High Court Division · Criminal Revisional Jurisdiction
Md. Mahabul Biswas v The State
Criminal Revision 4037/2023 · Decided 3 March 2026
RAB personnel stopped the accused on a bicycle and said they recovered 1 kg 900 grams of ganja (cannabis) from him. Tried in his absence, he was convicted under Table 7(ka) of section 19(1) and 19(4) of the Madok Drabbya Niyantron Ain, 1990 (the narcotics control law) and sentenced to one year's rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Taka 1,000, which the Sessions Judge affirmed. In revision, the High Court Division found that the seizure list witnesses signed blank paper at RAB's request and never saw the ganja, and witnesses contradicted each other and the FIR on the time and place of recovery. Since punishment depends on quantity, weight is crucial, yet no witness saw the substance weighed. The chemical examiner's report was never proved or exhibited; section 510 of the Code of Criminal Procedure dispenses with calling the examiner, but the report must still be formally produced. Without scientific proof of the substance, conviction on oral evidence was unsafe. The Rule was made absolute and the accused acquitted.
Rule made absolute; accused acquitted
- Rule absolute and Rule dischargedThe two final results of a Rule in the High Court Division: made absolute means the petitioner wins; discharged means the petition fails and the order below stands.Read the full explanation →
- Acquittal (khalash)A court's final finding that an accused person is not guilty of the offence charged, ending the case in their favour unless it is reversed on appeal.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether a conviction for possession of ganja can stand where the seizure list witnesses signed blank paper and did not see the seized article, and the weighing of the substance was not proved.
- Q2
Whether a chemical examiner's report that was neither tendered nor exhibited at trial can prove that the seized substance was a narcotic.
- The seizure list witnesses signed blank paper as asked by RAB and did not see the incriminating articles, which rendered the seizure list highly doubtful.
- There were material contradictions among the witnesses and with the FIR on the time and place of arrest and recovery, which the trial court wrongly treated as minor.
- As punishment under section 19 of the Madok Drabbya Niyantron Ain, 1990 depends on quantity, failure to prove how the substance was weighed made the recovery doubtful.
- A chemical examiner's report may be used under section 510 of the Code of Criminal Procedure without calling the examiner, but it must be formally produced and exhibited, and failure to do so goes to the root of the case.
- The prosecution failed to prove the charge beyond reasonable doubt, so the Rule was made absolute, the conviction set aside and the accused acquitted and discharged from bail.
In absence of scientific proof as to the nature of the seized material, it would be wholly unsafe to sustain a conviction merely on the basis of oral testimony.
In the court’s own words.
Criminal Revision 4037/2023, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 13 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2HIGH COURT DIVISION
3(CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION)
4Present:
5Mr. Justice Md. Bashir Ullah
6Criminal Revision No. 4037 of 2023
7In the matter of:
8An application under section 439 read with
9435 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
10-And-
11In the matter of:
12Md. Mahabul Biswas
13…Convict-Appellant-Petitioner
14-Versus-
15The State
16……………Respondent-Opposite Party
17Mr. Md. Mahabubur Rahman, Advocate
18………..For the petitioner.
19Mr. S. M. Aminul Islam Sanu, DAG with
20Mr. Md. Nasimul Hasan, AAG with
21Mr. Md. Golamun Nabi, AAG and
22Ms. Farhana Abedin, AAG
23………… For the State
24Heard on: 23.02.2026, 24.02.2026,
2526.02.2026 and 01.03.2026
26Judgment on: 03.03.2026
27This Rule was issued at the instance of the petitioner calling upon the opposite party to show cause as to why the judgment and
order dated 25.07.2023 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Kushtia in Criminal Appeal No. 67 of 2023 affirming the judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 04.08.2015 passed by the learned Senior Judicial Magistrate, Kushtia in G.R. No. 110 of 2010 (Daulatpur) arising out of Daulatpur Police Station Case No. 06 dated 04.03.2010 convicting the petitioner under Table 7(ka) of Section 19(1) and 19(4) of the Madok Drabbya Niyantron Ain, 1990 and sentencing him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for a period of 01(one) year with a fine of Taka 1,000/- should not be set aside and/or such other or further order or orders be passed as to this court may seem fit and proper.
28Facts relevant for disposal of the Rule, in brief, are that, the informant, Sub-Inspector Debashish Das of RAB-12, Kushtia lodged a First Information Report with Daulatpur Police Station, Kushtia against the accused-petitioner alleging inter alia that on 04.03.2010 at about 5.45 hours while the informant along with his force was on duty within the jurisdiction of Daulatpur Police Station, one Md. Mahabul Biswas was seen approaching on a bicycle. Upon being signalled to stop, allegedly he attempted to flee away but was apprehended and 01 kg and 900 grams of Ganja (marijuana/cannabis) were recovered from his possession. There
after having prepared a seizure list at the spot in the presence of witnesses the informant came to the Police Station. Thereafter, the informant lodged the FIR with Daulatpur Police Station which was registered as Daulatpur Police Station Case No. 06, dated 04.03.2010 under Table 7(ka) of Sections 19(1) and 19(4) of the Madok Drabbya Niyantron Ain, 1990.
29On closure of investigation, the Investigating Officer submitted police report being No. 121, dated 11.04.2010 recommending prosecution under Table 7(ka) of Sections 19(1) and 19(4) of the Madok Drabbya Niyantron Ain, 1990. Thereafter, upon taking cognizance of offence, charge was framed against the accused under Table 7(ka) of Sections 19(1) and 19(4) of the Madok Drabbya Niyantron Ain, 1990. At the time of framing of charge the accused was absconding. In course of trial, the prosecution examined 6 witnesses while the defence examined none. The accused was not examined under Section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure as he was absconding at that time.
30Upon conclusion of the trial, the learned Senior Judicial Magistrate, Kushtia by judgment and order dated 04.08.2015 convicted the accused-petitioner under Table 7(ka) of Sections 19(1) and 19(4) of the Madok Drabbya Niyantron Ain, 1990 and
sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 01(one) year with a fine of Taka 1,000/-, in default 01(one) month more rigorous imprisonment.
31Challenging the conviction and sentence, the petitioner filed Criminal Appeal No. 67 of 2023 before the learned Sessions Judge, Kushtia, who dismissed the appeal affirming the conviction and sentence by the judgment and order dated 25.07.2023.
32Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with judgment and order dated 25.07.2023, the petitioner preferred the instant Criminal Revision before this Court and obtained Rule and bail.
33Mr. Mahabur Rahman, the learned Advocate appearing on behalf the petitioner submits that the prosecution witnesses failed to support the alleged recovery of Ganza in a consistent and reliable manner and there are contradictions in depositions regarding time, place and manner of recovery.
34He next submits that no disinterested, independent and impartial witnesses even the Investigation Officer was not examined and as such the judgments and orders are liable to be set aside.
35He contends that the seizure list witnesses admitted that they signed on blank papers and did not see the recovered articles and even the seized substance was not properly weighed in accordance with law. He argues that the chemical examination report was neither proved nor exhibited during trial and thus the prosecution failed to prove the charge beyond reasonable doubt. . He lastly submits that the petitioner is a day labourer, the sole earning member of his family and he has no previous criminal record. He finally prays for making the Rule absolute.
36In support of his contention he refers to the case of Zafela Begum and others Vs Atikullah and others, reported in 16 BLC (AD) 46 and Kazi Mahabubuddin Ahmed Vs. The State, reported in 57DLR 513.
37Per contra, Mr. Md. Nasimul Hasan, the learned Assistant Attorney General contends that there is no illegality, impropriety or infirmity in the impugned judgments and orders. The trial Court rightly convicted and sentenced the petitioner and the lower appellate Court rightly affirmed the conviction and sentence passed by the trial Court.
38He further submits that admittedly, no scale was used to determine the actual quantum of the seized marijuana and the chemical report was not examined however it is fact that narcotics were recovered from the accused and the recovery was proved by six prosecution witnesses. So, the accused is not entitled to have any relief from the Court. In support of his contention the learned Assistant Attorney General refers to the case of Leon and another Vs. State, reported in 69 DLR(2017) 498 and Eliadha McCord Vs. The State, reported in 48 DLR(1996) 495. He prays for discharging the Rule.
39I have considered the submissions advanced by the learned Advocates for the respective parties and perused the impugned judgments and orders, annexure and other materials on records.
40It appears from the evidence of PW-5 Md. Milan Hossain, seizure list witness in his examination-in-chief stated that B¢j HL¢V hÉ¡N ®c¢Mz a¡l¡ Bj¡−L HL¢V L¡NS ü¡rl ¢c−a hm−m ü¡rl L¢lz
41Another seizure list witness, PW-6, Md. Jaynal also stated in his examination-in-chief that B¢j h¡¢s Bp¡l f−b lÉ¡−hl ®m¡LSe ®c¢Mz a¡l¡ Bj¡−L HL¢V L¡N−S ü¡rl Ll−a hm−m ü¡rl L¢lz HL¢V hÉ¡N ®c−M¢Rm¡jz lÉ¡h h−m−R a¡−a Ny¡S¡ B−Rz
42The above-mentioned evidence indicates that the seizure list witnesses signed on a blank paper as asked by RAB personnel which was subsequently exhibited as seizure list and they did not see the incriminating articles with their own eyes. The RAB authority informed them that they recovered Ganja (marijuana/canabis). Such evidence renders the seizure list highly doubtful and undermines its evidentiary value.
43It transpires from the evidence adduced by the prosecution witness that the time of occurrence was also not proved. The witnesses deposed contradictory statements regarding arrest of the accused and recovery of the Ganja (marijuana/canabis). PW-3, Nurul Azam, a member of the raiding party stated in his examination-in-chief that Be¤j¡¢eL pL¡m 5.55 ¢j¢e−Vl pju p¡C−Lm B−l¡q£ HL hÉ¢š²−L Bjl¡ b¡j−a h¢mz ®p e¡ ®b−j p¡C−Lm â¦a Q¡m¡−a b¡−Lz HL fkÑ¡−u Bj¡−cl p‰£u ®g¡pÑ a¡−L ®NËga¡l L−lz Whereas in the FIR it is stated that AcÉ Cw 04.03.2010 a¡¢lM Ae¤j¡e 6.55 O¢VL¡l ¢c−L dªa Bp¡j£ ®j¡x j¡q¡h¤h¤m ¢hnÄ¡p HL¢V p¡C−L−ml qÉ¡−ä−m fÔ¡¢ø−Ll hÉ¡−N ¢LR¤ j¡m¡j¡m pq p¡C−Lm Q¡m¡Cu¡ aõ¡n£ ÙÛ¡−e B−pz PW-4, Bashudeb Das, in his examination-in-chief stated that ¢f¢p¢p ew 82, a¡w 03.04.2010 j§−m pL¡m Ae¤j¡e 6.30 V¡l pju Vq−m ®hl qCz On the otherhand in FIR it is stated that ¢f¢p¢p ew 82/10 a¡¢lM 04.03.2010 pju 5.45 O¢VL¡ j§−m p‰£u
A¢gp¡l J ®g¡pÑpq ®c±maf¤l b¡e¡ Hm¡L¡ Vqm J ®QL−f¡ø ¢XE¢V Ll¡l SeÉ lJe¡ qCz
44There are material contradictions in the statements adduced by the witnesses regarding the place of occurrence. PW-2 stated that p¡C−L−ml qÉ¡−ä−ml p¡−b fÔ¡¢ø−Ll hÉ¡−Nl ¢ial Be¤j¡¢eL 1 ®L¢S 900 NË¡j Ny¡S¡ f¡Ju¡ k¡uz On the other hand PW-3 stated I hÉ¢š²l p¡C−L−ml ¢fR−el LÉ¡¢lu¡−l fÔ¡¢ø−Ll L¡N−S ®j¡s¡−e AhÙÛ¡u 1 ®L¢S 900 NË¡j Ny¡S¡ ¢Rmz PW-4 stated that a¡l p¡C−L−m b¡L¡ fÔ¡¢ø−Ll hÉ¡N aõ¡n£ L−l I hÉ¡−Nl ¢ial Ny¡S¡ f¡Ju¡ k¡uz
45The trial Court also observed in its judgment and order that there are contradictions in the evidence adduced by the witnesses but it treated as minor discrepancy. The trial Court observed that Dc¯’vwcZ mvÿx‡`i mv‡ÿ¨i g‡a¨ wKQz †QvU Lv‡Uv Discrepancies jÿ¨ Kiv †M‡jI Zv Av`vj‡Zi Kv‡Q minor discrepancy e‡j g‡b n‡q‡Q|
46The FIR alleges recovery of 1 kg 900 grams of Ganja (marijuana), however the prosecution failed to prove the weighing or scaling procedure in the FIR and also during the trial. In the case of narcotics, the weight of seized substance is crucial as punishment varies depending on quantum under section 19 of the
Madok Drabbya Niyantron Ain (The Narcotics Control Act, 1990). The table of punishment tiers runs as follows: œ²¢jL ew j¡cLâ−hÉl e¡j Cä
477. Ny¡S¡ h¡ ®k ®L¡e (L) j¡cLâ−hÉl f¢lj¡e Ae§dÄÑ 5 ®L¢S qC−m
48®ioS LÉ¡e¡¢hp Ae§Ée 6 j¡p Hhw Ae§dÄÑ 3 hvpl L¡l¡cäz
49(M) j¡cLâ−hÉl f¢lj¡e 5 ®L¢Sl E−dÄÑ qC−m
50Ae§Ée 3 hvpl Hhw Ae§dÄÑ 15 hvpl L¡l¡cäz
518. −k ®L¡e fÐS¡¢al LÉ¡e¡¢hp N¡−Rl pwMÉ¡ Ae§dÄÑ 25¢V qC−m Ae§Ée 6
52LÉ¡e¡¢hp N¡R j¡p Hhw Ae§dÄÑ 3 hvpl L¡l¡cäz
53(M) LÉ¡e¡¢hp N¡−Rl pwMÉ¡ 25¢Vl ®h¢n qC−m
54Ae§Ée 3 hvpl Hhw Ae§dÄÑ 15 hvpl L¡l¡cäz
55It appears that the witnesses do not testify that they saw the marijuana being weighed on a scale and the RAB authority took the accused to a nearby shop to weigh the item and as such the entire recovery became doubtful. Seizure list must be prepared at the spot of recovery in the presence of local witness mentioning how the materials were measured. The police failed to record how they weighed it at the scene or during booking; it raises a red flag about the integrity of the evidence. Thus seizure list became defective. Material contradiction regarding the recovery including how it was weighed makes the recovery doubtful. The prosecution failed to follow mandatory procedural steps, the benefit of doubt must go in favour of the accused.
56The witnesses did not see weighing the incriminating articles which makes the seizure list unreliable and the case collapsed. If the raiding party cannot explain the source of the weighing scale or the presence of a weighing memo, it creates a gap in the chain of evidence.
57Upon meticulous scrutiny of the evidence on record, it appears from the impugned judgment that recovered ganza was forwarded to the Chemical Examiner for forensic analysis and chemical examination report was obtained to establish that the seized substance was marijuana, a prohibited narcotic substance within the meaning of the মাদক ব িনয় ণ আইন, 1990z But the report was neither tendered in evidence nor marked as an exhibit during trial.
58In a criminal case the prosecution must proved beyond reasonable doubt that the seized substance is actually marijuana (canabis).
59The Courts below relied upon Section 510 of the Code of Criminal Procedure stating that the report of a Government Chemical Examiner can be used as evidence without calling the
chemical examiner as witness. It is true but it must be formally produced by any other prosecution witness and marked an exhibit.
60The failure to exhibit the report creates a massive gap in the chain of custody. Non-production or non-exhibition of the chemical examiner’s report is a fundamental defect. If the chemical examination report is not exhibited the charges of possession of narcotics will fail and the accused is certainly entitled to an acquittal.
61It is to be reiterated that to connect the forensic report with the substance allegedly recovered and seized from possession of the accused prosecution is required to prove the chemical examination report by examining the concerned chemical examiner or any other witness.
62In a case involving an offence of trafficking or carrying illegal narcotics chemical examination report is indeed crucial for proving the nature of the substance recovered and allegedly seized. But in the case in hand, it depicts that though the report of chemical examination forms part of the record, the concerned report issuing chemical examiner or any other witness has not been examined and thus the chemical examination report has not
been proved and exhibited before the trial Court. Such deficiency on part of prosecution indubitably creates doubt benefit of which goes in favour of accused.
63In such circumstances, this Court finds that the chemical examination report constitutes a substantive and reliable piece of evidence establishing that the seized substance was marijuana. However, where the chemical examination report has not been exhibited in accordance with law, or where the prosecution has failed to prove the same through a competent witness, such omission goes to the root of the case. In absence of scientific proof as to the nature of the seized material, it would be wholly unsafe to sustain a conviction merely on the basis of oral testimony.
64On careful scrutiny of the impugned judgments, I find that the Courts below failed to properly consider the aforesaid material discrepancies and proceeded to convict the accused-petitioner on conjectures and surmise rather than on evidence. The findings of the Courts below thus suffer from misreading and nonconsideration of material evidence on record.
65In the totality of the facts and circumstances, I am of the considered view that the prosecution has miserably failed to prove
the charge against the accused-petitioner under Table 7(ka) of Sections 19(1) and 19(4) of the Madok Drabbya Niyantron Ain, 1990 beyond all reasonable doubt. The accused-petitioner is, therefore entitled to the benefit of doubt. Both the Courts below committed error of law in convicting the petitioner for the offence charged with.
66In the result, the Rule is made absolute.
67The judgments and orders of conviction and sentence passed by the Courts below are hereby set aside.
68The accused-petitioner is acquitted of the charge under Table 7(ka) of Section 19(1) and 19(4) of the Madok Drabbya Niyantron Ain, 1990.
69Since the accused-petitioner is enlarged on bail he is discharged from his bail bond immediately.
70Let a copy of this judgment along with lower Court’s record be communicated to the concerned Court forthwith.
71(Md. Bashir Ullah, J.)
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











