High Court Division · Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Mrs. Zearatun Nesa v Md. Abul Kalam and others
First Appeal 196/2019 · Decided 5 January 2026
The plaintiff sued for a declaration of title to 20 decimals of land by adverse possession (title gained by long, hostile occupation). She said the owner agreed in 1990 to sell her the land for Taka 1,50,000/-, took Taka 50,000/- under a bainapatra (agreement for sale) and handed over possession, and that he never refused to execute a sale deed but complained against her to the Deputy Commissioner in 2002. The Joint District Judge dismissed the suit, and she appealed. The High Court Division found that the bainapatra required the balance to be paid and a sale deed obtained within two months and did not mention delivery of possession, and no witness proved it. Even if possession was given, possession received lawfully from the owner under a bainapatra is not adverse, and even counting from 2002 it had not ripened into title by the time of the suit in 2008. The appeal was dismissed.
- Q1
Whether possession taken under a bainapatra (agreement for sale) from the owner can be adverse possession capable of ripening into title.
- Q2
Whether the plaintiff proved the date and manner of her entry into possession and when it became adverse to the true owner.
- The bainapatra did not record any delivery of possession and no competent witness proved it, so the plaintiff's claim of entry into possession in 1990 was not established.
- Possession obtained lawfully and peacefully from the executant of a bainapatra is lawful possession and cannot be adverse possession.
- Even if the possession became adverse when the owner complained to the Deputy Commissioner in 2002, it had not matured into title before the suit was filed in 2008.
- A plaintiff claiming title by adverse possession must strictly prove the date and manner of entry, when and how the possession became adverse, and when it matured into title, which the plaintiff failed to do.
- Finding no illegality in the trial court's decree, the Court dismissed the appeal without costs.
When the recipient of a deed of bainapatra gets possession in the land of the bainapatra lawfully and peacefully from the executant of the bainapatra that is lawful possession.
In the court’s own words.
First Appeal 196/2019, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 7 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION)
Present:
Mr. Justice S M Kuddus Zaman
And
Ms. Justice Tamanna Rahman Khalidi
First Appeal No.196 of 2019
Mrs. Zearatun Nesa
….Appellant
-Versus-
Md. Abul Kalam and others
… Opposite parties
Ms. Rezina Mahmud, Advocate
… For the appellant.
None appears
… For the respondents.
Heard and Judgment on 05.01.2026
S M Kuddus Zaman, J:
1This First Appeal is directed against the judgment and decree dated 05.11.2018 passed by the learned Joint District Judge, 2nd Court, Gazipur in Title Suit No.2030 of 2008 dismissing the same.
2Facts in short are that the appellant as plaintiff instituted above suit for declaration of title by adverse possession for 20 decimal land as described in “Ga” schedule to the plaint and for further declaration that the registered deed of Power of Attorney No.26336 dated 21.01.2007 as described in “Ga” schedule to the plaint is not binding upon the plaintiff alleging that above land belonged to Rafiqul Islam who declared to sale the same and the plaintiff agreed to purchase
above land for a consideration of Taka 1,50,000/- and on receipt of Taka 50,000/- above Rafiqul Islam executed a deed of bainapatra on 20,01,1990 and delivered possession. The plaintiff is in continuous possession in above land from above date which has a matured into valid title by adverse possession on 19.01.2002. Above Rafiqul Islam never refused to execute and register a sale deed on the basis of above deed of bainapatra but on 04.11.2002 he raised objection against construction work of the plaintiff in above land and submitted a petition to the Deputy Commissioner designating the plaintiff as an unlawfully possessor in above land.
3Defendant No.10 contested above suit by filing a written statement wherein he has denied all material claims and allegations as set out in the plaint and stated that Rafiqul Islam while owning and possessing above land died leaving one wife, two sons and one daughter who got their names mutated for above 20 decimal land on 07.10.2007 by Misc. Case No.11289 of 2007-2008 and paid rent to the Government and they appointed Abul Kalam Azad as their constituted attorney by executing and registering a deed of power of attorney on 03.09.2008. Above Abul Kalam Azad was living and working in Italy which made him unable to ensure proper management of above property and he appointed DW1 Morsheda Begum as his appointed attorney. Rafiqul Islam did not execute any
bainapatra to the plaintiff for sale of above land nor he delivered possession to the plaintiff and the claim of title by adverse possession is false and without any material basis.
4At trial plaintiff examined five witnesses and defendants examined three. Documents produced and proved by the plaintiff were marked as Exhibit Nos.1 series – 9 series and those of the defendants were marked as Exhibit “Ka” series – “Jha” series.
5On consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case and evidence on record the learned Joint District Judge dismissed above suit.
6Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with above judgment and decree of the trial Court above plaintiff as appellant moved to this Court and preferred this First Appeal.
7Ms. Rezina Mahmud, learned Advocate for the appellant submits that Rafiqul Islam was the lawful owner and possessor of above 20 decimal land who declared to sale above land and the plaintiff agreed to purchase the same for a consideration of Taka 1,50,000/- and on receipt of Taka 50,000/- above Rafiqul Islam executed a deed of bainapatra on 20.01.1990 and delivered possession. While giving evidence as PW1 the plaintiff produced above original deed of bainapatra dated 20.01.1990 which was marked as Exhibit No.9. On the basis of above deed of bainapatra
plaintiff is continuing her possession in above land by constructing a two storied dwelling house. The plaintiff has succeeded to prove her possession in above dwelling house by oral evidence of five competent witnesses as well as by production of relevant documents such as Utility bills, rent receipts and municipal tax receipts. Above long and continuous possession of the plaintiff from 20.01.1990 to 07.09.2008 has matured into valid title by adverse possession. Since above Rafiqul Islam did not refuse to execute a sale deed nor disturbed the possession the plaintiff did not make any endeavor to obtain a registered kabla deed. But on 04.11.2002 above Rafiqul Islam submitted a complaint to the Deputy Commissioner alleging that the plaintiff was unlawfully possessing above land. The defendant could not prove by legal evidence that Rafiqul Islam or his heirs were in possession in above 20 decimal land. On consideration of above facts and circumstances of the case and materials on record the learned Joint District Judge should have decreed above suit but the learned Judge utterly failed to appreciate the facts and circumstance of the case and relevant points of law and most illegally dismissed above suit which is not tenable in law.
8None appeared on behalf of any respondents at the time of hearing of this First Appeal although this First Appeal appeared in the list for hearing on several dates.
9We have considered the submissions of the learned Advocate for the appellant and carefully examined all materials on record.
10It is admitted that above 20 decimal land belonged to Rafiqul Islam who died leaving one wife Noor Jahan, one daughter Mariam Jahan Moni and two sons ASM Ahsanul Haque and ASM Maksudul Haque as heirs.
11Plaintiff has filed this suit on 07.09.2008 for declaration of title for above 20 decimal land on the basis of adverse possession. As to the entry into the possession of above 20 decimal land it has been stated at Paragraph No.6 of the plaint that on the date of execution of above bainapatra Rafiqul Islam delivered possession and from above date plaintiff is continuously possessing above land. Plaintiff has produced and proved above deed of bainapatra which was marked as Exhibit No.9. It turns out from above deed of bainapatra that specific stipulations were made for payment of remaining Taka 1,00,000/and obtaining a registered sale deed within a period of two months in default above advance money would be forfeited. There is no mention in above deed (Exhibit No.9) that possession of above 20 decimal land was delivered to the plaintiff. There is no oral evidence of any competent witnesses as to delivery of possession. In view of above evidence we are unable to find any substance in the claim of
the plaintiff that he was inducted into possession of above land by Rafiqul Islam on 20.01.1990.
12Even if it is admitted that on the date of execution of above bainapatra Rafiqul Islam inducted the plaintiff into possession of above land that possession cannot be designated as unlawful or adverse possession. When the recipient of a deed of bainapatra gets possession in the land of the bainapatra lawfully and peacefully from the executant of the bainapatra that is lawful possession. The plaintiff did not mention in the plaint or in her evidence as DW1 as to when above alleged lawful possession of the plaintiff from Rafiqul Islam became adverse against above true owner.
13It has been alleged in the plaint that above Rafiqul Islam never refused to execute a sale deed nor disturbed possession and title of the plaintiff in above land and but for the first time above Rafiqul Islam made a complaint to the Deputy Commission against the plaintiff as to possession of above land on 04.11.2002. Even if it is accepted that the plaintiff was in possession in above land since 20.01.1990 and her above possession became adverse on 04.11.2002 even then above adverse possession did not mature into valid title before filing of this suit on 07.09.2008.
14In a civil suit the plaintiff is required to prove all claims and allegations as set out in the plaint by legal evidence. A claim of title
by adverse possession is the wildest from of acquisition of title and a plaintiff of such a suit has to prove strictly his manner and date of entry into the possession of the disputed land and the date and the manner how above lawful possession became adverse against lawful owner and how above adverse against the matured into valid title by legal evidence. The plaintiff has utterly failed to prove the date and manner of her entry into the possession of above 20 decimal land and how and when above possession became adverse against Rafiqul Islam or when above adverse possession matured into valid title.
15In above view of the facts and circumstances of the case and materials on record we are unable to find any illegality or irregularity in the impugned judgment and decree passed by the learned Joint District Judge nor we find any substance in this First Appeal which is liable to be dismissed.
16In the result, the First Appeal is dismissed.
17However, there shall be no order as to cost.
18Send down the lower Court’s record immediately. Tamanna Rahman Khalidi, J:
19I agree.
20MD. MASUDUR RAHMAN BENCH OFFICER
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











