High Court Division · Special Statutory Jurisdiction
BSI Inspectorate Limited v Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal and others
Customs Appeal 39/2010 · Decided 11 May 2026
The appellant, a licensed pre-shipment inspection agent, issued a certificate valuing an imported consignment of lead acid dry charged batteries at US$ 15,626.19. Customs at ICD Kamalapur reassessed the goods at US$ 25,887.59 by reference to another consignment, and after a dispute-settlement meeting at which the appellant objected that the goods differed in origin and brand, the Commissioner of Customs imposed a penalty of Tk. 10,64,232.50 under Article 10(5) of the PSI Order, 1999. The Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal upheld the penalty. On appeal, the High Court Division found that the authorities fixed the value hypothetically without applying the sequential valuation methods in the Valuation Rules, 2000. The dispute, unresolved at the meeting, should have gone to the Review Committee under rule 9(3), but was sent straight to the Commissioner, who imposed the penalty without a show cause notice or hearing. Following its earlier decision in Customs Appeal No. 41 of 2007, the Court allowed the appeal and set aside the penalty.
Appeal allowed; penalty set aside
- Q1
Whether the Commissioner of Customs lawfully imposed a penalty on a pre-shipment inspection agent for certifying a lower value without the dispute being referred to the Review Committee.
- Q2
Whether the penalty was imposed in breach of natural justice and without following the valuation methods in the Valuation Rules, 2000.
- Under the Valuation Rules, 2000, the transaction value is primary and, failing that, the alternative methods in rules 5 to 9 must be applied in sequence; where identical goods show different values, the lower transaction value applies.
- Customs authorities may not fix value in a hypothetical manner without identifying the comparison goods, the bill of entry and its date.
- Where a valuation dispute is not settled at the joint meeting, it must be referred to the Review Committee under rule 9(3) of the PSI Order before any penalty proceeding; bypassing that forum is unlawful.
- Imposing a penalty without a show cause notice or an opportunity of hearing violates the principles of natural justice.
- The Tribunal's order affirming the Commissioner's penalty of Tk. 10,64,232.50 was set aside.
Moreover, it appears from the record that respondent No. 2 without issuing any show cause notice or providing any opportunity of being heard to the appellant imposed the penalty which was a clear violation of the principles of natural justice.
In the court’s own words.
Customs Appeal 39/2010, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 15 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(SPECIAL STATUTORY JURISDICTION)
CUSTOMS APPEAL NO. 39 OF 2010
IN THE MATTER OF:
An appeal under section 196D of the Customs
Act, 1969.
And
IN THE MATTER OF:
BSI Inspectorate Limited.
……… Appellant.
-Vs-
Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal
and others.
……..Respondents.
Mr. M.A. Hannan, Senior Advocate
…… For the appellant
Mr. Akhtar Farhad Zaman, Deputy Attorney
General with Mrs. Shadia Afrin Shapla, Deputy
Attorney General with Mr. Arif Khan, Deputy
Attorney General with Mr. Sovan Mahmud, Mr.
Md. Faridul Islam, Mr. Md. Nazmul Haque and
Mr. Md. Sarwar Alam Chowdhury, Assistant
Attorney Generals
…….. For the Respondent-government
Heard on 28.04.2026, 05.05.2026
Judgment on 11.05.2026
Present:
Mr. Justice S.M. Maniruzzaman
&
Mr. Justice Dihider Masum Karim
S.M. Maniruzzaman, J:
1The instant Customs Appeal is directed against the order dated 29.08.2010 passed by the Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal, Dhaka (in short, the Tribunal) respondent No. 1, under Nathi No. CEVT/
Case- (Cus) -131/2001 communicated vide Nathi No. CEVT/Case(Cus)- 131/2001/363 dated 08.09.2010 upholding the Order dated 28.01.2001 passed by respondent No. 2 vide Nathi No. 5- Cus/PSI(1120)Bureau:/2000/9182(Chha) imposing penalty of Tk. 10,64,232.50 upon the appellant.
2Facts, relevant for disposal of the appeal, in short, are that the appellant was appointed as a PSI Agent of the Government of Bangladesh having licence under the Pre-Shipment Inspection Order, 1999 (in short, the order, 1999) for Block-B under Paragraph 5 made under Article 4(8) of the said Order. The importer, namely M/S White Products and Electronics Ltd., Sonartari Tower, 12, Sonargaon Road, Dhaka imported electronic machineries declaring “Acid Dry Charged Battery, YUASA Brand” from Singapore and for that purpose opened a Letter of Credit No. 864/LCY001302 dated 28.09.2000. Before shipment of the goods physical pre-shipment inspection was conducted by the appellant in accordance with the Order, 1999 and a preliminary CRF certificate was issued certifying and declaring the imported consignment as “Lead Acid Dry Charged Battery, YUASA Brand” under H.S. Code No. 8507.10.00 vide CRF No. SG/B/00/0018124/F01 dated 24.11.2000 certifying the value at US$ 15,626.19.
3After arrival of the goods at Customs House, ICD Kamalapur, Dhaka the importer in due course submitted the relevant documents along with the said CRF certificate for assessment and release of the same. However, the customs authority allegedly found that the appellant had certified a lower
value than another consignment of similar goods which had been certified at US$ 25,887.59. Accordingly, the customs authority assessed the goods at the value of US$ 25,887.59.
4Thereafter, respondent No. 3 issued a letter to the appellant on 18.12.2000 seeking an explanation for certifying a lower value instead of the real transaction value prevailing at that time in the international market and also asking why penal action should not be taken against the appellant under Article 10(5) of the PSI Order, 1999. However, no copy of the alleged reference CRF certificate was supplied to the appellant. The appellant replied the notice and thereafter a joint meeting was held on 25.01.2001 at the office of respondent No. 3 regarding settlement of the disputes stating that the imported consignment of M/S White Products and Electronics Ltd. was not similar to the goods mentioned by the customs authority in the show cause notice. The country of origin and brand names of both consignments were different and therefore, the appellant had correctly issued the CRF certificate showing the real value prevailing in the international market at the relevant time. The goods certified by the appellant were of Indonesian origin, manufactured under licence from a Japanese company whereas the goods mentioned in the reference CRF were of Japanese origin and manufactured in Japan. As the goods differed in quality, country of origin and brand name the international market price could not be the same and the goods could not be treated as identical or similar.
5After hearing the parties, respondent No. 3 came to the conclusion that certification of a lower price than the prevailing international market price had been established and that penal action might be taken against the appellant, i.e., the PSI Agency in accordance with Article 10(5) of the order and passed an order to that effect in Serial No. 6 of Ref: 5-Cus-PSI (Meeting)/Ins:/2000/9203 (Ka) dated 28.01.2001 in the joint meeting between the customs authority of ICD and the inspection agency regarding settlement of disputes.
6Subsequently, respondent No. 2, Commissioner of Customs imposed a penalty of Tk. 10,64,232.50 under Article 10(5) of the Order, 1999 upon the appellant for certifying a lower value than the real transaction value as decided by the Dispute Resolution Committee vide Nathi No. 5-Cus/PSI (1120) Bureau:/2000/9182 (Chha) dated 28.01.2001. It is further stated that before passing the said order of imposing penalty, respondent No. 2 neither issued nor served any show cause notice upon the appellant nor afforded the appellant any opportunity of being heard.
7Thereafter, the appellant preferred an appeal before the Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal, Dhaka (the Tribunal) against the said order. The Tribunal heard the appeal on 17.08.2010 where both parties appeared and participated in the hearing. After hearing the parties, the Tribunal rejected the appeal and thereby upheld the order passed by respondent No. 2 vide Nathi No. CEVT/Case (Cus)-131/2001/363 dated 29.08.2010.
8Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the order dated 29.08.2010 passed by respondent No. 1, the appellant preferred the instant appeal before this Court.
9Mr. M.A. Hannan, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant submits that the Tribunal committed an error of law and fact in dismissing the appeal and thereby upholding the order passed by respondent No. 2 dated 28.01.2001 without considering the fact and law that no notice had been issued by respondent No. 2 and no opportunity of hearing had been afforded to the appellant before passing the order dated 28.01.2001. As such, the said order was passed in violation of the principles of natural justice.
10Mr. Hannan next submits that the Tribunal further committed an error of law and fact in dismissing the appeal and thereby upholding the order passed by respondent No. 2 dated 28.01.2001 without considering the fact and law that the entire allegation against the appellant was based on another CRF Certificate wherein the value of “Lead Acid Dry Charged Batteries” had been shown at a higher rate whereas the appellant certified a lower value thereby allegedly causing scope for loss of revenue. However, no copy of such reference CRF Certificate was ever supplied to the appellant. Rather, from the contention of the customs authority itself, it appears that the country of origin, manufacturer and brand names of the referred goods were different. Therefore, the goods in question could not be treated as identical or similar goods and consequently the prices could
not be the same. The Tribunal without consider the same rejected the appeal there by affirm the order of the respondent No. 2.
11Mr. Hannan further submits that the Tribunal also committed an error of law and fact in upholding the order dated 28.01.2001 passed by respondent No. 2 inasmuch as the copy of the alleged reference CRF Certificate had neither been produced before Tribunal by the customs authority at the time of hearing nor supplied to the appellant at any stage of the proceeding thereby depriving the appellant of the opportunity to controvert the same.
12Mr. Hannan finally submits that the Tribunal has committed an error of law and fact in dismissing the appeal and thereby upholding the order passed by respondent No. 2 without considering the point of law as a required under Rule 9 of the Order, 1991. The concerned Commissioner without referring the dispute to the Review Committee as required under Rule 9(3) of the PSI Order, 1991 referred the matter for imposition of penalty. The Commissioner as well as the Tribunal without considering the said provision of law imposed the penalty and thereby committed an error of law in passing the impugned order.
13On the other hand, Mr. Akhtar Farhad Zaman, the learned Deputy Attorney General appearing for the respondent-government submits that there is no illegality in the impugned order inasmuch as the appellant willingly signed the disputed resolution and passing the said decision, the concerned customs authority referred the matter before the Commissioner as required under Rule 10(6) of the Order, 1991. Accordingly, the
Commissioner imposed penalty upon the appellant under Rule 10(5) of the Order, 1991. As such there is no error of law in passing the impugned order by the Tribunal.
14We have heard the learned senior counsel for the appellant and the learned Deputy Attorney General for the respondent-Government, perused the memo of appeal as well as the relevant materials on record so appended thereto and consulted the relevant provisions of the law.
15The main issue to be addressed in the instant appeal is whether respondent No. 2, the Commissioner imposed penalty amounting to Tk. 10,64,232.50 following the applicable provisions of law.
16It, however appears from the record that being aggrieved by the order dated 28.01.2001 passed by respondent No. 2, the appellant preferred appeal before the Tribunal being CEVT Case No. 131 of 2001. The Tribunal, after hearing the contesting parties passed the impugned order holding inter alia;
“…….. , – ( )( )
!" # $%ছ ' – ( )(#)
() *+ , – . / 0# 1 2 3 4 5 4 6$7
$ % ছ। 7/+ – % 9 2 :, ; –
!> !> $ % ছ। / ?+ * @% A + B+ !,
C C !" @% 7 cn¡Ñ−e¡ $ % ছ '+ D >/
!" A 2+ 1"+ ? C 6$ $%ছ । E C C+
5 C+ ! " #F + $ , + ? C+ + + 0#
1 2 ? ছ । G '- 1 2 H ( ) 'I 4 J K
54 + '- 5 C+ ! " A + B+ $H% %
?-L ;/ , + '- / =/ – =(M) ! %C C C
( ) '- +N/ 'O*+ 7 P ? +N/ + , –
=,;Q, L .M= ( ? 0@ S $ T ?+ ? ? U ?) V >/ W
7 X H " $ % ছ।”
17It further appears from the record that the present appellant before shipment of the consignment in question inspected the goods as well as the documents and issued CRF Certificate vide Memo No. SG/B/00/0018124/F01 dated 24.11.2000 fixing the value of the goods at US$ 15,626.19. After submission of the Bill of Entry, the concerned customs authority assessed the goods fixing the value of the consignment at US$ 25,887.59 ignoring the value certified by the PSI agent. In this regard the Commissioner as well as the Tribunal held that- HLC pj−u pjp¡j¢uL L¡−ml j§−mÉl a¥me¡u ¢pBlH−gl fÐaÉ¡¢ua j§mÉ B¿¹SÑ¡¢aL h¡S¡−l ¢hl¡Sj¡e fÐL«a h¡S¡l j§−mÉl ®Q−u US$ 10,261.40 Lj’’।
18But both the authorities below, without examining the declared value available before them and the contemporaneous value of similar goods available at the Customs House failed to mention in their order from which the said value was received by the concerned authority and also failed to mention the concern bill of entry along with its date. In this regard, the method for determination of the actual value of the imported goods has been incorporated in the ‘?Y . 2 % ( C 72 . 2 / 7) , ===’ for the purpose of assessment.
19In the scenario of the present case it is necessary to go through the methods for determining the actual value of imported goods incorporated in the "?Y . 2 % ( C 72 . 2 / ) , ===" i.e. the Rules 2000 for the purpose of assessment.
20The Rules, 2000 provides 6(six) methods in determining the actual transaction value of the imported goods. Relevant part of the said methods are quoted below for ready reference:
21L) . 2 % 5 +:- , Z?2 . 7 [,-
( ) N+ 72 . 2 ,$ % . 2 (transaction value)
$ ;
(#) ! G ( ) N + 72 . 2 /
\ $% + $ $ I M, ;, ],
! %C ,$ . 2 / +$ :
+ ?+/ > !, ' ^_ I ' ?Y ?
(Commissioner of Customs) I ]H
, C+ I (reverse sequence) A%" ! ।
Q) % . 2 (transaction value) :- ( ) ' ? ` , Z ?2
IC+ 72 A N + ? + ? ! "2 . 2, =
a% ' b 7/+ ?+/ ,1 72 % . 2
(transaction value) $ , !> -…………..
M) c 72 (identical goods) % . 2;-
() -Q ! C N + 72 . 2 /
\ $% + $ $ % > A% % ' ? N+
c 72 % . 2 ,1 N + 72 . 2$ ;
( )………………
Emphasis given by us
(L)………………
(Q) C c 72 % . 2 H% "
,$ 2 / % . 2 )+ N + 72
. 2 / +$ ।
😉 + 2 72 (similar goods) % . 2:-
() QHM ! N + 72 . 2 /
\ $% + $ $ % > A% % ' ?
N+ + 2 72 % . 2 ,1 N + 72 . 2$ ।
………………………………
………………………………
]) $C . 2 (deductive value) :- ( ) Q. M H ;
! N + 72 . 2 / \ $% + $ $
% > A% % N + 72 > c 72 >
+ 2 72 ! -% $%ছ – % I+ H I+
d e / !1 $ . I+ V /f 7 ! . 2
I% $%ছ . 2 $ + b 7/+ 2% % ,1 N+
72 . 2 / 7 + $ । !> :-
………………………………
………………………………
! N + 72 . 2 / \ $% + $ $
b 7/+ 2 % B ,1 72 . 2 $ !$ $ N+ . 2 %
$+ $ , !> –
………………………………
………………………………
) 2 2 5 +:- ( ) Q, M, ;, ] H < !
N+ 72 . 2 / \ $% + $ $
2 2 $+ '" + .7/ 2 ! 1 '"+ 5 + ' ' ^_ 72
. 2 'I 4 ! +>2 ' ? H% ! ,$ ) + ,1 72
. 2 / +$ ।
………………………………
………………………………
22It appears from rule 3(ka) that the price of the imported goods is to be transaction value of the goods, but rule 3(kha) provides that if it is not possible to determine the value of the goods under sub rule (ka), then the actual transaction value of the imported goods is to be determined by following the rules 5, 6, 7, 8 or 9 and those methods are to be applied chronologically one after another.
23Rule 5 provides that when it is not possible to determine the value of the imported goods under rule 4, then the value of the identical goods
imported in Bangladesh at the same time ( %) or almost same time (A %
24%) to be transaction value of the imported goods.
25The definition of the " %" (vary same time) or "A % %" (almost same time) provides in rule 2("") of the Rules, 2000. Rule 2("") reads as follow;
26" % A% %" >/ . 2 / T 2 A I% C 72 C % (time of importation) g . / !/4 %।
27Sub rule (4) of rule 5 provides that when differents value/price are found of any identical goods under this Rules, then less transaction value is to be actual transaction value of the said imported goods. (Emphasis given by us)
28However, in the instant case the customs authority without following the provision of the valuation Rules fixed the value hypothetical manner holding “HLC pj−u pjp¡j¢uL L¡−ml j§−mÉl a¥me¡u ¢pBlH−gl fÐ−aÉL¢V B¿¹SÑ¡¢aL h¡S¡−l ¢hl¡Sj¡e fÐL«a h¡S¡l j§−mÉl ®Q−u US$ 10,261.40 Ljz
29Moreover, another contention raised by the learned Senior Advocate is that the authority concern without following the provisions laid down in Rule 9 of the PSI Order, 1991 directly referred the matter to the Commissioner for imposing penalty. In order to appreciate such argument, it is necessary to examine the relevant provisions i.e. rule 9 of the PSI Order, 1999 which is quoted below for ready reference:
। – () 5 +। ( ) ?Y +N/ , ?/ '- H C
d 2 ? M, ] H < 7/+ @% () T 2
b 7/+ L ( + ) h ?_ !/A7 C 7 + $ , !> :-
( ) A> h – ,ৎসমূল i . / ( );
(#) j+C% h – , * (Review Committee) +N/ ( );
(") +N +C% h C +k 2 +N/ ( )।
() ,ৎসমূল i . / () b 7/+ 5 + 7
! , !> l-
( ) 72 # =] ( +) / 2 !" C C% @%
e / h + , m# . / #+ !" ' ^_ A + V ,n
। A+ . !" , + #H % #% A `
oC ' ,$ * !" C A ।
(#) !" A` / f =] ( +) !/ 2, % C%
@%* 2 d) 2 A+ ` J K B
। ,1 J K C% @%* d ) $ % " * 7C Ap+
% , % ,$ + o +l A +2 * % ' 7
।
(") J K C% @%* d ) $ A+ ,1 J K L
( + )* !/ 2 ! " e / +>2 H !" () $H%
7 5 % !" C *T A 7 ।
(O) , – ( ) ( ) (#) H (") , Z?2 . 7 [ ! ?$ ' ^_
? ` -+ ?$ ?/ '- ,$ * G –
' ! " 6$ 7 ) ,$ / +/ A 2+
q+ ।
(L) , * +N/ d) b 7/+ 5 + 7 + $ , !> :-
( ), – () d) $ A+ V$ +
#+ T A` > !0> J K B+ $ ] ( +) / 2
!" C d) T 2 , * V b 7/+ $
+ , !> l-
( ) A+ V ,n + A> !" ;
( ) A+ #+ T ;
( ) A+ ,) 6$7 ! "2 $ e / h + 2 #2
30In the Instance appeal, the dispute was raised by the customs authority alleging that the appellant issued CRF certificate fixing the lower value of the goods in violation of the Valuation Rules, 2000. Thereafter, for settlement of the dispute referred the matter before the joint meeting and
accordingly, the meeting was held on 28.01.2001. At the said meeting, the present appellant did not agree to the settlement and raised objection in the following terms:
Oral Argument: The PSI agency argued that the country of
origin of both the consignments was not the same. The agency
also added that even the brand was different. So, the goods of
Korea origin can not be compared with that of Japan origin
31However, the concerned authority without following the provisions of rule 9(3) directly referred the matter to the Commissioner of Customs for imposing penalty. Rule 9(2)(Ga) provides that if the dispute is not settled in the meeting, the complainant by noted the reasons for such nonsettlement shall submit a reply and send the same to the complainant and thereafter refer the matter to the Review Committee for final settlement as required under rule 9(3) of the Order, 1999.
32However, in the present case, the concerned customs authority without exhausting the forum of the Review Committee directly referred the matter before the Commissioner for imposing penalty and accordingly, the Commissioner imposed a penalty of Tk. 10,64,232.50. The Commissioner as well as the Tribunal without following the said legal requirements passed the impugned order. Moreover, it appears from the record that respondent No. 2 without issuing any show cause notice or providing any opportunity of being heard to the appellant imposed the penalty which was a clear violation of the principles of natural justice. It is well settled principle is that “no person should be punished unheard” (Andi Altera Partem).
33In this regard, one of unreported judgment passed by this Division in Customs Appeal No. 41 of 2007 wherein the present appellant was also appellant. The High Court Division after hearing the contending parties allowed the appeal holding inter alia:
We do see any legal process to proceed against the
appellant under Article 10(5) of the PSI Order, 1999.
Moreover, process though was adopted by the customs
authority to resolve the dispute by three tier dispute
resolution process but without exhausting the same the
Commissioner of Customs abruptly and without any
sanction of law adjudicated the dispute and imposed
penalty upon the appellant and in that event the
Appellate Tribunal while affirming the order of the
Commissioner of Customs failed to take notice of such
illegality of the Commissioner of Customs. This being
so, for the aforesaid reason we find merit in the appeal,
thus the same should be allowed.
34In view of the facts and circumstances of the cases, we find the substance of the submissions so made by the learned Senior Advocate for the appellant and merit in the appeal, accordingly, the appeal is allowed.
35The impugned order dated 29.08.2010 passed by the Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal, Dhaka, respondent No. 1, under Nathi No. CEVT/ Case- (Cus) -131/2001 communicated vide Nathi No. CEVT/ Case (Cus) -131/2001/363 dated 08.09.2010 upholding the Order dated 28.01.2001 passed by the respondent No.2 vide Nathi No. 5- Cus/PSI(1120)Bureau:/2000/9182(Chha) imposing penalty of Tk. 10,64,232.50 upon the appellant is hereby set aside.
36There is no order as to cost.
37Send down the lower Court’s record at once.
38Communicate the judgment and order to the concerned respondent forthwith. Dihider Masum Kabir, J
I agree.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











