High Court Division
Md. Hanif Howlader v Md. Ali Reaz Khan and another
Civil Revision 156/2021 · Decided 13 November 2025
The plaintiff sued for a declaration that registered Power of Attorney No. 271 of 2014, which he said covered 50 decimals of his land, was forged, null and void. The defendants did not appear. The Assistant Judge dismissed Title Suit No. 157 of 2018 for want of sufficient proof of forgery and the District Judge, Barishal dismissed the appeal. In revision, the High Court Division agreed that the plaintiff had not taken sufficient steps to prove his case, but found that the courts below had not applied a judicial mind, that the appellate court had not followed Order 41 Rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and that they could have compared his signatures on the record with the disputed one. The same deed had already been declared null and void in Title Suit No. 250 of 2014 by an unappealed decree in rem. The Court held the present suit redundant, disposed of the Rule with that observation and set aside the decrees below.
Rule disposed of; decrees set aside
- Rule NisiAn order of the High Court Division asking the other side to show cause why the relief sought should not be granted. It starts the full hearing; it is not a final decision.Read the full explanation →
- Set asideTo cancel an earlier court order, decree, award, sale or conviction so that it no longer has legal effect, usually by a higher court or by the same court on a proper application.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether a suit seeking a declaration that a registered Power of Attorney is forged and void has become redundant where a prior final decree in another suit has already declared the same deed null and void.
- A court may itself compare a party's admitted signatures on the record with a disputed signature to decide genuineness, since the court is the expert of all experts.
- The appellate court affirmed the trial court's decree in a slipshod and mechanical manner, failing to follow Order 41 Rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
- The function of a declaratory suit is to resolve an uncertain legal status by an authoritative judicial pronouncement; once a competent civil court has conclusively determined the status of an instrument, that status is established for all purposes.
- The unappealed decree in Title Suit No. 250 of 2014 declaring the Power of Attorney null and void was a decree in rem binding on everyone, so the deed is void as a whole and not only for the party who brought that suit.
- The present suit seeking an identical declaration was redundant; the Rule was disposed of with that observation, the decrees of the courts below were set aside and there was no order as to costs.
Once a competent civil court has conclusively determined the legal status of an instrument, that status is established for all purposes.
In the court’s own words.
Civil Revision 156/2021, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 14 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
Present :
Mr. Justice Md. Lutfor Rahman
Civil Revision No. 156 of 2021
Md. Hanif Howlader
… Petitioner
-vs-
Md. Ali Reaz Khan and another
……. Opposite parties
Mrs. Salina Akter, Advocate
…. For the Petitioner
None appears
……..for the opposite parties
Heard on 21.10.2025.
Judgment on 13.11.2025.
1This Rule has been issued calling upon the opposite party no. 1 to show cause as to why the judgment and decree dated 30.09.2020 passed by the District Judge, Barishal in Civil Appeal No. 35 of 2020 dismissing the appeal and affirming those dated 27.11.2019 passed by the Assistant Judge, Agoilzhara, Barishal, in Civil Suit No. 157 of 2018 dismissing the suit for declaration that the Power of Attorney being No. 271 of 2014 dated 06.01.2014 in respect of the suit land is forged, fabricated, null and void and also not binding upon the petitioner should not be set aside and/or such other or further order or orders passed as to this Court may seem fit and proper.
2Short facts, for disposal of the Rule are that, the Plaintiff- Petitioner filed Title Suit No.157 of 2018 before the court of learned Senior Assistant Judge, Barishal for declaration that the Registered Power of Attorney being No. 271/2014 dated 06.01.2014 in respect of the suit land is forged, created, fabricated, null and void and also not binding upon the petitioner. The suit was subsequently heard by the court of learned Assistant Judge, Agoilzhara, Barisal. The learned trial court on perusal of the plaint framed as many as 3 (three) issuses for determination of the suit. The defendants neither appeared nor contested the suit. At the trial, the plaintiff was examined as P. W. 1 The learned Assistant Judge, Agoilzhara, Barisal on perusal of the records and on consideration of both oral and documentary evidence was pleased to dismiss the suit by his judgment and decree dated 27.11.2019 (decree signed on 28.11.2019).
3Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the judgment and decree dated 27.11.2019 ( decree signed on 28.11.2019), the plaintiff preferred Title Appeal No.35 of 2020 before the learned District Judge, Barisal, who was pleased to dismiss the appeal on an exparte hearing by his judgment and decree dated 30.09.2020 (decree signed on 07.10.2020) on affirming those of the trial court.
4Being further aggrieved, the plaintiff petitioner moved this Court by filing an application under section 115 (1) of the Code of
Civil Procedure before this Court and obtained the instant Rule and status quo.
5Mrs. Salina Akter, the learned advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioner submits that that the disputed Power of Attorney is a registered deed. The plaintiff through two different registered deeds i.e. Deed no. 3867 dated 25.07.1996 and Deed no. 4045 dated 05.08.1996 purchased .50 acres (50 decimals) of land described in the Schedule “Ka” of the plaint from Shahajahan Mollah, Rejia Begum and Kulsum Bibi and mutated the said land in his name and has been in peaceful possession of the said property. That the defendant no.1 with an ulterior motive to grab the aforesaid property of the plaintiff created a forged and false Power of Attorney described in the “Kha” schedule of the plaint as being Deed no. 271of 2014 dated 06.01.2014 (actually 09.01.2014) registered with Barishal Sub-registry office by false personification showing one Amir Hossain Khan and Md. Hanif Hawladar (the plaintiff) falsely as the executants of the alleged forged Power of Attorney. That actually the alleged forged Power of Attorney was registered on 09.01.2014 but mistakenly it was written in the plaint “06.01.2014” in place of “09.01.2014”. That learned lawyer while preparing the plaint wrote perhaps the date of execution or the date of computer composing as the date of registration. That the alleged forged deed was created beyond the knowledge of the plaintiff
by using another one’s picture/photograph and by showing another man in place of the plaintiff. That the plaintiff never executed any such Power of Attorney, his signature is forged. That the date of birth of the plaintiff is 05.03.1966 but it was falsely written as 22.04.1955 in the said forged Power of Attorney. That one Md. Amir Hossain Khan has been shown to be one of the executants of the alleged false and forged Power of Attorney as executant no.1 and the said Md. Amir Hossain Khan already filed Title Suit No. 250 of 2014 in the Court of Senior Assistant Judge, Sadar Court, Barishal for cancellation of the alleged Power of Attorney Deed and the present plaintiff had been impleaded in the said suit as proforma defendant. Thereafter the present plaintiff came to know about the forgery and subsequently he collected the certified copy of the said power of Attorney and filed the present suit separately.
6Learned counsel further submits the suit was heard expartee as the defendants had not appeared before the trial court. The plaintiff was examined-in-chief and the documents submitted by the plaintiff were exhibited with exhibit marks. The trial court on expartee hearing dismissed the suit on the findings that the plaintiff had failed to prove his case by producing and examining sufficient witnesses in connection with the alleged forgery. Moreover, the plaintiff did not take any step for any expert opinion with regard to his alleged forged
signatures on the disputed Power of Attorney. Learned trial court further observed that the alleged Power of Attorney is a registered deed and the plaintiff failed to adduce sufficient evidence necessary for proving forgery of a registered deed and accordingly dismissed the suit even though on expartee hearing.
7Learned counsel further submits that signature of the petitioner on the alleged power of Attorney is forged, his date of birth was wrong and mother's name of the alleged executant no.1 (proforma defendant) was also wrong. That the signature of alleged executants No. 1 of the said Power of Attorney was also forged and that Amir Hossain Khan on 24.09.2014 filed Title Suit no. 250 of 2014 before the Court of the Senior Assistant Judge, Sadar, Barisal to cancel the alleged disputed Power of Attorney and during trial of that suit the present plaintiff petitioner came to know that his 50 decimals of land was also included in that disputed Power of Attorney. After searching, he obtained the certified copy of that disputed Power of Attorney deed from the Sub-Registry Office, Barisal Sadar and for the first time became able to know that the opposite party no.1 created a forged Power of Attorney in respect of his 50 decimals of land also and got it registered by false personification.
8The plaintiff thereafter filed the instant suit on 03.05.2016 for a declaration that the alleged Power of Attorney is forged and for cancellation of the same.
9Mrs. Salina Akter, learned counsel submits that appellate court dismissed the appeal on the observations and findings concurrent with the trial court, though on an expartee hearing. The defendant No.1 (the respondent No. 1) neither appeared nor contested the suit as well as the appeal. Both the learned courts below committed an error of law resulting in an error in the decision occasioning failure of justice by ignoring all other matters and aspects incidental thereto and as such the same is not sustainable in law and liable to set-aside. She submits that in Title Suit No. 250 of 2014 filed by Amir Hossain Khan, the Sadar Senior Assistant Judge, Barisal declared vide judgment and order dated 28.05.2017 that the disputed Power of Attorney deed is forged, created, null and void and legally not binding. But in the present suit both the courts failed to consider that the self same Power of Attorney had already been declared forged, and null & void by a competent civil court and committed an error of law resulting in an error in the decision occasioning failure of justice and as such the same is not sustainable in law and the same is liable to set-aside.
10Heard the learned advocate for the petitioner, perused the application, impugned judgment and order and other relevant papers of this instant revisional application.
11I am of the same view with the concurrent findings of the courts below in as much as the plaintiff did not take sufficient steps to prove his case by producing necessary documents which were either available in his hands or he could easily collect and produce those documents before the courts during trial and appeal. But for unknown reason or reasons, he failed to do so, might it be he had been illadvised and misguided in this regard. However, I cannot but hold that the trial court did not consider the materials available on records by applying Judicial mind. The appellate court passed the impugned Judgment and decree affirming those of the trial court in a slipshod manner and mechanical way and failed to follow the provision of law contained in order 41 Rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure which causes error of law resulting error in decision occasioning failure of Justice.
12Both the courts below could ascertain the fact as to the genuineness of the alleged Power of Attorney by comparing signature of the plaintiff put in the two wokalatnamas filed with the plaint and with the Memorandum of Appeal and also his signature put in all 16 pages of the plaint, his signature at the bottom of his deposition as PW-1 with his alleged forged signature apparent on the alleged Power
of Attorney. Moreover the plaintiff appellant put 2 (two) signatures in the application for condonation of delay in filing the appeal on 17.02.2020 along an affidavit therewith. He also put signature on the application for taking back the documents on 24.11.2020 submitted in the appellate court and these signatures could be easily compared with the alleged forged signature. If the courts below had taken this single step, they could arrive easily at the correct decision as to the genuineness of the alleged Power of Attorney.
13The only material issue before the courts was whether the alleged Power of Attorney was forged or not and it could have easily been decided and solved by the courts, the expert of all experts by making a comparative scrutiny of the signatures of the plaintiff available in the records before court with his alleged forged signature appearing on the disputed Power of Attorney. But they miserably failed to do so and hopelessly dismissed the suit as well as the appeal with concurrent finding that the plaintiff had not taken any step for expert’s opinion forgetting that the court is expert of all experts.
14However, I have examined the signatures of the plaintiff appearing on 3 (three) wokalatnamas, at the bottom of his deposition as PW-1 and on all 16 pages of the plaint, and on the application dated 17.02.2020 for condonation of delay in filing the appeal and on the application to take back the documents from records preferred on 24.11.2020 in the appellate court and the instant petition before this court and clearly found that all these signatures of the plaintiff-
appellant- petitioner are exactly same (resembling each other) but they do not have any similarity with his alleged forged signature appearing on the alleged Power of Attorney (Annexure-“E”), transpiring it to be a forged one in a vivid and crystal clear manner. Moreover, the plaintiff-petitioner puts signature as “®j¡x q¡¢eg q¡w” but the disputed signature of the plaintiff-peitioner on the alleged Power of Attorney appears as “ q¡¢ef q¡w” having a difference of g and f and presence and absence of “®j¡x” and having no similarity at all in respect of slant, sizing, writing style & pattern and spacing.
15That the alleged Power of Attorney was earlier challenged by the alleged executant No.1 Amir Hossain Khan in Title Suit No. 250 of 2014 filed in the court of the Senior Assistant Judge, Barishal Sadar. Barishal. Both the courts below failed to consider that Md. Ali Reaz Khan, the holder of the disputed Power of Attorney being the principal defendant of both the suits willfully abstained from appearing and contesting both the suits. He neither contested the Title Suit No. 250 of 2014 in trial, nor he contested the present suit i.e Title suit No. 157 of 2018 at any stage of trial, appeal and revision which gives rise to a strong presumption against him in respect of the genuineness and authenticity of the alleged Power of Attorney.
16I have gone through the alleged Power of Attorney and found that the alleged Power of Attorney No. 271 of 2014 was registered on 09.01.2014 but while drafting the plaint, learned lawyer wrote
06.01.2014 in place of 09.01.2014 as the date of registration. It was a bonafide mistake apparent on the face of the record. Learned lawyer while preparing the plaint was misled and misconceived by finding a computer typed date as 06.01.2014 at the bottom of the page No. 8 of the alleged Power of Attorney in spite of the remaining fact that in all appropriate places of all the pages, the date of registration of the forged deed appears to be correctly written as 09.01.2014. Though there has been no dispute, controversy or confrontation regarding this matter, the courts below considered this minor discrepancy as a major mistake and dismissed the suit as well as the appeal on misreading of evidence.
17However, it cannot be denied that both the courts correctly observed and found that the plaintiff-appellant petitioner did not take sufficient steps to prove his own case. At this conjecture, Mrs. Salina Akter learned counsel for the petitioner being instructed by her client, finally submits in the alternative that the alleged Power of Attorney was declared null and void by the court of the Senior Assistant Judge, Barishal in Title Suit No. 250 of 2014 vide Judgment and decree dated 28.05.2017. This decree remains unappealed and has thus attained finality and is binding upon all parties concerned. The plaintiffpetitioner unnecessarily filed the present suit seeking an identical declaration in respect of the self same alleged Power of Attorney
which already has been declared forged and null & void in its entirety by a competent court in an earlier Judgment and decree at the instance of the alleged executant No. 1 of the Power of Attorney in question. The present petitioner, as the alleged executant No. 2 of the self-same Power of Attorney does not at all require any identical declaration over the self same matter and accordingly she prays for disposing of the instant rule with aforesaid observations.
18It appears that the plaintiff instituted the present suit seeking a declaration that the Power of Attorney deed No.271 of 2014 dated 06- 01-2014 (actually 09.01.2014) is null and void. It is an undisputed fact that present suit was instituted at a time when another suit, being Title Suit No.250 of 2014 (before the Senior Assistant Judge, Sadar Court, Barishal) had already been pending concerning the very same power of Attorney. The subsequent key event is that the earlier suit being Title suit No. 250 of 2014 had already been decreed. The Judgment and order dated 28.05.2017 in that suit declared the entire Power of Attorney deed No. 271 of 2014 dated 09.01.2014 as null and void. This decree remains unappealed and has thus attained finality and a binding force on all parties concerned.
19Now the issue for determination is whether the present suit, seeking a declaration already granted by a prior final decree in Title
Suit No. 250 of 2014, has become redundant and unnecessary in the eyes of law.
20I am of the view that the function of a declaratory suit is to provide a legal resolution to an uncertain legal status regarding any matter by an authoritative judicial pronouncement. Once a competent civil court has conclusively determined the legal status of an instrument, that status is established for all purposes. A competent civil court has conclusively determined the legal status of the disputed Power of Attorney deed No. 271 of 2014 dated 09.01.2014 by declaring it to be null and void and that status is established for all purposes. The legal implication is that the alleged Power of Attorney deed No. 271 of 2014 dated 09.01.2014 ceases to exist ab-initio leading to a comprehensive effect upon all concerned and connected with the same. It is not merely void for the party who brought the first suit, but void as a whole. The plaintiff’ filed the present suit under the apprehension that as the alleged executant No. 2 of the alleged Power of Attorney he might require a separate declaration to the similar affect is moot. The final decree in Title Suit No. 250 of 2014 is a complete remedy for all connected with the subject matter of the suit. Therefore, the cause of action for the present suit, which is the desire to void the disputed Power of Attorney, has been extinguished by the final and binding decree in the earlier suit. It was a judgment and
decree in rem. It is conclusive and enforceable against everyone in the suit and binding against the entire world. A Judgment in rem determines the status, ownership or disposition of a specific property or thing rather than focusing on the personal liabilities of individuals. The legal action is directed at the alleged Power of Attorney itself and binds everyone connected with or affected by the same.
21The present suit has effectively been rendered unnecessary and moot by the progression and final conclusion of the prior litigation over the self same matter and concerning the same parties. Thus, I find that the present suit has lost its efficacy and is now redundant and unnecessary, as the relief sought has already been secured by a final judgment and decree of a competent court. That judgment and decree passed in Title Suit No. 250 of 2014 is binding on the parties of the present suit as it has conclusively settled the status of Power of Attorney Deed No. 271 of 2014 dated 09.01.2014 by declaring it null and void, the present suit seeking an identical declaration in respect of the self same matter is found to be unnecessary.
22Thus, from the discussions and reasons stated herein above, this court finds that there is nothing further to adjudicate in the present rule and accordingly the rule is disposed of with observation that the relief sought in the instant suit has been rendered redundant by prior final Judgment and decree dated 27.11.2019 passed by the Court of
Senior Assistant Judge, Sadar Court, Barishal in Title Suit No 250 of 2014 (decree signed on 28.11.2019).
23The impugned judgment and decree dated 30.09.2020 (decree signed on 07.10.2020) passed by the District Judge, Barishal in Title Appeal No. 35 of 2020 dismissing the appeal and affirming those dated 27.11.2019 passed by the Assistant Judge, Agoilzhara, Barishal, in Title Suit No. 157 of 2018 are hereby set aside.
24However, there is no order as to costs.
25Send down the Lower Court Records along with a copy of the judgment to the Court concerned at once.
26Bashar B.O.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











