Supreme Court Judgments, Summarised

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Nov 3, 2026

Summary

Famous Enterprise, a dealer in electrical goods, insured stock in its Sitakunda shop-cum-godown with Mercantile Insurance Company Limited, as security for credit from One Bank Limited. A fire in November 2015 destroyed the stock, and the insurer's own surveyors assessed the net loss at Tk.5,09,42,011. The insurer repudiated the claim on the ground that its cover note described the building as first-class construction whereas it was second-class. The IDRA Dispute Resolution Committee ordered payment with interest, and the insurer appealed under section 73(5) of the Insurance Act, 2010. The High Court Division found that earlier policies and two cover notes issued by the insurer itself described the building as second-class, and the insurer gave no explanation for a conflicting cover note. The inconsistencies came from the insurer's own records and could not prejudice the insured. No evidence showed knowing misrepresentation, and the discrepancy had no nexus with the fire or the loss. The Committee's findings were based on evidence, so the appeal was dismissed and payment ordered within 60 days.

Issues

  1. Q1

    Whether the insurer was justified in repudiating a fire insurance claim because the insured building was found to be second-class construction while the policy it relied on described it as first-class.

  2. Q2

    Whether the insurer proved any material misrepresentation or concealment by the insured.

  3. Q3

    Whether the Dispute Resolution Committee's findings warranted appellate interference.

Key points

  • The burden of proving concealment, misrepresentation or breach of utmost good faith lies on the insurer seeking to avoid liability, and the mere existence of a discrepancy is insufficient.
  • The insurer must establish that the insured knowingly made a false statement about a material fact which induced the insurer to undertake the risk.
  • Ambiguity arising from contradictory documentation originating in the insurer's own records and processes cannot operate to the prejudice of the insured.
  • Repudiation of the entire claim on the basis of an unexplained discrepancy with no nexus to the fire or the extent of loss cannot be sustained in law.
  • An appellate court does not interfere with findings of fact merely because another view is possible, but only where they are perverse, arbitrary, based on no evidence or manifestly illegal.

It is a settled principle of insurance law that the burden of proving concealment, misrepresentation or breach of utmost good faith lies upon the insurer who seeks to avoid liability under the policy. Mere existence of a discrepancy is insufficient.

From the judgment, Justice Md. Toufiq Inam
Law considered

Insurance Act, 2010, section 73(5)Insurance Development and Regulatory Authority (Dispute Resolution Committee) Regulations, 2012

The judgment

In the court’s own words.

Insurance Appeal 1/2023, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 13 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.

PDF
Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp