Supreme Court Judgments, Summarised

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Nov 3, 2026

Summary

A stockbroker pledged 4,447 share certificates with Rupali Bank to secure loans. After the loans were fully adjusted and the account closed on 01.10.1996, the bank did not return the certificates. He sued for Tk. 87,72,085.50, the highest market value of the shares in October and November 1996. The bank claimed the certificates had been delivered to defendant No. 5, his authorised representative, under an arbitration between the two. The trial court dismissed the suit. The High Court Division held that the bank bore the burden of proving the arbitration and produced neither an arbitration agreement nor an award; no arbitration could exist without an agreement, and the Dhaka Stock Exchange procedure was not followed. The bank was liable as bailee under section 161 of the Contract Act. Applying section 73, compensation was assessed at the average market value on the due-return date, not the later highest value, and the suit was decreed for Tk. 24,54,429.82 with 5 per cent simple interest from 01.10.1996.

Issues

  1. Q1

    Whether the bank proved that pledged share certificates were lawfully delivered to a third party under an arbitration between the plaintiff and that party.

  2. Q2

    Whether the bank, having failed to return the pledged share certificates after the loan was repaid, was liable as bailee under section 161 of the Contract Act, 1872.

  3. Q3

    How compensation for non-return of share certificates should be assessed.

Key points

  • A party pleading that a dispute was resolved by arbitration bears the burden of proving it under section 103 of the Evidence Act, 1872, including the existence of a valid arbitration agreement.
  • Under the Arbitration Act, 1940, as under the Arbitration Act, 2001, a valid arbitration agreement is the sine qua non of any arbitration, and letters and correspondence cannot substitute for proof of an agreement or award.
  • Arbitration under Article 17 of the Dhaka Stock Exchange Bye-laws is available only for disputes between members, begun by a written application in the prescribed form, and no complaint was shown to have been lodged with the Complaint Sub-Committee.
  • Once the loan was adjusted the bank's rights as pawnee ended and it held the certificates as bailee, so its failure to return them made it liable under section 161 of the Contract Act, 1872.
  • Under sections 161 and 73 of the Contract Act, compensation for non-return of shares is assessed at their market value on the due-return date (or nearest trading date) with interest, not the highest value reached after the breach.
  • The suit was decreed in part for Tk. 24,54,429.82 with simple interest at 5 per cent per annum from 01.10.1996, payable by the bank defendants within 60 days.

The claimant is entitled to be restored to the position he would have occupied had the shares been returned when due, but is not entitled to recover damages based on the highest market value attained after the breach.

From the judgment, Justice Md. Badruzzaman
Law considered

Contract Act, 1872, section 161Contract Act, 1872, section 73Evidence Act, 1872, section 103Arbitration Act, 1940Dhaka Stock Exchange Bye-laws, Article 17

The judgment

In the court’s own words.

First Appeal 113/2007, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 23 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.

PDF
Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp