High Court Division · Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction
Jugal Chandra Pramanik v The State and another
Criminal Appeal 5807/2023 · Decided 11 March 2026
A clerk at an Upazila Education Office tampered with 26 account payee cheques issued to primary schools, raising their amounts, and encashed them at a bank branch, misappropriating money he later partly repaid. The Anti-Corruption Commission charged the clerk, the bank's cash officer and the appellant, the branch's joint custodian (cash). The Divisional Special Judge convicted the appellant under sections 409 and 109 of the Penal Code with section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 and sentenced him to five years' simple imprisonment and a fine of Taka 20,000. On appeal, the High Court Division found that of nine prosecution witnesses, none named the appellant except the investigating officer. The informant did not implicate him, the bank's own investigation found no involvement, the co-accused's statement showed he was neither the passing officer nor the ledger keeper, and the bank had reinstated him after enquiry. The evidence did not show how he abetted the principal accused. The appeal was allowed and the appellant acquitted.
Appeal allowed; appellant acquitted
- Q1
Whether the prosecution proved that the appellant, a joint custodian (cash) of the bank branch, abetted a clerk's fraudulent encashment of tampered account payee cheques so as to justify his conviction under sections 409 and 109 of the Penal Code with section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947.
- Of the nine prosecution witnesses, none mentioned the appellant except the investigating officer.
- The informant did not implicate the appellant, and the bank's own investigation report found no allegation or involvement on his part.
- The co-accused cash officer's statement under section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure showed that the appellant had no role in passing the cheques and was neither the passing officer nor the ledger keeper.
- The evidence did not show how the appellant abetted the principal accused in committing the alleged offence.
- The conviction and sentence were set aside so far as they related to the appellant, who was acquitted and released from his bail bond.
Upon examining the above-mentioned evidence, it is not found that how the appellant-Jugal Chandra Pramanik abetted the principal accused Abdul Mazid in committing the offence alleged.
In the court’s own words.
Criminal Appeal 5807/2023, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 18 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2HIGH COURT DIVISION
3(CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION)
4Present:
5Mr. Justice Md. Bashir Ullah
6Criminal Appeal No. 5807 of 2023
7In the matter of:
8An Appeal under Section 10(1)(a) of the
9Criminal Law Amendment Act, 1958.
10And
11In the matter of:
12Jugal Chandra Pramanik
13…Convict-Appellant
14-Versus-
15The State and another
16…Respondent
17Mr. Md. Rasheduzzaman Bosunia with
18Ms. Bulbul Rabeya Banu, Advocates
19…For the Appellant
20Mr. Shahjada-Al-Amin Kabir, Advocate
21…For the Respondent No.2
22Mr. S.M. Aminul Islam Sanu, D.A.G with
23Mr. Md. Nasimul Hasan, A.A.G with
24Mr. Md. Golamun Nabi, A.A.G and
25Ms. Farhana Abedin, A.A.G and
26…For the State
27Heard on: 11.01.2026, 19.01.2026,
2820.01.2026, 01.02.2026, 01.03.2026 and
2904.03.2026
30Judgment on: 11.03.2026
31This appeal preferred under Section 10(1)(a) of the Criminal Law Amendment Act, 1958 is directed against the
judgment and order dated 28.05.2023 passed by the learned Divisional Special Judge, Dhaka in Special Case No. 118 of 2017 arising out of Belabo (Narsingdi) Police Station Case No. 10 dated 25.04.2010 corresponding to G.R No. 47 of 2010 convicting the appellant under Sections 409 and 109 of the Penal Code with Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 and sentencing him under Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 to suffer simple imprisonment for 05 (five) years with a fine of Taka 20,000/- in default to suffer simple imprisonment for 06(six) months.
32The facts relevant for disposal of the appeal, in short, are that the Upazilla Education Officer, Belabo, Narshingdi, lodged a First Information Report (FIR) with the Belabo Police Station, alleging inter alia that on 08.04.2010, the Manager, Sonali Bank Limited, Belabo Branch, Narshindi, contacted the informant over mobile phone and reported that one Abdul Majid, a Lower Divisional Clerk, had presented a cheque in the amount of Taka 25,000/-(twenty five thousand) for immediate cash encashment. The manager asked him whether he had issued the cheque, and he confirmed that he had not issued any cheque for cash encashment. He subsequently requested the Manager to withhold payment of
the cheque and detain Abdul Majid until his arrival. On that day, he went to the bank and upon inspection, it was discovered that the cheque was an “account pay” instrument issued in favour of a school for the sum of Taka 5,000/-(five thousand). It appeared that Abdul Majid had tampered with the instrument by inserting the digit ‘2’ before ‘5’ and thereby fraudulently converting the value from Taka 5,000/-(five thousand) to Taka 25,000/-(twenty five thousand). On further enquiry a broader pattern of malfeasance was revealed the accused had allegedly tampered with 26 numbers of cheques and misappropriated a total of Taka 4,00,000/-(four lac) through unauthorized bank withdrawal and committed forgery. When confronted, Abdul Majid admitted to the allegations and provided an undertaking to refund the misappropriated funds. Subsequently, Abdul Majid deposited Taka 4,00,000/-(four lac) back into the relevant bank account between 08.04.2010 and 13.04.2010. The matter was then formally reported to the higher authorities. It is suspected that other individuals may have complicit in the fraudulent withdrawal of account payee cheques, which was a matter subject to further investigation. Due to the absence of the accused starting 11.04.2010, a timely interrogation was not possible. Investigation
further suggests that between 11.07.2007 and 08.04.2010, the accused misappropriated the amount totaling Taka 4,00,000/(four lac) and Taka 4,50,000/- (four lac fifty thousand) during his tenure. Earlier, the accused committed a similar offence for which penalties were imposed upon him. Hence, the case was initiated.
33On closure of the investigation, Md. Akbar Ali, Deputy Assistant Director, Anti-Corruption Commission, Dhaka-2, submitted charge sheet No. 55 dated 28.05.2012 against Md. Abdul Majid, Md. Anwar Hossain and Jugal Chandra Pramanik under Sections 409 and 109 of the Penal Code with Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947.
34Subsequently, the case was transferred to the learned Divisional Special Judge, Dhaka and registered as Special Case No. 118 of 2017. On taking cognizance, the charge was framed under Sections 409 and 109 of the Penal Code with Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947, on 30.09.2018, and the same was read out and explained to the accused when he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
35In the course of the trial, 09 prosecution witnesses were examined while the defence examined none. The accused was examined under Section 342 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure drawing attention to the evidence adduced and he once again pleaded innocence and submitted a written statement.
36Upon conclusion of trial and hearing the parties the learned Divisional Special Judge, Dhaka convicted the accused under Sections 409 and 109 of the Penal Code with Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 and sentenced him under Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 to suffer simple imprisonment for 05(five) years with a fine of Taka 20,000/- in default 06(six) months simple imprisonment.
37Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the order of conviction and sentence the convict preferred this instant Criminal Appeal before this Court. This Court enlarged the appellant on bail for 06(six) months on 21.06.2023.
38Mr. Rasheduzzaman Busunia appearing on behalf of the appellant, Jugal Chandra Pramanik contends that PW6, informant did not implicate the convict-appellant in any manner either in the FIR or in his deposition. PW6 stated in his cross-examination that, ‘
39!" ।’
40He further contends that the name of the appellant is neither in the FIR nor any witness stated that he tempered 26 cheques and misappropriated the said money and thus the prosecution hopelessly failed to prove the case beyond all reasonable doubt.
41He contends that in passing a cheque in a bank many officers are involved including bank manager but none of them has been made accused except two bank officials.
42He further contends that PW2 and PW3 did not mention any involvement of Jugal Chandra Pramanik.
43The learned Advocate contends that the appellant was joint custodian of Sonali Bank Limited, Belabo branch and he was not liable for making payment against cheque and at the time of the occurrence junior cashier was Md. Nurul Islam, but he was not made accused as he expired after occurrence and as such the appellant is entitled to be acquitted.
44In support of his contention he refers to the decisions passed in the case of Mozibur Rahman (Md) Vs. State, reported in 6 BLC(AD)127 and A K M Mohiuddin Vs. State, reported in 50 DLR(1998)447.
45Per contra, Mr. Sahjada Al Amin Kabir, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent No. 2, contends that the
appellant is liable for the offence as he was authorized to keep all cheques under his custody and he was well aware of this incident.
46He further contends that in the investigation, it was revealed that the convict-appellant, who was the joint custodian of the Bank, abetted the principal accused, Abdul Majid in encashing 26 Account payee cheques, although there is no Banking Rule to pay in cash of the Account Payee cheques.
47He next contends that the convict-appellant being the joint custodian of the respective branch of the Bank, was under duty to protect cash, cheques, securities, deposit receipts and other valuables, ensure proper storage in vaults or secure custody systems. He is also liable to follow banking regulations, ensure custody operations complying Bangladesh Bank guidelines. The joint custodian of the bank is also under obligation to maintain accurate registers of the deposited cheques, other securities and documents and record movement of assets. He was also under obligation for ensuring reconciliation of physical and book records and under obligation to exercise reasonable care and diligence. If a custodian of a bank negligently losses cash of the bank, he is personally liable for the offence committed.
48He further contends that if the convict-appellant, joint custodian of the bank, was being vigilant in the course of business, he could identify the tampered cheques in question and could protect the assets of the customers. In spite of that, the convict-appellant maintained the record of the tampered cheques in the record as of his joint responsibilities and didn’t notify to the Branch Manager, otherwise, the series of the offence, could have been avoided.
49He next contends that the convict-appellant cannot avoid the responsibility of protecting the customers assets, in the instant case, cash of Taka 8.5 lacs, from losing. Therefore, the sentence imposed by the trial Court is correct and liable to be affirmed. Finally he prays for dismissal of the appeal.
50I have considered the submissions of the learned Advocates for both sides, perused the impugned judgment and order passed by the trial Court and the materials on records.
51To consider the merit of the case and analyze the facts, let me review the evidence of the prosecution's case.
52PW 1, Md. Osman Gani, Higher graded Assistant, Upazilla Education Office, Narshingdi, who is a seizure list witness. He
proved the seizure list as Exhibit 1 and proved his signature as Exhibit 1/1. He was not cross-examined.
53PW 2, Md. Sahidullah, Ex Manager, Sonali Bank Ltd., Belabo Branch, Narshingdi, who was a seizure list witness. Seized articles were kept under his custody. He proved the seizure list and his signature as Exhibit l ka and 1/ka/1.
54PW 3, Md. Abdul Hai, Ex-Senior Executive Officer, Sonali Bank Ltd., Principal Office, Narshingdi, deposed that he investigated the matter. He visited the concerned bank on 11.05.2010 to investigate into the matter of misappropriation done by Mr. Anwar Hossain, Officer Cash. He found that Abdul Majid had withdrawn Taka 5,77,500/- (five lac seventy seven thousand five hundred) by 26 cheques by practising fraud. Abdul Majid tampered with 26 cheques and thus misappropriated Taka 4,00,000/- (four lac) and subsequently he deposited Taka 4,00,000/- (four lac) to the concerned account of the bank. On query, Officer (cash), Md. Anwar Hossain admitted to the payment of the alleged cheques and informed that he arranged for the adjustment of Taka 4,00,000/- (four lac) within 3 days. After the closure of the investigation, he submitted an investigation
report to the Deputy General Manager on 16.05.2010. He proved the copy of the report as Exhibit 2.
55In cross-examination, he deposed that after the adjustment of money, the accused were reinstated in the service of the bank.
56PW 4, Md. Akmal Ali, Assistant Sub Inspector, AntiCorruption Commission, Head Office, Dhaka is a seizure list witness who proved his signature in the seizure list as Exhibit 1/2.
57PW 5, Md. Saidur Rahman Bhuiya, Inspector of Police, PBI, Dhaka-District recorded the FIR and he proved the FIR as Exhibit 5 and his signature as Exhibit 5/1. In cross-examination, he stated that it was recorded in the FIR that a delay was occurred in lodging the FIR.
58PW 6, Md. Mozibur Rahman, Education Officer, Department of Primary Education, Mirpur, Dhaka, is the informant of the case. He stated that on 08.04.2010, the Manager, Sonali Bank Limited, Belabo Branch, Narshindi, contacted him via mobile phone and reported that Abdul Majid, Lower Divisional Clerk of his office, had presented a cheque amounting Taka 25,000/- (twenty five thousand) for immediate cash encashment. The manager asked him whether he had issued the cheque, and he confirmed that he had not issued any cheque for
cash encashment. He subsequently requested the Manager to withhold payment of the cheque and to keep Abdul Majid detained until his arrival. On that day at 5:00 pm, he went to the bank and upon inspection, it was discovered that the cheque was an “account pay” instrument issued in favour of a school for the sum of Taka 5,000/- (five thousand). It appeared that Abdul Mojid had tampered with the instrument by inserting the digit ‘2’ before the ‘5’ and thereby fraudulently converted the value from Taka 5,000/- (five thousand) to Taka 25,000/- (twenty five thousand). Further inquiry revealed a broader pattern of malfeasance; the accused had allegedly tampered with 26 cheques and misappropriated a total amount of Taka 4,00,000/- (four lac) through unauthorized bank withdrawal and committed forgery. When confronted, Abdul Majid admitted to the allegations and provided an undertaking to refund the misappropriated funds within 3 days. Subsequently, Abdul Majid deposited Taka 4,00,000/- (four lac) back into the relevant bank account between 08.04.2010 and 13.04.2010. The matter was then formally reported to the higher authorities. He further made an investigation and found that Abdul Majid misappropriated more Taka 4,50,000/- (four lac fifty thousand). Thus, he
misappropriated Taka 8,50,000/- (eight lac fifty thousand) from 11.07.2007 to 08.04.2010. He lodged the FIR with the Belabo Police Station.
59He proved the FIR as Exhibit 5Ka and his signature Exhibit 5(ka)/1.
60In cross-examination, he stated that he did not mention the name of other accused except Abdul Majid in the statement made under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
61PW 7, Md. Abul Kashem Sarkar, Officer, Sonali Bank Ltd., Poradia Bazar Branch, Narshingdi, who is a seizure list witness proved the seizure list as Exhibit 1(ka)/2 and his signature as Exhibit 1(ka)/2.
62PW 8, Zahirul Islam, Manager, Sonali Bank, Belabo Branch, Narshingdi, who produced the alamats (kept in the bank) before the trial Court as Exhibit 6 series.
63In cross-examination, he stated that he brought the alamats from the almirah of the bank as per the order of the Court.
64PW 9, Md. Akbar Ali, Ex-Assistant Director, AntiCorruption Commission, Head Office, Dhaka, the investigating officer submitted the charge sheet. He proved the sanction letter as Exhibit 7.
65He stated that the cheques were issued in favour of 78 primary school of Belabo Upazilla and were kept under custody of the accused Abdul Majid. The cheques were issued for handing over to the Head masters of the primary schools. But Abdul Majid had withdrawn Taka 5,77,500/- (five lac seventy seven thousand five hundred) instead of Taka 1,77,500/- (one lac seventy seven thousand five hundred) from the Sonali Bank by 26 A/C payee cheques from 01.03.2010 to 08.04.2010. Later, he deposited Taka 4,00,000/- (four lac) to STD A/C No. 21.He further stated that it is transpired in the investigation that 26 cheques were presented for encashment at that time when the accused, Md. Anwar Hossain was in charge of the officer (cash). He debited and passed the cheques and put a seal for cash payment, violating the rules. At that time, the accused, Jugal Chandra Pramanik, was Joint Custodian (cash).
66In cross-examination, he deposed that after the adjustment of money, the accused were reinstated in the service of the bank.
67It appears from the record that co-accused, Anower Hossain submitted a written statement at the time of examination under section 342 0f the Code of Criminal Procedure wherein he admitted as follows:
68“Dc‡iv³ b¤^i gvgjvi NUbv¯’j †mvbvjx e¨vsK wjwg‡UW, †ejv‡ev kvLvq Avwg 08/01/2010 Bs nB‡Z 31/05/2010 Bs ZvwiL fkÑ¿¹ Kg©iZ wQjvg| Awdmvi K¨vk wn‡m‡e GUvB Avgvi cÖ_g `vwqZ¡ wQj| Dc‡iv³ b¤^i gvgjvi NUbvi mg‡q †mvbvjx e¨vsK wjwg‡UW mn AwaKvsk e¨vs‡Ki Kvh©µg wQj wb¤œiƒc: †Kvb MÖvnK UvKv DVvB‡Z Pvwn‡j Zvnvi †PK †Uv‡Kb K¬v‡K©i wbKU Rgv w`‡Zb| †Uv‡Kb K¬vK© †PKwU Rgv ivwLqv MÖvnK‡K GKwU †Uv‡Kb w`‡Zb| AZ:ci †Uv‡Kb K¬vK© †PKwU †jRvi KvD›Uv‡i †jRvi wKcv‡ii wbKU Rgv w`‡Zb| †PKwU †WwfU K‡i “bM` cÖ`vbÓ mxj w`qv cvwms Awdmv‡ii wbKU Rgv w`‡Zb| cvwms Awdmvi †PKwU cvk K‡i K¨vwkqv‡ii wbKU †cÖiY Kwi‡Zb| … g¨v‡bRvi fvDPvi¸wj cvIqvi ci p¤Q¡l¦l©−f †PwKs Kwiqv iw½b DW †cwÝj w`qv fvDPv‡ii Dci `vM Uvwbqv w`‡Zb| ïay ZvB b‡n, wZwb †jRvi †_‡K UvKv AvZœmvZ, †diZ I Abv`vqx _v‡K †mB †jRv‡ii bvg STD †jRvi hvnv g¨v‡bRvi mv‡ne cÖwZw`b †PwKs K‡i ü¡rl Kwi‡Zb| Avwg ¢ejÀü¡rlL¡l£l c~e© AwfÁZv bv _vKvq ‘A/C Payee’ †PK bM` cÖ`v‡bi †Kvb wbqg bv _vKv m‡Ë¡I biwms`x Dc‡Rjv ¢nr¡ Awdm Gi ¢ejÀj¡e mnKvix Avx gwR` †jRvi wKcvi‡K fzj eySvBqv ÕbM` cÖ`vbÕ mxj w`qv cvwms Awdmvi Gi wbKU cvVvB‡Zb| cvwms Awdmvi †PK cvk Kwiqv †`Iqvq D³ Avx gwR` wewfbœ Zvwi‡L 4,40,000/- UvKv D‡Ëvjb K‡i|Ó
69It appears from the statement made by another accused namely Md. Anower Hossain that there was no involvement of the
appellant Jugal Chandra Pramanik in passing of a cheque. Neither the appellant was passing officer or ledger keeper.
70PW 3, Mohammad Abdul Hai investigated into the matter and after closure of investigation he submitted an investigation report. In the investigation report, no allegation or involvement of the appellant, Jugal Chandra Pramanik was found. PW3 proved the investigation report as exhibit No. 3.
71Md. Abdul Hye, Senior Executive Officer, Sonali Bank Ltd., Principal office, Narsingdi was examined as PW3 and he stated in his examination-in-chief that “a¡R¡s¡ A¢gp¡l (LÉ¡n) B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe−L A¢eu¢ja i¡−h ®Q−Ll V¡L¡ f¢l−n¡−dl hÉ¡f¡−l ¢S‘¡p¡ Ll¡ q−m ¢a¢e a¡l paÉa¡ ü£L¡l L−le Hhw V¡L¡ ®f−j¾V Ll¡l 3 ¢c−el j−dÉ 4,00,000/- V¡L¡ Bc¡u L−l pw¢nÔø ¢qp¡−h Sj¡ Ll¡l hÉhÙÛ¡ L−le h−m S¡¢e−u−Rez” In the above deposition PW3 did not implicate the convict appellant Jugal Chandra Paramanik in any manner.
72The authority of Sonali Bank suspended the appellant from his service and after enquiry the authority found no specific allegation against the appellant and hence they withdrawn the suspension order and reinstated the appellant in service on 13.10.2014.
73The appellant in his written statement provided under section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure stated that “B¢j Eš² hÉ¡w−L k¤NÈ ¢SÇj¡c¡l ¢q−p−h b¡L¡ AhÙÛ¡u Bj¡l L¡S ¢Rm hÉ¡w−Ll ¢e¢cÑø i−ÒV ka f¢lj¡e V¡L¡ b¡−L a¡q¡ ®M¡m¡ Hhw hå Ll¡l SeÉ jÉ¡−eS¡l Hhw Bj¡l ¢eLV Bm¡c¡ Q¡¢h b¡Laz fÐ−aÉL¢ce B¢j Hhw jÉ¡−eS¡l HL−œ ¢j¢ma qCu¡ i−ÒV Q¡¢h Y¤L¡Cu¡ iÒV M¤¢mz a¡lfl ¢LR¤ f¢lj¡e V¡L¡ pqL¡l£ LÉ¡¢nu¡l ®L ®cCz Eš² LÉ¡¢nu¡l p¡l¡¢ce ®me−ce Ll¡l fl LÉ¡n ¢jm¡Cu¡ ¢c−m f¤el¡u B¢j Hhw jÉ¡−eS¡l k¤NÈ i¡−h Q¡¢h ¢cu¡ i−ÒV a¡m¡hÜ L¢lu¡ l¡¢Mz HC SeÉ B¢j k¤NÈ ¢SÇj¡c¡l…”
74Upon scrutiny of the totality of evidence adduced by the prosecution witnesses it is revealed that 9 witnesses were examined but none mentioned or uttered the name of the appellant, Jugal Chandra Pramanik in their evidence except PW9.
75Md. Akbar Ali, Investigating Officer as PW9 implicated the appellant stating in his examination-in-chief which run as follows:
76# $ % & ' , )* %, +"& ,+ ' &- . e /0 1 .-3 4 5 6 0 * 6 *-78 79:7 "% 48/:/4
77।0 1 .-3 6 $ & & A – %
78& ' / 6 B $ & CD 3 E = .+ 0 * $ ? F ' & ,++"& ? G । # $ H$ 6I ? J= & HNÈ ,+ ' )* %,
+"& । !" 6 B $ ? & A – $ & '& K & .
79*J= ।
80Upon examining the above-mentioned evidence, it is not found that how the appellant-Jugal Chandra Pramanik abetted the principal accused Abdul Mazid in committing the offence alleged.
81Considering the gravity of the alleged offence and the facts and circumstances of the case I am of the view that the judgment and order of conviction and sentence, so far as it relates to the appellant is liable to be set aside.
82In the result, the appeal is allowed.
83The judgment and order dated 28.05.2023 passed by the learned Divisional Special Judge, Dhaka in Special Case No. 118 of 2017 arising out of Belabo (Narsingdi) Police Station Case No. 10 dated 25.04.2010 corresponding to G.R No. 47 of 2010 so far as relates to the appellant namely Jugal Chandra Pramanik is hereby set aside.
84The appellant is acquitted of the charge leveled against him.
85The convict-appellant is released from the bail bond. Send down the lower Court's records (LCR) at once. Communicate the judgment and order to the Court concerned forthwith.
86(Md. Bashir Ullah, J) Md. Ariful Islam Khan Bench Officer
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











