High Court Division · Special Original Jurisdiction
Jhulan Kumar Das v Chattogram City Corporation and others
Writ Petition 1211/2025 · Decided 15 February 2026
The petitioner, an Executive Engineer of Chattogram City Corporation, was removed from service by the Mayor's order of 15.12.2024 under rule 64(2) of the City Corporation's Employee Service Rules, 2019, which allows removal on 90 days' notice or on payment of 90 days' salary in cash. An inquiry committee had looked into allegations that street lights were kept off during 3 to 5 August 2024 and found him negligent. He appealed to the Secretary, Local Government Division, and one month later filed this writ petition, arguing that the disciplinary procedure for a major penalty had not been followed. The High Court Division held that one month was not an unreasonable time for deciding the appeal, distinguished the case relied on by the petitioner, and found he was seeking the same remedy in two forums at once. Declining to express any view on the merits to avoid affecting the pending appeal, it discharged the Rule (the court's order to show cause) on maintainability only, without costs.
Rule discharged as not maintainable
- Rule absolute and Rule dischargedThe two final results of a Rule in the High Court Division: made absolute means the petitioner wins; discharged means the petition fails and the order below stands.Read the full explanation →
- MaintainabilityWhether a case can lawfully be heard at all, before its merits: the right court, the right person, filed in time and not barred by any law.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether a writ petition challenging a removal order is maintainable while the petitioner's departmental appeal against the same order is pending.
- Q2
Whether a pending appeal for one month amounts to unreasonable delay allowing the High Court Division to intervene under article 102.
- The Court held that rule 64(2) of the Chottogram City Corporation Employee Service Rules, 2019 empowers the authority to remove an employee on 90 days' notice or after paying 90 days' salary in cash.
- The Court found that the petitioner was removed with 90 days' salary in cash in accordance with rule 64(2).
- The Court held that the writ petition, filed only one month after the departmental appeal, did not show that the appeal had been left undecided beyond a reasonable time, and distinguished the decision in 14 BLT (AD) 25, where no appeal had been filed.
- The Court held that, as the petitioner was seeking a remedy in two forums at the same time for the same grievance, the writ petition was not maintainable while the appeal was pending.
- The Court declined to give any opinion on the allegations or on any procedural impropriety of the removal order, as that would bear directly on the pending appeal, and discharged the Rule without costs.
The petitioner was seeking remedy simultaneously in two different forums for the same grievances, so, the instant Rule is not maintainable.
In the court’s own words.
Writ Petition 1211/2025, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 11 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(SPECIAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION)
WRIT PETITION NO. 1211 OF 2025.
IN THE MATTER OF:
An application under Article 102 of the Constitution of
the People’s Republic of Bangladesh.
-AND-
IN THE MATTER OF:
Jhulan Kumar Das
………….Petitioner
-Versus-
Chattogram City Corporation, represented by the Mayor
and others
… Respondents
Mr. Pankaj Kumar Kundu, Senior Advocate with
Ms. Mukti Rani Kundu, Advocate
……….For the petitioner
Mr. M.A Hannan, Senior Advocate
… For the Respondent Nos.1 and 2
Mr. Akhtar Hossain Md. Abdul Wahab, DAG with
Mr. Sultan Mahmood Banna, DAG with
Ms. Khandaker Asma Hamid, AAG with
Mr. S.M. Emamul Musfiqur, AAG with
Mr. Md. Mashiur Rahman(Riad) AAG
Mr. Md. Mehebub Hossain, AAG with
……….For the Respondents
Heard on 14.01.2025 and 28.01.2026.
Judgment on 15.02.2026.
Present:
Justice Fatema Najib
-And-
Justice A.F.M. Saiful Karim
A.F.M. Saiful Karim, J.
1On an application of the petitioner under Article 102 of the Constitution of People’s Republic of Bangladesh a Rule Nisi was issued on the following terms:
2“Let the Rule Nisi be issued calling upon the
3respondents to show cause as to why the purported
4Memo No. 46.11.1600.001.31.076.10-1532 dated
515.12.2024 (Annexure-G) issued by the Mayor,
6Chotttogram City Corporation (respondent no.1)
7removing the petitioner from the post of Executive
8Engineer (Electrical) should not be declared to have
9been made without lawful authority and is of no legal
10effect and\or such other or further order or orders
11passed as to this Court may seem fit and proper.”
12The relevant facts for disposal of the Rule as stated in the writ petition are as follows:
131. The petitioner is the Executive Engineer, Chottogram City
14Corporation. The petitioner got first appointment as a Sub-
15Assistant Engineer by order dated 29.03.1989.
162. The petitioner was given current charge of Assistant Engineer on
1718.09.2001. Thereafter he was given current charge of Executive
18Engineer and lastly of Superintendent Engineer.
193. While he was performing function of Superintendent Engineer
20on current charge with original post of Assistant Engineer, he
21was promoted to the post of Executive Engineer by order dated
2209.01.2020 and he also was given additional charge of
23Superintendent Engineer. The Local Government Division,
24Ministry of LGRD appointed the petitioner as project Director
25under the name “Modernization of City Street Light System’’ at
26Different Areas under Chottogram City Corporation on
2726.08.2020.
284. While in service he completed B.Sc Engineering from IEB and
29MBA Degree for which he had a legitimate expectation to be
30regularized in the post of Superintendent Engineer with
31appropriate scale of pay. Then he made representations to the
32Mayor of Chottogram City Corporation on 20.12.2021 and
3310.01.2021 for regularization. But his representations were not
34considered. Thereafter, he filed Writ Petition no. 3635 of 2022
35and obtained Rule Nisi which is still pending.
365. While performing function as Superintendent Engineer
37(Additional charge) the petitioner was suspended from the
38service by office order dated 14.08.2024 against which he filed
39appeal to the Administrator of Chottogram City Corporation but
40no step was taken by appellate authority. Rather on 26.09.2024
41he was transferred to Rangpur City Corporation as Executive
42Engineer. Then he was re-transferred to Chottogram City
43Corporation on 08.12.2024.
446. Then the respondent no.1 removed him from the post of
45Executive Engineer vide memo dated 15.12.2024. He preferred
46an appeal to Respondent No. 3 i.e the Secretary, Local
47Government Division against the order of removal which has not
48yet been disposed of.
49With these averments the petitioner filed the instant Writ Petition and obtained Rule Nisi.
50The respondent No.1 contested the Rule by filing an affidavit-inopposition contending inter alia that the respondent removed the petitioner as per the provision of rule 64(2) of the Q–NË¡j ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlne LjÑQ¡l£ Q¡L¢l ¢h¢dj¡m¡, 2019; In the said rule it is clearly mentioned that the authority, either giving 90 days show case notice or after giving salary in cash of 90 days, can remove the employee; In the instant case the petitioner was removed giving 90 days salary in cash in accordance with rules, so, there is no illegality in removing the petitioner from service; The allegation was brought against the writ petitioner that during the anti-discrimination movement in July, 2024, the petitioner intentionally caused loadshedding at different points of Chottogram City between 3-5 August, 2024; The Chittagong City Corporation formed an inquiry committee to enquire into the matter; The inquiry Committee submitted a report giving opinion that there was negligence in performing his duty as he delegated the control of the road light server to a contractor company whose term had been expired long before. The petitioner filed an appeal against the impugned removal order which is still pending. During pendency of the appeal the petitioner is seeking remedy in the instant Writ Petition i.e the petitioner is seeking remedy simultaneously in two different forums for the same grievance which is not tenable in law. With these statements the respondent prays to discharge the Rule.
51Mr. Pankaj Kumar Kundu, learned Senior Advocate for the petitioner submits that prior to removal the petitioner from the post of Executive Engineer a three member inquiry committee was formed and the said committee submitted its report wherein the allegation of keeping street lights switched off during 3-5 August, 2024 was not proved against the petitioner. He further submits that before issuing major penalty like removal
from service, the authority must follow the provisions of Rules 53 and 54 of the Chotttogram City Corporation Employee Service Rules, 2019 but in the instant case the said provisions had not been followed. He next submits that the petitioner was removed from service under Rule 64(2) of the Chottogram City Corporation Employee Service Rules, 2019 but provisions of the said rule was not complied with. He by referring the decision reported in 14 BLT (AD)-25, submits that since the appeal filed was not disposed of within reasonable time, so Article 102 of the Constitution can be invoked. He also submits that even without filing appeal Article 102 of the Constitution can be invoked. With these submissions he prays to make the Rule absolute.
52Mr. M.A.Hannan, learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent Nos. 1 and 2 have drawn our attention to Rule 64(2) of the Q– NË¡j ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlne LjÑQ¡l£ Q¡L¢l ¢h¢dj¡m¡, 2019 i.e “HC ¢h¢dj¡m¡u ¢iæl¦f k¡q¡ ¢LR¤C b¡L¥L e¡ ®Le, Efk¤š² La«Ñfr ®L¡e L¡lZ cn¡ÑCu¡ ®L¡e LjÑQ¡l£L 90(eîC) ¢cel e¡¢Vn fÐc¡e L¢lu¡ Abh¡ 90(eîC) ¢cel ®hae eNc f¢ln¡d L¢lu¡ a¡q¡L Q¡L¢l qCa Afp¡le L¢la f¡¢lhz” and submits that the petitioner was removed as per second part of that provision which is reflected in the impugned order. He further submits that in the inquiry report the allegation brought against the petitioner that during the anti discrimination movement in July, 2024 the petitioner intentionally cause loadshedding at different points of Chottogram City between 3-5 August, 2024 was proved. He next submits that the petitioner preferred appeal against the impugned order of removal from service before the respondent no. 3 and only after 1 month of filing appeal the petitioner filed the instant Writ Petition and thus the petitioner is seeking remedy simultaneously in two different forums for the same grievance which is not tenable in law. He also submits that the decision referred by learned Advocate for the Writ petitioner are not
applicable in the instant Writ Petition as the facts and circumstances of the cited cases and the instant case are totally different . With these submissions he prays to discharge the Rule.
53We have heard the learned Advocates of the respective parties. Perused the Writ Petition, Supplementary Affidavit, Affidavit-in-opposition and the annexures annexed thereto.
54Admittedly, the petitioner got first appointment of Sub-Assistant Engineer on 29.03.1989. Then he was promoted to Assistant Engineer, Executive Engineer. While he was sub- Assistant Engineer he was given in charge of Assistant Engineer, given in charge of Executive Engineer and again in charge of Superintendent Engineer. While he was performing to the post of Executive Engineer he was appointed as the Project Director under name “Modernization of City Street Light System” of different area under Chottogram City Corporation”. While in service he completed B.Sc Engineering from IEB and MBA Degree for which he had a legitimate expectation to be regularized in the post of Superintendent Engineer with appropriate scale of pay. Then he made representations to the Mayor of Chottogram City Corporation on 20.12.2021 and 10.01.2021 for regularization. But his representations were not considered. Thereafter, he filed Writ Petition no. 3635 of 2022 and obtained Rule which is still pending. While performing the functions as Superintendent Engineer (Additional charge) the petitioner was suspended from the service by office order dated 14.08.2024 against which he filed appeal to the Administrator of Chottogram City Corporation but no step was taken by appellate authority. Rather on 26.09.2024 he was transferred to Rangpur City Corporation as Executive Engineer. Then he was retransferred to Chottogram City Corporation on 08.12.2024. Then the
respondent No.1 removed him from the post of Executive Engineer vide impugned memo dated 15.12.2024. He preferred an appeal to respondent No. 3 i.e the secretary, Local Government Division against the order of removal which has not yet been disposed of.
55Now let us consider the submissions of the petitioner that-
561. Before imposing the major penalty “removal from service” the
57authority should follow the previsions of Rules 53 and 54 of the
58Chottogram City Corporation Employee Service Rules, 2019
59which was not followed at all.
602. The allegation brought against him that keeping street light
61switched off during 3-5 August, 2024 which was not proved in
62the inquiry.
633. The petitioner was removed under Rule 64(2) of the Rules, 2019
64but the impugned order does not reflect the provisions of law.
65Perused Rule 50 (M) of Q–NË¡j ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlne LjÑQ¡l£ Q¡L¢l ¢h¢dj¡m¡,2019. The said provision clearly states which penalty are major. Those are:
66(L) ¸iæ `Û:
67(A) ¢ejÀfc h¡ ¢ejÀ ®hae ®úm Ahe¢ja LlZ ;
68(B) LjÑQ¡l£ La«ÑL pwO¢Va Lf¡Ñlnel B¢bÑL r¢al Awn ¢hno h¡ pÇf§ZÑ
69a¡q¡l ®hae h¡ AeÉ ®L¡e¡ M¡al f¡Je¡ qCa Bc¡uLlZ ;
70(C) hdÉa¡j§mL Ahpl ;
71(D) Q¡L¢l qCa Afp¡lZ Hhw
72(E) Q¡L¢l qCa hlM¡Ù¹z
73Rules 53 and 54 state as to how the inquiry would be initiated and what will be the procedures to be followed in case of major penalty.
74We have perused Annexure-2 to affidavit-in-opposition. It appears that on written allegation of the students against the petitioner an inquiry committee was formed consisting of three members. The petitioner was given an opportunity of being heard and the petitioner was allowed to submit his statement. The inquiry committee opined in their report as follows:
75“(1) pLm p¡r£l hš²hÉ, °c¢eL f¢œL¡u fÐL¡¢na fТahce, ac¿¹ L¢j¢V La«ÑL m¡C¢Vw
76p¡i¡Ñl f¢lcnÑe, fl£r¡-¢el£r¡ J ¢hno‘, ja¡ja NËqZ, ¢f¢X¢hl pw¢nÔÖV ®S¡el ja¡ja
77NËqZ, hqŸ¡lq¡V J j¤l¡cf¤l Hm¡L¡ f¢lcnÑe, ¢h¢iæ ®nÐZ£ J ®fn¡l ÙÛ¡e£u hÉ¢š²hNÑl hš²hÉ
78nÐhepq OVe¡l f¡¢lf¡¢nÄÑL AhÙÛ¡ fk¡Ñm¡Qe¡u ac¿¹ L¢j¢Vl ¢eLV fÐa£uj¡e qu ®k, 3-5
79BNØV 2024 ¢MË: a¡¢lM hqŸ¡lq¡V J j¤l¡cf¤l Hm¡L¡u ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlnel plL h¡¢a ®ei¡e¡
80¢Rmz
81(2) psL h¡¢a ®ei¡e¡l ¢hou Q–NÊ¡j ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlnel ¢hc¤Év ¢hi¡Nl ašÆ¡hd¡uL
82fÐL±nm£ (A¢a¢lš² c¡¢uaÅ) T¥me L¥j¡l c¡n Hl ¢hl¦Ü Be£a A¢ik¡N p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z à¡l¡
83fÐj¡¢Za qu¢ez ah ¢hc¤Év ¢h¢iNl fÐd¡e ¢qph Eš² 3 ¢ce I Hm¡L¡u ¯hc¤É¢aL h¡¢a
84®ei¡e¡l ¢hou ®L¡e lLj hÉhÙÛ¡ NËqZ e¡ Ll Hhw ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlnel EdÄÑae La«ÑfrL
85¢hou¢V AhNa e¡ Ll ¢a¢e c¡¢uaÅq£ea¡ J Ahqm¡l f¢lQu ¢cuRez c¡¢uaÅ f¡me Hl¦f
86Ahqm¡/ N¡¢gm¢al SeÉ a¡l ¢hl¦Ü ¢h¢d ®j¡a¡hL hÉhÙÛ¡ NËqZ Ll¡l SeÉ ac¿¹ L¢j¢V
87p¤f¡¢ln LlRz
88(3) S¡CL¡l AbÑ¡ue f¢lQ¡¢ma fÐLÒfl ®ju¡c Na 15/03/2022 ¢MË: a¡¢lM Hhw
89fÊLÒf flha£Ñ HL hRll ¢Xgƒ mCim¢V ¢f¢luX Na 15/03/2023 ¢MË; a¡¢lM pj¡ç
90qmJ fÐLÒfl ¢WL¡c¡l£ fТaù¡e HCQ¢VHjHp ¢m¢jVX ®ki¡h HMe¡ ®p¾VÌ¡m p¡i¡Ñl
91f¢lQ¡me¡l p¡b k¤š² BR a¡ ac¿¹ L¢j¢Vl ¢eLV Aü¡i¡¢hL, ¢euj h¢qÑi§a J A¯e¢aL
92fÐa£uj¡e quRz Eš² ¢hou ¢hc¤Év ¢hi¡Nl ašÆhd¡uL fÐL±nm£ (A¢a¢lš² c¡¢uaÅ) T¥me
93L¥j¡l c¡n a¡l c¡u ®L¡ei¡h Hs¡a f¡l e¡z Hja¡hÙÛ¡u, 18 j¡p f§hÑ fÐLÒfl ®ju¡c ®no
94qJu¡ üšÆJ T¥me L¥j¡l c¡n LaѪL ¢h¢d h¢qiѧa fÐLÒfi¨š² ¢WL¡c¡l£ fТaù¡eL ¢cu psL
95h¡¢al p¡i¡l ¢eu¿»Z h¡ ac¡l¢Ll c¡u a¡l ¢hl¦Ü fÐn¡p¢eL/BCe¡e¤N hÉhÙÛ¡ Ll¡ ®ka
96f¡lz”
97In the Inquiry report the committee found the Writ Petitioner’s negligence in performing his duty and the petitioner illegally delegated the control of the road light server to a contactor company whose term had been expired long 18 months before and recommended that administrative or legal action can be taken against him.
98To appreciate further the submissions advanced by the learned Advocates of both sides, we need to quote the Rule 64(2) of the Q–NË¡j ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlne LjÑQ¡l£ Q¡L¢l ¢h¢dj¡m¡, 2019z
99Rule 64 of the ¢h¢dj¡m¡, 2019 is quoted below:
100“ 64 Q¡L¢l Ahp¡l, Q¡L¢l qCa Afp¡lZ, CaÉ¡¢cz
101(1) …………………………………………………………………………
102(2) HC ¢h¢dj¡m¡u ¢iæl¦f k¡q¡ ¢LR¤C b¡L¥L e¡ ®Le, Efk¤š² La«Ñfr ®L¡e L¡lZ
103cn¡ÑCu¡ ®L¡e LjÑQ¡l£L 90(eîC) ¢cel e¡¢Vn fÐc¡e L¢lu¡ Abh¡ 90(eîC) ¢cel ®hae
104eNc f¢ln¡d L¢lu¡ a¡q¡L Q¡L¢l qCa Afp¡le L¢la f¡¢lhz”
105On plain reading the above sub rule-2 of Rule 64 it is crystal clear that the appropriate authority is given power to remove any employee giving 90 days show cause notice or after paying the salary of 90 days in cash.
106Let us consider the impugned order (Annexure-G to the Writ Petition) which is quoted below:
107“Q–NË¡j ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlne
108p¢Qh¡mu ¢hi¡N
109pwÙÛ¡fe n¡M¡ pÈ¡lL ew. 46.11.1600.001.31.076.10.1532 a¡¢lM 15.12.2024
110A¢gp Bcn
111Se¡h T¥me L¥j¡l c¡n, ¢eh¡Ñq£ fÐL±nm£ (p¡j¢uL hlM¡Ù¹), ¢hc¤Év Ef-¢hi¡N, Q–NË¡j ¢p¢V LfÑ¡lneL Q–NË¡j ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlne LjÑQ¡l£ Q¡L¢l ¢h¢dj¡m¡, 2019, Hl 64(2) d¡l¡l fÐcš rja¡hm Seü¡bÑ Q–NË¡j ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlnel Q¡L¢l qa Afp¡lZ Ll¡ qmz ¢a¢e ¢h¢d ®j¡a¡hL 90(eîC) ¢cel ®hae eNc fСfÉ qhez
1122. H Bcn AcÉ qa L¡kÑLl qhz
113(X¡: n¡q¡c¡a ®q¡pe)
114jul
115Q–NË¡j ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlnez”
116It reveals that the petitioner was removed with 90 days salary in cash in accordance with the provision of rule 64(2) of Q–NË¡j ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlne LjÑQ¡l£ Q¡L¢l ¢h¢dj¡m¡, 2019.
117It is pertinent to note that since appeal was filed against the impugned order and during pendency of the appeal this Writ Petition was filed after 01(one) month of filing appeal and only one month time can not be said to be reasonable for disposal of the appeal. In the decision, referred by the learned Advocate for the petitioner, reported in 14 BLT (AD)-25 it appears that the impugned dismissal order was declared to have been passed without lawful authority. In the said case without filing appeal writ petition was filed. Record shows that instant the petitioner filed appeal against the impugned order which is still pending for disposal before the respondent No. 3. During the pendency of appeal he filed the instant Writ Petition. Thus the facts and circumstances of the cited case is totally different from the instant one. So, the said decision is not applicable in the present case. The petitioner was seeking remedy simultaneously in two different forums for the same grievances, so, the instant Rule is not maintainable.
118At this stage this court consider it reasonable not to give any opinion as to the veracity of the allegations brought against the petitioner of
keeping street light switched off during Anti-discrimination movement on 3-5 August, 2024 and as to whether there is any procedural/legal impropriety of the impugned order which will have direct bearing upon the pending appeal to be disposed of by the respondent No.3.
119Having regard to facts and relevant law we are of the opinion that as the removal order passed as per the provision of Rule 64(2) of the Q–NË¡j ¢p¢V Lf¡Ñlne LjÑQ¡l£ Q¡L¢l ¢h¢dj¡m¡, 2019 is under challenge in appeal, during pendency of the said appeal the instant writ petition is not maintainable.
120In the result, the Rule is discharged on the ground of maintainability only without any order of cost.
121Let a copy of this judgment immediately be transmitted to the respondents at once.
122A.F.M. Saiful Karim, J: Fatema Najib, J:
123I agree.
124Fatema Najib, J: AZOM(BO)
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











