High Court Division · Special Original Jurisdiction
Mohammad Ullah Mintu and another v Commissioner of Customs, Customs House, Chattogram and others
Writ Petition 4006/2019 · Decided 6 November 2019
An importer of seamless pipes from China challenged under Article 102 of the Constitution the failure of the customs authority at Chattogram to make a final assessment of his goods within 120 working days of provisional assessment, and sought return of a bank guarantee of Tk. 23,01,716.77. The customs authority had rejected his declared H.S. Code, proposed another and suggested testing at BUET, releasing the goods on provisional assessment on 27.05.2018 against payment of duty at the declared code and a bank guarantee for the difference. No affidavit in opposition was filed; the State said the importer had not paid the expense of chemical examination. The High Court Division found that 209 working days had passed by 31.03.2019 without final assessment or any extension by the Board under the proviso to section 81(2). Following Government of Bangladesh v Md. Salim Hossain, it held that the provisional assessment was deemed final and directed return of the bank guarantee within 30 days.
Rule made absolute
- Q1
Whether the customs authority's failure to finalise a provisional assessment within 120 working days under section 81(2) of the Customs Act, 1969 was unlawful.
- Q2
Whether the importer was entitled to the return of the bank guarantee furnished as security on provisional assessment.
- Under section 81(2) of the Customs Act, 1969, duty on goods released on provisional assessment must be finally assessed within 120 working days, and only the Board may extend that period in exceptional circumstances recorded in writing.
- Where the customs authority fails to finalise the assessment within the statutory period and no extension is obtained from the Board, the provisional assessment on the declared value and H.S. Code is deemed final.
- On such deemed finality, the importer is entitled to return of the bank guarantee furnished as security on provisional assessment, and the customs authority has no scope to withhold it.
- The Commissioner of Customs was directed to return the bank guarantee within 30 days of receipt of the judgment.
the provisional assessment made by the customs authority on the basis of declared value/H.S Code shall be deemed to be treated as final. Consequent thereof the concerned importer/exporter is entitled to get return the bank guarantee(s) furnished by him as security on provisional assessment.
In the court’s own words.
Writ Petition 4006/2019, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 11 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(SPECIAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION)
WRIT PETITION NO. 4006 OF 2019
IN THE MATTER OF:
Applications under Article 102(2) of the
Constitution of the People’s Republic of
Bangladesh.
And
IN THE MATTER OF:
Mohammad Ullah Mintu and another
…. Petitioner
-Vs-
Commissioner of Customs, Customs House,
Chattogram and others.
….Respondents
Mr. Md. Saiful Islam, Advocate
… for the Petitioner
Mr. Samarendra Nath Biswas, D.A.G. with
Mr. Md. Abul Kalam Khan Daud, A.A.G. with
Mr. A.H.M. Ziauddin, A.A.G. with
Mr. Md. Modersher Ali Khan (Dipu), A.A.G with
Mrs. Rehana Sultana, A.A.G.
…….. For the Respondents-government.
Heard on: 23.10.2019 & 30.10.2019
And
Judgment on: 06.11.2019.
Present:
Mrs. Justice Farah Mahbub.
and
Mr. Justice S.M. Maniruzzaman
S.M. Maniruzzaman, J:
1In this Rule Nisi, issued under Article 102 of the Constitution of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, the respondents have been called upon to show cause as to why failure of the respondents to make final assessment of the petitioner’s imported goods covered under Letter of Credit No.
2296817010760 dated 11.12.2017 under Bill of Entry No. C-427603 dated 18.03.2018 within the stipulated period of 120 (one hundred and twenty) working days from the date of provisional assessment under the provision of section 81(2) of the Customs Act, 1969 should not be declared to have been done without lawful authority and hence, of no legal effect and also as to why a direction shall not be given upon the respondents to release/return the bank guarantee being No. SJIBL/Bangshal/Inv/2018/BG-04/2018 dated 23.05.2018 for Tk. 23,01,716.77 (Taka twenty three lac one thousand seven hundred sixteen and paisa seventy seven) lying with the respondent No. 4 and/or pass such other or further order or orders as to this Court may seem fit and proper.
3However, at the time of issuance of the Rule, the contending parties were directed to maintain status-quo in respect of encashment of the bank guarantee for a prescribed period.
4Facts, relevant for disposal of the Rule, in short, are that the petitioner is the proprietor of “M/S. Nippon Boiler House” and is engaged in the business of import various commodity from abroad and after importation sells the same in the local market.
5In course of his business, he opened Letter of Credit No. 296817010760 dated 11.12.2017 for importing “Seamless Pipe ASTM” from China under H.S. Code No. 7304.31.00. After arrival of the goods at Chattogram port, the petitioner however, collected shipping documents from his bank and accordingly, submitted the same to the customs authority through his C&F Agent for assessment and releasing the goods upon submitting the shipping documents, the customs authority generated Bill of Entry being No. C-427603 dated 18.03.2018 for assessment and releasing of the goods. Thereafter, the concerned respondent customs authority physically examined the goods and did not accept the H.S. Code of the goods as declared
by the petitioner. Rather, determined the goods to fall under H.S. Code No. 7304.90.00. The customs authority also suggested that the goods required to be (sample) examined in the BUET for determining the correct applicable H.S. Code. In this regard, the authority concerned suggested to allow the petitioner to release the goods by provisional assessment on furnishing bank guarantee for the differential amount of duty and taxes between the declared H.S. Code No. 7304.31.00 and the proposed H.S. Code No. 7304.90.00.
6The petitioner duly accepted the said proposal of the respondent customs authority and made payment of all customs duties and taxes as his declared H.S. Code in cash and furnished bank guarantee being No. SJIBL/Bangshal/Inv/2018/BG-04/2018 dated 23.05.2018 for Tk. 23,01,716.77 (Taka twenty three lac one thousand seven hundred sixteen and paisa seventy seven) for the differential amount of duty and taxes. Pursuant thereto the customs authority released the goods on provisional assessment dated 27.05.2018.
7However, the categorical assertion of the petitioner is that after releasing the respective goods by provisional assessment, the concerned respondent customs authority did not complete final assessment as required under section 81(2) of the Act, 1969. In that view of the matter, the petitioner has filed the instant writ petition challenging the inaction of the respondents failure to make final assessment of his imported goods within due time as required under the law and also seeking direction to return the bank guarantees furnished by him before the respondent customs authority as security on provisionally assessment and accordingly, obtained the present Rules along with order of statusque.
8Mr. Md. Saiful Islam¸ the learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioner of all the writ petitions submits that the respondent customs
authority miserably failed to make final assessment of the imported goods of the petitioner as per the specific provision of law, in as much as, section 81 of the Act, 1969 clearly stipulates to make final assessment of goods within 120 (one hundred and twenty) working days from the date of provisional assessment and the concerned respondents failed to make final assessment of the imported goods of the petitioner within the said stipulated period; and thus, acted illegally. He further submits that the respondent customs authorities have not made any final assessment within the stipulated 120 working days period of law and further most illegally asked the petitioner through his C&F Agent to deposit money for chemical examination of the imported goods from BUET after long days of the provisional assessment of the goods; these sort of actions by the respondents are utterly illegal, malafidy, arbitrary and without any sanction of law. He lastly goes to argue that the date of provisional assessment of the goods in question on 27.05.2018 and the concerned respondents failed to make provisional assessment of the petitioner’s imported goods final within of the said statutory period 120 (one twenty) working days under section 81(2) of the Act, 1969, which is a mandatory provision of law but grossly violated by the remiss actions of the respondents and for these bank guarantees furnished by the petitioner in good faith are now at risk of sudden arbitrally encashment by the respondents.
9Accordingly, he submits that a direction is required to be given upon the respondent No. 1 to return/release the bank guarantee being No. SJIBL/Bangshal/Inv/2018/BG-04/2018 dated 23.05.2018 issued by Shahjalal Islami Bank Ltd, Bangshal Branch, Dhaka lying with them in favour of the petitioner. In support of his aforesaid submissions, the learned Advocate for the petitioner has referred to the decisions of the case of Government of Bangladesh and others -vs- Md. Salim Hossain reported in 11 BLT (AD)
10page 71 and Nasir Glass Industries Limited -vs- National Board of Revenue and others reported in 17 BLT (HCD)243.
11Per contra, Mr. Abdul Kalam Khan Daud, the learned Assistant Attorney General entered appearance on behalf of the respondent No. 1, Commissioner of Customs by filing Vokalatnama. No affidavit in opposition has been filed by the concerned respondent controverting the assertions so made in the writ petition. So, the statements made in the writ petition have been uncontroverted. However, learned Assistant Attorney General submits that the goods has been released by the customs authority on provisional assessment as the instance of petitioner but, the petitioner however, did not deposit expenses for chemical examination of the goods as required under section 200, 1969 of the Act till date and for this reason, the respondent customs authority could not complete chemical examination of the goods in question. Hence, the petitioner cannot claim any benefit for his own fault.
12In the said context the learned Assistant Attorney General prays that the Rule may be disposed of with direction upon the respondent concern to complete final assessment of the goods in question as early as possible.
13Heard the learned Advocate for the petitioner the learned Assistant Attorney General appearing for the respondent No. 1, have perused the writ petition, materials on record so appended thereto and relevant provision of law.
14The cardinal issue requires to be determined in this writ petition is that whether the customs authorities have completed final assessment of the petitioner’s imported goods in question within the stipulated period of 120 working days as prescribed under section 81 of the Act, 1969 and the petitioner is entitled to get return the bank guarantee furnished by him at the time of releasing of the goods on provisional assessment.
15In order to appreciate the respective arguments of both the parties, it is pertinent to look into the relevant provision of law i.e. section 81 of the Act, 1969 for proper disposal of the instant Rules. Section 81 reads as follows;
81. Provisional assessment of duty.- (1) Where it is
not possible immediately to assess the customs duty
that may be payable on any imported goods entered
for home-consumption of for warehousing or for
clearance from a warehouse for home-consumption
or on any goods entered for exportation, for the
reason that the goods require chemical or other test
[or a further enquiry] for purposes of assessment,
or that all the documents or complete documents or
full information pertaining to those goods have not
been furnished, an officer not below that rank of
[Assistant Commissioner of Customs] may order
that the duty payable on such goods be assessed
provisionally:
Provided that the importer (same in the case
of goods entered for warehousing) or the exporter
pays such additional amount as security or
furnishes such guarantee of a scheduled bank for
the payment thereof as the said officer deems
sufficient to meet the excess of the final assessment
of duty over the provisional assessment.
[(2) Where any goods are allowed to be
cleared or delivered on the basis of such provisional
assessment, the amount of duty actually payable on
those goods shall, within a period of one hundred
and twenty working days from the date of the
provisional assessment, where there is a case
pending at any court, tribunal or appellate
authority, from the date of receipt of the final
disposal order of that case, be finally assessed and
on completion of such assessment the appropriate
officer shall order that the amount already
guaranteed be adjusted against the amount payable
on the basis of final assessment, and the difference
between them shall be paid forthwith to or by the
importer or exporter as the case may be:
Provided that the Board may, under
exceptional circumstances recorded in writing,
extend the period of final assessment specified
under this sub-section.
16Section 81 provides that when the customs authority is of the opinion that it is not possible to assess the duty and taxes immediately that may be payble on any imported goods or any goods entered for exportation for the reason that the goods require chemical or other test for purpose of assessment or that all the documents or complete documents or full information pertaining to those goods have not been furnished, an officer not below the rank of Assistant Commissioner of Customs may order that the duty payable on such goods be assessed provisionally. The importer or exporter pays such additional amount as security or furnishes such guarantee of a schedule bank for the payment thereof as the officer seems sufficient to meet the excess of the final assessment of duty over the provisional assessment. When any goods are released on the basis of such provisionally assessment, the amount of duty actually payable on those goods shall, within a period of 120 (one hundred twenty) working days be finally assessed but where any case pending before the any Court, or authority the date for final assessment be counted from the date of receipt of the final disposal order of the case. As per proviso of this section only the Board may under exceptional circumstances recorded in writing extend the period of final assessment specified under this section.
17In the instance case admittedly the petitioner released his imported goods on provisional assessment dated 27.05.2018 by furnishing bank guarantee for the differential amount of duties and taxes as security.
18However, the concerned customs authorities failed to complete provisional assessment as final within the prescribed period of 120 working days and also failed to extend the said period for final assessment from the Board as per proviso of section 81(2) of the Act, 1969; although, they could have assessed the goods finally under the said provision of law, but they did not take any step to that effect as yet. It appears from the record that 209 working days was passed away from the date of provisional assessment till the date on 31.03.2019.
19In this regard in the case of Government of Bangladesh and others vs- Md. Salim Hossain(Supra), it has been held that;
“The customs authority as per provision of
section 81 of the Act was required to make
the provisional assessment final within the
reasonable time. In respect of the
consignments of the respondent the customs
authority made provisional assessment in
between July, 1991 and February, 1992, but
till August 1997 the customs authority did
not make the assessment final although the
authority had the materials before it for
making the final assessment of duties and
other levies on the imported goods of the
respondent taking the value at US$ 400 per
Metric ton. The customs authority inspire of
having the materials for making the
provisional assessment final did not make
final assessment till August, 1997 taking the
value of the imported goods at US$ 400 per
Metric ton. The customs authority inspire of
having the materials for making the
provisional assessment final did not make
final assessment till August, 1997 taking the
value of the imported goods at US$ 400 per
metric ton, and thus the respondent was
compelled to file the writ petitions seeking
direction for the refund of the excess amount
of duties realized from him at the time of
provisional assessment without legal basis.
In our view in the background of the facts of
the case the High Court Division has
committed no error in making direction for
refund of the excess amount of duties
realized against the goods imported by the
respondent”
20Similar view has been adopted by this High Court Division in the case of Nasir Glass Industries Limited -vs- National Board of Revenue and others (Supra) that;
“Section 81(2) of the Customs Act
categorically says that the final assessment
is to be made within 150 working days from
the date of release of the goods on the basis
of provisional assessment and since more than
180 days have passed after provisional
assessment made on 17.05.2005, the Customs
authority under no circumstances can ask for
encashment of the bank guarantee. Thus, since
the respondents failed to obtain an expert
opinion and since the respondents failed to
assess the goods finally within 150 working days
from the date of provisional assessment the
order for encashment of the bank guarantee by
the impugned letter is illegal and without lawful
authority.”
21In view of the statutory provision of law and the ratio settled by our Apex Court, we are of the view that on the failure of the customs authority to complete provisional assessment as final within the statutory period of 120 working days as prescribed under section 81(2) of the Act, 1969 or failure to extend the said period for final assessment from the Board, the provisional assessment made by the customs authority on the basis of declared value/H.S Code shall be deemed to be treated as final. Consequent thereof the concerned importer/exporter is entitled to get return the bank guarantee(s) furnished by him as security on provisional assessment.
22In the instant case admittedly, the respondents customs authorities failed to assess the goods in question finally within the said statuary period; moreso, it also failed to show from record that said period has subsequently be extended by the Board in exercise of power as provided under the proviso to subsection (2) of section 81 of the Act. In view of the above stated position of fact the customs authority has no scope to withheld the bank guarantee furnished by the petitioner for the differential amount of duties and taxes against the provisional assessment
of the imported goods in question as security for the purpose of final assessment.
23In view of the above facts and circumstances of the cases, findings and observations we find substance in the submissions made by the learned Advocate for the petitioner and merit of the Rule.
24Accordingly, the Rule is made absolute.
25The respondent No. 1, the Commissioner of Customs, Customs House, Chattogram is directed to return the bank guarantee No. SJIBL/Bangshal/Inv/2018/BG-04/2018 dated 23.05.2018, issued by the Shahjalal Islami Bank Ltd, Bangshal Branch, Dhaka in favour of the petitioner within 30 days from the date of receipt of the copy of this judgment and order positively.
26There will be no order as to costs.
27The order of status quo granted earlier by this Court is hereby recalled and vacated.
28Communicate the copy of this judgment and order to the concerned respondents forthwith. Farah Mahbub, J:
I agree.
29M.A. Hossain-B.O.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











