High Court Division · Criminal Revisional Jurisdiction
Md. Mamun Or Rashid @ Almari v The State
Criminal Revision 5290/2023 · Decided 23 February 2026
The accused was charged with sodomy on an eight-year-old boy who attended private tuition at his house. The Chief Judicial Magistrate first discharged him for lack of prima facie material, but on revision a charge was framed. He was later convicted under section 377 of the Penal Code and sentenced to 10 years' imprisonment; on appeal the sentence was reduced to 4 years and a fine of Taka 2,000. In revision, the High Court Division found that the doctor who examined the victim within about twelve hours found no injury and no sign of sodomy, and this evidence went unchallenged. The informant's testimony departed from the FIR, a village salish (an informal village arbitration) mentioned for the first time in court was supported by no participant, and the allegedly stained clothes were never produced. The Court held the prosecution had not proved the charge beyond reasonable doubt, made the Rule absolute, set aside the conviction and acquitted the accused.
Rule made absolute; accused acquitted
- Rule absolute and Rule dischargedThe two final results of a Rule in the High Court Division: made absolute means the petitioner wins; discharged means the petition fails and the order below stands.Read the full explanation →
- Acquittal (khalash)A court's final finding that an accused person is not guilty of the offence charged, ending the case in their favour unless it is reversed on appeal.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether a conviction under section 377 of the Penal Code can stand where unchallenged medical evidence found no injury and no sign of sodomy and the prosecution witnesses contradicted each other and the FIR.
- The unchallenged medical evidence of PW-10, who found no injury and no sign of sodomy shortly after the incident, directly contradicted and negated the prosecution version of forcible penetration.
- Following Nur Mohammad @ Bog Master v The State (9 BLD 314), the Court held that the essential ingredients of the offence under section 377 of the Penal Code were not proved.
- The unexplained non-examination of any participant in the alleged village salish attracted an adverse inference against the prosecution.
- The deliberate non-production of the allegedly blood and semen-stained clothes attracted an adverse presumption under section 114(g) of the Evidence Act.
- The evidence being untrustworthy, uncorroborated and insufficient, the accused was given the benefit of the doubt, the conviction and sentence were set aside and he was acquitted and discharged from his bail bond.
For the foregoing reasons, the case of prosecution is riddled with insurmountable doubts and fatal inconsistencies that render the evidence wholly unreliable.
In the court’s own words.
Criminal Revision 5290/2023, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 14 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2HIGH COURT DIVISION
3(CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION)
4Present:
5Mr. Justice Md. Bashir Ullah
6Criminal Revision No. 5290 of 2023
7In the matter of:
8An application under section 439 read with
9435 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
10-And-
11In the matter of:
12Md. Mamun Or Rashid @ Almari
13… Convict-Petitioner
14-Versus-
15The State
17Mr. Syed Md. Zahangir Hossain, Advocate
18… For the Convict- Petitioner
19Mr. S.M. Aminul Islam Sanu, D.A.G with
20Mr. Md. Nasimul Hasan, A.A.G with
21Mr. Md. Golamun Nabi, A.A.G and
22Ms. Farhana Abedin, A.A.G
23… For the State
24Heard on: 02.02.2026, 03.02.2026 and
2515.02.2026
26Judgment on: 23.02.2026
27This Rule was issued calling upon the opposite party to show cause as to why the judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 14.05.2023 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, 1st Court, Naogaon in Criminal
Appeal No. 152 of 2021 dismissing the appeal with modification of sentence and thereby sentencing him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 04 (four) years and to pay a fine of Taka 2,000/-, in default to suffer simple imprisonment for 01(one) month and modifying the judgment and order dated 19.07.2017 passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Naogaon in Niamotpur Police Station Case No. 07 dated 19.03.2009 corresponding to G.R. No. 28 of 2009 (Niamotpur) convicting the petitioner under Section 377 of the Penal Code and sentencing him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 10 (ten) years with a fine of Taka 5,000/-, in default to suffer simple imprisonment for 01 (one) month more should not be set aside and/or such other or further order or orders be passed as to this court may seem fit and proper.
28Facts relevant for disposal of the Rule, in brief, are that, one Alhaj Al Mamun lodged an FIR with Niamotpur Police Station alleging, inter alia, that his minor son namely Md. Fazle Rabbi aged about 8 years used to attend private tuition at the house of the accused, Mamun-Or-Rashid alias Almari. On 18.03.2009 at about 9.00 pm, the accused had committed
sodomy upon Md. Fazle Rabbi. After that the victim was sent to his house. The victim returned home and disclosed the occurrence to his parents. Upon receipt of the information, the informant along with relatives went to the house of the accused to apprehend him but accused nos. 2 to 5 forcibly rescued him and obstructed the informant party. Subsequently, the victim was first taken to a village doctor for treatment and on the following day he was taken to Niamotpur Hospital. Accordingly, Niamotpur Police Station Case No. 07 dated 19.03.2009 under Section 377 of the Penal Code was initiated against the petitioner along with four others.
29On closure of investigation, the investigating officer submitted police report no. 57 dated 07.06.2009 under Section 377 of the Penal Code against the accused petitioner.
30The accused initially filed an application for discharging him from the allegations leveled against him. Upon hearing both parties the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Naogaon discharged the accused from the charge leveled against him on 09.02.2011 finding absence of prima facie materials.
31Against the said order of discharge, the prosecution filed Criminal Revision No. 81 of 2011. Upon hearing the learned Additional Sessions Judge, 2nd Court, Naogaon allowed the revisional application and directed to frame charge against the accused on 25.03.2014. Subsequently, charge was framed against the accused under Section 377 of the Penal Code. The accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried at the time of framing of charge and when the charge was read out.
32During trial the prosecution examined 10 (ten) out of 11(eleven) charge sheeted witnesses. The accused was examined under section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and once again he claimed innocence. However, he did not examine himself nor led any evidence in his defence.
33Upon conclusion of trial and considering the evidence, the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Naogaon convicted the accused under Section 377 of the Penal Code and sentenced him to suffer 10(ten) years simple imprisonment with fine of Taka 5,000/- by judgment and order dated 19.07.2017.
34Challenging the judgment and order of conviction and sentence the convict-accused filed Criminal Appeal No. 152
of 2021 before the learned Sessions Judge, Naogaon. On transfer, learned Additional Sessions Judge, 1st Court, Naogaon heard and dismissed the appeal modifying the sentence of imprisonment from 10 years to 4 years and fine Taka 2,000/- by judgment and order dated 14.05.2023.
35Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the judgment and order dated 14.05.2023, the petitioner preferred this instant Criminal Revision and obtained the Rule.
36Mr. Syed Md. Zahangir Hossain, the learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioner contends that the doctor (PW-10) categorically opined that no physical injury was found present on any part of the body of victim, no injury mark was detected in or around the anal region and no sign of sodomy could be detected and such medical opinion remained uncontroverted. However, the Courts below failed to appreciate the medical evidence which does not support the ocular testimonies of the prosecution witnesses and directly contradicts and completely negates the prosecution version of sodomy and as such, the conviction under Section 377 of the Penal Code is unsustainable in the eye of law. In support of
his contention learned Advocate relied upon the decision passed in the case of Nur Mohammad @ Bog Master Vs. The State, reported in 9 BLD(1989)314.
37He further argues that there is glaring contradiction between the FIR and sworn version of its maker PW-1. Besides, the narrative made by PW-1, PW-3 and PW-4 in respect of rescuing the accused, alleged village Salish suffers from patent contradiction. Prosecution also failed to examine independent witness and to produce blood and semen stained apparels. Courts below seem to have utterly failed to appreciate and consider all these pertinent matters, in arriving at decision.
38He next contends that the trial Court and Appellate Court failed to consider earlier discharge order that at the stage of framing of charge in passing which the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate found no prima facie materials and medical evidence in support of allegation and therefore the petitioner was rightly discharged. The later conviction without any fresh or stronger evidence is legally
unsustainable. The courts below failed to explain how evidence and materials which once found insufficient to frame charge suddenly became sufficient to convict beyond reasonable doubt and as such the impugned judgment and orders of the courts below involve an error of law occasioning failure of justice.
39He submits that the convict-petitioner has served out a term of imprisonment of more than 4 years. Since he has served the sentence imposed upon him, he may be acquitted of the charges leveled against him for the ends of justice and to prevent further harassment the impugned judgment and order should be set aside.
40On these grounds, the learned Advocate for the petitioner prays for making the Rule absolute.
41Per contra, Mr. Md. Golamun Nabi, the learned Assistant Attorney General appearing on behalf of the State contends that there are specific allegations against the petitioner in the FIR, which were duly proved and corroborated by PW1.
42He further submits that there is no illegality, infirmity or impropriety in the impugned judgments and orders; as such the Rule is liable to be discharged.
43I have considered the submissions advanced by the learned Advocates for the respective parties and perused the impugned judgments and orders, Annexure and other materials on records.
44The victim was admittedly examined by Dr. Md. Abdur Rahman (PW-10), the Medical Officer, within about twelve hours of the alleged occurrence. PW-10 categorically opined that "no physical injury was found present on any part of victim’s body, no injury mark was detected in or around the anal region and no sign of sodomy could be detected". PW-10 produced the medical report as exhibit-3 and proved it in his examination-in-chief. It appears that such medical opinion remained wholly unchallenged. This objective medical evidence directly contradicts and completely negates the prosecution version of forcible anal penetration allegedly causing bleeding, pain and injury, as asserted by PW-3
(victim) and PW-4 (mother of the victim) for which the prosecution offered no explanation whatsoever.
45It appears that despite inconsistency found in deposition of PW-1, PW-3 and PW-4 the conviction seems to have been based solely on interested and contradictory testimony which reflects a grave misdirection in law by Courts below that resulted in gross miscarriage of justice.
46Thus, totality of facts and gravely contradictory testimony lead to conclude that the prosecution having completely failed to prove the essential ingredients to constitute the offence arraigned, punishable under Section 377 of the Penal Code.
47This view gets support from the decision passed in the case of Nur Mohammad @ Bog Master vs. The State, reported in 9 BLD 314. In the cited case it has been held that the prosecution failed to prove the essential ingredient of penetration that the sole testimony of the alleged victim remained uncorroborated by any independent witness and there was absence of a medical report or medical opinion supporting the allegation of sodomy rendering the prosecution version inherently doubtful.
48Material contradictions are evident in the case. In the FIR, PW-1 categorically stated that immediately after disclosure of the alleged incident by the victim, he along with his two brothers and nephew went to the house of the accused and attempted to bring the accused to their house, but the accused was forcibly rescued from the informant party by accused Nos. 2-5 in presence of local witnesses. However, in his deposition, PW-1 made a complete departure from the FIR by stating that when he and others went to the house of the accused he had already fled away.
49PW-1, for the first time in course of testifying in Court stated that a large village salish attended by about 100-150 persons was held in connection with the alleged occurrence. But nothing has been mentioned in the FIR regarding the salish. The prosecution did not examine even a single salishdar or participant of the said salish, nor offered any explanation for such omission. This unexplained nonexamination of natural and independent witnesses attracts an adverse inference against the prosecution.
50It transpires that the indiscriminate implication of accused Nos. 2-5 in the FIR who were subsequently found to
have no involvement and were not sent up for want of evidence-clearly suggests prior hostility between the families and it lends support to the defence contention that the case was motivated by animosity.
51The prosecution case is further riddled with irreconcilable contradictions between the testimonies of PW1, PW-3 (alleged victim) and PW-4 (mother of the victim), which are wholly inconsistent with the objective medical evidence of PW-10. While PW-3 claimed that he screamed loudly for two minutes, and his apparels were soaked with blood and semen, PW-4 categorically admitted that she did not hear any scream and no neighbour heard any such scream.
52However, the alleged blood and semen-stained clothes were neither produced before the police nor seized or exhibited in court. In such circumstances, the deliberate nonproduction of the alleged stained apparels attracts an adverse presumption under section 114(g) of the Evidence Act. These mutually destructive oral versions are further found to have been demolished by the testimony of PW-10, the Medical Officer, who found no injury whatsoever and no sign of
sodomy upon examination of the victim shortly after the alleged incident.
53It transpires that the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate found no prima facie materials and medical evidence in support of the allegation and therefore he discharged the petitioner at the stage of framing of charge.
54The record shows that the convict-petitioner has already served out a term of imprisonment of more than 4 years which was imposed upon him and he is not a habitual offender and has no previous criminal record.
55For the foregoing reasons, the case of prosecution is riddled with insurmountable doubts and fatal inconsistencies that render the evidence wholly unreliable. The foundational allegations patently lack credible corroboration and are contradicted by the entirely of the medical and forensic evidence.
56In view of the facts and circumstances discussed above, I am of the considered view that the prosecution has miserably failed to prove the charge against the petitioner
beyond reasonable doubt. The evidence on record is untrustworthy, uncorroborated, and insufficient to sustain a conviction. Consequently, the case against the accusedpetitioner being highly doubtful, the benefit of doubt is extended to him and he is entitled to acquittal.
57Thus both the Courts below committed an error of law in convicting the petitioner under Section 377 of the Penal Code and sentencing him there under to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 4(four) years and to pay fine of Taka 2,000/- (two thousand) which are liable to set aside.
58In the result, the Rule is made absolute.
59The judgments and orders of conviction and sentence passed by the Courts below are hereby set aside.
60The petitioner is acquitted of the charge leveled against him.
61Since the petitioner is enlarged on bail he is discharged from his bail bond immediately.
62Let a copy of this judgment along with the lower Court’s records be communicated to the concerned Court forthwith.
63(Md. Bashir Ullah, J) Md. Ariful Islam Khan Bench Officer
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











