High Court Division · Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction
Jahsim Uddin Ahmed v The State and another
Criminal Appeal(H) 9274/2021 · Decided 15 June 2026
On a first information report lodged by an Assistant Director of the Anti-Corruption Commission, the appellant was charged with obtaining employment with Jiban Bima Corporation in 1979 by submitting a forged Secondary School Certificate and serving until his retirement in 2017. The Special Judge, Court No. 8, Dhaka, convicted him under sections 420, 467, 468 and 471 of the Penal Code and sentenced him to one year's rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Tk. 50,000. The High Court Division found that the recruitment circular was never recovered, so it was not established that an SSC certificate was a mandatory requirement; that the complaint was made by the appellant's elder brother in his personal capacity amid a land dispute; and that no witness identified who fabricated the certificate or showed the appellant knew it was false. These gaps created reasonable doubt. The conviction was held perverse and unsupported by legally sustainable evidence, the appeal was allowed and the appellant was acquitted.
Appeal allowed; appellant acquitted
- Q1
Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant forged, or knowingly used as genuine, a forged SSC certificate to obtain employment with Jiban Bima Corporation.
- Where the prosecution fails to produce the recruitment circular, it cannot be conclusively established that an SSC certificate was a mandatory prerequisite for the post or that the accused used it to gain employment by deception.
- A non-speaking complaint lodged by the accused's brother in his personal capacity, rather than by the employer, amid personal animosity casts severe suspicion on the bona fides of the prosecution.
- In the absence of evidence linking the accused to the fabrication or to knowing use of a forged document, charges under sections 420, 467, 468 and 471 of the Penal Code cannot be sustained.
- Without proof of who forged the document, the court cannot presume that the accused was the forger.
- The cumulative discrepancies created a reasonable doubt whose benefit must go to the accused, and the conviction was perverse and set aside.
Without proving who forged the document, the Court cannot presume that the appellant was the forger, specially when the complaint is lodged by a brother with a history of animosity.
In the court’s own words.
Criminal Appeal(H) 9274/2021, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 22 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2HIGH COURT DIVISION (CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION)
Present:
3Mr. Justice Md. Bashir Ullah
4Criminal Appeal No. 9274 of 2021
5In the matter of:
6An Appeal under Section 10 of the Criminal
7Law Amendment Act, 1958.
8And
9In the matter of:
10Md. Jahsim Uddin Ahmed
…Convict-Appellant
11-Versus-
12The State and another
…Respondent
13Mr. Md. Khurshid Alam Khan, Senior Advocate
with
14Mr. Md. Moniruzzaman Rana with Mr. Sanjana Arvy with Mr. Robiul Islam with Mr. Manik Chan and Mr. Moniruzzaman Sobuj, Advocates
…For the Appellant
15Mr. S. M. Iqbal Bahar Bhuiyan, Advocate
…For the Respondent No.2
16Mr. Md. Shafiquil Islam, D.A.G with Ms. Farhana Abedin, A.A.G with Mr. Hemayth Uddin, A.A.G and Mr. K. M. Saiful Islam, A.A.G
… For the State
17Heard on: 08.03.2026, 17.05.2026, 19.05.2026 , 20.05.2026 and 21.05.2026
18Judgment on: 15.06.2026
This appeal, preferred under Section 10 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act, 1958 is directed against the judgment and order dated 23.11.2021, passed by the learned Special Judge, Court No. 8, Dhaka in Special Case No. 02 of 2020 arising out of Motijheel Police Station Case No. 29 dated 26.02.2019 corresponding to A.C. G.R. No. 52 of 2019 convicting the accused under Sections 420/467/468 and 471 of the Penal Code and sentencing him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 01 (one) year with a fine of Taka 50,000/-, in default to suffer simple imprisonment for 01(one) month more.
19The facts, relevant for disposal of the appeal, in short, are that PW 1, Md. Abdul Kader Bhuiya, Assistant Director, Anti- Corruption Commission (ACC), Head Office, Dhaka lodged a First Information Report (FIR) with Motijheel Model Police Station on 26.02.2019 alleging inter alia that the accused secured employment as a Junior Assistant Cum Typist with Jiban Bima Corporation on 01.10.1979 by submitting a fabricated Secondary School Certificate (S.S.C.) as genuine and continued in service until his retirement on 30.06.2017. During the inquiry, the inquiry officer came to learn from the Head Master of Mograpara HGGS Smriti School that the accused, Jashim Uddin Ahmed sat for the
S.S.C examination in 1974 in the Humanities group but had failed. Thereafter, the said Certificate was subsequently sent to the Controller of Examinations of Dhaka Board who opined it to be forged and pursuant to the direction of the higher authority the instant case was instituted against the accused.
20On closure of the investigation, the investigating officer submitted charge sheet No. 234 dated 09.07.2019 against the accused under Sections 420/467/468 and 471 of the Penal Code.
21Subsequently, the case was transferred to the learned Special Judge, Court No. 8, Dhaka which was registered as Special Case No. 02 of 2020. Upon hearing the parties, learned Special Judge, Court No. 8, Dhaka thereafter framed charges against the accused under sections 420/467/468 and 471 of the Penal Code on 14.09.2020 to which the accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
22In course of the trial, 11(eleven) prosecution witnesses were examined while the defence examined none. The accused was examined under Section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure when he repeated his innocence.
23Upon conclusion of trial and hearing the parties, the learned Special Judge, Court No. 8, Dhaka convicted the accused under
Section 420/467/468 and 471 of the Penal Code and sentenced him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 01 (one) year with a fine of Taka 50,000/-.
24Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the judgment and order of conviction and sentence the convict preferred this instant Criminal Appeal before this Court. This Court enlarged the appellant on bail on 22.12.2021, which was lastly extended till disposal of the appeal on 04.12.2022.
25Mr. Md. Khurshid Alam Khan, the learned Senior Advocate along with Mr. Md. Moniruzzaman Rana, the learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellant contends that there is a critical discrepancy which exists between the signature on the application for appointment (Material Exhibit-III) and joining letter (Material Exhibit-IV). The court did not take any step for opinion of a handwriting expert to review the signature. Furthermore, the appointment letter as Junior Assistant dated 03.12.1979 (Exhibit-VI) references a prior application dated 24.08.1978 which the Investigating Officer failed to seize. This omission casts a grave doubt on the authenticity and integrity of the prosecutions documentary evidence.
26He further submits that the Special Judge framed charges under sections 420/467/468 and 471 of the Penal Code; but it was defective under the proviso of section 222 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, so it vitiates the entire proceeding, as such the conviction and sentence may kindly be set aside.
27He next submits that the P.W.1 namely Md. Abdul Kader Bhuiyan, in his cross-examination stated that " ,
, PRL
28ু ! z” This testimony creates doubt as to when the certificate was submitted and who submitted it. Furthermore, P.W.11 in his cross examination stated that " ,
" #$ % &ু '
ু , ( ) *+ (
29" considering that the appeal may kindly be allowed for the ends of justice.
30He next argues that PW 5, namely Topon Kumar Sarker, who was the former controller of examinations, in his crossexamination stated that he did not know who fabricated the certificate as such the statement creates doubt and raises a question as to who is the main culprit in the commission of this alleged offence and no hand-writing expert was called to establish that the appellant was the fabricator.
31Learned Advocate contends that P.W. 6 namely Md. Delowar Hossain, in his cross-examination admitted that he is the elder brother of the appellant and he filed the complaint to the Anti-Corruption Commission vide Exhibit No.06/01; because there was a land dispute between them and for that reason several notices were served upon him and arbitration was also held by the concerned local authority. Due to that reason he became furious, and filed the complaint with mens rea. Moreover, from the evidence of P.W-6, it is clear that the matter is a family dispute with regard to the land. A family dispute does not come within the schedule offences of the Anti Corruption Commission.
32He further contends that P.W. 11 namely Md. Abdul Kader Bhuiyan, stated in the cross-examination that the accused was appointed on an adhoc basis and he failed to recover or produce any formal recruitment notice or circular under which the appellant was appointed. The appellant was appointed by the concerned Managing Director (M.D.) under Jiban Bima Corporation at his own choice without publishing any circular. The essential prerequisite that submission of an SSC certificate was a mandatory condition for employment has not been proven.
33This crucial lacuna creates doubt as to the involvement of the accused with mens rea in commission of the alleged offence.
34He argues that the elder brother of the appellant filed the complaint to the Anti-Corruption Commission, having mens rea and thus there is a doubt about the involvement of the accused. In support of his contention, the learned Advocate referred to the decision passed in Mahbub Hossain Vs. The State, reported in 33 BLD (HC)(2013)83.
35He next submits that in connection with this case no act of forgery was committed and who prepared the forged document was not proved. In this connection he referred to the case of Manu Mia and others Vs. the State, reported in 42 DLR 191.
36He next submits that the appellant performed his official duties with the complete satisfaction of the concerned authority. As to the service rules, previous job experience and satisfaction of the authority the appellant was promoted from time to time, and thereafter, retired from the service. So, he has the legitimate expectation of the service benefit at his last stage of life as the Hon'ble High Court Division held in Asaf Khan and others vs. the Court of Settlement, First Court and others, 8 BLC (2003) 1; otherwise, he is suffering a lot considering his humanitarian
condition of life the appeal may kindly be allowed for the ends of justice he is entitled to be acquitted from the charge levelled against him..
37He submits that the definition of forgery has been given in section 463 of the Penal Code. Accordingly, to the definition, it appears that the forgery has not been duly proved by adducing oral and documentary evidence as such the conviction and sentence is not sustainable in the eye of law.
38He submits that from the trend of evidence, it appears that out of grudge with regard to the land dispute, P.W-6 lodged the case only for the humiliation of the convict-appellant and as such, the instant case is engineered by some vested quarter. The matter has been ended by an order of conviction and sentence which creates doubts regarding the bonafideness of the conviction as such the benefit goes to the convict-appellant and he is entitled to the benefit of Section 114 (g) of the Evidence Act.
39He submits that the appellant is a man of advanced age and about 70 years old and there is no previous criminal record against the convict. He has been suffering mental agony since 04.05.2017, though he did not commit the alleged offence.
40He finally prays for allowing the appeal and for setting aside the judgment and order of conviction and sentence.
41Per contra, Mr. S.M. Iqbal Bahar Bhuiyan, the learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent No. 2, contends that the appellant had submitted an application for employment on 25.05.1979 to the Jiban Bima Corporation wherein he mentioned his educational qualification that he was S.S.C pass bearing 2nd Division which is evident from Material Exhibit No. III and the appellant did not deny the application dated 25.05.1979.
42He further submits that the charges of the instant case under Sections 420/467/468/471 of the Penal Code were validly framed against the convict-appellant. In view of the provision laid down in Section 6(1) of the Criminal Law Amendment Act, 1958, the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, should in so far as they are not inconsistent with the Act, apply to the proceedings of the Court of a Special Judge. That the said Act, 1958 does not state anything about the charge and therefore, the provisions of Chapter XIX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 with the heading "OF THE CHARGE" are applicable to the proceedings of the Court of a Special Judge.
43He next submits that the learned Special Judge upon proper assessment of the evidence and materials on record, found the appellant guilty under Section 420/467/468/471 of the Penal Code and thus, rightly convicted him and therefore, the Judgment dated 23.11.2021 is liable to be sustained.
44Mr. Bhuiya submits that on a plain reading of the depositions of the P.W's, all the prosecution witnesses supported the FIR case and although they were cross-examined but the defence could not deviate them from their depositions and relying upon such depositions the learned Special Judge convicted the appellant by the Judgment dated 23.11.2021 which needs to be upheld by this Hon'ble Court.
45He further submits that in view of the Exhibits particularly the Material Exhibit Nos. I, II and III the convict-appellant forged his S.S.C. certificate which he used to be employed in the Jiban Bima Corporation and he is the ultimate beneficiary of such forged certificate and therefore, the conviction is liable to be sustained and the criminal appeal may kindly be dismissed.
46He next submits that the cited decisions are distinguishable and hence are not applicable in the instant case.
47Mr. Bhuiyan contends that the accused used the SSC certificate as a genuine document knowing it was a forged one and he is the sole exclusive beneficiary of the forged document and the allegations against the accused under Sections 420/467/471 and 468 of the Penal Code have been proved and as such the instant appeal is liable to be dismissed.
48I have considered the submissions of the learned Advocates for both sides, perused the impugned judgment and order passed by the trial Court and the materials on records.
49For the proper adjudication of the matter and analysis of the facts on record the prosecution's evidence is reviewed as follows:
50PW1, Abdul Kader Bhuiyan, Assistant Director, Anti- Corruption Commission, informant deposed that he was entrusted with the investigation of the instant case. Upon receipt of the competent authorities sanction order, he proceeded with the investigation. Consequently, he lodged the First Information Report (F.I.R) with Motijheel Police Station on 26.02.2019. During the investigation, he established that the accused, Jashim Uddin had procured employment with Jiban Bima Corporation on 01.10.1979 by utilising a forged Secondary School Certificate (SSC). The Head Master of HGGS Memorial School informed
that Md. Jashim Uddin had appeared for the S.S.C examination in 1974 but had failed. The Controller of Examination of Dhaka Board opined that the subject certificate was a forgery. The accused illicitly served at Jiban Bima Corporation from 01.10.1979 to 30.06.2017 by leveraging the said forged SSC certificate, which prompted the lodging of the case.
51He proved the sanction letter as Exhibit-1, and the FIR as Exhibit-2.
52During cross-examination, he stated that the accused proceeded on Post Retirement Leave (PRL) on 01.07.2017 and the case was lodged against him thereafter. The accused submitted character certificate and testimonial of school at the time of joining the service. He denied the suggestion that the accused had not submitted the forged certificate. Upon his initial appointment, it was interpolated. He further denied the suggestion that the former Upper Divisional Assistant had submitted the forged certificate due to enmity arising from a land dispute.
53He stated that it was untrue that the forged certificate was produced at the time of appointment and that it was only retained and the case lodged when the accused proceeded on PRL.
54PW 2, Md. Helal Uddin, the Deputy Controller of Examination, Dhaka Board, deposed that the register reflected that one Jashim Uddin (Roll No. 40842, Registration No. 28111 of 1972) was recorded as “unsuccessful”. The Assistant Director of the Anti-Corruption Commission seized the tabulation sheet for the S.S.C examination of 1974.
55He proved the seizure list as Exhibit 3.
56PW 3, Din Dawal Ram, Office Assistant at Dhaka Board and a seizure list witness stated that the Assistant Director of A.C.C seized a register from Md. Helal Uddin at his presence. Subsequently, the officer of A.C.C retained the seized register in his custody by executing a Jimmanama (custody bond).
57He proved the Jimmanama as Exhibit-4.
58PW 4, Kazi Sohel, another Office Assistant at Dhaka Board and a seizure list witness deposed that the Assistant Director of the Anti-Corruption Commission arrived on 30.04.2019 and seized a register in his presence. Thereafter, it was placed in the custody of Ram Dawal. He signed the Jimmanama which was exhibited and marked as Exhibit 4/4.
59PW 5, Tapan Kumar Sarker, former Controller of Examinations deposed that the alleged certificate was verified by
him and found that the accused Jasim Uddin had not passed the examination.
60In cross-examination he stated that although the accused appeared for the examination and he failed. He admitted that he possessed no knowledge regarding the identity of the author or fabricator of the disputed certificate.
61PW 6, Md. Delwar Hossain, former Upper Divisional Assistant, Jibon Bima Corporation deposed that he submitted a written complaint before the Chairman of the Anti-Corruption Commission alleging that the accused secured employment in service by submitting a forged certificate. He further stated that he forwarded a copy of the said complaint to the Managing Director of Jiban Bima Corporation.
62He proved the complaint as Exhibit 6.
63In cross-examination, he deposed that the accused is his younger brother and he lodged the complaint with the Anti- Corruption Commission on 04.05.2017. He denied the suggestion that he had facilitated the accused’s employment at Jiban Bima Corporation in 1978. He also denied the suggestion that he lodged the complaint with the ACC due to a land dispute. He admitted that he lodged the complaint first and only thereafter did the
dispute arise. He stated that the residential address of the accused and himself is the same and he could not recall when he first learned that the accused obtained an appointment using a forged certificate. He denied the suggestion that he himself forged the SSC certificate and submitted it. He further denied the suggestion that he secured a position for his younger brother and later lodged the complaint due to enmity.
64PW 7, Premankar Sarkar, Manager (law) and a seizure list witness proved the seizure list as Exhibit 7.
65He produced the impugned SSC certificate as Material Exhibit I, the testimonial as Material Exhibit II, the application for appointment as Material Exhibit III, the Joining letter as Material Exhibit IV, the application for PRL as Material Exhibit V and the permanent and temporary appointment letter as Material Exhibit VI.
66In cross-examination, he denied the suggestion that PW 6 (Delwar, the brother of the accused) had submitted the documents exhibited as material Exhibits I through VI. He stated that he could not verify who actually submitted the certificates into the concerned section.
67PW 8, Md. Hafizur Rahman, Office Assistant and seizure list witness stated that the Assistant Director of A.C.C seized certain documents and entrusted them to Din Dayal Ram. He signed the Jimmanama and proved his signature thereon as Exhibit 4/3.
68PW 9, Md. Ali Hossain, Deputy Manager at Jiban Bima Corporation and seizure list witness deposed that the Assistant Director seized several documents produced by Premankar Sarkar. He signed the seizure list and proved the same as Exhibit 07/02.
69PW 10, Moni Mohan Mondal, Office Assistant and seizure list witness was tendered and declined to cross examination by the defence.
70He proved his signature as Exhibit 07/03.
71PW 11, Abdul Kader Bhuiyan, Investigating Officer deposed that he visited the place of occurrence, seized the materials and recorded statements under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
72He proved sanction letter as Exhibit 8.
73He stated that upon receipt of the sanction letter, he submitted charge sheet No. 234 dated 09.07.2019 against the accused under sections 420/467/468 and 471 of the Penal Code.
74In cross-examination, he stated that the complaint was lodged by PW 6, Delowar Hossain, who is the elder brother of the accused. He conceded that he did not recover the appointment circular pursuant to which the accused was appointed. He denied the suggestion that no educational certificate was required at the time of the accused’s appointment. He also denied the suggestion that the certificate was submitted by the elder brother of the accused owing to the latter’s limited education. He further denied the suggestion that the accused had not submitted any documents whatsoever.
75It appears from the testimony of the Investigating Officer (PW-11) who candidly admitted that the official appointment circular or recruitment notice pursuant to which the accused was inducted into service, was never recovered during the course of the investigation. He stated in his cross-examination that " ড! *. । 0 1, & । ( 23 M.D. $ 45/46 – 7 z"
76The above admission assumes considerable significance. Since the prosecution has failed to produce the foundational
employment circular, it cannot be conclusively established that the submission of a Secondary School Certificate (SSC) was a mandatory prerequisite for the post. The prosecution’s failure to produce this primary document creates a material lacuna failing to establish that the accused used the certificate intending to wrongfully gain employment by practising deception upon the employer.
77It further appears that Delwar Hossain (PW-6) admitted during cross-examination that he is the elder brother of the accused and that they reside at the same ancestral address. Crucially, PW-6 conceded that deep-seated enmity exists between them stemming from an ongoing land dispute.
78Furthermore, the record reveals that the initial complaint is a non-speaking one and the same was lodged before the Anti- Corruption Commission by PW-6 in his personal capacity, rather than by the aggrieved employer, the Jibon Bima Corporation. This circumstance casts severe suspicion on the bona fides of the prosecution's case. It highly probabilizes the defence’s contention that the instant complaint was maliciously motivated by personal animosity, designed primarily to penalize the accused and
maliciously deprive him of his service benefits, gratuity, and pension.
79It is also evident from the record that PW-5, the former Controller of Examinations of the Board of Intermediate and Secondary Education, Dhaka, categorically stated in crossexamination that he possessed no personal knowledge as to the identity of the individual who allegedly fabricated the impugned certificate. Perusal of the record confirms that not a single prosecution witness has advanced any testimony identifying the author of the alleged forgery. Furthermore, the prosecution has failed to adduce an iota of evidence to demonstrate that the accused had knowledge of the certificate’s allegedly spurious nature, or that he used it with dishonest or fraudulent intent. Absence of any evidence linking the accused to either the fabrication or the intentional knowing use of a forged document, the charges under the penal law cannot be sustained. Without proving who forged the document, the Court cannot presume that the appellant was the forger, specially when the complaint is lodged by a brother with a history of animosity.
80It also depicts that there is no evidence to show that the accused had either committed alleged forgery or he knowingly used forged document as genuine in getting his employment.
81The appellant served the state enterprise for a prolonged period, nearly four decades without a single scandal on his administrative record, retiring after standard promotions. Depriving a citizen of liberty and his accrued post-retirement security on the basis of an investigation marred by missing foundational links and motivated by malice violates the core principles of safe criminal adjudication. The prosecution has failed to produce any contemporaneous evidence showing that at any stage during such service period any objection was raised regarding the genuineness of the certificate allegedly submitted by him and clear the threshold of proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
82The cumulative effect of the material discrepancies in the prosecution’s evidence, the absence of the foundational recruitment circular, the personal animosity driving the complaint, and the failure to prove the identity of the forger, all create a pervasive and reasonable doubt regarding the alleged guilt of the
appellant. The benefit arising from such reasonable doubt must necessarily enure to the accused.
83Considering the gravity of the alleged offence, the facts and circumstances of the case, and the ratio passed in the abovementioned decisions, I am of the considered view that the judgment and order of conviction and sentence are found to be perverse, based on conjectures and unsupported by legally sustainable evidence and cannot be sustained in law, and is liable to be set aside.
84I find merit in the appeal and substance in the submissions advanced by the learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellant.
85In the result, the appeal is allowed.
86The judgment and order dated 23.11.2021 passed by the learned Special Judge, Court No. 8, Dhaka in Special Case No. 02 of 2020 is hereby set aside.
87The appellant, Md. Jashim Uddin Ahmed is acquitted of the charges brought against him.
88The convict-appellant is hereby discharged from his bail bond.
89Let a copy of the judgment along with the lower Court's records (LCR) be communicated to the Court concerned forthwith.
(Justice Md. Bashir Ullah)
90Md. Ariful Islam Khan Bench Officer3
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











