Appellate Division
Shafika Chowdhury and others v Badrul Amin alias Manu Sardar and others
Civil Appeal 518/2017 · Decided 17 January 2023
The plaintiff sued in Dhaka for a declaration of title to a plot, saying the original RAJUK lessee had sold it to him by a registered deed in 1978 after permission from the then DIT. The lessee's heirs, the defendants, said the deed was forged. The trial court dismissed the suit, doubting the deed because, among other things, the sub-registrar's seal bore a wrong spelling and the plaintiff did not prove it from the registry volume. The High Court Division allowed the plaintiff's appeal after hearing him alone. In the Appellate Division, the Court found that the plaintiff's own documents were inconsistent with his case, that he did not know the vendor's village or visit his home, and that he had not proved possession, so a suit for mere declaration without a prayer for recovery of possession was not maintainable. It held that the High Court Division ignored this evidence and decided the appeal cursorily. The appeal was allowed and the High Court Division's judgment and decree were set aside.
Appeal allowed; High Court Division decree set aside
- High Court Division (HCD)The lower of the two Divisions of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh, which hears writs, appeals, revisions, bail matters and some original cases.Read the full explanation →
- Decree (dikri)The formal order recording a civil court's final decision on the parties' rights in a suit, which can be appealed and is enforced by execution.Read the full explanation →
- Set asideTo cancel an earlier court order, decree, award, sale or conviction so that it no longer has legal effect, usually by a higher court or by the same court on a proper application.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether the High Court Division was right to reverse the trial court and decree a suit for declaration of title on a sale deed that the defendants said was forged.
- Q2
Whether a suit for mere declaration of title, without a prayer for recovery of possession, was maintainable where the plaintiff failed to prove possession.
- Q3
Whether the High Court Division decided the first appeal in accordance with Order XLI rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
- The Court held that the plaintiff's documents, including the alleged agreement and the RAJUK permission papers, were inconsistent with his plaint case and appeared to have been created for the suit.
- The Court held that the plaintiff's evidence showed no previous acquaintance with the lessee, which made the alleged agreement, sale deed and payment of consideration doubtful.
- The Court held that the plaintiff failed to prove his possession of the suit land, so the suit without a prayer for recovery of possession was not maintainable.
- The Court held that the trial court's conclusion was more acceptable and that the High Court Division ignored the evidence in reversing it.
- The Court held that the High Court Division decided the first appeal in a cursory manner without meeting Order XLI rule 31, and allowed the appeal, setting aside its judgment and decree.
That is, the plaintiff has failed to prove his possession in the suit land. In such view of the matter, the instant suit, without the prayer for recovery possession, was not maintainable.
In the court’s own words.
Civil Appeal 518/2017, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 14 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2APPELLATE DIVISION
3PRESENT:
4Mr. Justice Hasan Foez Siddique,
5Chief Justice
6Mr. Justice M. Enayetur Rahim
7Mr. Justice Jahangir Hossain CIVIL APPEAL NO. 518 OF 2017.
8(From the judgment and decree dated 18.06.2013 passed by the High Court Division in First Appeal No.59 of 2010)
9Shafika Chowdhury and others : Appellants.
10=Versus= Badrul Amin @ Manu Sardar and others : Respondents. For the Appellant : Mr.Nozrul Islam Chowdhury,
11Senior Advocate, instructed
12by Mr. Md. Zahirul Islam,
13Advocate-on-Record.
14For the Respondent No.1: Mr. Md. Nurul Amin, Senior
15Advocate, instructed by Mr.
16M. Soyeb Khan, Advocate-
17on-Record.
18For the Respondent No.2 : Mr. Waliul Islam, Advocate-
19on-Record.
20Respondent No.3 : Not represented.
21Date of hearing : 04.01.2023 & 10.01.2023 Date of judgment : 17.01.2023.
22JUDGMENT Hasan Foez Siddique, C. J: This civil appeal is directed against the judgment and decree dated 18.06.2013 passed by the High Court Division in First Appeal No.59 of 2010 reversing those dated 25.11.2009 passed by the Joint District Judge, First Court, Dhaka in Title Suit No.187 of 2008.
23The relevant facts, for the disposal of this appeal, are that the respondent No.1 filed Title Suit No.187 of 2008 in the First Court of Joint District Judge, Dhaka, praying for declaration of his title in respect of the suit land stating that one Nurur Rahman Chowdhury took lease of suit land by lease deed No.1104 dated 08.07.1976 from the then DIT, at present, RAJUK. He constructed structure thereon. He sold the suit land to the plaintiff at a consideration of Tk.3,70,375.00 by a registered deed dated 18.4.1978. He got sale permission from the RAJUK on 26.9.1977. The plaintiff got his name mutated in 2006 and paid rents and taxes. The defendants claimed that Nurur Rahman Chowdhury did not sell the suit property.
24Accordingly, the plaintiff lodged G.D. No.83 dated 01.11.2007 with Uttara Police Station. The plaintiff came to know from the RAJUK that the defendants applied for mutation of their names though their predecessor Nurur Rahman Chowdhury had sold the suit land to the plaintiff. Hence, the plaintiff has filed this suit.
25The defendant appellants contested the suit contending that Nurur Rahman Chowdhury got lease
of the suit land from D.I.T (now RAJUK). He died on 20.05.1986 leaving behind wife, three sons and two daughters, who, on 11.06.2006, applied to the RAJUK for mutation of their names and, accordingly mutation was made in their names. One Abu Sayeed Bepari made an attempt to grab the property by force. The matter was referred to the law enforcing authority and Abu Sayeed Bepari, on 26.9.2005, executed a “nadabipatra” in favour of the defendants admitting the title of the defendants in the suit land. One Hosne Ara Daud, on 17.01.1993, instituted a suit for specific performance of contract stating that Nurur Rahman Chowdhury came to an agreement for sale of the suit land with her which was dismissed. The defendants came to know that, on 26.06.2003, one Sardar Abdur Rahman filed Title Suit No.65 of 2005 for declaration of his title in the suit land. The said suit was dismissed on 26.06.2007. The instant suit has been filed by forging sale permission from the RAJUK. The defendants made boundary wall
and constructed tin-shed in the suit land. The suit should be dismissed.
26The trial Court dismissed the suit. The plaintiff preferred First Appeal No.59 of 2010 in the High Court Division. The High Court Division, upon ex-parte hearing of the plaintiff, by its judgment and decree dated 18.06.2013 allowed the appeal upon setting aside the judgment and decree of the trial Court.
27Against the judgment and decree passed by the High Court Division the defendants have preferred this appeal upon getting leave.
28Mr. Nozrul Islam Chowdhury, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants, submits that the respondent has obtained an ex parte decree in appeal by practising fraud upon the Court suppressing the notices upon the present defendant appellants, so the judgment and decree of the appellate Court is liable to be set aside. He further submits that the positive finding arrived at by the trial Court, upon consideration of the evidence and materials, was, inter alia, that;‘‘D³ gvgjvi avivevwnKZvq KzPµxgn‡ji cÖ‡ivPbvq eZ©gvb ev`x RvwjqvwZ P‡µi m`m¨ nBqv GKwU
Rvj `wjj m„Rb Kwiqv Av`vj‡Zi mvg‡b bvwjwk m¤úwËi gvwjKvbvi Kvwnbx m„Rb Kwiqv‡Qb|ÕÕ which has not been reversed by the Appellate Court. He submits that the impugned judgment and decree passed ex parte by the High Court Division is violative of the provisions of Order XLI Rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure and as such, the same is liable to be set aside. He, lastly, submits that the plaintiff being out of possession of the suit land, suit for mere declaration was not maintainable.
29Mr. Md. Nurul Amin, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondents, submits that original lessee Nurur Rahman Chowdhury, at first, executed a bainanama in favour of the plaintiff on 20.01.1978 and, thereafter, executed and registered a sale deed dated 18.04.1978 in his favour, thereby, his right, title, interest and possession in the land, in question, has been divested to the plaintiff, the High Court Division upon proper appreciation of the evidence on record, decreed the suit.
30It appears that the plaintiff Badrul Amin @ Manu Sardar, represented by his power of Attorney Md. Helal Uddin, filed instant Title Suit No.187 of 2008 on 09.01.2008 stating that Nurur Rahman Chowdhury got the suit land from DIT, at present
RAJUK. The plaintiff purchased the same from him by registered sale deed dated 18.04.1978 upon payment of consideration of a sum of taka 3,70,375/-. Before sale, Nurur Rahman Chowdhury took permission from the then DIT by letter communicated under Memo No.DIT.Estate/3169 dated 26.09.1977. Thereafter, the plaintiff purchaser mutated his name in the khatian as well as in the office of the RAJUK. It is the case of the contesting defendant-appellants that the aforesaid kabla deed of the plaintiff is forged one and their predecessor Nurur Rahman did not execute and register any such sale deed in favour of the plaintiff. The trial Court, upon consideration of the evidence on record, held that,Ò ‡mB K_v weev`x c‡¶i bvwjkx m¤úwË AvZ¥mvr Kivi KzgZj‡e ev`x B‡Zvc~‡e© Ab¨ †jvK w`qv gvgjv `v‡qi Kiv nBqvwQj Ges D³ gvgjvq civwRZ nBqvwQj| D³ gvgjvi avivevwnKZvq KzPµxgn‡ji cª‡ivPbvq eZ©gvb ev`x RvwjqvwZ P‡µi m`m¨ nBqv GKwU R¦vj `wjj m„Rb Kwiqv Av`vj‡Zi mvg‡b bvwjkx wb¯úwIi gvwjKvbvi Kvwnbx m„Rb Kwiqv‡QbÓ . Thereafter, the trial Court observed that, ÒmyZivs R¦vj `wjj Gi gva¨‡g ev`x Av`vj‡Z gvgjv Kwiqv R¡vj `wjj e‡j bvwjkx m¤úwˇZ gvwjKvbv cªwZôv Kivi cªkœB Av‡m bv|Ó The High Court Division, while reversing the finding as to the creation of the title deed of the plaintiff by way of forgery, has stated, “It is true that seal in sale deed appeared with spelling as ‘Sadar Sub-Register’ but signature of
the Sub-Register was with each of the seal of the deed”. The trial Court observed that it is difficult to accept that a responsible office of Sub-Registrar shall prepare and use its seal as “Office of the Sub-Register”. The word “ SubRegister” in the official seal of Sub-Registrar created a doubt about the genuineness of the deed itself. Since it is the case of the defendants that the said deed is forged one it was the duty of the plaintiff to prove his deed upon calling the volume book from the concerned SubRegistrar’s office but he did not take any such step.
31It further appears from the materials on record that the plaintiff Badrul Amin earlier came to an agreement with admitted owner Nurur Rahman Chowdhury on 20.01.1978. In his examination- inchief P.W.1 Md. Badrul Amin @ Manu Sardar has said, Òbyi“i ingvb †PŠayixi mwnZ evqbv 20/1/78 Bs Zvwi‡L nq Dnvi Kwc Av`vj‡Z `vwLj Kwijvg| (cª`t 8) Ó that is, it is definite claim of the plaintiff (P.W.1) that he came to an agreement on 20.01.1978 with Nurur Rahman Chowdhury. In his pleading, the plaintiff has said Nurur Rahman Chowdhury filed an application for getting permission for sale of the suit land to the plaintiff and, accordingly, he got permission for
sale from the then DIT vide Memo No.DIT/Estate/3169 dated 26.09.1977. That is, according to pleading and evidence of the plaintiff Nurur Rahman Chowdhury got permission from the then DIT on 26.09.1977 and executed “bainanama” with the plaintiff on 20.01.1978. According to the plaint case, Nurur Rahman Chowdhury took permission from RAJUK to transfer the suit land on 26.09.1977 but the Exhibit-8, the alleged “bainanama” dated 20.01.1978, shows that it was recited, inter alia, ÒB¤úªyf‡g›U óªvó wWAvBwU feb nB‡Z AbygwZ cvIqvi ci evqbvbvgv `wjj MªwnZv‡K wjwLZfv‡e Zvnv Rvbv‡bv nB‡e| Z‡e B¤úªyf‡g›U óªv‡ói AbygwZ wb‡Z hw` †Kvb µ‡g †`wi nq Zvnv nB‡j 90 w`‡bi ¯n‡j Avjvc-Av‡jvPbvi wfwˇZ mgq e„w× Kiv hvB‡e|Ó If story of getting permission to transfer the suit land on 26.09.1977 was true then, at the time of execution of alleged “bainanama” dated 20.01.1978 the above quoted statement in the “bainanama” would not be mentioned. It further appears from the Exhibit-8 that price of the property, in question, was settled at tk.3,70,375/ and Nurur Rahman, receiving tk. 1,00,000/-, executed the same and there was a stipulation that the plaintiff should pay the rest amount of taka 2,70,375/- within 90 days but the plaintiff in his evidence did not say so.
32It further appears from the Exhibit-6 to 6(Ka)
33Nurur Rahman Chowdhury had allegedly filed application for getting permission on 26.09.1977, the contents of the said application for permission run as follows:
34Òcª`k©bx bs-6-6(K)t 26/09/1977 Zvs Gi Av‡e`b I
358/1/78Bs Zvs Gi Aby‡gv`b cÎ| eivei,
36Dc-cwiPvjK (G‡óU)
37wW,KAvB,wU, feb, XvKv-2|
38welqt DËiv g‡Wj UvD‡bi 13bs †m±‡ii 4bs †iv‡Wi Aew¯nZ 9bs c ‡Ui BgviZ mn
39n¯—vš—i cªms‡M| g‡nv`q,
40mwebq wb‡e`b GB †h, Avwg DËiv g‡Wj UvD‡bi 13 bs †m±‡ii 4bs †iv‡W Aew¯nZ 9bs c ‡Ui eivÏ MªwnZv Ges weMZ 30/10/69 Bs ZvwiL †iwRwóªK…Z -11004 jxR `wjj g~‡j D³ c ‡Ui gvwjK| wW,AvB,wU KZ…©K Aby‡gvw`Z bKmv Abyhvqx D³ c ‡U GKLvbv GKZjv BgviZ wbg©vb Kiv nBqv‡Q| eZ©gv‡b Avgvi Avw_©K cª‡qvR‡b BgviZ mn D³ c U Lvbv †gvU UvKv 3,70,375/- (wZb j¶ mËi nvRvi wZbkZ cuPvËi UvKv ) gy‡j¨ Rbve †gvt e`i“j Avwgb Ii‡d gby mi`vi, wcZv Ave`yj nvw` Gg,Gg 33 †K we †Nvl óªxU , _vbv- †KvZqvjx, †Rjv- XvKv Gi wbKU n¯—vš—i Kwi‡Z gb¯— KwiqvwQ| D‡j wLZ Ae¯nvi cwi‡cªw¶‡Z cªv_©bv GB †h, BgviZ mn Dc‡ivwj wLZ c U Lvbv Rbve e`i“j Avwgb Ii‡d gby mi`vi, wcZv Ave`yj nvw`, Gg,G, 33 bs †K,we, óªxU †Nvl, _vbv- †KvZqvjx, †Rjv- XvKv Gi wbKU n¯—vš—i Kivi Rb¨ AbygwZ cª`vb Kwi‡Z AvÁv nq| ZvwiLt 26/09/1977Bs
41Avcbvi wek¡¯—
42¯^vt A¯có
4326/9/77
44(byi“b ingvb †PŠayix)
45wcZv nvRx †gvZvnvi Avjx
46†PŠayix
47mvs-Mvbcvov, _vbv- RvwKMÄ,
48‡Rjv-wm‡jU| Ó
49Exhibit-6(Ka) shows that a letter was issued from the Deputy Director, Estate to Nurur Rahman Chowdhury, the contents of the said letter run as follows:
50Òcª`k©bx bs-6(K)t
51¯^viK bs- wW, AvB,wU/G‡óU/3169/26/9/77B , ZvwiLt 08/01/78Bs
52‡cªiKt Dc-cwiPvjK (G‡óU)
53wW,AvB,wU feb
54XvKv-2|
55cªvcKt byi“b ingvb †PŠayix (jxR MªwnZv),
56wcZv- nvRx †gvZvnvi Avjx †PŠayix
57mvs-Mvbvcvo, _vbv-RvwKMÄ,
58‡Rjv- wm‡jU|
59welqt DËiv AvevwmK GjvKvq 13bs †m±‡ii 4bs iv¯—vi BgviZ mn 9bs c ‡Ui
60n¯—vš—i cªms‡M|
61Avcbvi weMZ 26/9/77 Bs Zvwi‡Li Av‡e`b cÎ AÎ Awd‡mi ¯^viK bs-
623161 ¯’vt ZvwiL 26/9/77 Bs †gvZv‡eK wbg¥ ¯^v¶iKvix Avw`ó nBqv RvbvB‡ZwQ †h,
63Dc‡ivwj wLZ BgviZ mn c U wU Rbve †gvt e`i“j Avwgb Ii‡d gby mi`vi, wcZv
64†gvt Ave`yj nv`x Gg,G, 33, †Kwe †Nvl wóªU, †cvt evey evRvi, _vbv-†KvZqvjx, †Rjv-
65XvKv Gi wbKU n¯—vš—i we‡ePbv mv‡c‡¶ n¯—vš—i wd eve` 30,8,548/- (wÎk j¶
66AvU nvRvi cvuPkZ AvUPwj k) UvKv gvÎ Ges 18/11/68 Bs nB‡Z 18/01/78 Bs
67ch©š— mvwf©m PvR© eve` 2,489/- (`yB nvRvi PvikZ DbbeŸB) UvKv †mvbvjx e¨vsK ,
68wW,AvB,wU feb, kvLvq AvMvgx 8/2/78 Bs Zvwi‡Li g‡a¨ Rgv w`qv RgvK…Z UvKvq
69e¨vsK iwk` cª‡qvRbxq Kvh©Kix e¨e¯nv Mªn‡bi Rb¨ wbg¥ ¯^v¶iKvixi wbKU `vwLj
70Kwi‡Z nB‡e| D‡j wLZ Zvwi‡Li g‡a¨ UvKv Rgv w`‡Z e¨_© nB‡j †Kvb cªKvi †bvwUk
71e¨wZ‡i‡KB D³ evwZj ewjqv MY¨ nB‡e|
72¯^vt A¯có
73(Dc-cwiPvjK G‡óU)
74wW,AvB,wU feb, XvKv| Ó
75The RAJUK allegedly gave permission with certain terms and conditions which run as follows:
76Òcª`k©bx bs- 7t- 15/1/78 Zvs wd Rgvi Kwc|
77Zvs-15/01/78
78XvKv B¤úªf‡g›U U«vó
79wW, AvB, wU feb, XvKv-2|
80¯^viK bs- wW, AvB,wU/G‡óU/3169/26/77B , ZvwiLt 15/01/78Bs
81‡cªiKt Dc-cwiPvjK (G‡óU)
82wW,AvB,wU feb
83XvKv-2|
84cªvcKt byi“b ingvb †PŠayix (jxR MªwnZv),
85wcZv- nvRx †gvZvnvi Avjx
86mvs-Mvbvcvo, _vbv-RvwKMÄ,
87‡Rjv- wm‡jU|
88welqt DËiv AvevwmK GjvKvq c U bs 9, †m±i bs-13, †ivW bs-4, BgviZ mn c UwU
89n¯—vš—i cªms‡M|
90Rbve,
91Avcbvi 26/9/77 Bs Zvwi‡Li Av‡e`‡bi cwi‡cªw¶‡Z I AÎ Awd‡mi m¥viK
92bs-wW,AvB,wU/G‡÷U/3169 ZvwiL 26/9/1977Bs †gvZv‡eK wbg¥ ¯^v¶iKvix Avw`ó
93nBqv RvbvB‡ZwQ †h, Dc‡ivwj wLZ c U wU Rbve †gvt e`i“j Avwgb Ii‡d gby
94mi`vi, wcZv -g„Z †gvt Ave`yj nv`x Gg,G, 33 †K,we, †Nvl wó«U, †cvt evey evRvi,
95_vbv- †KvZqvjx, †Rjv- XvKv……. Gi eive‡i wbg¥ wjwLZ kZ© I wbqgvejx m¤ú~Y©i“‡c
96KviY ¯^v‡c‡¶ wbg¥i“‡c Aby‡gv`b Kiv nBj|
97cª¯—vweZ n¯—vš—i MªwnZv KZ…©K mshy³ Pzw³ bvgv I AsMxKvi bvgvi bgybv
98†gvZv‡eK 1.50 (GK UvKv cÂvk) UvKv bb RywWwkqvj óv‡¤úi Dci wjwLZ mwnZ
99KiZt Rgv Kwi‡Z nB‡e|
100Avcbvi 26/9/77Bs Zvwi‡Li Av‡e`‡bi D‡j wLZ n¯—vš—i g~j¨ 3,70,375/-
101(wZb j¶ mËi nvRvi wZbkZ cuPvËi) UvKv Gi Dci n¯—vš—i MªwnZv/MªwnÎxi mwnZ
102n¯—vš—i `wjj m¤úv`b I †iwRwóª Kwi‡Z nB‡e|
103wW AvB wU I g~j eivÏ MªwnZvi/ MªwnÎx g‡a¨ mswk ó c ‡Ui m¤úvw`Z jxR
104`wjj G D‡j wLZ kZ© I wbqgvejx cª¯—vweZ n¯—vš—i MªwnZv/ MªwnÎx gvwbqv Pwj‡Z
105eva¨ _vwK‡eb| GB g‡g© n¯—vš—i kZ© Av‡ivc Kwi‡Z nB‡e Ges D³ n¯—vš—i
106`wj‡ji mwn †gvni bK‡ji g~j Kwc cª¯—vweZ MªwnZv/MªwnÎxi bvg Rvixi Rb¨ AÎ `߇i
107`vwLj Kwiw‡Z nB‡e|
108GB wPwV Bmy¨i ZvwiL nB‡Z 4(Pvi) gv‡mi g‡a¨ Dc‡i D‡j wLZ kZ© I
109wbqgvejx m¤ú~Y© Kwi‡Z e¨_© nB‡j n¯—vš—i Av‡`k evwZj ewjqv we‡ewPZ nB‡e|
110¯^vt A¯có
11115/1/78
112(mnKvix cwiPvjK G‡óU)
113wW,AvB,wU feb, XvKv-2| Ó
114From those documents of the plaintiff it is clearly proved that those documents are created for the purpose of instant suit since those had no consistency with the plaint case.
115Plaintiff Badrul Amin in his cross examination has said, Òbyi“i ingv‡bi evox wm‡j‡U †Rjvi RvwKM‡Ä Z‡e Zvnvi Mªv‡gi bvg Avgvi g‡b bvB| by‡ii ingv‡bi Avmj Mªv‡gi bvg Avwg Rvwb bv|Ó Thereafter, he said, ÒAvwg by‡ii ingv‡bi evox‡Z hvB bvB| Avwg wm‡j‡U by‡ii ingv‡bi mwnZ †÷k‡b †`Lv Kwiqv wQjvg|Ó He further admitted that, ÒAvgvi `vwLj `wj‡j mve †iwRó«v‡ii bv‡gi evbvbwU fzj fv‡e †jLv Av‡Q| Ó P.W.1, has failed to
say the year of the execution and registration of the sale deed. Aforesaid evidence clearly indicates that there was no previous acquaintance of the plaintiff with Nurer Rahman, admitted owner of the suit land. Which also made the execution of the alleged “bainanama” and sale deed and payment of consideration doubtful.
116It further appears that in examination-inchief the plaintiff claimed that there are three tin-shed in the suit land. But in his crossexamination he has said ÒAÎ gvgjvi AviRxi Zcwm‡j m¤úwËi weeiY nBj bvwjkx m¤úwË eZ©gv‡b Lvwj Av‡Q|Ó P.W.2 in his evidence has said, Òbvwjkx m¤úwË Lvwj RvqMvq|Ó The plaintiff did not examine any other witness to prove his possession.
117That is, the plaintiff has failed to prove his possession in the suit land. In such view of the matter, the instant suit, without the prayer for recovery possession, was not maintainable.
118In view of the nature of the evidence as adduced by the plaintiff, it appears that the conclusion arrived at by the trial Court is more acceptable. While reversing the finding of the trial Court, the High Court Division ignored those evidence, thereby, erroneously set aside the well reasoned judgment of the trial Court.
119The High Court Division committed an error while deciding the first appeal in a cursory manner without meeting the requirements of Order XLI Rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The appeal has been decided without following the procedure prescribed for deciding the first appeal, thus, the impugned judgment is liable to be set aside.
120Considering the aforesaid facts and circumstances, we find substance in the appeal
121Thus, the appeal is allowed. The Judgment and decree of the High Court Division in First Appeal No.59 of 2010 is, hereby, set aside.
122C.J.
123J.
124J. The 17th March, 2023.
125/words- 2674/
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











