Death reference
ডেথ রেফারেন্স
The automatic referral of a death sentence by the trial court to the High Court Division, which must confirm it before it is carried out, or may change the sentence, order a retrial or acquit.
Death reference, step by step.
A death reference is the process by which every death sentence passed by a trial court is sent to the High Court Division for confirmation.
Under section 374 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the sentence cannot be carried out unless the High Court Division confirms it.
This happens even if the prisoner does not appeal, but the prisoner should still file an appeal or jail appeal so that his own arguments are heard.
File an appeal quickly
File a criminal appeal or a jail appeal through the jail authorities as soon as possible, ideally within seven days of the sentence.
Get the judgment copy
Under section 371 the prisoner is entitled to a copy of the judgment. Obtain it and the full record for the lawyer.
Arrange representation
Engage an advocate for the High Court Division, or ask the court or legal aid to appoint a State Defence Lawyer.
Follow the paper book and cause list
Check that the paper book is prepared and watch the cause list so the hearing is not missed.
A death reference is the process by which every death sentence passed by a trial court is sent to the High Court Division for confirmation. Under section 374 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the sentence cannot be carried out unless the High Court Division confirms it. This happens even if the prisoner does not appeal, but the prisoner should still file an appeal or jail appeal so that his own arguments are heard.
What a death reference is
When a Court of Session sentences a person to death, its job is not finished. The law treats a death sentence as needing a second, independent check. The trial court must "refer" or submit the whole case record to the High Court Division, and the High Court Division decides whether the conviction and the death sentence should stand. That submission is the death reference, and High Court Division case lists number it as "Death Reference No. ... of [year]".
The reference exists to protect life. It is not an appeal filed by anyone. It is a duty placed on the courts, and the High Court Division examines the evidence for itself rather than just looking for legal errors. Because of the stakes, it reads the whole record closely.
The legal basis
Section 31(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898 says a Sessions Judge or Additional Sessions Judge may pass any lawful sentence, but a death sentence is subject to confirmation by the High Court Division. Section 374 requires the proceedings to be submitted and bars execution until confirmation. Under section 371(3), the trial judge must tell the prisoner the period for appealing.
The High Court Division's powers are in sections 375 to 379. It may take further evidence, and a confirmation or new sentence must be signed by at least two judges. If the judges are equally divided, the case goes to a third judge. Once the High Court Division decides, the Court of Session carries out its order under section 381. Death sentences passed by some special tribunals, such as Nari-o-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Tribunals, are also sent to the High Court Division as death references.
How the reference is heard
The record is sent to the High Court Division and a paper book, a printed set of the evidence and documents, is prepared. A Division Bench of two judges hears the reference together with any criminal appeal or jail appeal by the condemned prisoner. A Deputy Attorney General presents the State's case. If the prisoner has no lawyer, the court appoints a State Defence Lawyer.
Section 376 says the High Court Division may confirm the sentence or pass another lawful sentence, convict of a different offence, order a new trial, or acquit. It cannot confirm until the appeal period has expired or any appeal is decided. Delay is a serious problem. The Daily Star reported in December 2021 that 782 death references were pending as of August 2021, with trials that had ended six to sixteen years earlier.
Possible outcomes and what happens next
Judgments use set phrases. "Death reference accepted" means the sentence is confirmed. "Death reference rejected" means it is not confirmed, and the court then commutes the sentence, usually to imprisonment for life, acquits the accused, or orders a retrial. A prisoner whose death sentence is commuted may also be ordered out of the condemned cell.
If the High Court Division confirms a death sentence or itself sentences someone to death or life imprisonment, article 103(2)(b) of the Constitution gives an appeal to the Appellate Division as of right. Under the Appellate Division Rules 1988, it must be lodged within 30 days of the judgment, and a prisoner in jail may submit it through the officer in charge of the jail. The State needs leave to appeal against an acquittal or commutation.
After the Appellate Division
If the Appellate Division upholds the death sentence, the prisoner may apply to it for review under article 105. Its rules require a review application within 30 days of the judgment, and in criminal cases review is limited to an error apparent on the face of the record. It is not a rehearing.
The last step is a mercy petition. Under article 49, the President has power to grant pardons, reprieves and respites and to remit, suspend or commute any sentence. Separately, section 382 of the Code requires the High Court Division to postpone the execution of a woman sentenced to death who is found to be pregnant, and allows it to commute her sentence to life imprisonment.
Common misunderstandings
A death reference is not the prisoner's appeal. It runs automatically, but on its own it may not put the prisoner's best arguments before the court. That is why an appeal or jail appeal should be filed too. The time limit is short: Article 150 of the Limitation Act 1908 allows seven days from the sentence for an appeal from a death sentence passed by a Court of Session, although section 5 of that Act lets a court admit a late appeal if sufficient cause for the delay is shown.
Nor does a death sentence from the trial court mean the case is over. The High Court Division often reduces or overturns death sentences after reweighing the evidence, for example where a confession was not properly recorded or a key fact such as a dowry demand was not proved.
Suppose a Sessions Judge sentences a man to death for murdering his neighbour, relying mainly on his confession. The judge sends the record to the High Court Division as a death reference and tells him the appeal period. He files a jail appeal through the jail authorities. Years later a Division Bench hears the reference and the jail appeal together, with a State Defence Lawyer for him. It finds the confession was not shown to be voluntary, rejects the reference and acquits him.
What to do if this affects you
- 01File an appeal quickly
File a criminal appeal or a jail appeal through the jail authorities as soon as possible, ideally within seven days of the sentence.
- 02Get the judgment copy
Under section 371 the prisoner is entitled to a copy of the judgment. Obtain it and the full record for the lawyer.
- 03Arrange representation
Engage an advocate for the High Court Division, or ask the court or legal aid to appoint a State Defence Lawyer.
- 04Follow the paper book and cause list
Check that the paper book is prepared and watch the cause list so the hearing is not missed.
- 05Plan the next stage
If the sentence is confirmed, lodge an appeal to the Appellate Division within 30 days and consider a mercy petition later.
Test yourself on Death reference
Death reference in real judgments
Recent Supreme Court of Bangladesh judgments summarised on trw.co where the term appears.
Questions about Death reference
Does every death sentence go to the High Court Division?
Yes. Under sections 31(2) and 374 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, a death sentence passed by a Sessions Judge or Additional Sessions Judge must be submitted to the High Court Division, and it cannot be carried out unless the High Court Division confirms it. This happens whether or not the prisoner appeals.
Do I still need to appeal if there is a death reference?
Yes, you should. The reference is a check by the court, but an appeal or jail appeal lets the prisoner put his own grounds before the court, and the two are heard together. The Limitation Act allows only seven days from the sentence to appeal against a death sentence, so act at once.
How long does a death reference take?
Often years. The Daily Star reported in December 2021 that 782 death references were pending in the High Court Division as of August 2021, in cases whose trials had ended six to sixteen years earlier. The prisoner usually remains in custody, often in a condemned cell, while the reference is pending.
What does "death reference rejected" mean?
It means the High Court Division did not confirm the death sentence. The judgment then says what happens instead: the sentence may be commuted, usually to imprisonment for life, the accused may be acquitted, or a retrial may be ordered. Read the operative part of the judgment for the exact result.
Can the prisoner appeal if the High Court Division confirms the death sentence?
Yes. Article 103(2)(b) of the Constitution gives an appeal to the Appellate Division as of right where the High Court Division confirms a death sentence. Under the Appellate Division Rules 1988 it must be lodged within 30 days of the judgment. A prisoner can submit it through the officer in charge of the jail.
Who can grant mercy after all appeals fail?
The President. Article 49 of the Constitution gives the President power to grant pardons, reprieves and respites and to remit, suspend or commute any sentence. A mercy petition is normally made once the Appellate Division has finally decided the case and any review.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











