High Court Division · Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Mohammad Joynal Abedin and others v Marcantile Bank Ltd. Banani Branch and others
First Appeal 350/2018 · Decided 10 November 2025
The plaintiffs sought a declaration of title to 11.1384 acres and that a registered mortgage deed and irrevocable power of attorney, given to the bank in 2005 as security for a borrower's loan, were forged. The bank had already obtained an ex parte decree in Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013, in which the plaintiffs were defendants as third-party mortgagors. The Joint District Judge, 2nd Court, Dhaka rejected the plaint under Order VII rule 11(d) of the Code of Civil Procedure as barred by law. The High Court Division held the property was the subject of the Artha Rin decree. Section 3 of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 makes the Act prevail, section 20 bars other courts from entertaining challenges to Artha Rin proceedings, and section 33(7Kha) empowers the Artha Rin Adalat to decide whether a mortgage deed is forged. Unlike an innocent third party, the plaintiffs were parties to the earlier suit. Rejection before a written statement was not premature; the appeal was dismissed.
Appeal dismissed; rejection of plaint affirmed
- Q1
Whether a civil suit by third-party mortgagors, who were defendants in an Artha Rin suit, to declare the mortgage deed and power of attorney forged is barred by sections 3 and 20 of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003.
- Q2
Whether the plaint could be rejected under Order VII rule 11(d) of the Code of Civil Procedure before a written statement was filed.
- The property in the title suit was the subject matter of the judgment and decree passed in Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013, in which the plaintiffs had been impleaded as third-party mortgagors.
- Under section 33(7Kha) of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 the Artha Rin Adalat is amply empowered to decide questions of fraud and forgery in execution of mortgage deeds, so the dispute fell within section 3 of the Ain and the civil suit was barred, read with section 20.
- The decision in Sekandar (Md) and another vs Janata Bank Ltd., 22 BLC (AD), did not apply because the plaintiffs there were innocent third parties, whereas these plaintiffs were mortgagors impleaded in the earlier suit.
- As only a jurisdictional question of law was decided without going into the merits, no written statement was needed and the rejection of the plaint was not premature.
- The appeal was dismissed, the decree rejecting the plaint was affirmed and the connected Rule was discharged.
It appears to us that as per section 33(7Kha) of the Ain, 2003 the Artha Rin Adalat is amply empowered to determine any question as to fraud and forgery in execution of the mortgage deeds/documents
In the court’s own words.
First Appeal 350/2018, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 24 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION)
Present:
Mr. Justice Sheikh Md. Zakir Hossain
And
Mr. Justice A.F.M. Saiful Karim
FIRST APPEAL NO. 350 OF 2018.
IN THE MATTER OF :
Mohammad Joynal Abedin and others.
…. Plaintiffs-appellants.
-Versus-
Marcantile Bank Ltd. Banani Branch and others.
……. Defendants-respondents.
Mr. Khaled Hamid Chowdhury, Advocate with
Mr. Ibrahim Khalil , Advocate
…..For the Plaintiffs-appellants.
Mr. M. Shakhawat Hossain, Advocate with
Ms. Sinthea Siraj Rintu, Advocate
….For the Defendants-respondents.
Heard On: 04.09.2025
and Judgment on: 10.11.2025.
A.F.M. Siful Karim, J:
1This first appeal has arisen out of the judgment and decree dated 05.07.2018 (decree signed on 08.07.2018) passed by the learned Joint District Judge, 2nd Court, Dhaka in Title Suit No. 143 of 2018, rejecting the plaint by allowing the application under order 7 rule 11(D) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
2The appellant as plaintiff instituted Title Suit No. 143 of 2018 on 20.02.2018 for declaration that they are owners of 11.1384 acres landed property as described in schedule 'Ka' with further declaration that the deed of mortgage as described in schedule 'Kha' and deed of irrevocable general power of attorney as described in schedule 'Ga' in respect of 19.6575 acres landed property including the 'Ka' schedule 11.1384 acre suit property describing the plaintiffs as executants of those deeds in favour of the Defendant No.1, i.e loan giver Bank, are forged, fraudulent, illegal and not binding upon the Plaintiffs. It is also the case of the plaintiff that- while Plaintiff No.6 had been owning and possessing the 'Ka' schedule suit property through its allotees, 4/5 officers of the Defendant No. 1 came to the 'Ka' schedule suit property on 03.01.2018 at about 3.00 P.M. and expressed that total 19.6575 acre property including the 'Ka' schedule 11.1384 acre suit property was mortgaged by the Plaintiffs No. 1 to 5 by executing and registering 'Kha' schedule mortgage deed and also by executing and registering 'Ga' schedule
irrevocable power of attorney in favour of the Defendant No.1 Bank against the loan of Tk. 55,00,000/-(Fifty five lac) taken by one Mr. Jahangir Sattar Tinku, Proprietor of the "M/S ATCO INTERNATIONAL"; that the said loanee Jahangir Sattar Tinku defaulted in payment of loan of Tk. 55,00,000/-(Fifty five lac) against which the mortgaged deed and power of attorney was executed and registered; that the site Engineer Mizanur Rahman of the plaintiff No. 6 informed about the aforesaid incident on the next day on 04.01.2018 at the Head Office of Plaintiff No.6 at 72, Mohakhali, Dhaka; that an Officer of Plaintiff No.6, Mr. Md. Mustafijur Rahman went on that very day to the office of the Defendant No. 1 and collected the Photostat copies of the alleged 'Kha' schedule mortgage deed and 'Ga' schedule power of attorney, that thereafter on 08.01.2018 the Plaintiff No.6 obtained the certified copy of the exparte Judgment and decree passed in Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013 and order sheet of Artha Jari Case No. 210 of 2015 and communicated with Plaintiffs Nos. 1 to 5 who specifically denied of execution and registration
of the alleged deed of mortgage and power of attorney and told that those documents have been created by the defendant No.1 and Jahangir Sattar Tinku in cllusion with each other by taking recourse of fraud and forgery; that Plaintiff No.6 after hearing such statement from the Plaintiff Nos. 1 to 5 obtained certified copies of the 4 alleged purchased deeds on the basis of which the defendant No.1 alleged that the Plaintiff Nos. 1 to 5 acquired title in 19.6575 acre property including the 11.1384 acre suit property and found that those are not purchase deeds, rather are the amalnama deeds executed by tenants in favour of the Government and thus the Plaintiff No. 6 was convinced that the Defendant No.1, Bank and its corrupted officers in collusion with late Jahangir Sattar Tinku had created all those documents and managed to have misappropriated Bank money in the name of obtaining loan by fraud and forgery; that the Plaintiff No.6 further found that apart from creating mortgage documents by way of fraud and forgery the defendant No.1 has also practiced fraud in publishing the
proclamation of sale without attaching the alleged mortgaged property prior to such proclamation; that Plaintiffs in such circumstances having found no other way had been compelled to file the instant suit for protecting their valuable properties as described in schedule 'Ka' along with a prayer for permanent injunction as well. The plaintiff also filed an application for temporary injunction under order 39 rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
35. The Defendant No.1 i.e the present respondent No.1-Bank appeared in the suit and filed an application under Order 7 Rule 11(D) of the Code of Civil Procedure praying for rejection of plaint mainly on the ground that the suit is barred by law under the provision of sections 3 and 20 of Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003. The defendant No. 1 also filed written objection against the application for temporary injunction.
46. The plaintiffs-Appellants filed written objection opposing the application under Order 7 Rule 11(D) of the Code of Civil Procedure mainly on the ground that Artha
Rin Adalat Ain does not expressly or impliedly exclude Civil Court’s jurisdiction in respect of suits seeking declaration of title or alleging forgery of mortgage instruments and on the ground that the remedies available under the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 do not apply to the plaintiff and thus prayed for rejection of the application under order 7 rule 11(D) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
57. That the Learned Joint District Judge, 2nd Court, Dhaka heard both the parties and passed an order allowing the application under order 7 rule 11(D) and thereby rejected the plaint as prayed for by the defendant.
68. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid impugned judgment and decree dated 05.07.2018 (decree signed on 08.07.2018), the plaintiffs-appellants preferred this appeal and also obtained an order of status-quo in respect of the suit property till disposal of this appeal.
79. Mr. Khaled Hamid Chowdhury, the learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the plaintiffs-appellants submits that the learned Joint District Judge, 2nd Court, Dhaka erred in law in allowing the prayer for rejection of
the plaint without properly considering the facts of the case and the law point involved in the case and the same occasioned failure of justice.
810. Mr. Chowdhury further submits that the plaintiffs-appellants, due to the complete forgery of their signature in the mortgage deeds as well as in the power of attorney, were not legally parties to the Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013, the plaintiff-appellants were never aware of any of the steps taken in such proceedings and as a complete stranger to the loan, the plaintiff-appellants’ only lawful recourse was to seek declaration and protection through the civil court.
911. Mr. Chowdhury further submits that the rejection of plaint under order 7 Rule 11(D) of the Code of Civil Procedure was premature and erroneous before filing of the written statement as maintainability of this suit involves mixed questions of law and fact particularly regarding forgery of signatures and determination of title of the suit property and therefore the appeal may kindly be allowed.
1012. Mr. Chowdhury lastly submits that the trail court below erred in rejecting the plaint by allowing an application under Order VII Rule 11(D) of the Code of Civil Procedure as the suit is not barred as per the provision of section 3 and 20 of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 and therefore, the impugned judgment and decree causing miscarriage of justice, is liable to be set aside.
1113. Mr. Chowdhury in support of his submissions has relied on the decisions reported in 22 BLC (AD)53 and 11 MLR (AD) 58.
1214. Mr. M. Shakhawat Hossain, the learned Advocate, appearing for the Respondent No. 1, supporting the impugned judgment and decree submits that the learned trail court below justly, properly and lawfully rejected the plaint of the suit filed by the appellants who as owners of 19.6575 acres of land have jointly executed registered Mortgage deed No. 4665 and irrevocable Power of Attorney No. 4666 both dated 13.03.2005 in favour of the instant Respondent No. 1 Bank as security of the loan for which the Bank filed Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013
for recovery of outstanding loan against the borrower as well as instant Appellants as third party Mortgagors and summons of the suit were duly served upon the defendants including instant appellants and therefore the suit is barred by law under the provision of section 3 and 20 of Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003.
1315. He also submits that whether the appellant’s claim that appellants property was fraudulently mortgaged or not in connection with a loan from which the Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013 and Money Execution Case No. 210 of 2015 derived can lawfully be determined under the provision of section 33(7Kha) of Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 and therefore the appellants’ suit is impliedly barred under the provision of sections 3 and 20 of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 and thus the impugned judgment and decree is a lawful one and hence, not liable to be set aside.
1416. He next submits that the instant appellants being the land Owners-Mortgagors-Defendants-Judgment Debtors of Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013 were duly made parties in the plaint as per the provision of sub-
section (5) of section 6 of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 and therefore they can not be treated as innocent third party and thus the decision of our Apex Court reported in 22 BLC (AD) 2017 P-53 is not applicable in the present case.
1517. He next submits that in deciding the application under order 7 rule 11(D) by the learned Court below no factual aspect was to be determined and therefore the case cited in 11 MLR (AD) 58 is not applicable in the present case.
1618. He lastly submits that with a view to deprive the instant Respondent No. 1 Bank from the decretal amount appellants filed the instant suit and therefore the suit can not survive and hence the appeal may kindly be disallowed.
1719. We have heard the learned Advocate of both the sides at length and perused the connected documents as filed by the respective parties along with the impugned judgment and decree.
1820. Now, it is the only question before us whether the trail Court below in passing the impugned judgment and decree erred in holding that the suit is barred by law.
1921. To consider the submissions of the learned Advocates of both the parties, let us examine first whether the suit property, mortgage deed and power of attorney in connection with which the Title Suit No. 143 of 2018 filed by the Plaintiffs-Appellants praying for a decree of declaration of title, decree of declaration that the ‘Kha’ schedule Mortgage deed and ‘Ga’ schedule Power of Attorney are forged and fraudulent, not binding upon the plaintiff and seeking permanent injunction are the subject matter of the judgment and decree of the Artha Rin Adalat passed in Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013 as well as Artha Rin Execution Case No. 210 of 2015.
2022. To get answer of the abovementioned question, we need to consider the plaint of the instant suit. It is pertinent to quote hereunder relevant portion of the plaint of title suit No. 143 of 2018 which reads as follows:
21“(১৬)। ৬ নং বাদী কা ানী উ েপ নািলশী 'ক' তফিসল বিণত
22স ি েত বধ দখলকার থাকাবস্স্ ায় হঠাৎ গত
23০৩/০১/২০১৮ ইং তািরেখ িবকাল ৩.০০ ঘ টকায় ১ নং িববাদী
24ব াংেকর বনানী শাখার ৪/৫ জন কমকতা ও কমচারী নািলশী
25'ক' তফিসলভূ বিণত " পায়ন আ িলয়া িস ট” নামীয়
26কে আিসয়া ৬ নং বাদী কা ানীর েজ ই িনয়ার
27িমজানুর রহমান এর িনকট এই সব থম কাশ কেরন য,
28৬ নং বাদীর মাধ েম ১-৫ নং বাদীর দখলীয় নািলশী 'ক'
29তফিসল বিণত ১১.১৩৮৪ একর স ি সহ তাহােদর
30দখলহীন আরও ৮.৫১৯১ একর ভূ িম অ ভূ েম একুেন
31১৯.৬৫৭৫ একর ভূ িমর মািলক িহসােব ১-৫ নং বাদীপ েক
32উপ াপেন ৩ হইেত ৮ নং িববাদীগেণর পূববত মর ম ডাঃ
33জাহা ীর ছা ার টংকু সােহেবর া াইটশীপ ফাম- "
34মসাস ATCO International"-এর নােম গৃহীত ৫৫ ল
35টাকার ঋেণর িবপরীেত গত ১৩/০৩/২০০৫ ইং তািরেখ
36তাহােদরেক ৩য় প ব ক দাতা িহসােব উে েখ 'গ'
37তফিসেল বিণত অপর এক র জ কৃত আম- মা ার নামা
38দিলেলর দাতা িহসােব উে েখ স াদন ও রজ
39কিরয়ােছন। তাহারা আরও বেলন য, পরবত েত উ ঋণ
40িহতা ফােমর াপাইট মর ম ডাঃ জাহা ীর ছা ার টংকু
41সােহব কতৃক উহার াপাইটশীপ ফােমর নােম গৃহীত
42ঋেণর টাকা পিরেলােধ খলাপী হইেব ১নং িববাদী ঋণদাতা
43ব াংক ঋণ িহতা মর ম ডাঃ জাহা ীর ছা ার টংকু সােহব
44কতৃক 'গ' তফিসেলর ব কী স ি সহ ১৯.৬৫৭৫ একর
45ব কীর িবপরীেত গৃিহত ঋেণর টাকা আদােয়র জ থেম
46টাকার অথঋণ আদালত নং-২ ত অথঋণ মাক মা নং-
47২৮০/১৩ দােয়ের ১৪ নং আেদশ মূেল গত ১৬/১০/২০১৪ ইং
48তািরেখ একতরফা রায় ও গত ২৩/১০/২০১৪ ইং তািরেখ
49একতরফা িড ী া হয় এবং পরবত েত উ িড ীকৃত
50টাকা আদােয়র জন অথজারী মাক মা নং- ২১০/১৫ জু
51কিরয়া উহােত নািলশী 'ক' তফিসল বিণত ১১.১৩৮৪ একর
52স ি সহ 'গ' তফিসেল বিণত আম- মা ার নামা দিলেল
53উে িখত মাট ১৯.৬৫৭৫ একর স ি এবং ব কীকৃত
54অন ান মািলেকর অন ান স ি িব েয়র ব ব া
55কিরেতেছন মেম দাবী কিরয়া তাহারা ১নং িববাদী ঋণদাতা
56ব াংেকর কমকতা ও কমচারী িহসােব নািলশী স ি র
57বতমান আকৃিত- কৃিত অব া এবং অব ান দখার জন
58নািলশী 'ক' তফিসেলর স ি েত আিসয়ােছন। (১৭)। নািলশী স ি র সাইট অিফেস অব ানরত ৬ নং বাদী
59কা ানীর েজ ই িনয়ার জনাব িমজানুর রহমান
60িবষয় ট পেরর িদন গত ০৪/০১/২০১৮ ইং তািরেখ সকাল
61১০.০০ ঘ টকায় ৬ নং বাদী কা ানীর হড অিফস পায়ন
62স ার ৭২, মহাখালী, ঢাকােত াত কিরেল হড অিফেসর
63কমকতা জনাব মাঃ মা ািফজুর রহমান ঐ িদনই ১ নং
64িববাদী ব াংেকর সংি বনানী শাখার বতমােন কমরত
65সহকারী ভাইস িসেড জনাব মিনর হােসন খান এর
66সে সা াত কিরয়া তাহােদর দাবীকৃত আম- মা ারনামা ও
67ব কী দিলেলর ফেটাকিপ চািহয়া ব ক ও িড ী াি র
68িবষেয় িন ত কিরেত বিলেল িতিন তাহােদর দাবীকৃত গত
69১৩/০৩/২০০৫ ইং তািরেখ র জ কৃত যথা েম- 'খ'
70তফিসেল বিণত ৪৬৬৫ নং ব কনামা দিলেলর ও 'গ'
71তফিসেল বিণত ৪৬৬৬ নং আম- মা ার নামা দিলেলর
72মূলকিপর ফেটাকিপ দান কিরেলও মাক মার িড ী ও
73িড ীজারী মাক মা সং া দিলল দ ােবজ দােন
74অ ীকার কেরন। (১৮)। এমতাব ায়, ৬ নং বাদী কা ানী উহার িনযু ীয় িব
75কৗ লী জনাব আ স
76ু সালাম সােহব এর মাধ েম ১ নং
77িববাদী ঋণদাতা ব াংেকর জুকৃত অথঋণ মাক মা নং-
78২৮০/২০১৩ এর একতরফা রায় ও িড ীর এবং অথজারী
79মাক মা নং- ২১০/২০১৫ এর আেদশ সীেটর সইম রী
80নকল গত ০৮/০১/২০১৮ ইং তািরেখ সং হ কিরয়া ঐ িল
81পাঠাে ১ নং িববাদী ঋণদাতা ব াংক কতৃক মাক মা
82দােয়র, একতরফা রায় ও িড ী াি এবং তৎপর জারী
83মাক মা চলমান থাকার িবষয় স েক িন ত হন। (১৯)। ৬ নং বাদী কা ানী উ েপ ১ নং িববাদী ঋণদাতা ব াংক
84কতৃক মাক মা দােয়ের উহােত িড ী া িবষেয় িন ত
85হওয়ার পর 'খ' তফিসল বিণত ব ক দিলল ও 'গ' তফিসল
86বিণত আম- মা ার নামা দিলল িবষেয় জানার জন অ
87মাক মার ১ হইেত ৫ নং বাদীর সিহত যাগােযাগ কিরেল
88তাহারা সু ভােব ৬ নং বাদী কা ানীর কমকতা উ
89মাঃ মা ািফজুর রহমান ক জানান য এবং তাহারা ৩-৮
90িববাদীপে র পূববত ডাঃ জাহা ীর সা ার টংকু ক িচেনন
91না ও জােনন না, তাহােদর সিহত উ ডাঃ জাহা ীর ছা ার
92টংকু সােহেবর কান আ ীয় বা অন কান কার স ক
93কান িদন কান কােল িছল না। তাহারা কহই ৬ নং বাদী
94কা ানীর মাধ েম তাহােদর বধ মািলক দখলীয় নািলশী
95'ক' তফিসল বিণত স ি সহ মািলক ও দখলহীন আরও
96৮.৫১৯১ একর স ি অ ভূ েম িবষেয় ১ নং িববাদী
97ঋণদাতা ব াংেকর দাবীমেত নািলশী 'খ' তফিসল বিণত
98ব কী দিলল ও নািলশী 'গ' তফিসল বিণত আম- মা ার
99নামা দিলল স াদন ও র জ কিরয়া দন নাই। উ দুই ট
100দিলল ঋণ হীতা " মসাস ATCO International"- এর
101তৎকালীন াপাইটর ৩-৮ নং িববাদীপে র পূববত জনাব
102ডা ার জাহা ীর ছা র টংকু ও ঋণ দাতা ১নং িববাদী
103ব াংেকর তৎকালীন কমকতা/কমচারীেদর পর র
104যাগসাজেশ ১-৫ নং বাদী প কতৃক নািলশী স ি
105িব েয়র উে েশ জিম বচা- কনার িবিভ দালালেক
106তাহােদর া রযু য িব েয়র াব দন- সই সকল
107িব েয়র াব হইেত বা অন কান অিফস আদালেত
108থাকা নমুনা া র হইেত া র সং হাে উ া েরর
109অনু প া র িভ কান ব ারা করাইয়া ১ হইেত ৫ নং
110বাদীগেণর পিরবেত ও অজাে অন লাক দাঁড় করাইয়া
111ত কতা ও জাল-জািলয়ািত মূেল 'খ' ও 'গ' তফিসেলর দিলল
112রজ র মাধ েম সৃজন কিরয়ােছন মা । তাই উ দিলল
113দুই টর স াদন ও রজ সং া সকল কায িদ
114ত কতা ও জাল-জািলয়ািত মূেল সৃ জত বেট।“
11523. The Title Suit No. 143 of 2018 is instituted with the following prayers:
116“(ক)। ৬নং বাদীপে র মাধ েম ১-৫ নং বাদীপ গণ 'ক' তফিসল
117বিণত ১১.১৩৮৪ একর স ি েত বধ মািলক দখলকার
118আেছন মেম িববাদীগেণর িব ে এক ঘাষণার িড ী
119িদেত;
120(খ)। ৬নং বাদীর মাধ েম ১ হইেত ৫ নং বাদীপে র কৃত
121দখলীয় উ 'ক' তফিসেল বিণত উ ১১.১৩৮৪ একর
122স ি র সিহত ও দখলহীন আরও ৮.৫১৯১ একর ভূ িম
123সংযু েম মাট ১৯.৬৫৭৫ একর স ি অ ভ করতঃ
124ঋণদাতা ব াংক ১ নং িববাদীর দাবীকৃত 'খ' তফিসেল বিণত
125ব কী দিলল 'গ' তফিসল বিণত আম- মা ার নামা দিলল
126দুই ট ৩-৮ নং িববাদীগেণর পূববত মর ম ডাঃ জাহা ীর
127ছা ার টংকু এর সিহত যাগ সাজেশ, ত কতা ও জাল-
128জািলয়ািত মূেল সৃ জত এবং উহা বাদীপে র উপর বাধ কর
129নয় মেম িববাদীপে র িব ে অপর এক ঘাষণামূলক
130িড ী িদেত;
131(গ)। অ মাক মার িববাদীপ গণ যাহােত তাহােদর পর র
132যাগসাজশী, জাল-জািলয়ািত ও ত কতামূেল সৃ জত 'খ'
133তফিসেল বিণত ব কী দিলল 'গ' তফিসল বিণত আম-
134মা ার নামা দিলেলর অনুবেল 'ক' তফিসেল বিণত স ি
135িবষেয় কান কার হ া র দিলল বা অন কান কার
136দিলল স াদন ও র জ কিরেত না পাের এবং উহােত
137বাদীপে র বধ ও ভাগ দখেল কান কার বাধা িব
138সৃ কিরেত না পাের বা উহা হইেত বাদীপ ও তাহােদর
139বরা িহতােদর বদখল কিরেত না পাের তৎমেম,
140িববাদীপ গণ িব ে এক িচর ায়ী িনেষধা ার িড ী
141িড ী িদেত;
142(ঘ)। বাদীপক্ষগণ নািলশী 'ক' তফিসেল বিণত স ি েত দখল
143থাকার িবষয় ট ি র করতঃ িববাদীপে র িব ে দখল
144ি রতেরর িড ী িদেত;
145(ঙ)। মামলা মাক মার যৎ-যাবতীয় খরচািদর িড ী িদেত;
146(চ)। বাদীপ আইন ও ন ায় িবচােরর ােথ আর য সকল
147িতকার পাইেত পাের উহােদর িড ী িদেত ম জ হয়।“
148From the plaint it appears that in the plaint the plaintiff after making certain statements regarding title of the suit property made statements as to the fact of deed of Mortgage and power of attorney alleged to be created by the defendant no. 1 and the predecessor of the defendant Nos. 3-8, Zahangir Satter Tinku, in collusion with each other by taking recourse of fraud and forgery.
14924. It appears from the plaint of Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013 that the plaintiff Nos. 1-5 of Title Suit No. 143 of 2018 were made defendants Nos. 8, 9, 10, 11, and 12 respectively as Mortgagors third parties. The relevant portion of the plaint of Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013 is reproduced herein below:
150“That the aforesaid credit facilities were secured by a
151FDR value for an amount of Tk. 248.47 lac was duly
152lien with the plaintiff Bank followed discharging the
153same in favour of the plaintiff Bank; that the defendant
154Nos. 2, 3 and 4 also mortgaged three numbers of flat
155being Nos.C-2, D-2, E-2 each of 1523 sft. with
156proportionate 0,5 Katha land with three car parking
157space located at Plot No. 40, Road No.9, Sector-11,
158Gorib-E-Nawaz Avenue, Uttara Model Town, Mouza-
159Bailjuir, Uttara, Dhaka, that the Late Dr. Jahangir
160Sattar Tinku also mortgaged 200 decimals of land
161within District- Chittagong, Police Station-
162Doublemoring, Mouza-Uttar Pahartoli and he also
163mortgaged another 14.50 decimals of land situated
164within District-Chittagong. Police Station-
165Panchlaish, Mouza- East Nasirabad, that the
166defendant Nos. 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12 also mortgaged
167their landed property measuring 1965.75 decimals of
168land situated within District- Dhaka, Police Station-
169Ashulia, Mouza-Baro Ashulia (more specifically
170described in the schedule-B below); that it is
171mentioned here that the mortgagors also executed the
172Power of Attorney Deeds empowering the plaintiff
173Bank to self the mortgaged properties.”
17425. It appears from the above quoted averments of the plaint, the prayer portion and the schedule of the plaint of title suit No. 143 of 2018 and from the plaint of Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013 that the property as described in the schedule of the plaint is the subject matter of the previous judgment and decree of the Artha Rin Adalat passed in Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013.
17526. It also appears from the record that the appellants as owners of 19.6567 acres of land have jointly executed registered Mortgage deed No. 4665 and Irrevocable Power of Attorney No. 4666 both dated 13.03.2005 in favour of instant Respondent-Bank; on 12.11.2013 the Bank filed Artha Rin Suit No. 280 of 2013 for recovery of Tk.58,91,27,484.30 against the Borrower and instant Appellants as third party-mortgagors and on 16.10.2014 the learned Court below decreed the suit ex-parte; the Respondent-Bank then filed Money Execution Case No. 210 of 2015 on 27.07.2015; the said Execution Case No.
176210 of 2015 was fixed on 03.02.2021 for issuance of certificate under section 33(7) of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 but due to order of status-quo passed in this First Appeal the learned Court below have not yet issued the said certificate in favour of the instant Respondent No. 1-Bank.
17727. To see whether the relief sought for in the rejected plaint attracts the provision of Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003. We have now consulted with the provision of sections 3, 20 and 33(7Kha) of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 which read as follows:
178“3| আইেনর াধান । -আপাততঃ বলবৎ অন কান
179আইেন িভ তর যাহা িকছই থাকুক না কন, এই আইেনর
180িবধানাবলীই কাযকর হইেব।“
181“২০। অথ ঋণ আদালেতর আেদেশর চূ ড়া তা। এই
182আই নর িবধান ব িতেরেক, কান আদালত বা কতৃপে র
183িনকট অথ ঋণ আদালেত িবচারাধীন কান কাযধারা বা
184উহার কান আেদশ, রায় বা িড ীর কান উ াপন
185করা যাইেব না, এবং এই আইেনর িবধানেক উেপ া কিরয়া
186কান আদালত বা কতৃপে র িনকট আেবদন কিরয়া কান
187কার দাবী বা াথনা করা হইেল, ঐ প আেবদন কান
188আদালত বা কতৃপ াহ কিরেব না।“
189’’৩৩(১)………………………………………………………………
190…………………………………………………………………………..
191৩৩(৭ক ). . . . . . . . ………………………………………………………
192……
193“33(৭খ) উপ-ধারা (৭ক) এর অধীন িড ীদারেক
194স ি র দখল অপণ কিরবার পূেব আদালেত পুনঃিন ত
195হইেত হইেব য, উ স ি ই আইনানুগভােব উহার
196কৃত মািলক কতৃক িড ীর সংি ঋেণর িবপরীেত
197ব ক দান করা হইয়ািছল অথবা িড ী কাযকর কিরবার
198লে দািয়েকর কৃত দখলীয় স ি িহসােব উ
199স ি ই াক করা হইয়ািছল।“
20028. From the provision of sections 3, 20 and 33(7Kha) of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 it appears that as per section 3 of the Ain, notwithstanding anything contained in any other law in force, the provision of this Act shall prevail. It also transpires that if any dispute can be adjudicated under the provision of Ain, 2003 and can be resolved by the Artha Rin Adalat applying the provision of the Ain, 2003 then the dispute will attract the provision of section 3 of the Ain, 2003 And as per section 20 of the Ain except under the provisions of this Act, no question shall be raised before any Court or authority about any pending proceeding in the Artha Rin Adalat, or its order, judgment or decree, and no court or authority shall take cognizance of any application claiming or
praying for any remedy, filed in such court or authority ignoring the provisions of this Act and any judgment or decree or any order of the Artha Rin Adalat would be final. It appears to us that as per section 33(7Kha) of the Ain, 2003 the Artha Rin Adalat is amply empowered to determine any question as to fraud and forgery in execution of the mortgage deeds/documents and it also appears to us that if it is found by the court that mortgage deed is a forged one then the court will not pass any order directing to handover the possession of the mortgaged property to anyone and on that count we are of the view that the dispute agitated in the plaint falls within the ambit of section 3 of the Ain, 2003.
20129. Let us consider the decision reported in 22 BLC (AD) 2017 (Sekandar (Md) and another vs Janata Bank Ltd. and others) relied by the learned Advocate of plaintiff-Appellants in support of his contention.
20230. In the suit from which the decision arrived at by the Appellate Division is instituted by an innocent third party whose property has been collusively mortgaged by
the judgment debtors of Mortgage suit No. 35 of 1995 and though not stated anywhere in the judgment passed by the Appellate Division in the above cited case but it can well be conceived from the judgment that the plaintiff of other class Suit No. 99 of 2004, from which the decision derived, were not parties to that suit. But in the instant case the plaintiffs are not innocent third parties rather they are third-party-mortgagors and they had been impleaded as defendants in the earlier suit instituted for recovery of the loan money by the bank the result of which is affecting them and therefore the fact of the case is fundamentally different and thus in our view the ratio of the cited decision is not applicable in the present case.
20331. We also considered the ratio of the case Ismat Zerin Khan vs World Band and others as cited in 11 MLR (AD) 2006 and took view that the ratio is not also applicable in the present case as there is no factual aspect of the suit to decide the question of maintainability of the suit. We found that in the present case the question of law whether the Civil Court’s jurisdiction is ousted by
operation of law i.e. by the provision under sections 3, 20 and 33(7Kha) of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 or not can be determined by determining the only question of law as to whether the Artha Rin Adalat exercising the power conferred under the provision of section 33(7Kha) of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 can determine genuinity of mortgage deeds alleged to be executed by practicing fraud. For the reason, in our view, that in the instant case only the jurisdictional question of maintainability was ascertained without going through the merit of the suit and thus to decide the question submission of written statement is not necessary and thus in our view the impugned order is not premature one.
20432. Having considered all the facts and circumstances of the case, the submissions of the respective parties and the propositions of law cited and discussed above we find substance in the submissions of the learned Advocate for the Respondent and we are led to hold the view that this first appeal does not bear any merit
and for this reasons, this first appeal is liable to be dismissed for ends of justice.
205Accordingly, this first appeal is dismissed.
206Resultantly, the impugned judgment and decree dated 05.07.2018 (decree signed on 08.07.2018) passed by the learned Joint District Judge, 2nd Court, Dhaka in Title Suit No. 143 of 2018, rejecting the plaint by allowing the application under order 7 rule 11(D) of the Code of Civil Procedure is affirmed.
207For the reasons stated above, the connecting Rule is also discharged.
208Let a copy of this judgment and decree together with LCR be sent down to the learned Judge of the concerned Court below, at once.
209A.F.M. Saiful Karim, J: Sheikh Md. Zakir Hossain, J:
210I agree.
211Sheikh Md. Zakir Hossain, J:
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











