
12The appellant, having served as Chief Judicial Magistrate for several years following a promotion to Additional District Judge, has accumulated extensive
experience in judicial matters over the years. Therefore, he cannot be regarded as a junior officer lacking in experience. However, his actions in the pending criminal case, as evidenced by his written explanation, statement, and affidavit seeking apology, indicate a deficiency in judicial temperament. Despite his experience, he has repeatedly committed acts of contempt against the High Court Division and has persisted in justifying his behavior.
13Form above facts, we find with pain not pleasure that the appellant has shown wanton disregard, disrespect, defiance and disobedience in the implementation of the order of the High Court Division. Such conduct of the appellant is short of anything but contumacious. By his conduct he tried to bring down the authority and majesty of the Supreme Court in the estimation of the people particularly those who are coming to this court for redress, so to say justice. His disregard, defiance and disobedience to the command and his intention to flout the order
of the High Court Division is so deliberate and contumacious that he does not deserve any mercy or leniency. His conduct is devoid of any compunction.
14Bewildered with severe grief and resentment we encountered one of the most unprecedented and unusual instance of criminal act of contempt that was perpetrated violating the order of stay of the High Court Division. It came as shock when we found that in a most abrupt, rather I would put that in an unexpected manner, the contemnor before us has made obnoxious order defying the order of the High Court Division which the said contemnor was constitutionally bound to comply with.
15It is not the case of the appellant that he misunderstood the order of the High Court Division or there is ambiguity therein. Because, he did not say a single word that the court’s order was unclear and ambiguous.
16The trivia and tradition of the Supreme Court are well identified and preserved. One should not forget that the hands of the Courts are long enough to catch
hold of wrong doers wherever they hide. This is an unfettered and inherent right attached to the Court.
17In addressing the gravity of the situation where a judge of the subordinate judiciary has intentionally disobeyed the order of the Apex Court, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh must exercise its authority with unwavering diligence. The sanctity of judicial orders and the integrity of the legal system demand nothing less than a resolute response to such defiance.
18The contemnor before us has rendered unconditional and unqualified apology. In accepting the apology offered by the convicted contemnor, the Appellate Division must emphasize the paramount importance of respecting and implementing judicial directives without reservation or hesitation.
19Therefore, while extending clemency to the convicted contemnor, this Division delivers a stern admonishment to serve as both a reminder and a warning. This admonishment serves not only to remind the individual judge of their solemn duty but also to
reaffirm the collective obligation of the entire subordinate judiciary to honor and implement the directives of the Apex Court without reservation or equivocation.
20Hence, we hereby absolve and exonerate the contemnor, Mr. Sohel Rana. Nevertheless, it is crucial to issue a strong admonition, underscoring the significance of adhering strictly to directives from the highest court in the country. It is our expectation that this incident serves as a lesson for all judicial officers, reaffirming the principle that the authority of the judiciary must be respected and upheld at all times.
21Since this is the First Offence of the appellant and he has solemnly promised never to do any act of omission in defiance of or in disobedience to any order of the Supreme Court we have taken a view and seriously censor and warn him for his conduct and if he repeat such kind of act in future he will be severely dealt with.
22In the light of the above observations, this appeal is disposed of. The impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court Division is hereby set aside.
CJ.
J.
J.
J.
J.
23The 04th February,2024 /Ismail,B.O./*5879*
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











