Rule absolute and Rule discharged
The two final results of a Rule in the High Court Division: made absolute means the petitioner wins; discharged means the petition fails and the order below stands.
Rule absolute and Rule discharged, step by step.
When the High Court Division hears a writ petition, civil revision or criminal revision, it first issues a Rule asking the other side to show cause.
At the final hearing the Rule is either made absolute, meaning the petitioner wins and the challenged order is set aside or corrected, or discharged, meaning the petition fails and the order below stands.
Read the judgment for directions, costs and what happens to any stay.
Get the certified copy
Apply for a certified copy of the judgment at once. Time limits for any further challenge run from the date of judgment.
Read the operative part
Check whether the Rule was made absolute, discharged, made absolute in part or disposed of, and note any directions, remand or costs.
Check interim orders
If a stay or status quo order was in force, confirm whether it has been vacated and inform the lower court or office concerned.
Decide on leave to appeal
If you lost, take advice promptly on a leave petition to the Appellate Division: 60 days in civil matters, 30 days in criminal matters.
When the High Court Division hears a writ petition, civil revision or criminal revision, it first issues a Rule asking the other side to show cause. At the final hearing the Rule is either made absolute, meaning the petitioner wins and the challenged order is set aside or corrected, or discharged, meaning the petition fails and the order below stands. Read the judgment for directions, costs and what happens to any stay.
What Rule absolute and Rule discharged mean
A Rule is an order the High Court Division issues at the start of certain cases. It calls on the other side, and sometimes a government office, to show cause, that is, to explain why the order or action under challenge should not be declared unlawful or set aside. It is often called a Rule Nisi, from the Latin nisi, meaning "unless": the order will be made unless good cause is shown.
The case ends when the Bench decides the Rule. If the petitioner succeeds, the Rule is made absolute: the court grants the relief asked for. If the petitioner fails, the Rule is discharged: the court refuses relief and the challenged order or action stays in force. A Rule can also be made absolute in part, where some relief is granted and the rest refused, or be disposed of with directions.
Where Rules come from in Bangladesh law
Rules arise in the High Court Division's writ and revisional jurisdictions. In writ cases the power comes from article 102 of the Constitution, which lets the court enforce fundamental rights and, where no other equally efficacious remedy exists, declare that a public act was done "without lawful authority and is of no legal effect". In civil revision the source is section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908, and in criminal revision sections 435 and 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898.
The words "Rule", "show cause", "made absolute" and "discharged" are not defined in any one statute. They come from long-standing Supreme Court practice and appear in almost every revision and writ judgment of the High Court Division. A judgment usually ends with a line such as "In the result, the Rule is made absolute" or "the Rule is discharged without any order as to costs".
How a Rule is heard and decided
The petitioner files a petition and a Bench hears it briefly at the motion stage. If the Bench sees an arguable case, it issues the Rule and may grant an interim order, such as a stay of the challenged order or a status quo direction. The other side then files an affidavit-in-opposition. Later the Rule appears in the cause list for final hearing, the lawyers argue it, and the Bench decides it in a written judgment.
Delay is common. Rules in civil revisions can stay pending for many years. The court sometimes discharges an old Rule because the dispute has ended and the Rule has become infructuous (pointless), or because a party died and no heirs were brought on record, so the case abated. A Rule may also be discharged for default if the petitioner does not take steps to have it heard.
What each result means for the parties
When a Rule is made absolute in a civil revision, the High Court Division usually sets aside the lower court's judgment. It may then restore the trial court's decision, decide the point itself, or send the case back for a fresh decision. In a writ case the challenged order is declared unlawful or the authority is directed to act. In a criminal revision the conviction may be set aside and the accused acquitted.
When a Rule is discharged, nothing changes below. The lower court's decree or order, or the government action, remains valid and can be enforced. Any stay granted when the Rule was issued ends, and judgments usually say that the order of stay "stands vacated". If the stay had stopped an execution case, a trial or an eviction, that matter can now go ahead.
Costs follow the judgment. Many Rules are decided "without any order as to costs", so each side pays its own lawyers. Sometimes the court orders one side to pay a fixed sum to the other, and the judgment states the amount and any deadline. A costs order made in the lower court remains in place if the Rule is discharged, unless the High Court Division changes it.
What the losing side can do next
The usual next step is a petition for leave to appeal to the Appellate Division under article 103 of the Constitution. Under the Supreme Court of Bangladesh (Appellate Division) Rules 1988, a civil leave petition must be filed within 60 days of the High Court Division's judgment, and a criminal one within 30 days, or 60 days where the Government challenges an acquittal. An appeal lies as of right only in limited cases, such as a certified constitutional question.
In civil matters a party may instead ask the High Court Division to review its own judgment under Order XLVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, but review only corrects an error apparent on the record or deals with important new evidence. It is not a rehearing. Where a Rule was discharged for default rather than on the merits, an application to restore it may be possible. Time runs from the date of judgment, so obtain a certified copy quickly.
Rule discharged, disposed of or infructuous: telling them apart
"Rule discharged" does not mean the petitioner has been released or let off. It means the petition failed. "Rule absolute" does not always mean final victory in the wider dispute either, because the court may send the case back to the lower court. A Rule "disposed of" ends the case with directions or observations, often without a full finding for either side. A Rule discharged as infructuous or abated says nothing about who was right. Always read the operative paragraph, not just the headline result.
Suppose a landowner loses an injunction appeal before a District Judge and files a civil revision. The High Court Division issues a Rule and stays the District Judge's order. Some years later the Rule is heard. If the Bench finds that the District Judge misread the evidence, it makes the Rule absolute, sets that order aside and restores the trial court's injunction. If it finds no error of law, it discharges the Rule, the stay ends, and the District Judge's order applies again.
What to do if this affects you
- 01Get the certified copy
Apply for a certified copy of the judgment at once. Time limits for any further challenge run from the date of judgment.
- 02Read the operative part
Check whether the Rule was made absolute, discharged, made absolute in part or disposed of, and note any directions, remand or costs.
- 03Check interim orders
If a stay or status quo order was in force, confirm whether it has been vacated and inform the lower court or office concerned.
- 04Decide on leave to appeal
If you lost, take advice promptly on a leave petition to the Appellate Division: 60 days in civil matters, 30 days in criminal matters.
- 05Comply or enforce
If you won, file the judgment with the lower court or authority so it can act on it, and start execution where needed.
Test yourself on Rule absolute and Rule discharged
Rule absolute and Rule discharged in real judgments
Recent Supreme Court of Bangladesh judgments summarised on trw.co where the term appears.
Questions about Rule absolute and Rule discharged
Does Rule discharged mean I lost the case?
Usually, yes. It means the High Court Division refused the relief you asked for, so the lower court's decision or the government action stands. Check the reasons, though. A Rule discharged as infructuous, abated or for default says nothing about the merits, and the court sometimes adds directions or observations that still help the losing side.
What happens to the stay order when a Rule is discharged?
It ends. A stay granted when the Rule was issued lasts only while the Rule is pending, unless the court says otherwise, and judgments usually state that the order of stay stands vacated. Proceedings that were halted, such as an execution case or a trial, can then continue, and the other side may move quickly to enforce.
If the Rule is made absolute, is the case over?
Not always. The judgment may finally settle the matter, but it may also send the case back to the trial or appellate court for a fresh decision, or direct an authority to reconsider. The other side may also seek leave to appeal to the Appellate Division within the time allowed. Follow the directions in the judgment carefully.
How long do I have to challenge the High Court Division's decision?
Under the Appellate Division Rules 1988, a petition for leave to appeal in a civil matter must be filed within 60 days of the judgment. In criminal matters the period is 30 days, or 60 days when the Government challenges an acquittal. Delay can sometimes be condoned for good reason, but do not plan on that.
What does 'made absolute in part' mean?
The court accepted some of the petitioner's grounds and rejected others. For example, it may set aside one part of an order while leaving the rest in force, or grant a declaration but refuse a further direction. Read the operative paragraph carefully to see exactly what has changed and what still binds each party.
Who pays the costs?
The judgment decides. Many Rules end without any order as to costs, which means each party pays its own lawyers. Sometimes the court orders one side to pay a fixed amount to the other. That amount is stated in the order, and the court may say what happens if it is not paid on time.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











