Res judicata
The rule that a matter already heard and finally decided between the same parties by a competent court cannot be tried again in a new case.
Res judicata, step by step.
Res judicata means "a matter already judged".
Under section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, once a competent court has heard and finally decided an issue between the same parties, no court may try that issue again.
It also covers points that could and should have been raised the first time.
Find the earlier case
Identify the earlier suit or writ, its number, the court and the parties.
Get certified copies
Obtain certified copies of the earlier plaint, written statement, judgment and decree.
Compare the cases
Check whether the parties, the title they claim under and the issue decided are truly the same.
Plead it early
Raise res judicata in the written statement, or apply under Order VII rule 11 if it is clear from the plaint.
Res judicata means "a matter already judged". Under section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, once a competent court has heard and finally decided an issue between the same parties, no court may try that issue again. It also covers points that could and should have been raised the first time. If you are sued again over something already decided, raise it at once in your written statement or by asking the court to reject the plaint.
What res judicata means
Res judicata is Latin for "a thing decided". The rule serves two ideas: a person should not be troubled twice over the same dispute, and court decisions should be final. Without it, a losing party could keep filing fresh suits until a court gave a different answer.
The rule bars a later case only where the same matter was directly and substantially in issue in the earlier one, between the same parties or people claiming through them, and was heard and finally decided by a court competent to try the later case. If any of those elements is missing, the bar does not apply, even if the two cases concern the same land or the same family.
Where it comes from in Bangladesh law
The main source is section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908. Its six Explanations fill in the detail. A "former suit" means one decided earlier, even if it was filed later (Explanation I). Competence is judged without regard to rights of appeal (Explanation II). A relief claimed but not expressly granted is treated as refused (Explanation V). Where people litigate in good faith about a public or common right, everyone interested is bound (Explanation VI).
Related rules sit nearby. Section 10 stops a court proceeding with a suit whose matter is already in issue in an earlier pending suit. Section 12 and Order II rule 2 bar a further suit for a claim or relief the plaintiff left out. Order XXIII rule 1(3) bars a fresh suit after withdrawal without the court's permission. In criminal cases, article 35(2) of the Constitution and section 403 of the Code of Criminal Procedure protect against being tried twice for the same offence.
Constructive res judicata
Explanation IV to section 11 says that any matter which might and ought to have been raised as a ground of attack or defence in the former suit is treated as having been in issue there. Lawyers call this constructive res judicata. It stops a party from holding back an argument and using it later as the basis for a new case.
The High Court Division has applied the same principle to writ petitions. Where petitioners could and ought to have challenged regulations in earlier writ petitions, and the relief sought was substantially what had already been refused, a fresh petition was held barred by constructive res judicata. The safe lesson is to put every available ground into the first case.
How it is raised and decided
A defendant raises res judicata in the written statement, because Order VIII rule 2 requires pleas showing that a suit is not maintainable to be pleaded. Where the bar is clear from the plaint itself, the defendant may instead apply for rejection of the plaint under Order VII rule 11. The court may then frame res judicata as an issue and decide it early.
Proof is documentary. The party relying on the bar should file certified copies of the earlier plaint, written statement, judgment and decree, so the court can compare the parties, the issues and what was actually decided. The court looks at substance, not labels. A later suit claiming that a deed was forged can raise a different issue from an earlier partition suit over the same land, and then it is not barred.
What it means for each side and what they can do
If the court upholds the bar, the plaint is rejected or the suit dismissed, and the earlier decision stands. The plaintiff can challenge that order on appeal or in civil revision, depending on the order, within the time allowed. If the court rejects the plea, the case goes on to trial, and the defendant can raise the point again on appeal against the final decree.
A party who says the earlier judgment should not bind him has limited arguments. Under section 44 of the Evidence Act 1872, a party may show that a relevant earlier judgment was delivered by a court not competent to deliver it, or was obtained by fraud or collusion. He can also argue that the parties, the title or the issue were different. Simply disagreeing with the earlier result is not enough.
Common misunderstandings
Res judicata is not the same as limitation (tamadi). Limitation bars a case because it was filed too late, while res judicata bars it because the point was already decided. Nor is it the same as a pending case: if the first suit is still running, section 10 (often called res sub judice) may pause the second suit, but section 11 has not yet been triggered.
Not every earlier order counts. The matter must have been heard and finally decided. A point merely mentioned in passing, or a suit dismissed for a technical reason without a decision on the issue, may not create the bar. And res judicata binds only the parties and those claiming under them, not strangers to the earlier case.
Suppose two brothers fight a title suit over a pond, and the court decides, after a full trial, that the pond belongs to the elder brother. The decree is upheld on appeal. Ten years later the younger brother's son sues the elder brother for a declaration that he inherited a half share of the same pond through his father. The defendant files the earlier judgment and decree. The court holds that the son claims under his father on the same title, so the suit is barred by res judicata.
What to do if this affects you
- 01Find the earlier case
Identify the earlier suit or writ, its number, the court and the parties.
- 02Get certified copies
Obtain certified copies of the earlier plaint, written statement, judgment and decree.
- 03Compare the cases
Check whether the parties, the title they claim under and the issue decided are truly the same.
- 04Plead it early
Raise res judicata in the written statement, or apply under Order VII rule 11 if it is clear from the plaint.
- 05Ask for an early decision
Request that it be framed as an issue and heard first, to avoid a full trial if the bar applies.
Test yourself on Res judicata
Res judicata in real judgments
Recent Supreme Court of Bangladesh judgments summarised on trw.co where the term appears.
Questions about Res judicata
Does res judicata apply if I lost the earlier case ex parte?
It can. The question is whether the matter was heard and finally decided by a competent court. If you were never properly served, the better course is usually to apply to set aside the ex parte decree, or show fraud or collusion under section 44 of the Evidence Act, rather than start a new suit on the same issue.
Can I file a writ petition on a point I lost in an earlier writ?
Generally not. The High Court Division has applied res judicata, including constructive res judicata, to writ proceedings. A second petition that seeks substantially the same relief, or raises grounds that could and should have been raised before, is likely to be found barred. Challenge everything in the first petition.
Does res judicata apply to my heirs?
Yes. Section 11 covers parties "under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title". Heirs and buyers who claim through a party to the earlier case are usually bound by its decision on the same issue. A person with an independent title of their own is not bound simply by being related.
What if new evidence turns up after I lost?
New evidence does not usually lift the bar on a fresh suit. The remedies lie within the earlier case itself, such as an appeal, or an application for review to the court that decided it, which has its own grounds and time limits. Take advice quickly, because those time limits are short.
Is res judicata the same as double jeopardy?
They are related ideas. Res judicata in section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure applies to civil suits and similar proceedings. In criminal cases, article 35(2) of the Constitution says no person shall be prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once, and section 403 of the Code of Criminal Procedure bars a second trial for the same offence.
Who has to prove res judicata?
The party who raises it. That party should put the earlier pleadings, judgment and decree before the court as certified copies. The court then compares them with the new case. Without those documents the plea usually fails, however strongly it is asserted.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











