Appellate Division
The State v AHM Fuad
Criminal Petition for Leave to Appeal 1690/2022 · Decided 1 June 2023
An accused was charged with money laundering under section 4(2) of the Money Laundering Protirodh Ain, 2012 after an FIR alleged that he and others took control of government tenders and amassed property valued at Tk.2000 crore. Four co-accused made confessional statements under section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure naming him. The Special Judge refused bail, but the High Court Division made the Rule absolute and granted bail on 14.11.2022, reasoning that co-accused confessions cannot be the sole basis of implication. The State petitioned the Appellate Division. The Court held that section 13 of the Ain, which sets conditions for bail, governs such cases, and that the High Court Division had not considered it or the settled principles. It noted that money laundering is heinous, that confessions of co-accused, though weak, may be weighed at trial, and that the accused had been released hastily. The petition was disposed of, the High Court Division's order set aside and the bail cancelled.
Petition disposed of; High Court Division bail order set aside
- High Court Division (HCD)The lower of the two Divisions of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh, which hears writs, appeals, revisions, bail matters and some original cases.Read the full explanation →
- Jamin (bail)Release of an arrested or accused person from custody on a bond, with or without sureties, on condition that they attend court when required.Read the full explanation →
- Set asideTo cancel an earlier court order, decree, award, sale or conviction so that it no longer has legal effect, usually by a higher court or by the same court on a proper application.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether the High Court Division was justified in granting bail to an accused in a money laundering case without considering section 13 of the Money Laundering Protirodh Ain, 2012.
- Q2
Whether the High Court Division could treat the confessional statements of co-accused as insufficient to refuse bail.
- Because the Money Laundering Protirodh Ain, 2012 is a special law, section 13 of the Ain governs a bail application in such a case, not sections 497 and 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
- The High Court Division did not consider section 13 and treated the application as if it were an ordinary bail application under the Code.
- Confessions of co-accused are generally not admissible against another accused but may be weighed in exceptional situations, and at the bail stage the Court could not foretell whether other corroborating evidence would be adduced.
- Bail turns on whether reasonable grounds exist for believing the accused is guilty, and the High Court Division wrongly rested on the view that co-accused confessions could not be the sole basis of implication, overlooking that money laundering is heinous and that the accused had been released within a very short time of arrest.
- The High Court Division's judgment was set aside and the bail granted to the accused was cancelled.
In this particular case, section 13 of the Ain, 2012 will govern in dealing the prayer for bail, not section 497 and 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
In the court’s own words.
Criminal Petition for Leave to Appeal 1690/2022, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 23 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2APPELLATE DIVISION
3PRESENT:
4Mr. Justice Md. Nuruzzaman
5Mr. Justice M. Enayetur Rahim
6Mr. Justice Md. Ashfaqul Islam CRIMINAL PETITION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL NO.1690 OF 2022 (From the judgment and order dated 14.11.2022 passed by the High Court Division in Criminal Miscellaneous Case No.24677 of 2022)
7The State, represented by the Deputy Commissioner, Dhaka …… Petitioner
8=VERSUS= AHM Fuad …… Respondent For the Petitioner :Mr. Mehedi Hasan
9Chowdhury, Additional
10Attorney General,
11instructed by Mr. Md.
12Helal Amin, Advocate-
13on-Record For the Respondent :Mr. Munsurul Hoque
14Chowdhury, Senior
15Advocate, instructed by
16Syed Mahbubur Rahman,
17Advocate-on-Record Date of hearing :The 1st June, 2023
18JUDGMENT M. Enayetur Rahim, J: Having gone through the proposed judgment delivered by my learned
brother Md. Ashfaqul Islam, J. I would like to add some few words.
19Money laundering Protirodh Ain, 2012 (hereinafter referred to as the Ain, 2012) is a special law and it is now well settled that the special law should prevail over the general law, if same provision of law is made in both the laws.
20In a case under Money Laundering Ain, section 13 of the Ain, 2012 makes provision relating to granting bail to an accused, which runs as follows:
21""13| Rvwgb msµvšÍ weavb|- GB AvB‡bi Aaxb Awfhy³ †Kvb
22e¨w³‡K Rvwg‡b gyw³ ‡`Iqv hvB‡e, hw`-
23(K) Zvnv‡K Rvwg‡b gyw³ †`Iqvi Av‡e`‡bi Dci Awf‡hvMKvix
24cÿ‡K ïbvbxi my‡hvM †`Iqv nq; Ges
25(L) Zvnvi weiæ‡× AvbxZ Awf‡hv‡M wZwb †`vlx mve¨¯’ nIqvi
26hyw³m½Z KviY iwnqv‡Q g‡g© Av`vjZ mš‘ó bv nb; A_ev
27(M) wZwb bvix, wkï ev kvixwiKfv‡e weKjv½ Ges Zvnv‡K Rvwg‡b gyw³
28†`Iqvi Kvi‡Y b¨vq wePvi wewNœZ nB‡e bv g‡g© Av`vjZ mš‘ó nb|''
29(Underlines supplied).
30In this particular case, section 13 of the Ain, 2012 will govern in dealing the prayer for bail, not section 497 and 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
31From the impugned order it does not transpire that the High Court Division in granting bail to the accused has at all considered the provision of section 13 of the Ain, 2012; rather it shows that the High Court Division has considered some inconsequent issues and disposed of the matter as if it had dealt an application for bail under the provision of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
32This Division in the case of State Vs. Joy GopalSarker reported in 27 BLC (AD) 48 has observed as follows:
33“Having gone through the first
34information report it appears that the
35allegation of money laundering has
36been imputed therein though the
37respondent’s name was not disclosed in
38the first information report. His name
39was disclosed by one of the confessing
40accused. Money laundering is a serious
41offence now-a-days. In such view of
42the matter the High Court Division was
43not justified in allowing the appeals
44and enlarging the respondent on bail.”
45(Underlines supplied).
46In the above case, this Division had set aside the order of bail granted to the accused of the said case by the High Court Division.
47Upon consideration the above proposition of law settled by this Division coupled with attending facts and circumstances of the present case, in particular the offence of money laundering is an organized crime, the allegations made in the police report against the accused and, purport and scope of section 13 of the Ain, 2012, I have no hesitation to hold that the High Court Division committed serious error in granting bail to the accused.
48J. Md. Ashfaqul Islam, J:
49This criminal petition for leave to appeal is directed against the judgment and order
dated 14.11.2022 passed by the High Court Division in Criminal Miscellaneous Case No.24677 of 2022 making the Rule absolute and granting bail to the accused respondent-AHM Fuad.
50Prosecution case, in brief, is that one S M Miraz Al Mahmud, BP No.7096009017, Police Inspector, Team Number-3, Dhaka Metro-Poshchim Bibhag, Bangladesh Police, CID, Dhaka as an informant lodged the First Information Report (in short, FIR) against the FIR named accused persons on 26.06.2020 at around 13.45 hours under section 4(2) of the Money Laundering Protirodh Ain, 2012 (as amended in 2015) (in short, Ain, 2012) before the Officer-in-Charge, Kafrul Police Station, DMP, Dhaka alleging, inter alia, that, the accused persons are blood
connected brothers and they had no property before 2008. But, after that, they took control over tender process of different Government offices and also involved in land grabbing, taking commission from transport sector and earned crores of money. Moreover, they also earned huge amount of illegal money from drug business. They established an office in Dhaka and grabbed effective control of all the offices of the LGED, BRTA, Roads and Highway, Pourashava, District Council, Passport Office, Education and Health Sector of District Faridpur from 2008 and they are also owner of 23 buses named as South Line Jatri Paribahan.
51At the time of investigation, it is ascertained that, the accused persons become owner of the property which is valued at an amount of
Tk.2000 crore (Taka two thousand crore). Hence, the accused persons committed offence under section 4(2) of the Ain, 2012. Accordingly, Kafrul Police Station Case No.24 dated 26.06.2020 corresponding to G.R. No.135 of 2020 under section 4(2) of the Ain, 2012 was started against the accused persons in pursuance of the F.I.R.
52The Assistant Police Super of CID as Investigating Officer, after completion of investigation, submitted charge-sheet being Charge-sheet No.58 dated 02.03.2021 under section 4(2) of the Ain, 2012 against the accused persons including the accused respondent-AHM Fuad which was submitted before the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Dhaka.
53The learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Dhaka transferred the case record to the learned Special Judge, Court No.10, Dhaka for disposal and trial, who took cognizance against the accused persons under section 4(2) of the Ain, 2012 and registered the Special Case No.10 of 2021.
54The four co-accused namely, Sazzad Hossain Borkot, Imtiaz Hasan Rubel, Ashikur Rahman Farhan and Nazmul Islam Khondakar Levy made inculpatory confessional statements under section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 before the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, Dhaka and mentioned the name of the instant accused respondent-AHM Fuad in their statements.
55The accused respondent prayed for bail on 20.02.2022 before the learned Special Judge, Court No.10, Dhaka which was rejected.
56Feeling aggrieved by the order dated 20.02.2022 passed by the learned Special Judge, Court No.10, Dhaka in Special Case No.10 of 2021, the accused respondent filed an application for bail being Criminal Miscellaneous Case No.24677 of 2022 before the High Court Division and obtained Rule.
57The opposite party-State contested the said Rule by filing counter affidavit.
58The High Court Division, upon hearing both the parties, made the Rule absolute and granted bail to the accused-respondent-AHM Fuad by the impugned judgment and order dated 14.11.2022.
59Feeling aggrieved by the impugned judgment and order dated 14.11.2022 passed the High Court Division, the opposite party-State as petitioner herein preferred the Criminal Petition for Leave to Appeal No.1690 of 2022 before this Division.
60Mr. Mehedi Hasan Chowdhury, the learned Additional Attorney General appearing on behalf of the Petitioner submits that, the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court Division in making the Rule absolute clearly shows non-application of judicial mind having failed to appreciate that, the allegation brought against the accused respondent-AHM Fuad under section 4(2) of the Ain, 2012 that, the accused respondent illegally earned a huge amount of money by doing various offences in
the locality by way of illegally controlling tender in the offices of LGED, BRTC, Roads and Highway, Pourashava, Zila Parishad, Passport Office, Education and Health Sector and committed offence of money laundering with full knowledge. So, there is no way to enlarge him on bail during the period of trial, considering the gravity of offence. He further submits that, the accused respondent is a habitual offender and involved with various offences specially when he was APS of the former Minister Mr. Khondaker Mosharraf Hossain and using that identity, he illegally controlled tender process and earned a lot of money. He further submits that, co-accused namely, Sazzad Hossain Borkot, Imtiaz Hasan Rubel, Ashikur Rahman Farhan, and Nazmul Islam Khondakar Levy
made in-culpatory confessional statements under section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and mentioned the name of the instant accused respondent as he is a member of so-called syndicate circle and directly involved with the alleged offence. He finally submits that, the allegation against the accused respondent is of money laundering offence and the money laundering offence is a serious offence against the country, the activities of the accused respondent is highly prejudicial to the State and discipline and such kind of person is a threat to the nation, but, the High Court Division without considering these points, made the Rule absolute and enlarged the accused respondent on bail which calls for interference by this Division and, as such, the impugned
judgment and order passed by the High Court Division is liable to be set aside.
61Mr. Munsurul Hoque Chowdhury, the learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the accused respondent made submissions in support of the impugned judgment and order of the High Court Division. Therefore, he prays for dismissal of the instant leave petition.
62We have considered the submissions of the learned Additional Attorney General for the leave petitioner and the learned Senior Advocate for the accused respondent. Perused the impugned judgment of the High Court Division and connected other materials on record.
63It appears that, there is specific allegations mentioned in the charge-sheet
against the accused-respondent and four coaccuseds made their confessional statements under section 164 of the Code and they mentioned the name of the accused respondent in their statements directly implicating him in money laundering. He has been involved with the co-accused in the case, hence, the co-accused mentioned his name in their confessional statements made under section 164 of the Code and, as such, there is a strong presumption against the accused respondent of commission of offence under section 4(2) of the Ain, 2012 (as amended in 2015).
64In connection with the aforementioned annotations this Division observed in the case of Major Md. Bazlul Huda (Artillery) vs. State reported in 2010 30 BLD (AD) 67 that:
65“With due respect, I am unable to endorse
66the latter views for, once a reasonable
67ground exists to believe that two or more
68persons have conspired together to commit
69an offence, anything said, done or written
70by one of the conspirators in reference to
71the common intention after the common
72intention was entertained, is relevant
73against the other, not only for the
74purpose of proving existence of the
75conspiracy but also for proving that the
76other person was a party to it.”
77This Division further in the case of Sumon vs. The State reported in 14 ADC (2017) 931 that:
78“…confessional statement of the co-
79accused per se is not admissible
against the appellant……The confession of a co-accused is not evidence as defined in Section 3 of the Evidence Act and that Section 30 enables the Court to take into consideration the confession of a coaccused to lend assurance to other evidence against the co-accused. The expression "may take into consideration" means that the use of the evidence of confession of an accused may be used for purposes of corroborating the evidence on record against the co-accused and that no conviction can be based on such confession. If the Court believed other evidence and felt the necessity
80of seeking an assurance in support of
81its conclusion deducible from the said
82evidence, the confession of the co-
83accused would be used……The
84preponderance of opinion expressed in
85the decided cases of our apex court
86that confession of an accused may be
87taken into consideration against co-
88accused by the provision of section 30
89of the Evidence Act, its value is
90extremely weak and there could be no
91conviction without any independent
92evidence as to the connection of the
93accused.”
94From the discussion above it is clearly evident that, though generally the confessions of a co-accused are not admissible, however,
there are certain exceptions where such confessional statements could be weighed up in reaching a verdict. Nevertheless, these rules applied at the time of convicting and sentencing any person after taking all the evidences. This is merely a plea for granting bail of an under trial accused. At this summary proceeding and premature stage, we cannot foretell whether there will be no other incriminating evidence adduced that could be corroborated by the confessions of the coaccused.
95Granting of bail is undoubtedly a discretion of the Court. But, that discretion has to be exercised upon a sound footing of laws governing the gamut of a particular case.
96It has to be remembered that, it is not the
prima facie case against the accused respondent, but, the ‘reasonable grounds’ for believing that, he has been guilty__ is the concept of granting bail that gets paramount consideration. The Court has to examine the data available to connect whether reasonable grounds exist for considering, as such, in a particular case (for granting or non-granting bail). In the instant case, as we have found that, the High Court Division did not exercise its discretion while making the Rule absolute and by granting bail to the accused respondent inasmuch as in so doing it has not considered the well settled proposition of law as hinted above. The findings of the High Court Division simply rest upon the consideration that, confessional statements of co-accused cannot
form the sole basis of implication and for that reason, it granted bail to the accused respondent. Palpably, it escaped notice of the High Court Division that, allegation of money laundering is heinous in nature and is under public condemnation and that, the accused respondent is a habitual offender. These are the criterion to be regarded as predominant aspect of considering granting of bail under section 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
97The accused respondent was enlarged on bail within a very short period of time from the date of his arrest. Offence of this kind should not have been dealt with by the High Court Division in such a manner while granting bail to the accused respondent. Indeed, it was done hastily.
98Besides, it has already been discussed under what circumstances confessional statements of co-accused becomes relevant and weighty. That being the position, we are of the view that, the High Court Division has certainly misdirected itself enlarging the accused respondent on bail ignoring the settled principle of granting bail under section 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
99In view of the above discussions, the High Court Division wrongly made the Rule absolute and enlarged the accused respondent on bail.
100So, we are inclined to interfere with the same.
101Accordingly, this petition is disposed of. The impugned judgment and order of the High Court Division is set aside and the order of
bail granted to the accused respondent-AHM Fuad is cancelled.
102J.
103J.
104J.
105The 1st June, 2023______ Hamid/B.R/ *Words 2481*
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











