High Court Division · Admiralty Jurisdiction
Chittagong Dry Dock Limited v M.T. FADL-E-RABBI and others
Admiralty Suit 92/2016 · Decided 1 March 2026
Chittagong Dry Dock Limited repaired the tanker M.T. FADL-E-RABBI at its owner's request in 2016, after warning that dock/jetty charges of Tk. 5,00,000 per day would apply. It received an advance of Tk. 10,00,000 and issued a repair bill of USD 191,039.41 (Tk. 1,66,01,325.02), which was never paid. The undocked vessel stayed at the jetty and was later arrested in another suit. The dry dock sued the vessel in rem (against the ship itself) and the defendants in personam. Defendants 1 and 3 entered appearance but filed no written statement. On unchallenged evidence, the High Court Division held that the claim was a maritime claim under section 3(2)(m) of the Admiralty Court Act, 2000, and that the repairs, acceptance by the vessel's officers and the unpaid bill were proved. As a bailee for reward, the dry dock had a possessory lien under section 170 of the Contract Act, 1872. The Court decreed Tk. 6,56,01,325 with 6% interest, payable from the vessel's sale proceeds subject to lawful priorities.
- Q1
Whether a claim for ship repairs and dock or jetty charges is maintainable in the admiralty jurisdiction both in rem against the vessel and in personam against the defendants.
- Q2
Whether the dry dock proved the unpaid repair bill and accrued dock/jetty charges, and in what amount.
- Q3
Whether the dry dock, as bailee, had a possessory lien over the vessel, and what rate of interest should be awarded.
- A claim for ship repairs and dock or jetty charges is a maritime claim within section 3(2)(m) of the Admiralty Court Act, 2000, so the suit was maintainable in rem against the vessel and in personam against the defendants.
- The plaintiff proved on the balance of probabilities that the repairs were ordered, performed and accepted by the vessel's officers, that the bill remained unpaid, and that jetty charges accrued up to 30.11.2016.
- The proved repair bill of Tk. 1,66,01,325 and jetty charges of Tk. 5,00,00,000 for 100 days, less the Tk. 10,00,000 advance, left Tk. 6,56,01,325 due.
- A dry dock taking possession of a vessel for repair acts as a bailee for reward and, under section 170 of the Contract Act, 1872, had a possessory lien over the vessel when the cause of action arose; all issues except issue 6, on whether that lien ranks above all other liens, were decided for the plaintiff.
- As no contractual or statutory basis for 20% interest was proved, the Court awarded interest at 6% per annum from filing until realisation, to be satisfied from the vessel's sale proceeds held by the Marshal subject to lawful priorities and competing claims.
A Dry Dock facility when taking possession of a vessel for repairs or maintenance, operates in the capacity of a bailee for reward.
In the court’s own words.
Admiralty Suit 92/2016, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 7 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2HIGH COURT DIVISION
3(ADMIRALTY JURISDICTION)
4Present:
5Mr. Justice Sikder Mahmudur Razi
6ADMIRALTY SUIT NO. 92 of 2016.
7IN THE MATTER OF:
8Chittagong Dry Dock Limited
9… Plaintiff.
10VERSUS
11M.T. FADL-E-RABBI, IMO No. 9078177, Flag:
12Panama, and others.
13… Defendants.
14Mr. Mohiuddin Abdul Kadir, Adv. with
15Ms. Zinia Amin, Adv. with
16Mr. Noor Mohammad Mozumder Roni, Adv.
17…For the plaintiff.
18None appears
19…. For the defendants.
20Heard on: 10.02.2026
21And
22Judgement on: The 1st March, 2026
231. The instant admiralty suit has been instituted by the plaintiff, Chittagong Dry Dock Limited, for recovery of unpaid ship-repair charges and dock/jetty charges in respect of the vessel M.T. FADL-E-RABBI (IMO No. 9078177), together with interest and costs.
242. The case of the plaintiff, as disclosed in the plaint, is that Chittagong Dry Dock Limited is an enterprise of Bangladesh Steel & Engineering Corporation providing dry docking and ship repair facilities to the vessels that call the Chattogram Port. By a letter dated 24.05.2016, the registered owner of the defendant vessel requested the plaintiff to provide drydocking and repair services. The plaintiff accepted the request, confirmed
the schedule, and asked for advance payment while also notifying that dock/jetty charges would accrue at the rate of Tk. 5,00,000 per day. In response, the defendants paid a total sum of Tk. 10,00,000 by two pay orders as advance against the repair works.
25The vessel was docked at the plaintiff’s facility on 28.07.2016. An official work order dated 30.07.2016 was issued by the owner specifying the scope of work. The plaintiff carried out the repairs accordingly, and the vessel was undocked on 12.08.2016. Upon completion of the repairs, the plaintiff prepared work done certificates and a list of general services, which were duly signed by the Master and responsible officers of the vessel, thereby acknowledging that the works had been satisfactorily completed.
26Thereafter, on 14.08.2016, the plaintiff issued a repair bill for USD 191,039.41, equivalent to Tk. 1,66,01,325.02. Despite repeated demands, the defendants failed to make payment of the said bill. Although, under the plaintiff’s internal rules, payment is required before undocking, the plaintiff allowed the vessel to be undocked in order to mitigate further loss and operational difficulties. However, the vessel continued to remain tied up at the plaintiff’s jetty, and the plaintiff notified that dock/jetty charges would accrue from 22.08.2016 onwards at the previously communicated daily rate.
27The plaintiff claims dock/jetty charges for a period of 100 days up to 30.11.2016. It is further pleaded that the vessel was subsequently arrested
in another admiralty suit, giving rise to apprehension that the plaintiff’s lawful dues might not be realized unless enforced through admiralty process. Accordingly, the present suit was filed seeking recovery of the repair bill and dock/jetty charges from the vessel in rem and from the defendants in personam.
283. Although defendant nos. 1 and 3 entered appearance in the suit, they neither filed any written statement nor contested the suit at subsequent stage.
294. The following issues have been framed in the instant suit:
301. Whether the suit is maintainable under the Admiralty
31Jurisdiction of this Court?
322. Whether the plaintiff actually commenced docking and repair
33works to the defendant no. 1 vessel M.T. FADL-E-RABBI?
343. Whether the plaintiff raised invoices against their docking,
35repair works, and jetty charges?
364. Whether the defendants are liable to pay the plaintiff for
37docking and repair works to the defendant no. 1 vessel M.T. FADL-
38E-RABBI and also the jetty charges?
395. Whether the plaintiff had possessory lien over the vessel M.T.
40FADL-E-RABBI, when the causes of action arose?
416. Whether possessory lien of the plaintiff ranks over all other
42types of lien upon the vessel M.T. FADL-E-RABBI?
435. In order to prove its case, the plaintiff examined three witnesses. PW-1, an Assistant Engineer of the plaintiff, proved the repair
engagement, docking and undocking of the vessel, completion of works, and the relevant documents including the work order, work-done certificates and repair bill and the documents produced by the said PW-1 was marked as Exhibit- 1 to 14. PW-2, the Legal Officer corroborated PW1 as well as proved the institution of the suit, the plaintiff’s entitlement to recover its dues through admiralty proceedings, and the authorizations under which the suit was conducted. The documents produced by the said PW-2 was marked as Exhibit 15 and 16. PW-3, the Accounts Officer also corroborated PW-1 & 2 as well as, proved the computation of the outstanding dues, including the advance received and the net amount payable. Their evidence appears to be consistent, cogent, and supported by contemporaneous documents. No contrary evidence has been produced by the defendants.
445.1. The exhibited documents are Official nomination of witnesses of the Plaintiff dated 02.02.2021 (Ext-1), Drydocking/repair request schedule of M.T. Fadl-E-Rabbi dated 24.05.2016 (Ext-2), Drydocking schedule of M.T. Fadl-E-Rabbi dated 28.06.2016 (Ext-3), Drydocking schedule of M.T. Fadl-E-Rabbi dated 12.07.2016 (Ext-4), Letter issued by Eden Line dated 29.06.2016 along with a copy of a Pay Order (Ext-5), Letter issued by Eden Line dated 25.07.2016 along with a copy of a pay order & Interdepartmental note dated 26.07.2016 (Ext-6), Work Order dated 28.07.2016 (Ext-7), Letter issued by Eden Line dated 30.07.2016 appointing Chittagong Dry Dock Ltd to do certain job for the vessel (Ext-8), Memo issued for undocking of the vessel (Ext- 9), List of General Services
provided to the vessel (Ext-10), Work Done Certificate (Ext-11), Bill for Dry Docking Repair (Ext-12), Reminder for bill payment dated 26.08.2016 (Ext- 13), Breakdown of the total Bill (Ext-14), 2 Letter of Authorizations (Ext- 15 & 16) .
456. The learned advocate for the plaintiff, taking us through the plaint and other materials on record, submitted that the plaintiff carried out repair works and docking of the vessel M.T. Fadl-E-Rabbi, maintained a possessory lien on the vessel against their outstanding dues, and was in the position of a bailee. The learned advocate further submitted that the bill amount for the services provided was never disputed, but rather admitted, and therefore, in law as well as in fact, the plaintiff is entitled to the decree as prayed for.
467. Upon careful consideration of the pleadings, the oral evidence of PW1, PW-2 and PW-3, and the materials on record, this Court finds that the plaintiff has been able to prove that the repairs were duly ordered and performed, that the works were accepted by the vessel’s officers, and that the repair bill remains unpaid. The advance payment of Tk. 10,00,000/has been correctly credited. The evidence further establishes that the vessel continued to occupy the plaintiff’s jetty after completion of repairs and that dock/jetty charges accrued as claimed up to 30.11.2016.
478. A claim for ship repairs and dock or jetty charges is a maritime claim squarely falling within the admiralty jurisdiction of this Court particularly under Section 3(2)(m) of the Admiralty Court Act, 2000. The
suit, as framed, is therefore maintainable both as an action in rem against the vessel and as an action in personam against the defendants. The plaintiff has also discharged its burden of proof on the balance of probabilities, which is the standard applicable in civil proceedings. 8.1. As regards the quantum, the plaintiff has proved a repair bill amounting to Tk.1,66,01,325.00 and dock/jetty charges amounting to Tk.5,00,00,000.00 for 100 days, making a total of Tk. 6,66,01,325.00. After deducting the admitted advance of Tk. 10,00,000.00, the net outstanding amount comes to Tk. 6,56,01,325.00, which this Court finds to be duly proved.
488.2 Admittedly, the plaintiff Chattogram Dry Dock Limited carried out repair works and docking of the vessel. A Dry Dock facility when taking possession of a vessel for repairs or maintenance, operates in the capacity of a bailee for reward. Section 170 of the Contract Act, 1872 runs as follows;
49170. Bailee’s Particular Lien: Where the bailee has, in
50accordance with the purpose of the bailment, rendered any
51service involving the exercise of labour or skill in respect of
52the goods bailed, he has, in the absence of a contract to the
53contrary, a right to retain such goods until he receives due
54remuneration for the service he has rendered in respect of
55them.
56Therefore, the plaintiff had possessory lien over the vessel M.T. FADL-E-RABBI, when the causes of action arose.
579. Accordingly, all the issues except issue no. 6 are hereby decided in favour of the plaintiff. Further, the plaintiff prayed for interest at the rate of 20% per annum. However, no contractual or statutory basis for such rate has been proved. In the absence of any agreed rate of interest, the Court is required to award interest at a reasonable rate. Considering the commercial nature of the transaction and the prolonged non-payment of a proved debt, this Court is of the view that interest at the rate of 6% would meet the ends of justice.
5810. In view of the foregoing reasons, the suit is decreed in favour of the plaintiff. The plaintiff shall recover a sum of Tk. 6,56,01,325.00 from the defendants, jointly and severally, and from the defendant vessel in rem. The plaintiff is awarded pendente lite interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of filing of the suit until realization.
5911. The decretal amount shall be satisfied out of the sale proceeds of the defendant vessel lying with the Marshal of this Court, subject to lawful priorities and competing claims.
6012. The suit is thus decreed. The court fee paid is sufficient. However, there shall be no order as to cost.
61(Sikder Mahmudur Razi, J:)
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











