High Court Division · Civil Revisional Jurisdiction
Md. Abdur Rouf Bhuyan and others v Momena Begum and another
Civil Revision 1844/2015 · Decided 7 October 2020
After the father died, the Family Court in Comilla appointed the mother as guardian of her minor son and his property, and later permitted her to sell 23 decimals of the minor's land, directing her to deposit the sale money in a scheduled bank and account for expenditure from time to time. The minor's paternal uncles appealed, saying they had not been made parties, that the land was ejmali (undivided) family property and that they bore the minor's expenses. The Additional District Judge dismissed the appeal, finding the mother the child's closest relation. In revision, with no one appearing, the High Court Division noted that only 23 of the 53 decimals the minor inherited were involved, that the uncles did not deny those facts and that the trial court's safeguards protected the minor. No rights of the petitioners were infringed and there was no error of law causing failure of justice. The Rule was discharged without costs.
Rule discharged; mother's permission to sell minor's land upheld
- Q1
Whether the courts below erred in permitting the mother, appointed guardian of her minor son, to sell 23 decimals of the minor's inherited land despite the objection of the minor's paternal uncles that they were not made parties and that the land was ejmali (undivided family) property.
- The mother, appointed guardian by the trial court, was rightly found by the appellate court to be the best well-wisher and closest relation of her child.
- The permission covered only 23 decimals out of the 53 decimals the minor inherited from his father, and the petitioners did not deny those facts.
- Since the trial court directed the sale money to be deposited in a scheduled bank and an account of expenditure for the minor's welfare and studies to be submitted, no rights of the petitioners were infringed.
- There was no error of law occasioning failure of justice warranting revisional interference, and the petitioners had taken no steps to hear the Rule for more than 5 years.
- The Rule was discharged without any order as to costs.
So, no rights of the petitioners have been infringed by the order of the trial court for which the appellate court rightly dismissed the appeal.
In the court’s own words.
Civil Revision 1844/2015, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 7 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1In the Supreme Court of Bangladesh
2High Court Division
3(Civil Revisional Jurisdiction)
4Present:
5Mr. Justice Md. Riaz Uddin Khan
6Civil Revision No. 1844 of 2015
7IN THE MATTER OF :
8An application under Section 115(1) of the Code
9of Civil Procedure.
10-And-
11In the Matter of:
12Md. Abdur Rouf Bhuyan and others
13…… Petitioners
14Versus
15Momena Begum and another
17None appears
18Heard and Judgment on: 07.10.2020. Md. Riaz Uddin Khan, J-
19By this rule the opposite parties were asked to show cause as to why the impugned judgment and order dated 20.01.2015 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Comilla in Family Appeal No. 25 of 2010 should not be set aside and/or pass such other or further order or orders as to this court may seem fit and proper.
20At the time of issuance of the rule the prayer for stay was rejected and the opposite party no. 1 was directed not to transfer more than 23 decimals of minor’s (Md. Joy Solaiman Bhuiyan) land. However, the opposite party No. 1 was at liberty to transfer 23
decimals of land as described in the application as per order of the trial court dated 04.07.2010.
21No one appears to support or oppose the rule when it was taken up for hearing.
22The facts for disposal of this rule are that the plaintiffOpposite Party No.1 Momena Begum is the wife of late Md. Liakot Ali Bhuiyan @ Mokhles Mia and the minor (Md. Joy Solaiman Bhuiyan) is their son. After the death of Md. Liakot Ali Bhuiyan @ Mokhles Mia the plaintiff filed Family Suit No. 77 of 2010 before the Family Court and Senior Assistant Judge, Sadar, Comilla for appointing her as the guardian of her minor son and his property which was allowed by the Court by its judgment and order dated 06.06.2010. The plaintiff then filed Miscellaneous Permission Suit No. 51 of 2010 before the same Court for permission to sell 23 decimals of land which is the minor’s property. The trial court after taking evidence on behalf of the plaintiff allowed that application vide its order dated 04.07.2010 and permitted the plaintiff Opposite party no. 1 to sell 23 decimals of minor’s property and further directed to deposit the money from that sale to any of the schedule banks and also to submit the account of expenditure to the Court time to time. Against that order of permission the present
petitioners filed Family Appeal No. 25 of 2010. They have claimed before the Appellate Court that the Opposite party No. 1 as plaintiff filed the Suit without making the petitioners party to the suit who are the paternal uncles of the minor. They further claimed that the land permitted to sell was not the sole property of the minor rather it is ejmali (undivided) property of their family. The appellants further claimed that the plaintiff opposite party no. 1 and his minor son were living with them i.e the paternal uncles in the same mess. So, there is no question of maintenance of the minor since the maintenance and the expenditures are borne by the uncles, the present petitioners. After hearing the appeal the Lower Appellate Court by the impugned judgment and order dated 20.01.2015 dismissed the appeal and thereby affirmed the order of permission passed by the trial Court. The Appellate Court in its finding observed that the mother (the plaintiff opposite party no.1) is the closest relation of a child in the world and the trial court did not appoint anybody as a guardian other than the mother. Since the court below appointed the mother as a guardian of the minor and his property and permitted to transfer the property of the minor for his welfare and studies, the court below rightly passed the impugned order.
23Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said judgment and order the appellant petitioners filed the instant Revision and obtained this rule and the ad-interim order as stated at the very outset.
24When this Rule was taken up for hearing, no one appears to support or oppose the Rule.
25I have perused the application filed under section 115(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure along with two supplementary affidavits filed on 22.06.2015 and 23.06.2015. I have also perused both the judgments and orders passed by the trail Court as well as the lower appellate Court along with the papers annexed with the Revisional Application and supplementary affidavits.
26The petitioners contended that both the courts below by misreading of the evidence on record committed error in law as well as in facts which resulted an error in decision occasioning failure of justice. The petitioners further stated that without complying the provisions laid down in section 15 of the Family Courts Ordinance, 1985 the impugned judgments and orders have been passed. They further stated that the Courts below without asserting the age of the minor passed the impugned order. Their further case is that since the Suit property is ejmali property, without filing a partition suit or
in absence of any bontonnama deed the case is not maintainable for which the judgments and orders passed by the courts below are liable to be set aside.
27It appears from the order of the trial court that the plaintiff opposite party no. 1 filed the Miscellaneous Permission Case No. 51 of 2010 for permission to sell 23 decimals of land belongs to the minor and that application was allowed by the trial court and also in appeal the appellant was unsuccessful in reversing that order. It has already been noticed that during issuance of Rule this court also did not interfere with the order of the trial court or of the Appellate Court rather during issuance of this Rule this court passed order that the Opposite party No. 1 was at liberty to transfer 23 decimals of land as described in the application as per order of the trial court dated 04.07.2010.
28It is admitted position that the opposite party No.1 Momena Begum is the mother of the minor who have been appointed as the guardian of the minor by the trial court. Then on an application for permission to sell only 23 decimals of land out of 53 decimals which the minor inherited from his late father Md. Liakot Ali Bhuiyan @ Mokhles Mia the trial court allowed the prayer. The appellantpetitioners did not deny that facts. Their contention is that they
were not made parties and the property in question is ejmali property. Since opposite party No.1 is the mother of the minor and the court of appeal below rightly found that mother is the best well wisher of her child in the world who is the closest relation. Moreover, it is mentionable that the trial court directed the mother to deposit the money after selling the minor’s 23 decimals of land to a schedule Bank and also to submit report of expenditure for the welfare and studies of the minor time to time. So, no rights of the petitioners have been infringed by the order of the trial court for which the appellate court rightly dismissed the appeal.
29In that view of the matter I do not find any error of law occasioning failure of justice which warrants interference by this Court. Moreover, this Rule was issued on 22.06.2015. Meanwhile, more than 5 years have been passed. The petitioners did not take any steps for hearing this Rule and by virtue of the ad-interim order of this court allowing the opposite party no.1 to sell the 23 decimals of land of the minor, whether in the main time, has already been sold out or not there is no information before this Court in that regard.
30In the facts and circumstances there is no substance in this rule and I am not inclined to interfere with the judgments and orders passed by the courts below.
31In the result the rule is discharged without any order as to cost.
32Communicate the judgment and order at once.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











