High Court Division · Admiralty Jurisdiction
Basic Bank Limited v M.V. CRYSTAL SAPPHIRE and others
Admiralty Suit 29/2017 · Decided 26 February 2026
The bank sanctioned a term loan of BDT 64,98,00,000/- on 04.01.2012 to the vessel's registered owner to buy the ship. The loan was secured by a registered mortgage of the vessel. After the owner defaulted and ignored a legal notice, the bank sued under section 3(2) of the Admiralty Court Act, 2000 for BDT 128,52,82,267.12 by sale of the vessel. The defendants argued the claim fell outside admiralty jurisdiction. Following First Security Islami Bank Ltd v MV Javed (69 DLR (2017) 408) and Bank Asia Limited v M.T. Atlanta (25 BLC (2020) 677), the High Court Division held the suit maintainable, adding that its admiralty jurisdiction rests on Article 101 of the Constitution and is defined by the vessel, not by whether the claimant is a bank. The defendants called no witness and did not in substance dispute the liability. The suit was decreed with 12% interest, payable from the sale proceeds of the vessel, which had already been sold at judicial auction in another suit.
- Q1
Whether a bank's suit to recover a loan given to buy a vessel, by sale of the mortgaged vessel, is maintainable in the Admiralty Court despite section 5 of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003.
- Q2
Whether the plaintiff bank proved the loan, the mortgage of the vessel and the owner's default so as to be entitled to a decree.
- Following First Security Islami Bank Ltd v MV Javed, 69 DLR (2017) 408, and Bank Asia Limited v M.T. Atlanta Ex. Vinashin Atlantic, 25 BLC (2020) 677, the Court held that section 5 of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 does not bar the suit, which is maintainable under section 3(2) of the Admiralty Court Act, 2000.
- When the Admiralty Court Act, 2000 confers jurisdiction on the High Court Division it activates the Division's constitutional capacity under Article 101, which cannot easily be displaced by sub-constitutional statutes unless the ouster is explicit.
- The Artha Rin Adalat's jurisdiction is limited to recovery of money or loans provided by financial institutions, whereas admiralty jurisdiction is defined by the nature of the asset, the vessel, regardless of whether the claimant is a bank or an individual.
- The defendants did not in substance controvert the liability, and the bank proved its claim through its witness and documents exhibited without objection.
- The suit was decreed against the principal defendants for BDT 128,52,82,267.12 with interest at 12% from filing until realisation, to be satisfied from the sale proceeds of the vessel, with no order as to costs.
In contrast, the Admiralty Court’s jurisdiction is defined by the nature of the asset which is “vessel/ship” and the specialized maritime claims arising from it, regardless of the status of the claimant as a bank or an individual.
In the court’s own words.
Admiralty Suit 29/2017, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 13 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2HIGH COURT DIVISION
3(ADMIRALTY JURISDICTION)
4Present:
5Mr. Justice Sikder Mahmudur Razi
6ADMIRALTY SUIT NO. 29 of 2017.
7IN THE MATTER OF:
8Basic Bank Limited
9… Plaintiff.
10VERSUS
11M.V. CRYSTAL SAPPHIRE (IMO No:
128321096, Flag: Bangladesh), and others.
13… Defendants.
14Mr. Monzur Alam Khan, Adv.
15…For the plaintiff.
16Mr. M. Belayet Hossain, Sr. Adv. with
17Mr. Md. Humayun Kabir, Adv.
18Mr. M. Mahmudul Hasan, Adv.
19…. For the defendants.
20Heard on: 09.02.2026
21And
22Judgement on: The 26th February, 2026
231. The instant admiralty suit has been instituted by Basic Bank Limited, Dilkusha Branch, Dhaka for recovery of dues by sale of the mortgaged ship.
242. Plaintiff’s case in short is that the plaintiff is a state-owned banking company duly incorporated and carrying on banking business in Bangladesh with its Head Office at Motijheel, Dhaka, and the relevant transaction relates to its Dilkusha Branch, Dhaka.
25Defendant No. 1 is the vessel MV CRYSTAL SAPPHIRE (IMO No.: 8321096, Flag: Bangladesh), Defendant No. 2 is the Master of the vessel. Defendant No. 3 is the registered owner of the vessel, and Defendant No. 4 is its manager and local agent. Defendants Nos. 5 to 8 are pro-forma defendants, being port and maritime authorities, impleaded for effective implementation of orders of the Court.
26On 15.11.2011, Defendant No. 3 approached the plaintiff bank seeking long-term credit facilities for setting up a bulk cargo shipping business and for importing a second-hand ocean-going dry cargo vessel. Upon due consideration, the plaintiff sanctioned a term loan of BDT 64,98,00,000/- under Sanction Letter dated 04.01.2012 for purchase of the vessel MV CRYSTAL SAPPHIRE.
27As security for the said loan, Defendant No. 3 created a registered first-ranking charge by hypothecation over all its assets, including the vessel, with the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies and Firms on 14.02.2012. A registered mortgage of the vessel was executed on 22.01.2012 in favour of the plaintiff bank with the Mercantile Marine Department, covering a sum of BDT 64,98,00,000/-, along with execution of Power of Attorney authorizing sale of the mortgaged vessel in default.
28The defendant failed to maintain repayment schedules due to alleged recession in the global shipping market. Despite repeated reminders and demands, the liabilities were not adjusted, resulting in
classification of the loan. A written reminder was served on 05.01.2017 and legal notice dated 25.04.2017 was also served upon the defendants demanding liquidation of dues within fifteen days, but the defendants failed to comply with the said demand.
29As on 08.05.2017, the outstanding liability stood at BDT 128,52,82,267.12, inclusive of interest and other related charges. The plaintiff asserts that the dues are admitted and acknowledged and that the defendants are unwilling to repay unless compelled by law.
30Apprehending that the defendants may cause the vessel to sail away or be demolished to defeat recovery, the plaintiff instituted the present admiralty suit invoking section 3(2) of the Admiralty Court Act, 2000, seeking recovery of its dues by sale of the mortgaged vessel and consequential reliefs, including arrest of the vessel
313. Defendant nos. 1-4 entered appearance in the suit and filed written statement stating inter alia that the plaintiff has no locus standi and that the subject-matter of the dispute does not fall within the admiralty jurisdiction of this Honourable Court under the Admiralty Court Act, 2000 or the Admiralty Rules, 1912.
32The defendants further assert that no cause of action has arisen for filing the present suit and that the suit is bad for mis-joinder and nonjoinder of necessary parties. The defendants dispute the allegations relating to default, outstanding liabilities, and alleged acknowledgments of debt. The defendants deny the contention of the plaintiff that the
defendants intend to remove or demolish the vessel to avoid repayment. The defendants also deny that the plaintiff is entitled to arrest or sale of the vessel under admiralty jurisdiction.
33It is further contended that the facts narrated in the plaint, even if admitted, do not constitute a legally enforceable cause of action under admiralty law. Consequently, the defendants pray for dismissal of the suit with costs and for such other reliefs as the Court may deem fit and proper.
344. The issues framed in the instant suit are as follows:
351. Whether this suit is maintainable in its present form and
36nature?
372. Whether there is any cause of action for the plaintiff?
383. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get the relief prayed
39for?
404. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get any other relief(s)
41in this suit?
425. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree as prayed for?
436. Whether the defendants Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 4 are entitled to any
44relief?
457. Whether the Defendant No. 3 took loan from the plaintiff-
46Bank?
478. Whether the Defendant No. 3 became defaulter?
489. Whether the Ship namely M.V. Crystal Sapphire was mortgaged
49to the Plaintiff-Bank against the loan liability of the defendant
50no. 3?
515. The plaintiff in support of his case examined Tamim Hossain (Turjo), Officer (Cash) of BASIC Bank Limited, Dilkusha Branch,
Dhaka as PW-1. The said PW-1 was cross-examined by the defendants. However, the defendants did not produce any witness in support of their case.
52The plaintiff in support of its case exhibited letter of authority (Ext- 1), sanction for opening L/C for importing vessel namely MV Crystal Sapphire and acceptance of shipping documents (Ext-2), sanction letter dated 04.01.2012 (Ext-2A), ship registration certificate (Ext-3), mortgage registration certificate (Ext- 4), charge creation certificates with RJSC with relevant deeds (Ext-5), power of attorney (Ext-6), Legal Notice dated 25.04.2017 (Ext-7), Bank Statement of Loan Account (Ext8). The documents were exhibited without any objection from the defendants.
536. Mr. Md. Monzur Alam Khan, learned advocate for the plaintiff drawing attention of this court to the plaint and exhibited documents submitted that the instant suit is maintainable and the plaintiff has been able to establish and prove its case and therefore, entitled to get the decree as prayed for. As to maintainability the learned advocate has relied upon in the case of First Security Islami Bank Ltd vs MV Javed and others, reported in 69 DLR (2017) 408.
546.1 No one appears on behalf of the defendants at the time of argument hearing.
557. Issue of Maintainability:
56As to the issue of maintainability the learned advocate for the plaintiff has referred the case of First Security Islami Bank Ltd (supra) wherein it has been held in that-
5745. There is another important aspect of the matter. The authority
58of the Admiralty Court is being entrusted upon a bench of the High
59Court Division in accordance with the provision of section 8 of the
60Admiralty Court Act 2000. The Jurisdiction of the High Court
61Division is derived from the provision of article 101 of the
62Constitution which provides that "the High Court Division shall
63have such original, appellate and other jurisdiction and powers as
64are conferred on it by this constitution or any other law".
65Therefore this particular bench of the High Court Division, despite
66its identification as 'court (Admiralty Court)' is a bench of the
67High Court Division of the Bangladesh Supreme Court, which is
68being constituted under the Constitution of Bangladesh, having no
69essence of Civil Court constituted under the provision of 'Civil
70Court Act 1887. The restriction imposed by section 5 of the Artha
71Rin Adalat Ain 2003 is directed towards the Civil Court and not to
72any court constituted under the provision of the constitution of
73Bangladesh. If any restriction upon the jurisdiction of the High
74Court Division is to put, that has to be done by direct wording. No
75implied restriction shall bar the functioning the High Court
76Division and, as such, cannot be taken into consideration.
7746. In the referred case of ICICI Ltd. vs MFV SHILPA, reported in
78AIR 2002 Bombay 371, it was argued that recovery of debt due to
79Banks under the banks and Financial Institution Act 1993 (Act 51
80of 1993) of India through the provision of its section 17 and 2(g)
81barred the jurisdiction of the Admiralty Court to entertain a suit
82the object of which was to realize the loan amount advanced to the
83maritime vessel. There lordship Mr. DK Deshmullah J refused to
84agree to the arguments on the ground that the said Act did not
85categorically barred the jurisdiction of the Admiralty court and, as
86such, outstanding loan amount against a vessel can be realized by
87way of Admiralty suit against the vessel (the res) and the said
88provision shall have no application against the Admiralty suit.
8946. We are in humble agreement with his lordship since the similar
90question is involved in the instant application.
9147. XXX
9248. Therefore this court is in firm view that the provision of
93section 5 of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain 2003 is not applicable
94against the Jurisdiction of this bench of the High Court Division
95known as Admiralty Court, which has been imposed upon it
96through section 8 of the Admiralty Court Act 2000. A suit for the
97purpose of realization of investment/loan amount against a
98maritime or inland vessel or any navigable device is squarely
99maintainable under section 3(2) of the Admiralty Court Act 2000,
100against which the provision of section 5 of the Artha Rin Adalat
101Ain 2003 is not applicable. Therefore, this court finds that the
102instant suit, filed in the Admiralty Jurisdiction for realization of
103invested money on the vessels is squarely maintainable. ] Moreover, in the case of Bank Asia Limited vs. M.T. Atlanta Ex. Vinashin Atlantic and Ors. reported in 25 BLC (2020) 677 as to the issue of maintainability it was held as follows:
10415. The learned Advocate Mr. Kamal-ul Alam, appearing on
105behalf of the plaintiff while taken this court through the provision
106of section 3(2)(Ga) of the Admiralty Court Act 2001, drew the
107attention of this court to the fact that the plaintiff being a financial
108institution, invested money on the defendant No. 1 vessel by way of
109establishing L/C and paying the L/C amount to the seller of the
110vessel, upon creating primary charge upon the res, the defendant
111No. 1 vessel, as appears from the sanction letter, exhibit 4(a) and
112as such the instant suit is primarily a proceeding in rem against
113the defendant No. 1 vessel and also a proceeding in personam
114against the defendant No. 2 through its proprietor Mr. Md. Gias
115Uddin, being the applicant for the documentary credit for
116purchasing the defendant No. 1 vessel. The provision of section
1173(2)(Ga) of the Admiralty Court Act 2000 categorically entitled the
118plaintiff to instituted the suit in the Admiralty Court and
119accordingly the instant suit is maintainable.
12016. It appears that the plaintiff, being a financial institution, has
121filed the instant suit praying decree for realization of the
122outstanding dues of the invested money it has made in purchasing
123and importing the defendant No. 1 vessel. The plaintiff claims that
124the proprietor of the defendant No. 2 one Mr. Md. Gias Uddin was
125allowed to establish Letter of Credit through the plaintiff Bank for
126an amount of US$ 7682,902.28, equivalent to BD Tk.
12759,92,70,000.00, conversion rate being US$ 1=BD Tk 78.00. at a
128margin of 15%, upon which the defendant No. 2 deposited BD Tk.
12989.89 million in two method, a part by way of cash deposit and
130part by way FDR deposit, Accordingly plaintiff established the L/C
131by engaging its own fund of BD Taka 44,48,67,247.80 for the total
132L/C value of US$ 7,682,902.28.
13317. By the documents, exhibit Nos. 5 and 6, the sanction letters and also by other documents as to the documentary credit, being Exhibit Nos. 7, 8, 9 and 10. It appears that the plaintiff has opened the Letter of Credit for the purchase and import of the defendant No. 1 vessel on the account of the defendant No. 2 on the primary charge upon the vessel as appears from exhibit No. 4(a). The law relating to documentary credit provides
that so long the defendant No. 2 does not retrieve the documents upon paying the L/C amount, upon adjustment of the L/C margin paid by it, along with the stipulated interest, the title of the imported goods, subject to the sanction letter, shall remain with the L/C opener bank on the account of the L/C applicant. The defendant No. 2 allegedly did not retrieve the documents for the defendant No. 1 from the Plaintiff vessel and the sanction letters, exhibits 4 and 4(a) having not shown no derogation, as such the plaintiff remained the owner of the defendant No. 1 vessel. This being an investment on the vessel, a maritime devise, and not simple loan allowed to the defendant No. 2, the plaintiff is entitle to invoke the provision of section 3(2) of the Admiralty court Act 2000 and not the provision of Artho Rin Adalat Rin 2003, and accordingly the plaintiff is entitled to recover and realize the outstanding L/C amount along with the stipulated interest, through initiating a proceeding in the Admiralty Jurisdiction. Therefore the instant suit is maintainable in the Admiralty Court. Accordingly issue No. 1 is disposed off the plaintiff. 7.1 In addition to the observations made hereinabove, this Court further observes that the term "Original Jurisdiction" signifies a court's power to hear and decide a matter as the court of first instance. Unlike subordinate courts, the High Court Division’s original jurisdiction is directly recognized by the Constitution, placing it in a unique position within the judicial hierarchy. When the Admiralty Court Act, 2000 confers jurisdiction on the High Court Division, it is activating the constitutional capacity of the court under Article 101.
134This constitutional status carries profound implications for the maintainability of suits. A court established or empowered by the Constitution, such as the High Court Division acting as a Court of Record, possesses inherent powers that cannot be easily displaced or overridden by sub-constitutional statutes unless such ouster is explicit and does not infringe upon the "basic structure" of the judiciary. In the context of admiralty matters, the High Court Division serves as a specialized forum for the protection of international trade and maritime assets, a role that transcends general civil litigation.
135While Parliament has the power to establish specialized tribunals, such as the Artha Rin Adalat, for specific purposes, these tribunals remain subordinate to the High Court Division. The jurisdiction of the Artha Rin Adalat is limited to the recovery of "money/loans" provided by financial institutions. In contrast, the Admiralty Court’s jurisdiction is defined by the nature of the asset which is “vessel/ship” and the specialized maritime claims arising from it, regardless of the status of the claimant as a bank or an individual.
1367.2 In the present admiralty suit it is the case of the plaintiff that on prayer of defendant no. 3, they issued at first a sanction letter for opening L/C for importing the defendant vessel (Ext-) and subsequently sanctioned a term loan of BDT 64,98,00,000/- under Sanction Letter dated 04.01.2012 for purchase of the vessel (Ext- 2A).
137As security for the said loan, Defendant No. 3 created a registered first-ranking charge by hypothecation over all its assets, including the vessel, with the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies and Firms on 14.02.2012 (Ext-5). A registered mortgage of the vessel was executed on 22.01.2012 in favour of the plaintiff bank with the Mercantile Marine Department (Ext- 4). But despite repeated reminders and issuance of legal notice the principal defendants failed to repay the loan liability and adjust the dues of the Bank.
138Therefore, having regard to the facts, circumstances, and legal issues involved, the principles enunciated in the above-cited decisions are squarely applicable to the present case and as such, the instant suit is held to be maintainable.
1398. The remaining issues, being inextricably connected with one another, are taken up together for consideration and disposal.
140In the present admiralty suit it is the case of the plaintiff that on prayer of defendant no. 3, they issued at first a sanction letter for opening L/C for importing the defendant vessel (Ext-) and subsequently sanctioned a term loan of BDT 64,98,00,000/- under Sanction Letter dated 04.01.2012 for purchase of the vessel (Ext- 2A).
141As security for the said loan, Defendant No. 3 created a registered first-ranking charge by hypothecation over all its assets, including the vessel, with the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies and Firms on 14.02.2012 (Ext-5). A registered mortgage of the vessel was executed on
22.01.2012 in favour of the plaintiff bank with the Mercantile Marine Department (Ext- 4).
142The plaintiff further asserted that despite repeated reminders and demands, the liabilities were not adjusted, resulting in classification of the loan. A legal notice dated 25.04.2017 was served upon the defendants demanding liquidation of dues within fifteen days, but the defendants failed to comply with the said demand (Ext- 7). The plaintiff also has also produced the relevant statement Loan Account (Ext-8)
143PW-1 was extensively cross-examined by the defendants. A careful reading of the cross-examination reveals that the defendants, in substance, did not controvert the liability itself but confined their objection primarily to the maintainability of the suit in this forum. And the issue of maintainability has already been decided in favour of the plaintiff in earlier paragraphs.
1448.1 Therefore, on a careful appreciation of the evidence on record and the legal principles discussed hereinabove, this Court holds that the plaintiff has duly established and proved its claim and is entitled to the reliefs sought for in the plaint. It is further been informed to this court that the defendant vessel has already been sold by way of judicial auction in connection with another Admiralty Suit.
1459. Accordingly, the instant suit is required to be decreed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants.
146The court fee paid is sufficient.
147Hence ordered that-
148The instant suit is hereby decreed against the principal defendants for an amount of BDT 128,52,82,267.12 with interest @ 12% from the date of filing of the admiralty suit till the date of realization.
14910. The plaintiff is further entitled to realize the decretal amount by executing the decree and to satisfy the decretal amount from the sale proceeds of the defendant No. 1 vessel M.V. CRYSTAL SAPPHIRE.
150However, there shall be no order as to cost.
151(Sikder Mahmudur Razi, J:)
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











