High Court Division
Redwan Ahmed v The State and another
Criminal Appeal 9078/2024 · Decided 28 October 2025
The informant alleged that in 2002 Tk. 50,00,000.00 was withdrawn by three bearer cheques from the Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangsad's welfare account for distressed freedom fighters and misappropriated. The accused, then its Chairman, was convicted in his absence by the Special Judge, Special Judge Court No. 2, Dhaka under section 409 of the Penal Code and sentenced to three years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Tk. 50,00,000.00. After the Government suspended the sentence, he appealed. The High Court Division held that entrustment of property, or dominion over it, is an essential ingredient of criminal breach of trust. The FIR itself said the accused had returned Tk. 20,00,000.00 he had borrowed, through the other two accused, who failed to deposit it. No evidence showed entrustment, the cheques did not bear his name, and the informant admitted signing the FIR in 2007 at the army's direction. Following A.K.M. Hafizuddin v State and Shakir Hussain v State, the conviction was set aside and the accused acquitted.
Appeal allowed; section 409 conviction set aside, acquitted
- Conviction and sentenceA conviction is a criminal court's finding that the accused is guilty; the sentence is the punishment it then imposes, such as imprisonment or a fine.Read the full explanation →
- Set asideTo cancel an earlier court order, decree, award, sale or conviction so that it no longer has legal effect, usually by a higher court or by the same court on a proper application.Read the full explanation →
- Acquittal (khalash)A court's final finding that an accused person is not guilty of the offence charged, ending the case in their favour unless it is reversed on appeal.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether a conviction for criminal breach of trust under section 409 of the Penal Code can stand where the prosecution did not prove that the accused was entrusted with the money or had dominion over it.
- Entrustment with property or dominion over it is an essential ingredient of criminal breach of trust under section 405, and no one can be convicted under section 409 of the Penal Code unless entrusted with something.
- The FIR itself stated that the accused had returned the Tk. 20,00,000.00 he borrowed through the other two accused, and it disclosed no allegation of entrustment against him.
- Neither the FIR nor the prosecution evidence proved entrustment, and the bank witnesses showed that the three cheques were bearer cheques not bearing the accused's name.
- Following A.K.M. Hafizuddin v State (15 BLD (HCD) 234), mere retention of money for some time without using it, or delay in repayment if properly explained, is not an offence under section 409, and following Shakir Hussain v State (9 DLR (SC) 14) the prosecution must prove both entrustment and dishonest misappropriation.
- The prosecution failed to prove its case, so the conviction and sentence were set aside, the accused was acquitted and discharged from his bail bond.
So, as per section 405 of the Penal Code entrustment is an essential ingredient of an offence of criminal breach of trust. A man can not be held guilty of the offence under section 409 of the Penal Code
In the court’s own words.
Criminal Appeal 9078/2024, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 68 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1Present:
2Mr. Justice Md. Khasruzzaman
3Criminal Appeal No. 9078 of 2024
4Redwan Ahmed, Ex Minister of State, Ministry
5of Liberation War Affairs and Ex- Chairman,
6Central Command Council, Bangaldesh
7Muktijoddha Sangsad.
8….Convict appellant.
9-Versus-
10The State and another.
11…Respondents
12Mr. S M Shahjahan, Senior Advocate
13… for the convict-appellant.
14Mr. M. Masud Rana, D.A.G. with
15Mr. Ashraful Alam, A.A.G. and
16Mrs. Mahfuza Akhter, A.A.G.
17Mr. Frauk Ahamed, A.A.G
18…..For the State.
19Judgment on: 28.10.2025
20This appeal has been arisen out of judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 14.08.2023 passed by the learned Special Judge, Special Judge Court No. 2, Dhaka in Special Case No. 14 of 2007 (previous number Metro Special Case No. 133 of 2007), arising out of Ramna Police Station Case No. 40 dated 15.02.2007, convicting the appellant under section 409 of the Penal Code and
sentencing him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 3 (three) years with a fine of Tk. 50,00,000.00 (fifty lac).
21The prosecution case, in short, is that on 15.02.2007 one Md. Nurul Islam (Bir Muktijoddha) as an informant lodged a first information report (hereinafter referred to as ‘the FIR’) with Ramna Police Station, Metropolitan Area, Dhaka against the appellant and two others under sections 409 and 109 of the Penal Code read with section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act alleging inter alia that 4% (four percent) of the amount received against lease money of all Hat-Bazars of the country under the Ministry of the Local Government, Rural Development and Co operative are deposited with the account of Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangsad to be spent for the welfare of the distressed and unemployed freedom fighters through Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangsad Central Command Council, Dhaka.
22The amount so collected stood at approximately Tk. 5.00 (five) Crore and the same is deposited with Sonali Bank, Moghbazar Branch, Dhaka. It is alleged that in 2002 while the then Chairman Mr. Redwan Ahmed and the then Finance Secretary (at present Secretary General) Shah
Alam Chowdhury of Muktijoddha Council were the custodian of the Muktijoddha Council then at the instance of the then Vice Chairman (at present Chairman) Md. Kabir Ahmed without taking any approval of the organization by abuse of their powers withdrew Tk. 50,00,000.00 (fifty lac)
23from the account of Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangsad and misappropriated the same without spending for the welfare of the distressed and unemployed freedom fighters. The cheques by which the money withdrawn are cheque No.
241474213 dated 11.06.2002 for an amount of Tk.
2520,00,000.00 (twenty lac), cheque No. 1474214 dated 11.06.2002 for an amount of Tk. 20,00,000.00 (twenty lac)
26and cheque No. 1474215 dated 11.06.2002 for an amount of Tk. 10,00,000.00 (ten lac) thus total amount at Tk.
2750,00,000.00 (fifty lac). It is stated in the FIR that the appellant after resignation from the office of the Chairman of the Muktijoddha Sangsad deposited Tk. 20,00,000.00 (twenty lac) (which he borrowed) to the accused Kabir Ahmed Khan and Shah Alam Chowdhury in presence of present Vice Chairman Sofiqul Islam Robi, Member Sattar Shaheb and the informant Nurul Islam. But the accused
Kabir Ahmed Khan and Shah Alam Chowdhury did not deposit the said amount of Tk. 50,00,000.00 (fifty lac)
28including Tk. 20,00,000.00 (twenty lac) of the appellant. It is also stated that the audit authority recommended for taking legal action against those two accused but the Sangsad authority did not take any legal action against them. Thus, the informant lodged the FIR stating the aforesaid facts.
29Initially, the case was investigated by police and thereafter, Anti Corruption Commission, and Anti Corruption Commission submitted Charge Sheet No. 526 dated 08.10.2017 against the appellant including one Md.
30Shah Alam Chowdhury under section 409 of the Panel Code read with section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947, but the investigating officer did not send up the accused Md. Kabir Ahmed Khan in the charge sheet.
31In due course, on 16.10.2007 the case was transmitted to the learned Metropolitan Senior Special Judge, Dhaka for holding trial and on 17.102007 the case was registered as Metropolitan Special Case No. 133 of 2007. Thereafter, on 30.10.2007 the case was transferred to
the Special Judge, Special Judge Court No. 2, Dhaka and on 01.11.2007 the same was renumbered as Special Case No. 14 of 2007. Thereafter, on 19.08.2018 charge was framed against the appellant under sections 409 and 109 of the Panel Code read with section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947.
32In order to prove the charge levelled against them, the prosecution examined 10 (ten) witnesses, on the other hand, the defence examined only 2 (two) witnesses in support of the defence case.
33The examinations-in-chief and cross examinations of 10 (ten) P.Ws and 2 (two) D.Ws are quoted below:
34P.W.1, Md. Nurul Islam (Bir Muktijoddha)
35(informant), in his examination-in-chief stated that / /
36," # $ % & '(#
37) $ & * * + ,% ." / 01 2 $ 3 4& ) 01 2 $4$ 5# 67 8 9&
38** +/ । 81 * 01 2 67 89 &
$ &# 3 4 ) । $ 01 2 $4$ : 3 ;& 1 %# ।
3901 2 $4$ ' $: ;& ) & :=> $ : 3 ;& । ?
4001 2 $4$ ' @ ;& । / ) & :=4 : 4- , , ? 4- /B/ * +
41&C * , : 4 , , , 4 /B/ * &C * , : 4- , , 4 /B/ * + &C * $ &# 3 4 ) 8 D& । 81 '
42.>" / 01 2 &3 3 E$ F
43। @ 8D & &C * &C * ) GH& $& , , $D $ /)
44& $ G 8+ " । +=
45* $ < * :& । $ # $@& 81 &C * E$ F । $4 I resolution +) 81 ' 3 &/ E$ F
46। / / $ # J2
47। $ >- ।
48KC – / ।
49While he was cross-examined by the accused Shah Alam Chowdhury, he stated that $ 3 , L* , F$ $ B + । $ 3 , #L $ $ # & M
50$ N )& + ) ;। &#
51* + -I 😯 । $ 3 ,
52$
530 ; । + &
54$
550 ;।
56+0 > :-
57$
580 । $
590 + $
60। $ 3 ,) & :=> )Q R
61$
620 । S + ) ?/ / & ;। $ 3 , ?/ /
63;। $ 3 , T 01 2। L* $ 01 2 67 89 & : #
64$ $3 ;& । < $ $D $ 89 & $ $3
; & । $D $ M# H O & : U ।
65* & I +M ; । 4J
66J * & & + । * & $ $D / ) GH& $& 8+ " ;&। $ 3 , 01 2 $4$ ' 7* +* । $ 3 , C '+ 3 8 1 8 V)3 । $ 3 , $4 I 'W ;M 8 1 8 V)3 । $ 3
67,) & :=> X Y$ Z N ;।
68+T '[ / & '
69; । $ 3 , ) & :=> 01 2 $4$ ' @ ;& । $ 3 ,) & :=> 01 2 67 89 & &C * 8 D& । $ 3 ,) & :=> /B/ 4 , , ? 4 : T& &C * 8 D& । $ 3 ,
70, , , 4 : T& ) & :=> &C * 8 D& । $ 3 , , , ? 4 : T& \ $ / &C * 8 D& ; । , , , 4 : 0&
71&C * . &8 D& $ 3 ।$ 3
72$ 3 + ;।
73+0 > >-
74** / N & &;
75। $ 3 , $ # X * E$ N
76^ _ 😯 । $ 3 , $ # += )* * :& / N
77😯 । $ 3 , $4 I resolution + ) 81 ' 3 E$ F 'WJ+ 😯 ।+ & 😯 । $ 3 , $ # $@& &C * E$ F
78। $ 3 , $ # * 8 D& E$ F । $ KC ।
79The accused Redwan Ahmed adopted the cross examination of the accused Shah Alam Chowdhury and thereafter, he cross examined P.W.1, and in his cross examination, P.W.1 stated that $ # : ।
01 2 $4$ $ $ $ M ;& । 01 2 $4$ & 8 D& ^ _ ;।
80;& $4$ : 3 , $: / ' $: $2 `
81* 8 D& । : 3 / ' $:
82= KC * 8 D& । $ 3 , : 3 /
83$: (' ) ' 8 D& । 8D & *
843 $ N । 8 D& X ' 01 2 $4 ( $@ / &3 ' 3
85c ;।
86The prosecution declared P.W.1 as hostile witness and thereafter the prosecution cross examined P.W.1 and in his cross examination, P.W. 1 stated that 1 3 $ 3 KC ;। ' $ 3।
87+ M KC ;। 8 D & X ' $ @& 3
88। $ 3 , $ # $ $ $
89& 3 $ C3 ;।
90On recall
91XXX
92* ,% 01 2 $4$ 5#
9367 8 9&- cJ e ।
94$ f +/ +T '(3C
95:=(0 # 01 2 $4$ : 3 ; & । '(3C
96:=(0 # : 3 & f $ / $ + ` 34 $ * ;& e
97। @ $ + `
988 9& : 3 ;& & + । / /
99$ $2 ` 01 2 67 89 & 34 $ / * ' 0& – ' ; g g $ 8 9 & 'Wh $ # '
10089 & : 3 @ *
1018 9& i j ? /B/ (3 : 3 @ + )(
102c ;। &k 😯 ।
103P.W.2, Lina Sarker, D.G.M. (Rtd.), Agrani Bank, in her examination-in-chief stated that /l/ 'jm# 3 4 + * ) AGM $
;& । < . $ > + :& / & I/0 >
104&
1050 $ & $ । : 8+" + ;0 +r s & T& s ।
106s & , 4 t s X +r ;। + '7 4 l l 4 l l 4 /B/ $ &# 34 ) , * + m , , +
107, , * 8: :& $ 4- ,,
108/ । / :& $ 4- ,, / / -? /B/ + ` $
109#। $ s & >- । s &
110KC >- / । s X +r @
111। s X +r $ 3 'W & + &
112& & । >-? $ (, G )।
113While she was cross-examined by the accused Redwan Ahmed, she stated that + '7 * s +T . 1.0 :I । + '7 #
114$ ; & + । s & $ C#
115& ।$ 3 , ' 8F$ # $ C3
116$ ;। $ 3 , $ # + '7
117# । $ 3 , &# $ m#
118X
119+C X 'W । $ 3 ,
120& 3 $ C3 w।
121The accused Shah Alam Chowdhury adopted the cross examination of the accused Redwan Ahmed.
122P.W.3, Md. Johir Uddin, Member, Vatchar Union Parishad, Madaripur in his examination-in-chief stated that
123/ / 4& ) 01 2 5# 67
1248 9& ' G$ $ # $ & $, G &
1250 $& : C 01 2 67
12689 & : 3 @ 8+" +
127/ & $ 8+ " F &# 01 2 $4$ $: ) & :=(0 # X $ : 3 @ X ? $ &
128, , /-* G :I m ;& $ :I – B $ & ' 7* +* s । s &
129KC ;। / / s & ( >-,)
130/ KC ( >-,/ )। 81 s X ;
131@ F &# S.I G &
1320 $& + G* + । 81 T
133& + +
134। m : # ' 3 ;&। $
135@ ( >- ) / KC ( >- / )। $ : I, 7 ) / ' 7* +* G* +( >-B $ )।
136The accused Shah Alam Chowdhury declined to cross examine P.W. 3.
137But the accused Redwan Ahmed cross examined him and in his cross examination, P.W. 3 stated that $z
138? $ & : H # cJ । / /
139s & KC ;। +r T
140& + &
141& । s X ;। $ 3 & * G :I + # $X ;। $ 3 81 $X X $ $ C# $ ;। ' 7* + *
142$ # * E$ F ; 😯 ;
143। / B $ & ' 7* +* & ;।
144P.W.4, Md. Kabir Ahmed Khan, Vice Chairman, Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangsad Central Command
Council in his examination-in-chief stated that
145/ / 4& ) 01 2 $4$ 5#
14667 8 9& $ : 3 ;& । S.1 G &
1470 $& 'G $ $ । : C 01 2 $4$ $ : 3 @ : I 8+" + ;। 81 : I F &# $: ) & :=(0 # @ ;& 81 : I e 4 0 1/+r/? {/ ? 4 ,/ B/ ? $ * 7
148) / ' 7* + * S.I G &
1490 ;& ।
150The accused Shah Alam Chowdhury declined to cross examine P.W. 4.
151But the accused Redwan Ahmed cross examined him and in his cross examination, P.W. 4 stated that ,
152+ ` 5# 89 & : 3 ;& । +T ;& @ & |& 8+" +
153;। 7 ) T
154& + । & T
155& +
156& । G* + & ;। T
157& + ;।
' 7* +** / B $ & ' 7* + * G* +
158& ;।
159P.W.5, Md. Badruzzaman, A.G.M. (Rtd.), Sonali Bank, in his examination-in-chief stated that ? / /
160$ &# 34 ) 3 $
161;& । < . $ # + :& > &
162$ & $ । : C
16334 j 5# 67 8 9& 4& )
16401 2 $4$ $ 4$ 86* 4- B? ?* :
165k , , ?, , , ,, , , – /B/ * + m t , , /-, , , /-,
166, , /- * s । : + 01 2 67
1678 9& : 3 KC ;। / c(0 $: $#& ;। s $ $ ' G$ > /
168> J& $& KC ; । 8+" + 81
169s । + @ 81 7H 6* ।
170@ KC ;। $ ? / /
171s & ( >- ) / KC ( >- / )। : T
172&
173+| & 34 ;। + &# ;।
17481 : G* + & & । $ ?* : G* +( >-l $>)।
175While he was cross-examined by the accused Shah Alam Chowdhury, he stated that &# : G* + 34 $ । I.0 $4j ;। 81 3 4 &# / $ + #) 3 "+ ; f 0g ;। : ?*
176* ) & :=(0 # KC । , , ? :
177$ $ / , , , : > &
178;। $ 3 f$I +& ।
179The accused Redwan Ahmed adopted the cross examination of the accused Shah Alam Chowdhury and thereafter, he cross examined him and in his cross examination, P.W.5 stated that . $ # + :&
180:I &; & 34 +r
181। 81 : I e 4/ । k
182( : / ^ । * : ।
: + # KC * j । Cash & : * @ * KC ;।
183@ KC ; । s &
184#: @ KC ;। & @ j ;। 81 & 34 ;। $ 3 : 8+" + / : @ ।
185P.W.6, Md. Abdul Aziz Khan, Principal Officer (Rtd.), Sonali Bank, in his examination-in-chief stated that
186? / / $ &# 34 ) $ ' G$ $ ;& । < . $ # + :& > &
1870 $ & $ 4 : C F &# 34 3 ?* : 8+" +
188& s । s & KC ।
189s & KC ( >- / )।
190While he was cross-examined by the accused Shah Alam Chowdhury, he stated that s X &
191; 4 s & +M 0g $ KC ; 4
1921 3 s & & । s & : $ |&
193/B/ & ;। ? * : /) & :=(0 # KC ।
194While he was cross-examined by the accused Redwan Ahmed, he stated that ? / / 3 $ J : s ;। T : |&
195& । : * j ; 7H 6* ।
196s & : /B/ & ;। $ 3
197s & • $ ;& । $ 3 + #
198KC ;। $ 3 ` # *
199s & • + # KC ;। $ 3
200$ & 82 । $ 3 '$ 3 $ C# & ।
201P.W. 7, Md. Faruque Hossain, Assistant Office Super, Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangsad Central Command Council, in his examination-in-chief stated that
202/ / 4& ) 01 2 $4$ 5#
20367 8 9& +, $ *0 : 3 ;& । < S.I G &
2040 $& F &# $: * :I : 3
205/ K# +r / – B ' 7* +* T & + s । 81 +r > $ @
206। $ 8+ " ;& 4 $ C# $
207@ KC ;। KC ( >- / )।
208The accused Shah Alam Chowdhury declined to cross examine this witness but the accused Redwan Ahmed cross examined him and in his cross examination, P.W. 7 stated that / / @ • ;।
209@ / & $ $ C# ;। &
210$ KC + Over writing ;। & T & + । G* + ;। / /
211@ $ 01 2 $4$ : 3 ;& । :I +I ‚ 7 )# ;। $ 3 /?/ @ KC ;। $ 3 / /
212@ KC । $ 3 •
213@ j ।$ 3 '$ 3 $ C3 & ।
214P.W. 8, S. M. Mahbubur Rahman, Managing Director of Bangladesh Muktijoddha Kalyan Trust, in his examination-in-chief stated that /{/ ƒ
215„ + &* & 4 * „ + &* 3 ‚*
216$ ;& । < … C.M.M $ # ) & :=(0 # & &
217/B 4 & m |& 0g & 4 :` [ ? L6* $ । + Kw
218N K# # / N K# T
2191 &
220U# & + 2 ।G $4H& / ' 1 .* + $4 1
2210 ;। $ # * * KC ;।
222* ) & / ? * +Tm K C ;। $ #) & :=(0 # N K# T
2231 & U# ( >-{) / KC ( >-{/ ) & $ C# @ &#
224U# G=> > > B, ( &+ 2 ;। $ C# * ? * KC ;। KC ;। $ C# @ &# U# ( >- )/ KC ( >- / )।
225While he was cross-examined by the accused Shah Alam Chowdhury, he stated that 4 & ?. &
226;। a.m / p.m 8 O । ?. & p.m ।
227$ C#। … C.M.M +I ;
228Forwarding । & + । * $ U# & cJ & & । 81•+ & । $ 3 4 & +2
229+T । $ 3 4 & +2
230+T । 4 & +T m m
231$ # +0 & ) (3 $ । U &+ 2
232) ‘ ( $ ;&। $ 3 0 $ ) $
233‘ ( $ ;& $ m & +T
234& )
2350 # U# & + 2 ;। $ 3 ? 4
236& +T । , 4 & +T
237। ? 4 & $ # :` [ C $
238; & ^ ; । B, 7
239[ $ # :` [$
240। 4 & + M; 4 $ # c ;/
241g
2420 ;। $ 3 $ # g
2430 ; 😯
244। B 4 & 😯 , +0 &) 3 ‚*। B 4 & 😯 , + N K#
245(3 4 N K# & + J2 + । B 4 & 😯 , K (# / Kw
246$ # U# ;। B 4 & 😯 , + K# 1 & + +0 &) G । l 4
247& $ # ) # L :’ ; 😯 4 $ # ;& 😯 ।
248W ,* $ U# 7 )N ।
249/ & । $ 3 G= # ( ?B, ( 'W$ U# & + 2 ;। $ 3 + "
250m ( U# 7/ + ।
251$ # B, / $ C# B, ;। $ 3 $ .* U# 7 ;। B 4 + Xh $ #
252X +Mc ; 😯 ।
253XXX ।
254While he was cross-examined by the accused Redwan Ahmed, he stated that $ # “*
255;&। … $ $ B, 7 [
256; + I ; । $ # … $. . ; S
257; Form 😯 । & ? * $
258U# & cJ ;। 4+ K# 1 # KC
259& । , 4 & +T
260। 4 & 8D & ^ । B 4 & $ # Kw U# ('+ I3) ” ;। $ # & m +0 &) •7 B 4 & ”
261। , 4+ K# 1 # KC & *। $ # Kw m U# ; { 4 & ;0 😯 । ' 1+ 3 ;। , 4+ 😯 * + ' 1 3 ;। ' – ? * + Xh K# 1 # KC ( * (✔) :’ ;। :& + -B 67 । G + $ ?. L* / 😯 ।
262* :& &# $ 😯 ;। L* "& 01 2
263N %m & %# ' G$ J 😯 ;।
264/?/ $ * ‘ ( $ &। $ 3
265$ # D N K# 1 U# । $ 3
G=> > > B, / ?B, ( 'W$ K# 1
266U# 7 ।
267$ C# @ & ; 8+" + ;
268U# 😯 । $ C3 * $ &+ 2 😯 । X * + 😯 । + Xh k । + + X :& 😯
269। @ & KC + ) * (✔) :’ ;। $— @ & X । $ 3 $ KC * X • & &
270;। $ 3 @ & K) # ; 8+ " ।$ 3 '$ 3 $ C# & ।
271P.W. 9, A. K. M. Daulat Akbor, A.S.P of S.B, Dhaka, in his examination-in-chief stated that / /
2727& $
273" # * + X ' + m# Form +T & J 0 k , / B,
274/ / । F.I.R Form ( >- )/ KC ( >- / )
275While he was cross-examined by both the accused, he stated that $ 3 F.I.R & +T ।
276+ M ;& । F.I.R & &k m8O
277। &k m 😯 । # KC $ 1 । ` # । $ 3 #
278$ $ # KC $ 1 ।
279P.W. 10, Md. Abul Hossain, Deputy Director, Anti Curroption Commission, in his examination-in-chief stated that $ # + :& $ . ( & , ƒ
280& e 4-,{ / / T&
281& 4-, , – / / ` #
282। $ +r ( >- )।
283& * ` & ? / / $ & 34 ,
284) : 3 J™ 8+" + $ C# 8+ " $ 4B? 01 2 &3 „ • ?* : s ।
285$ s & 4 KC ( >- /?)। s X
286) 3 "+ @ । /l/
287'jm# 3 4 , + * ) , ƒ . , & $ 8+" + $ C# 8+ " * + '7
2884 @ $ 4- ,, X 81
289$ m# s । $ s & 4 KC ( >- / )। + 81 +r 8+" + #
290; @ । & * ` & $ &# 34 ,
291) 3 "+ X e 4- l? –
292/{/ T& / / ? /B/ + `
29301 2 $4$ 34 •* 6* $4j । $ 34 •* 6* • ( >-Ⅰ)। ` & ) & :=(0 # $ $: 4& ) 01 2 $4$ 5# 67
2948 9& X )+ +T L Nm 7
295/{/ 4 $ KC । $ )+ +T LN ( >- ?)। ` & s X /
2967+r + &: 01 2 $4$ $
2974- B? 8D & ?* : (3 * , /* .* : &C &C , &C * + '7
2983 (3 @ :& $ 4- ,,
'jm# 3 4 , + * ) । ' )_ &C * 8 D& @
299। 8 O 3 81 * 01 2 $4$ F &# $:
300) & :=(0 # +r 4- 0 1/+r/? {/ ? – ,/B/ ? T& &C * 01 2 $4$ $ G
301[ @ 3 6* 1
3020 š $ + _ (3 +r m । ;M & ` & $ C# 1 3 , › 81 * G m F &# ( %# N * ' / + 8 %f । ;M
30301 2 $4$ ' G$ ^+ @ & :
304/ ' $4t ` # 7+r $4 C । …
3053 ‚* * B, ( $ N ^œ_ 😯
306; । ;M G=> > > B, ( F &# $:
307) & :=(0 # 8 O , &C * / , &C * + '7 .* @ *
308$ । G& $ # › $
309%# 01 2 N %m & 4 $ : 3
3105# 67 8 9& 4& ) 01 2 $4$ 4 ) & :=(0 # $ $: (' + • ) 5#
31167 8 9& 4& ) 01 2 $4$ J 2 ?* : (3 &C * '\ ( & /
312N '+ ( T
313& Y$ Z / C '+ 3 (3
314E$ ' / '+ ( $ 67 ( , {/ { F$ {, $ & . # ( ( ) ( : )#* & ^+ ) $ C3 e & & . # ) e 4- $/?{- ( `- )/{ ?,
315/ / T & : )#* & 'W
316: )#* 4- B -l/ / … & &
317। : )#* & 'W +r ( >- ,)।
318While he was cross-examined by the accused Redwan Ahmed, he stated that ` +/ + / Form + &: ;। ? J2 ;&।
319; M '[ ;& @ । FIR Form- ^ _ 😯 । / /
320;। • ?/ / ।
321&k m 4 &k m $ž
322# ; ;0 । •
323? &k N # ;
324। &k 3 3 ` 😯 । ? 4 +3 $ &C * 😯 ;। #
325…$ ; /{/ । B 7
326;। # U# /B/ ?* : T& * &C * 8 D& B
327& ; । $4 I 0 &) • 81 ' 3
328&/ E$ F
329; B । ? / / s &
330s X ?* : / B/ 😯 ;।
331X +C / B/ । / B/ 0 &t &
332; ` 3 3 m ।
333@ $ + ` 01 2 5 67 89 & : 3 ;& & + । ` &# $ : 3 ;&
01 2 $4$ ' ;
334। @ f + $ &# 3 4
335* ;& । 01 2 $4$ ' F$ & &
3360 ? 0 + ` + । / / ? / B/ + ` ' F$ । $ &# 34 , ) $ m# / / ? / B/ + ` / / ? / B/ + `
33786* •* 6* s । ' F$ )N 01 2 $4$ ' 7* 4 N ` । ' 7* +* s । ? / / + ` $ &# 3 4 , l, .B * । / / ? / B/ + ` 34 •* 6* ;,
338$I । W # / + ` 01 2 $4$ K (# $$ Ÿ $4 ( / Wh
339। / / B/ / + ` $ 8+& C r+0 F &# )C %# Xf $ $3 $4 ( / ^U *& / , 01 2 $4 ( ; । @ $
/ / fj + / ' ;
340Ÿ 'Wh l, ,, B. * :
341। ` & ( 3 m + । $ 3 , / ' ; ' 7* +* + &: & + , @ $ $4$ ?, , /- * & ; 4
342N $4$ 0 &) ;&। $ 3 81 & + )(
343D @ $ 34 86* + '7
344(3 । @ $ ƒ
345Y 3& 3 : ;r 4 ^ # * # । # 01 2 ;& , + + , $4$ $ $3 : ;
346। B.G.M.E.A + + ? : $ + ;&
347। 01 2 %# $ + 3 + 3 %m & $4t ` " # * : 3
348। ƒ ¢ ,H *& &G ¢ , |&) ¢ $ Ÿ $ $ 4£X * $ $3 ; &
349। ' | & )C h h
350। $ 3 ) # / 01 2 &C * E$ F 8 V)¨ ;& । $ 3
351J2 D # : )#* & ;।
352@ $ $4$ : 3 +T : 3 ;&
353` । 01 $ # @
354Not Sent $ C# ;। @ +T # : 3 :=(0 # + 3 $4t ` & # $
355;& । @ $ : 3 @ $ : 3 ;&
356। :=(0 # @ $ $ 0g ; ` । / / 01 2 5# 67 89 & # * $
357। 81 : 4 , , ? > $ : 4- , , , > & : 4 , , 3 )।
358. $ / . & $ C# [ । : 4, , , / , , * , &–N * + '7
359(3 @ 8 6* ;
3603 +r । 81 * + '7 (3
361; ` + ;। * ' 7* +* &
362; / / ? / B/ + `$ ।
363/ ' F$ 01 2 $4$
364/ # $ । 01 2 $4$ 3 *
365; । / ' F$ ' 7* 'W # $ )N , B, , l. , * : ; ।
36601 2 $4$ 01 2 m im j +
3674 01 2 $4$ im + । $ 3 / ' F$ ,B , ? /- * * 3
368;। 81 ' F$ 34 8 D& l , , . * { . * ) ;
369। ' 1* 01 2 @ $ ' ; $4$ i ; $ 3 । $ 3 c(0 @ ; im j ; ?, , /* , ) & :=(0 # B, ( N K# T
3701 & U# L* "& 0 1 2 N %m &
371%# J (' G$ J )। ) & :=(0 # … 3 ‚*
372; Kw ;& 4 ;& ।
$ C# @ &# Kw ;& $ 3
373@ jG + $ C# @ &# § 3 ‚* ; ;। ,/B/ ? +r ( >-B) 3 6*7 š $ ‚ 7 m
374;। 7 ) @ 4& ) 01 2 $4$ 8D ƒ & ;। $ 81 : I j
375; 7 3 ।
376K# । :I 7 ) G* +
377$ 3 । $ 3 @ 81•+
378m । $ 3 / / + #
379‘ ( $ 81 : I $ X _ ; । @
380%f ; & &
381। # $ & 01 2 67
38289 & $ $3 ; & & + ।
383# 01 2 ;& $4j
384। / ' F$ 01 2 5# 67
38589 & # $ $3 $ C# ।
386/ ' F$ 01 2 $4$ 5# 67
8 9& ' 7* [ $ )# 67 ž #
387;& । 01 2 $4$ $ $ + (' )
388# Z# # / $: ( )$ ) 0 ;¨ $4$ $ ; im j m [ * +r N ` । $ 3
389# 01 2 $4$ $4 ©_ 31 । 01 2 $4$ @ ; im
3904) + )( ; $ 3 । $ 3 Accounting / Audit N + … N $I ` । $ 3 ('œ_) ‘ ( $ ;0 NM % # R ' +r &
391;। $ 3 @ J2'
392$ ‘/ < NM % # R ' 3
393;। $ f &# & $ &
394* $ $3 $ C# [ m
395।$ 3 '$ 3 $ C# & ।
396While he was cross-examined by the accused Shah Alam Chowdhury, he stated that L* , F$ l $,
+ & ;। $ *? & ` #
397। / / ` cJ । / / ` )N । `
398; $ & + । $ 3 )
399& :=(0 # & / [ '[ &
400[ 01 2 $4$ * ।$ 3 $4t ` ) & :=(0 # T
401'+ ( & Y$ Z । $ 3
402) & :=(0 # 01 2 $4$ *
403E$ F । $ 3 ) & :=(0 # 01 2 $4$ * E$ N 8 $ ।$ 3
404) & :=(0 # 67 ( , {/ { ( '+ (
405। $ 3 ) & :=(0 # $ . # (
406( ) ( '+ ( । ) & :=(0 # B, ( U [ G 74 (3 … 3 ‚* * +I ।
407` cJ C.D + &: ;।
408` # ) & :=(0 # G 74
409(3 3 ‚* ;G 7 । ) &
:=(0 # N K# U# # / 3 ‚* ; ;। $ 3 / +2
410&+ & ` ;। + &:
411;। $ 3 😯 : ?* s & T& s ।? / / s & ,( ) t : /B/ & ;। $ 3 )+ j C ;& । < $ )+ j C ;&। । $ 3 &
412Ÿ ;। $ 3 (
413( +& ` & ) & :=(0 # N# $ 3" + ।
414D.W. 1, Redwan Ahmed, in his examination-in-chief stated that $ # $ $ C# w। # +T : । + ;। 4& ) 01 2 $4$ 01 2 I * $ # $4 I । 01 2 $4$ h $ – $4 I । $ & $ 01 2 N %m & I । %# ;& । # 01 2
4158 9& I । /,/ । ,/ / 01 2 Ÿ $4 I – ( & ।
416+ 01 2 $4$ – । 01 2 %m & fj 01 2 $4$ : 3 ; & '(3C s&
4170 :=(0 #। $ & BNP C
418$ + t – 4 $4$ Ÿ
419& * + $ 0 & । 01 2 $4$ $: , $ : 3 / ' & $
420; $ । & :=(0 #
421& + * 3 " । $
422_$ $ + * & $ 7 । < & $ $ & $ $3 $ $@ $2 ` :=(0 # '+$ $2 ` । $ $ $@ 01 2 $4$ 5 89 & : 3 , F$ [। 81 & $ $ : 3 ?
423$ : / '[ [ & Ÿ+ +T Z * I । B/ / $ 01 2 $4$ 5 67 8 9& ' G $ 4 8 9&
*4 fj । && G 67
424* + $ । ; $ 3: । ?/ / ,{l, ,B. /- *
425। $ C , ' $ž / $: (' ) K C 8– * j । i $ j । 81 8: G* + & & । D* 3
426+ / / / 2 & * ;&। 01 2 $4$ Ÿ$ 'Wh । $G& 3 $ #, 6*$ & / +N & $ ?
427$ 76* ;& । $ [ ; * : ।
428&& *$ 4 * 4 * G । / / $ + f * 8 9& *4 । 81 89 & S +)
429$ $ 01 2 $4$ ; i j 4 * * $
430* G । < $ $2 ` * + +r m । # Z# & KC
43181 : I । 81 $ $2 ` G * + 4 T :I & & & । r+0 )C %# Xf
432* * 01 0 2 Ÿ ;0 [ $
4334 B 7 $k $ +& [* &
434& * & । # Z# & 81
435& * 3 ; 4 * ; 4
436h N #8 + [ & * i : * :I । 81 : I + & & ।
437& * i & । ?/ /
438# Z# $ & $ ) m
439* :I 4 $ + # B ) : K (# $ 'Wh $ 01 2 $@
440) , $4 ( 3 'Wh [ & *
441& +r । 81 + r + & & । 01 2 $4$ F$ & & &
4420 ? ) 0 + `। f j + ? ) 0 / + `' | & 'Wh । $$ & B 7 $k $ +& , r+0 )C %# $4 ( , ? G¯ #
44301 2 $4$ ? F$ +T , B ) : K (# $ 8 + ,? ) & 01 2 $ $
444ƒ / + $4 ( , Z -0 K ) 3 $, 0 $ / 8 ) N #। /B/ # Z# #
445+r G ; *
446?, , /- * i ; 4 *
447X * i + )( । 81 : I +
448& & । $ : (' ) & * : ; *)#* /। $: (' ) $ $ * )# * + । 81 * )# * G* + & & । ' F$ 3 $ ' 7* । – ' F$ $ ) 67
449ž # ' 7* । 81 ' 7* + * $ C , ' $: (' ) / KC ;। 81 ' 7* + * + &
450& । 81 + * ; i 4 * : 😯 ;। i + ) ( , , , /* l 4 + Xh 😯 ;। ` # –
' F$ ' 7* +* + &: । 😯 & * * : 8 6* ।
451* : ; * ž # 6„ ° $
452;। &$ / &। & * + '7
453(3 01 2 $4$ ;। N $ C
454> s&
4550 / ' G$ ^+ @ & 3 ;
456+ & & । @ &# X ।
457# WJ& $& X 01 2
4584& ) 01 2 $4$ ++ … । … +
459& & । ƒ Y 3& 3 : LLB ($@ ) / LLM ; r। ^ # * # / ƒ # $ $3। { { $ & $4$ $ h $4$ $ $3 ;& । { $ & + S
460# J2 01 2
4610 ;। 4& )
462h 6*$ 3 $ #। :& 3 $ h
463: # $ /B & * । {l $ & @ & : U h
464;। 01 2 $ & h ;। ) #
4658 & ;। * £0& * & £0&
466;। , $4$ $ $3 %# ;& । : U
467Ÿ j ? * 3& h ; 4
468$ $ # ;। = , & * E$ [ J2 3 & ;।
469N।
470While he was cross-examined by the prosecution, he stated that 4& ) 01 2 $4$ G 67 *
471: [ ( # & ;। $ 3 *
472,% * c(0 r ." / '$ / 01 2 $ 3 [। $ 3 )# )#
473[ 81 ' 3 ( । 8: 4- ?/ / j # KC * & ;। j # KC KC । 8:
474* 3 😯 । $ 3 &
475: [ 8: * $ X & ;। 0 1/$ >/ { ( )/ ?/ / * 01 2 $4$ +3 7 $ X & ;। :I*
4768 V)3 & ; :I + 😯 ।
477# Z# KC #: । $ 3
478:I* ; +0 [ M
479+ * $ ;। :I / /
4800 &) + & ;। $ 3 0 &) * e # / # $X * । $ $2 ` # * (3 0 &) $4 C । $ 3 0 &) + । $ 3 :I 4 0 &) + # * $ $3 KC
4814 :I # Z# ।
482# Z# C 3 1 ;&। + C
483। $ 3 e 4-l /
484– / / , e 4- , / ?/ / , e 4- B / /B/
485|& $X_ ;। $ 3 $ |& $² & & & ;। $ 3 $ |& 0I 0M + $
486; +0 । $ 3 $( m # *
:I f $: +& । #
487* $2 ` :I $: X KC &
488। # * $2 ` # Z# $ & 'Wh f ;&। $ $3
489)_ * ;&। : | & h ^3 ।
490😯 : * ž # ;।
491ž # : ^3 । ?* : (3 *
492, , /- * Cash. '[ * , , /- * $ / '+ * , , /- * & । $ 3
493&C * : |& # 'jm# 3 4 ) ,, 4 $ + '7 / &C * 3) + [ F & $: )
494& :=(0 # &। $ 3 ) & :=(0 # $ 'W # ;। $ 3 $: ( )$ )KC e
4954-? {/ ? ,/B/ ? T & 'W # j
496&C * G [ +r ;। 81 :I । $ 3 $: :+
497; * [। h & Account
Payee : (3 +
498$ । $ 3 $ # 'W
499h & । $$ & $ $ *
500& X , , /-* & & $X_ G* + & ;। : / 3 )
501+ # & : [ & ;। $ 3 '$F 8 V )3 | & $X_ ;। $ 3 $X X ' 7*
502+* & ; 4 01 2 $4$ 3 + । $ 3 ' 7* +** $ 3 & X
503+C X $ 3 । $ 3 ' 7* + * l 4 + Xh & , , , /- * / , 4 + Xh ?, , /- * & |&
504X $X । 01 2 $4$ Account
505/B/ * &C * : (3 8 D& । Bank Statement 😯 ;। Account , &C * +-'7 (3 ;। $ 3 $: ( )$ ) ) & :=(0 # $ $ $ (3 $ ( %# &
506&C * E$ N & N
507* 4 L* $ 3 + 01 2 %m &
508% 4 01 2 $4$ : 3 + ' 3 । $ 3 01 2 $4$ &C *
509E$ ; & # * 0 &)
510& + ।$ 3 ' 01 2 $4$ ( & ) & :=(0 # : I (3 * G : ; । $ 3 C +* *
511E$ ;। $ 3 D.W-1 $ 01 2 $4$ i 4 G 4 $ $
512+r & ; '$ 3, D # ।
513D.W. 2, Kazi Jahangir Amir, Vice Chairman, Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangsad Central Command Council, in his examination-in-chief stated that
51401 2 5# 67 8 9& $ : 3 ;& ।
51501 2 $4$ 5# 67 8 9& ' F$ &
5160 + `। $ & '° $ F &# $ : 3 $ + f * & $ ।
517& $ F &# 01 2 $4$ : 3 '(3C
518s&
5190 :=(0 # '+$ @ : 3 , $ : 3 / ? $: $
520+ 0 * I । $ : 3 1
5210 । 01 2 $4$ ' " & ;& । 01 2 $4$ : # / $ $3 / 4 $4$ : & * / 7 $k
522$ @ $ + f *$ । $ $2 ` @ ; i
523$ * $4$ t :& । $ $2 `
524:I (3 @ ;। $ ?/ / 0 1/$ >/ {( )/ :I ( >-
525) / KC ( >- / )। +
526@ ; & i । 81 * :
527; @ $ / / :I
528' 4 86*$ । $
529/ / :I ( >- ) / KC ( >-
530/ )। 81 : I . * 'Wh [ &C * & 😯 ;। + h N #+& [
531& * i $ j । 81 * :
532& 3 3 ?/ / @
533* :I । $ ?/ / :I ( >-
534) / KC ( / )। 81 : I K (# $ +& [ & i : 4 ?& i j ।
535– ' F$ 01 2 $4$ @
536; * ?& B / * i j । *
537* +/ + @ * G
538/B/ @ :I । $ /B/ :I ( >-L) / KC ( >-L/ )। 01 2 $4$ @ ;0 * G ; * ; ।
539While he was cross-examined by the prosecution, he stated that ?/ / :I* 8 V)3 & ; 😯 । + I 😯
540। KC #: । $ 3 :I m # * $ । $ 3 :I + # $X $² & & & ;। $ 3
:I* ; +0 । e k 3 & *
541_ । $ _ + & ।
542:I C +r ;। $ C +r &
543। $ 3 KC ?/ / , / / , ?/ / :I m @ 01 2 $4$ i । i
544& । $ 3
545@ 01 2 $4$ i । $ 3
546@ 01 2 $4$ * E$ F ; 4 & / + 81 & : [
54781 | & $X_ & ;। $ 3 $ # 'W h 31 ; i
548( । " # $ %m & *
549,% * c(0 r ." 0 1 2 &3 3 $ 3 । $ 3 )+ j ." 01 2 ' @ E$ F
550: [ '$ 3 $ C# & ।
551After recording the evidences as stated above and on consideration of the materials on record, the learned Special Judge of Special Judge Court No. 2, Dhaka convicted the appellant under section 409 of the Penal Code and sentenced him there under to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 3 (three) years and also to pay a fine of Tk. 50,00,000.00 (fifty lac) and acquitted the accused Shah Alam Chowdhury of the charge under sections 409 and 109 read with section 5(2) of the Prevention of corruption Act.
552Afterwards, the appellant filed an application to the Ministry of Home Affairs for suspending the operation of the execution of the sentence passed against him. The Ministry of Home Affairs, having considered the prayer and on the basis of the opinion of the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs, under section 401 of the Criminal Procedure suspended the execution of the sentence of the appellant vide Notification No.
55358.00.0000.085.04.003.24-333 dated 21.10.2024 and he was also permitted to file the appeal. Accordingly, the convict appellant filed the present appeal.
554Mr. S M Shahjahan, the learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of convict appellant, by referring rule 4 of the Anti Corruption of Commission Rules, 2007 has submitted that with regard to any schedule offence, FIR can be lodged with Police Station, and after two days of lodging the FIR, police will send the case to the Anti Corruption Commission for investigation but this case was sent after five months of the FIR which is violation of the Rules. The learned Advocate further submits that in the charge sheet it was not mentioned as to whether any sanction was accorded or filed along with the charge sheet.
555This is also violation of section 32 of the Anti Corruption Commission Act, 2004. Referring to the FIR, Mr. S M Shahjahan, the learned Advocate also submits that the convict appellant, Mr. Redwan Ahmed, paid Taka 20,00,000.00 (twenty lac) to Mr. Kabir Ahmed and Mr.
556Shah Alam Chowdhury in presence of Mr. Sofiqul Islam Robi, the then Vice Chairman of the Muktijoddha Sangsad, Abdus Sattar, member of the Sangsad, and the informant.
557But they did not deposit the money for which the audit authority recommended to take legal action against those
Kabir Ahmed and Shah Alam Chowdhury but the Muktijoddha Sangsad authority did not take any legal action against them. Referring to the cross examination of P.W. 1, the learned Advocate contends that P.W. 1 has candidly replied that “2007 m‡b Avwg©i K_vg‡Zv Avwg GRvnv‡i ¯^vÿi Kwi” which clearly shows that upon pressure of Army after one-eleven, the informant was forced to file the case against the appellant though the appellant did not commit any offence. By referring to the impunged judgment, the learned Advocate further contends that co-accused Md.
558Shah Alam Chowdhury while making confession statement implicated the appellant in the case which is exculpatory in nature and as such the same can not be termed as confessional statement on the basis of which the conviction and sentence passed by the Trial Court is not sustainable in law. Referring to section 409 of the Penal Code, the learned Advocate also contends that the appellant was not entrusted with any property or any money as a public servant and as such section 409 of the Penal Code does not attract the appellant in this case. The learned Advocate submits that the prosecution has miserably failed to prove that there was
an entrustment and misappropriation of entrusted money by the appellant, and as such the judgment and order of conviction of sentence passed by the Trial Court under section 409 of the Penal Code against the convict appellant can not be sustainable in law, and as such the same is liable to be set aside. Accordingly, the learned Advocate has submitted that this criminal appeal may kindly be allowed by setting aside the impugned judgment and order of conviction and sentence.
559The learned Deputy Attorney General appeared in this matter but none was present on behalf of the AntiCorruption Commission.
560I have considered the submissions of the learned Advocate for the convict appellant and gone through the FIR, depositions, impugned judgment and order, other materials on record and the relevant law.
561It appears from the records that the FIR was lodged upon an allegation brought under section 409 of the Penal Code against the convict appellant and two other accused namely- (1) Mr. Shah Alam Chowdhury and (2) Mr. Kabir Ahmed Khan, and charge sheet was submitted under
section 409 of the Penal Code read with section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 against the appellant and another accused Mr. Shah Alam Chowdhury, but the accused Mr. Kabir Ahmed Khan was not sent up in the charge sheet and charge was framed against the appellant and accused Mr. Shah Alam Chowdhury under sections 409 and 109 of the Penal Code read with section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947.
562The learned Special Judge of the Special Judge Court No. 2, Dhaka by his judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 14.08.2023 convicted the appellant under section 409 of the Penal Code and sentenced him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 3 years with a fine of Tk.
56350,00,000.00 (fifty lac). The impugned judgment was passed in absence of the appellant. It appears that after the judgment the appellant filed an application to the Ministry of Home Affairs and after taking opinion from the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs, the Ministry of Home Affairs has suspended the operation of the execution of the sentence for 1 (one) year and the appellant was
permitted to prefer appeal before this Court. Accordingly, he filed this appeal.
564So, the point involved in the appeal for adjudication as to whether section 409 of the Penal Code does attract in case of the appellant and whether the conviction and sentence against him by the impugned judgment is lawful or not.
565It appears that the FIR was lodged on an allegation of criminal breach of trust. In section 405 of the Penal Code criminal breach of trust has been defined as follows:
566“Section 405.- Whoever, being in any manner
567entrusted with property, or with any dominion
568over property, dishonestly misappropriates or
569converts to his own use that property, or
570dishonesty uses or disposes of that property in
571violation of any direction of law prescribing the
572mode in which such trust is to be discharged, or
573of any legal contract, express or implied, which
574he has made touching the discharge of such
575trust, or willfully suffers any other person so to
576do, commits ‘criminal breach of trust’.”
577Upon a plain reading of the above section, it appears that the essential ingredients for an offence of criminal breach of trust are:
578(i) the accused must have been entrusted with
579property or with dominion over property;
580(ii) (a) the accused must have
581misappropriated or converted to his own
582use, that property; or
583(b) used or disposed of that property in
584violation of any direction of law
585prescribing the mode in which such
586trust is to be discharged; or
587(c) used or disposed of the property in
588violation of any legal contract (express
589or implied) which he has made touching
590the discharge of such trust ; or
591(d) willfully suffered any other person
592so to do ;
593(iii) such misappropriation or user or
594disposal must be dishonest or such
595sufferance must be willful. [AIR 1953 SC
596478; 1954 Cr LJ 102]
597So, as per section 405 of the Penal Code entrustment is an essential ingredient of an offence of criminal breach of trust. A man can not be held guilty of the offence under section 409 of the Penal Code and can not be convicted under the same section unless he or she is entrusted with something.
598Now let us examine whether the convict appellant was entrusted with any property in any manner and whether the convict appellant dishonestly misappropriates or converts to that property his own use in violation of any direction of law prescribing the mode in which such entrustment is to be discharged or of any legal contract. It is the settled principle of law that the prosecution has to prove the prosecution case by evidence. It appears that allegation of criminal breach of trust, cheating and misappropriation of Tk. 50,00,000.00 (fifty lac) has been made in the FIR against the convict appellant and two other accused namely- Saha Alam Chowdhury and Md. Kabir Ahmed Khan. Interestingly, it has been mentioned in the FIR that :
599😯 3 , $4$ : 3 + 81 $ + 3 + 😯 * (3 81 $
60020,00,000.00 ( ) &C) * ;& $4$ $ : 3 ) GH& $& / $4$ $ $3 ; D $ 4 8+ " 81
601/ 81 ) & ; । `0 81 ) &C * / r) &C * (55) /) & (55) ; $ $ * &C * / &/ + `* ।
602N ' 7* X
603+C 81 31 J2 3 " j m [ ^+ ) ; । `0 $4$ X
604+C
605# [ + C+ ।
606It is clear from the contents of the FIR that the informant himself has stated and admitted in the alleged FIR that the appellant Mr. Redwan Ahmed has paid returned 20,00,000.00 (twenty lac) (which he burrowed) to the other two accused namely Kabir Ahmed Khan and Shah Alam Chowdhury in presence of present Vice Chairman Shofiqul Islam Robi, Sangsad member Sattar Saheb and the
informant. But these two accused persons did not deposit Tk. 50,00,000.00 (fifty lac) including aforesaid Tk.
60720,00,000.00 (twenty lac) which was handed over by the appellant to the aforesaid accused persons and as such, the audit authority, while conducting the audit, recommended the Sangsad authority to take legal action against the aforesaid accused persons but the Sangsad authority did not take any action against them for the reasons best known to them. It would be more explicit if I requoted the relevant sentence of the FIR that 8 O 3 , $4$ : 3 + 81 $ + 3 + 😯 * (3 81 $ 20,00,000.00 ( ) &C * ) ;& $4$
608$ : 3 ) GH& $& / $4$ $ $3 ; D $ 4 8+ " 81 / 81 ) & ; । (underlined for emphasized).
609From the above version of the informant, it appears that there is no allegation against the convict appellant.
610Moreover, nowhere in the FIR it has been established that the appellant was entrusted by any documentary evidence
with the property or dominion over the property as required under section 405 of the Penal Code. Furthermore, on examination of the depositions of the prosecution witnesses, it does not appear that there was any entrustment upon the convict appellant with the property or dominion over the property rather it can easily be said that the prosecution has failed to prove that the convict appellant was entrusted with the property or with the dominion over the property as provided in section 405 of the Penal Code.
611So, the elements of entrustment are absent in the instant case and as such, the allegations brought against the convict appellant do not fall within the mischief of section 405 of the Penal Code. Consequently, the conviction and sentence handed down upon the appellant under section 409 of the Penal Code can not be sustainable in law, and the same is liable to be set aside.
612It appears that while D.W.1 was examined, he deposed that $G& 3 $ #, 6*$ & / +N & $ ? $ 76* ;& । $ [
613; * : । && * $
6144 * 4 * G ।
615/ / $ + f * 8 9&
616*4 । 81 89 & S +) $ $
61701 2 $4$ ; i j 4 *
618* $ * G । < $ $2 ` * + +r
619m । # Z# # KC 81 : I
620। 81 $ $2 ` G* + 4 T :I
621& &
622& ।( ) # 4 , 4 )।
623And he further deposed that /B/ #
624Z# # +r G ;
625* ?, , /- * i ; 4 *
626X * i + )( । 81 : I +
627& & । $ : (' ) & * : ; *)#* /। $: (' ) $ $ * )# * + । 81 * )# * G* + & & ।( ) # 4 L)।
628D.W. 2 supported the statements of D.W. 1 and both the D.Ws. denied the suggestions given by the prosecution.
629It also appears that P.W.1 in his cross examination admitted the above statements of P.W.1 and stated that / / $ $2 ` 01 2 67
63089 & 34 $ / * ' 0& –
631' ; g g $ 89 & 'Wh $ # ' 89 & : 3 @
632* 8 9& i j ? /B/
633(3 : 3 @ + )(
634c ;।
635Thus, P.W.1 admitted that on 01.12.2021 a resolution was passed by the Muktijoddha Sangsad Command Council that they would borrow money from the appellant to bear the experditures of various events of the sangsad and the said loan amount would be paid by 30.06.2002.
636It also appears that as per the admission of the informant, the convict appellant took Tk. 20,00,000.00 (twenty lac) form the Muktijoddha Sangsad and he returned the same through the other two accused. It is alleged that
the two other accused did not deposit the same in the account of the Sangsad. So, it may at best be said that said money was lying for some times in the hands of the appellant. In the case of A.K.M. Hafizuddin Vs. the State, 15 BLD (HCD) 234, on similar circumstances, it has been held that mere retention of money for some time without actual use of it or mere delay in payment of the money due from the accused, if properly explained, will not constitute any offence under section 409 of the Penal Code.
637In the case of Shakir Hussain Vs. the State, 9 DLR (SC) 14, it has been held that where the charge against an accused person is that of criminal breach of trust, the prosecution must prove not only entrustment of or dominion over property but also that the accused either dishonestly misappropriated, converted, used or disposed of that property himself or that he wilfully suffered some other person to do so.
638Thus above two decisions are relevant and applicable in the facts of the present case and it should be considered.
639It is required to be mentioned that in the FIR the specific allegation was made against the accused Shah
Alam Chowdhury and Md. Kabir Ahmed Khan but the investigating officer while holding investigation and submitting charge sheet did not send up the accused Shah Alam Chowdhury and recommended to relieve from the charge. And the learned Judge of the Trial Court while passing the impugned judgment acquitted the other accused Md. Kabir Ahmed Khan. But it is not understandable as to under what basis and materials the appellant was convicted under section 409 of the Penal Code inspite of the fact that the elements of entrustment are absent rather the prosecution could not prove by any documentary evidence that the appellant was entrusted with property or dominion over property as required under section 405 of the Penal Code.
640On perusal of the depositions of the bank officials i.e.
641P.Ws. 2 and 5, it appears that the aforesaid 3 (three)
642cheques were bearer cheques and did not contain the name of the convict appellant. The convict appellant as D.W. 1 categorically denied the allegations made against him. P.W.
6431 i.e. the informant of this case in his cross examination categorically and explicitly admitted that 2007 m‡b Avwg©i
K_vgZ Avwg GRvnvi ¯^vÿi Kwi| In view of the above facts and circumstances and the decisions referred above, there is no gainsaying to hold that the prosecution has miserably failed to prove the case against the convict appellant. Moreover, I have already found that there is no entrustment upon the appellant with the property or dominion over the property as per section 405 of the Penal Code.
644For the reasons and discussions made hereinabove, I have found substance in the submissions of the learned Advocate for the appellant as well as merit of the appeal and as such the impugned judgment and order of conviction of sentence against the appellant is liable to be set aside.
645In the result, the appeal is allowed.
646Thus, the judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 14.08.2023 passed by the learned Special Judge, Special Judge Court No. 2, Dhaka in Special Case No. 14 of 2007 (Metro Special Case No. 133 of 2007), arising out of Ramna Police Station Case No. 40 dated 15.02.2007, convicting the appellant under section 409 of the Penal Code and sentencing him to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for 3 years with a fine of Tk. 50,00,000.00 (fifty lac) is hereby set aside.
647The convict appellant is acquitted of the charge levelled against him.
648The appellant is discharged from the bail bond furnished earlier.
649Send down the records.
650Communicate the judgment.
651(Md. Khasruzzaman, J:)
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











