Mala fide
Latin for 'in bad faith': an act done dishonestly, out of ill will or for an improper purpose, which courts can strike down when done by a public authority.
Mala fide, step by step.
Mala fide is Latin for 'in bad faith'.
In Bangladesh courts it describes action taken dishonestly, out of personal spite, or to achieve a purpose the law did not allow.
If an official decision against you was made in bad faith, the High Court Division can declare it void.
Write down the facts
Record dates, meetings, complaints and statements that show why the decision was made for an improper reason.
Collect the documents
Obtain the order, notices, correspondence and, where possible, copies from the official file.
Check other grounds
Consider whether the decision also breaches the statute or natural justice, which are often easier to prove.
Plead specifically
State exactly who acted in bad faith and how, rather than making a general allegation.
Mala fide is Latin for 'in bad faith'. In Bangladesh courts it describes action taken dishonestly, out of personal spite, or to achieve a purpose the law did not allow. If an official decision against you was made in bad faith, the High Court Division can declare it void. But the allegation must be stated precisely and backed by evidence; a bare claim of bad faith will not succeed.
What mala fide means
Mala fide means 'in bad faith'; its opposite is bona fide, 'in good faith'. The noun is mala fides. In judgments the term is used mostly about public authorities. An order is mala fide if the person who made it acted from personal ill will, to favour or punish someone, or to achieve an aim other than the one for which the power was given. It is a serious charge against the decision-maker.
Courts often divide bad faith into two kinds. Malice in fact is actual ill will or a dishonest motive, which must be proved. Malice in law needs no personal spite: it arises where a power is knowingly used for an unauthorised purpose or in plain disregard of the law. Using a power for a purpose other than its true one is also called a colourable exercise of power.
Where the idea sits in Bangladesh law
No statute defines mala fide. The closest definitions are of good faith. Under section 3(20) of the General Clauses Act 1897, a thing is done in good faith where it is in fact done honestly, whether or not it is done negligently. The Penal Code 1860 sets a stricter test for criminal law in section 52: nothing is done in good faith if it is done without due care and attention.
In public law, bad faith is a ground of judicial review developed by the courts under article 102 of the Constitution. Because no law gives a power to be used in bad faith, an act done mala fide is treated as unauthorised, and the High Court Division can declare it done without lawful authority and of no legal effect. The idea also appears in criminal law, for example where a prosecution is said to be malicious.
How an allegation of bad faith is raised and proved
The person alleging bad faith must prove it. The petition should set out specific facts: who acted, what they did, and why that shows an improper motive or purpose. The Appellate Division has held that evasive or stray statements that an order is discriminatory or mala fide are not enough. General words such as 'illegal, mala fide and arbitrary' in a petition carry little weight without facts behind them.
In writ cases the court decides on affidavits and documents, so the evidence is usually the official file, letters, timing and the sequence of events. A decision taken in haste right after a dispute, or one that ignores the statute's own procedure, may support an inference of bad faith. The record relied on must also be genuine: the Appellate Division has set aside a finding of mala fides that rested on a note which did not exist in the official file.
Why it matters: the alternative remedy rule
Normally the High Court Division will not hear a writ where the law provides another equally effective remedy, such as a statutory appeal. Bad faith is one of the recognised exceptions. High Court Division benches have said that a mala fide act goes to the root of jurisdiction, so the petitioner need not first use the statutory remedy. See the alternative remedy rule for the other exceptions.
The same idea appears in criminal cases. A proceeding started with an improper motive, for example to pressure someone in a civil dispute, may be quashed by the High Court Division under section 561A of the Code of Criminal Procedure as an abuse of the court's process. Malicious prosecution and political victimisation are also among the reasons courts accept for anticipatory bail.
What each side can do
A person affected by an order made in bad faith can file a writ petition, attach the documents that show the motive or improper purpose, and ask for an interim stay. If the High Court Division agrees, the order is declared void, and the authority may be directed to decide the matter afresh and lawfully. Either side may then seek leave to appeal in the Appellate Division within sixty days of the judgment.
An authority facing the allegation should answer each factual claim with documents from its file, explain the reasons for the decision and show that the statutory procedure was followed. A clear record of reasons made at the time of the decision is the best answer to a charge of bad faith, because the court will look at what was actually considered.
Common misunderstandings
Bad faith is not the same as a wrong decision. An official can make an honest mistake of law or fact, which is an error, not mala fides. A failure to give a hearing is usually argued as a breach of natural justice rather than bad faith, and acting beyond the powers a statute gives is ultra vires whatever the motive. Because mala fides accuses a person of dishonesty, courts expect it to be pleaded with care and proved, not assumed.
Suppose a union parishad cancels a trader's lease of a market stall two days after he complained to the deputy commissioner about the chairman, giving no reason and skipping the notice the lease rules require. The trader files a writ petition, attaching his complaint, the dates and the cancellation letter, and argues that the cancellation was made in bad faith to punish him. If the parishad's file shows no lawful reason, the High Court Division may declare the cancellation without lawful authority, even though the rules also provide an appeal to a higher officer.
What to do if this affects you
- 01Write down the facts
Record dates, meetings, complaints and statements that show why the decision was made for an improper reason.
- 02Collect the documents
Obtain the order, notices, correspondence and, where possible, copies from the official file.
- 03Check other grounds
Consider whether the decision also breaches the statute or natural justice, which are often easier to prove.
- 04Plead specifically
State exactly who acted in bad faith and how, rather than making a general allegation.
- 05Act promptly
File the writ petition or other challenge without delay and ask for interim relief if harm is close.
Test yourself on Mala fide
Mala fide in real judgments
Recent Supreme Court of Bangladesh judgments summarised on trw.co where the term appears.
Questions about Mala fide
Is an illegal order automatically mala fide?
No. An order can be unlawful because the official misread the law or missed a step, without any dishonesty. That makes it open to challenge as illegal or without jurisdiction, but not necessarily as mala fide. Courts treat bad faith as a separate and serious allegation, which needs facts showing an improper motive or a deliberate misuse of power.
Who has to prove bad faith?
The person who alleges it. The petition must give specific facts showing ill will or an improper purpose, and the supporting documents must back them up. Vague statements that an order is mala fide or discriminatory are not enough, as the Appellate Division has made clear. The authority then answers with its own records and reasons.
Can I skip the statutory appeal if the order was made in bad faith?
Possibly. The High Court Division has treated mala fide action as going to the root of jurisdiction, so a statutory appeal does not necessarily bar a writ. But the court decides case by case and will expect real evidence of bad faith. If the allegation is weak, the petition may be rejected, and by then the time for the appeal may have run out.
What is the difference between malice in fact and malice in law?
Malice in fact means actual personal ill will or a dishonest motive. Malice in law does not need spite: it covers using a legal power for a purpose it was not given for, or acting in plain disregard of the law, which the law treats as bad faith whatever the official felt. Either can make an order void.
Does mala fide matter in criminal cases?
Yes. A criminal case started to harass someone or to gain an advantage in a civil dispute can be challenged as an abuse of process, for example by an application under section 561A of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Courts have also accepted malicious prosecution or political victimisation as one reason that can justify anticipatory bail.
What does bona fide mean?
Bona fide means 'in good faith', the opposite of mala fide. It is used, for example, of a bona fide purchaser who bought property honestly without knowing of another person's claim. Under the General Clauses Act 1897, an act is done in good faith if it is in fact done honestly, even if it is done carelessly.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











