Supreme Court Judgments, Summarised

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Nov 3, 2026

Summary

The appellant, a licensed pre-shipment inspection agent, issued a certificate valuing an imported consignment of lead acid dry charged batteries at US$ 15,626.19. Customs at ICD Kamalapur reassessed the goods at US$ 25,887.59 by reference to another consignment, and after a dispute-settlement meeting at which the appellant objected that the goods differed in origin and brand, the Commissioner of Customs imposed a penalty of Tk. 10,64,232.50 under Article 10(5) of the PSI Order, 1999. The Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal upheld the penalty. On appeal, the High Court Division found that the authorities fixed the value hypothetically without applying the sequential valuation methods in the Valuation Rules, 2000. The dispute, unresolved at the meeting, should have gone to the Review Committee under rule 9(3), but was sent straight to the Commissioner, who imposed the penalty without a show cause notice or hearing. Following its earlier decision in Customs Appeal No. 41 of 2007, the Court allowed the appeal and set aside the penalty.

Issues

  1. Q1

    Whether the Commissioner of Customs lawfully imposed a penalty on a pre-shipment inspection agent for certifying a lower value without the dispute being referred to the Review Committee.

  2. Q2

    Whether the penalty was imposed in breach of natural justice and without following the valuation methods in the Valuation Rules, 2000.

Key points

  • Under the Valuation Rules, 2000, the transaction value is primary and, failing that, the alternative methods in rules 5 to 9 must be applied in sequence; where identical goods show different values, the lower transaction value applies.
  • Customs authorities may not fix value in a hypothetical manner without identifying the comparison goods, the bill of entry and its date.
  • Where a valuation dispute is not settled at the joint meeting, it must be referred to the Review Committee under rule 9(3) of the PSI Order before any penalty proceeding; bypassing that forum is unlawful.
  • Imposing a penalty without a show cause notice or an opportunity of hearing violates the principles of natural justice.
  • The Tribunal's order affirming the Commissioner's penalty of Tk. 10,64,232.50 was set aside.

Moreover, it appears from the record that respondent No. 2 without issuing any show cause notice or providing any opportunity of being heard to the appellant imposed the penalty which was a clear violation of the principles of natural justice.

From the judgment, Justice S.M. Maniruzzaman
Law considered

Customs Act, 1969, section 196DPre-Shipment Inspection Order, 1999, Article 10(5)Pre-Shipment Inspection Order, 1999, rule 9(3)Valuation Rules, 2000, rules 3 and 5

The judgment

In the court’s own words.

Customs Appeal 39/2010, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 15 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.

PDF
Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp