Supreme Court Judgments, Summarised

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Nov 3, 2026

Summary

A young man's slaughtered body was found in a lane in Dhaka in 2009. In this unseen murder, the trial tribunal convicted two accused under sections 302/34 of the Penal Code, 1860, mainly on their confessions under section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the alleged recovery of a knife, and sentenced both to death. The High Court Division heard the death reference with the jail appeal of the convict in custody. None of the seizure list witnesses said the knife was recovered at a convict's pointing out, and the knife was never produced in court. One convict had been illegally detained for more than 72 hours before confessing, so his confession was inadmissible. The two confessions also contradicted each other and placed the killing inside a house, whereas the FIR and sketch map placed it in a lane. Applying the double test of voluntariness and truth, the Court gave the convicts the benefit of the doubt, rejected the reference, allowed the appeal and acquitted both.

Issues

  1. Q1

    Whether the prosecution proved that the murder weapon was recovered at the pointing out of one of the convicts.

  2. Q2

    Whether the confessional statements recorded under section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure were voluntary and true, given the illegal detention of one convict and the contradictions between the two confessions.

  3. Q3

    Whether the death sentences for murder under sections 302/34 of the Penal Code, 1860 could be sustained in this unseen murder.

Key points

  • None of the seizure list witnesses stated that the knife was recovered at the pointing out of the convict, and the knife was not produced as a material exhibit, so the trial Judge wrongly found the recovery proved.
  • A convict produced before the Magistrate for the first time after being held by the investigating officer without a remand order for more than seventy-two hours made a confession that was not admissible.
  • Following Humayun Kabir (Md.) v The State, 74 DLR (AD) 91, where conviction in a capital case rests mainly on confession, the court must be satisfied that the confession is both perfectly voluntary and perfectly true.
  • The two confessions lost credibility because of material contradictions, including placing the killing inside a house when the FIR, inquest and sketch map showed it occurred in a lane.
  • The prosecution failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt, so the death reference was rejected, the jail appeal allowed and both convicts, including the absconding one, acquitted.

In the present case, we are clearly of the opinion that, apart from the illegal detention of convict Md. Jafor, the confessional statements of the convicts have lost their credibility due to contradictions and inconsistencies in various material particulars.

From the judgment, Justice Md Atoar Rahman
Law considered

Penal Code, 1860, section 302Penal Code, 1860, section 34Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, section 164Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, section 374

The judgment

In the court’s own words.

Death Reference 108/2018, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 23 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.

PDF
Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp