High Court Division · Special Original Jurisdiction
Md. Jahed Hossain v Government of the People's Republic of Bangladesh and others
Writ Petition 7631/2021 · Decided 13 November 2025
The petitioners were engaged by Bangladesh Railway between 2016 and 2019 as temporary labourers on a no work no pay basis, working as gate keepers, porters and waymen in the West Zone. A 2017 memo resolved to regularise such labourers after three years' service, and internal directions followed, ending in a committee recommendation of 29.01.2020 naming the petitioners for absorption into the revenue budget. No final action was taken, and their wages stopped from January 2020. The Government opposed the Rule without filing any affidavit. The High Court Division relied on Government circulars of 1969 and 1972 on making long-standing temporary posts permanent, a 2003 Cabinet Division circular, and earlier writ judgments under which similarly placed workers were absorbed. Following Bangladesh Biman Corporation v Rabeya Bashir Irene, it held that the petitioners, with more than three years' unblemished service, had a legitimate expectation of absorption. The Rule was made absolute and the respondents directed to absorb them expeditiously unless otherwise disqualified.
Rule made absolute; railway temporary labourers to be absorbed
- Q1
Whether Bangladesh Railway's failure to absorb temporary labourers into the revenue budget, despite Government policy circulars, internal directions and a committee recommendation naming them, was unlawful.
- Q2
Whether temporary labourers with more than three years' continuous service had a legitimate expectation of being absorbed against permanent posts, as similarly placed workers had been under earlier writ judgments.
- The Court relied on Government circulars of 28 March 1969 and 21 April 1972 providing for long-standing temporary posts to be made permanent and the employees absorbed, noting that they had not been superseded by the circular dated 24.01.1996.
- The petitioners had rendered unblemished service for more than 3 years and therefore had a legitimate expectation of being absorbed against permanent posts.
- Following Bangladesh Biman Corporation v Rabeya Bashir Irene, 55 DLR (AD) 132, an existing practice of absorbing employees of the petitioners' category gives reasonable ground to expect permanent absorption.
- As the same facts and law had been decided in favour of similarly placed petitioners in earlier writ petitions, the same result had to follow here.
- The Rule was made absolute and the respondents directed to absorb or regularise the petitioners into the revenue budget against vacant posts, as per the memo dated 29.01.2020, as expeditiously as possible if they are not otherwise disqualified.
The petitioners have been rendering unblemished service for more than 3 years and they have been continuing their service in their respective offices. Therefore, they have legitimate expectation that they would be absorbed against the permanent posts.
In the court’s own words.
Writ Petition 7631/2021, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 11 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(SPECIAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION)
Writ Petition No. 7631 of 2021
IN THE MATTER OF:
An application under Article 102 of the
Constitution of the People’s Republic of
Bangladesh.
-AND-
IN THE MATTER OF:
Md. Jahed Hossain and others
……Petitioners
-Versus-
Government of the People’s Republic of
Bangladesh represented by the Secretary,
Present
Ministry of Railway, Bangladesh
Mr. Justice Sashanka Shekhar Sarkar
Secretariat, Ramna, Dhaka and others.
And
Mr. Justice Faysal Hasan Arif ….. Respondents
Mr. Md. Khurrum Jha Murad, Advocate
… For the petitioner.
Mr. Mohammad Waliul Islam, D.A.G.
….For the respondents
Judgment on: The 13th November, 2025
Sashanka Shekhar Sarkar, J:
1This rule nisi at the instant of the petitioner was issued on an
2application under Article 102 of the Constitution in the following
3terms;
4Let a Rule Nisi be issued calling upon respondents to show
5cause as to why inaction of the respondents in implementing the
6Memo bearing No. 54.01.0000.006.11.025.12 dated 03.12.2017
7issued from the office of respondent No. 2 in respect of
8regularization/absorption of Temporary Labors (TRL) into
9vacant posts of Railway as evident from (Annexure-F) to the
10writ petition and failure of the respondents No. 3, 4, 5 8 10 and
1111 in recommending the names of the Temporary Labors (TRL)
12to be regularized/absorbed into revenue budget against vacant
13posts of Bangladesh Railway as per the Memo bearing No.
14¢h¢f/f¡Ln£/BaÈ£uLle/AxSehm/2020 dated 29.01.2020(Annexure-K)
15issued from the office of respondent No. 7 and/or pass such
16other or further order or orders as to this court may seem fit
17and proper.
18During the pendency of the Rule, co-petitioner Nos. 12 to 55 were added as parties to the Rule by an order dated 03.01.2022.
19The facts leading to issuance of the Rule Nisi, in brief, are that the petitioners are temporary employees of Bangladesh Railway. They were engaged as TLR for the posts of Gate Keeper, Porter, and Wayman under the Traffic Level Crossing Division (Traffic) of the West Zone (Pakshi) of Bangladesh Railway on different dates between 2016 to 2019 on the basis of Master Roll by the respondents. Since their appointment, the petitioners have been continuously and uninterruptedly discharging their duties with honesty, integrity, sincerity, and competence and were duly paid wages as Temporary Labour/TLR by the respondents. However, most unfortunately, from January, 2020, the respondents stopped paying the salaries of the petitioners and in respect of some of them, the respondents even
resorted to forcibly restraining them from signing the attendance register, notwithstanding their readiness and willingness to perform their assigned duties. Although the Cabinet Division, vide its Memo dated 03.05.2003, adopted a policy decision to regularize/absorb temporary employees after completion of a prescribed period of service, in furtherance of the said policy, respondent No. 2 issued Memo No. jf¢h/Lx¢hxn¡x/Lfd-11/2001-111 dated 03.12.2017, resolving to regularize the service of TLR/Temporary Labourers of Bangladesh Railway upon completion of three years of service and directing the concerned authorities to take necessary steps in that regard. Pursuant thereto, the Office of the Chief Personnel Officer (West Zone), Bangladesh Railway, Rajshahi (respondent No. 4), on behalf of the General Manager (West Zone) (respondent No. 3), issued a letter vide Memo dated 25.10.2018 (Annexure-G) directing all Divisional Heads, including the Divisional Railway Manager, Pakshi and the Divisional Railway Manager, Lalmonirhat to take steps for absorption of the petitioners and other similarly situated employees into the revenue budget. Thereafter, the Office of the Chief Engineer (West Zone), Bangladesh Railway, Rajshahi, vide Memo dated 12.11.2018, instructed the Divisional Engineers (1 & 2), Pakshi, the Divisional Engineer, Lalmonirhat, and other concerned offices to furnish the necessary documents relating to TLR/Temporary Labourers for the purpose of absorption/regularization. Subsequently, respondent No. 4 issued a Memo dated 05.11.2019 outlining the absorption process and
constituted a three-member committee to submit a report in respect thereof. In continuation thereof, respondent No. 5 issued an office order vide Memo dated 06.01.2020, upon recommendation of the Director General, Bangladesh Railway, directing the authorities concerned to take all necessary steps to absorb the petitioners and other similarly situated employees. Thereafter, respondent No. 7, the Divisional Railway Manager (DRM), West Zone, issued a further office order directing respondents Nos. 3, 4, 5, 8, and 10 to proceed accordingly. A committee was formed and, upon completion of its proceedings, forwarded its recommendation vide Memo No.
20/ / / / dated 29.01.2020, recommending the names of the present petitioners and directing necessary steps for their absorption into the revenue budget as regular employees. Despite such clear policy decisions, administrative directions, and specific recommendations, the respondents failed to take any final action and kept the matter pending for an unreasonable length of time. Having no other efficacious alternative, the petitioners were compelled to invoke the writ jurisdiction of this Hon’ble Court by filing the present writ petition and obtained the rule.
21Mr. Md. Khurrum Jha Murad, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioners, submits that, on earlier occasions, temporary employees of Bangladesh Railway engaged on a “no work no pay” basis filed several writ petitions, being Writ Petition Nos. 2263 and 5265 of 2011; 773, 1122, 4402, 6245, and 6958 of 2014; and 14155 of
2016, 14156 of 2016, and 3451 of 2016, seeking directions upon the respondents for absorption into service. Upon hearing the said writ petitions, this Hon’ble Court was pleased to dispose of the same by directing the respondents to absorb those temporary employees into the revenue set-up, and in compliance with the said judgments and orders, the respondents duly absorbed them.
22He further submits that the present petitioners are similarly situated and stand on the same footing as the petitioners of the aforesaid writ petitions, having been engaged in the same manner, having rendered continuous service for a long period, and having acquired the requisite skills and experience while serving Bangladesh Railway. Despite this parity of status, the respondents failed to extend the same treatment to the present petitioners.
23He further submits that even after issuance of the Memo dated 21.01.2020, whereby direction was given to recommend the names of the TLR/Temporary Labourers to the Divisional Railway Manager for absorption into the revenue set-up, the concerned committee neither took any effective step nor arrived at any final decision and kept the matter pending for an unreasonable length of time.
24He finally submits that such inaction on the part of the respondents, despite clear policy decisions, previous judicial precedents, and express administrative directions, is illogical, arbitrary, and unlawful. Since the petitioners stand on the same footing as those already absorbed pursuant to earlier writ petitions, a
direction is required to be given upon the respondents to absorb the petitioners into the revenue set-up.
25The learned Deputy Attorney General without filing any affidavit in opposition opposes the rule.
26We have heard the learned counsels for both the sides and perused the writ petition along with all the annexures appended thereto.
27On perusal of the record placed before us we find that the petitioners were employed on a temporary "no work no pay" basis in different posts under the Ministry of Communication, Government of the Peoples Republic of Bangladesh in Bangladesh Railway.
28The government issued a circular on 28th March, 1969 which stated that the government has decided that all class III post of permanent nature which has been in existence for five year or more may be converted into permanent one in consultation with the Finance Department. The Circular is reproduced here which runs as under:
29SERVICE AND GENERAL ADMINISTRATION DEPARTMENT.
30Regulation Branch
31Section-1
32No. SCA/RI/IS-33/69/71(350), dated Dacca, the 28th March, 1969
33Subject: Conversion of temporary posts into permanent ones
34and contingent and work-charged staff into regular
35establishment.
36In super session of all previous orders on the subject note
37above, Government have been pleased to decide in consultation
38with the Finance Department as follows:
391) All temporary class III and class IV of permanent nature which
40have been in existence for five years or more may be converted
41into permanent ones in consultation with the Finance
42Department.
43(2) …………………
44(3) ………………..
45L.R Khan
46Deputy Secretary (Emphasis supplied)
47Thus, all posts of class III and class IV which are in the category of contingency and those who have been continuing for 5(five) years or more may be made permanent in consultation with the Finance Department.
48The government again issued a circular Memo No. Estb./RI/S46/72/55, dated Dacca, 21st April, 1972, which runs as under:
49Government of Bangladesh
50Ministry of Cabinet Affairs
51Establishment Division
52Regulation Wing-l
53Memo No. Estb/RI/S-46/72/55, dated Dacca, 21st April. 1972.
54Subject: Conversion of temporary posts into permanent ones
55and contingent and work-charged staff into regular
56establishment.
57The Government under Memo No SGA/RI/IS-
5833/69/71(350), dated 28" March, 1969 (copy enclosed) issued
59orders for conversion of certain temporary posts into permanent
60ones and contingent and work charged staff into regular
61establishment. It appears that these decisions have not been
62fully implemented as a result of which the employees
63concerned have not got the benefit of the said decisions. It has
64therefore, been decided that the decisions referred to above
65should be implemented immediately. It has further been
66decided that the conversion, as decided earlier of the posts
67which have been in existence for 5/10 years or more, should be
68done with effect from the date the posts were created and the
69employees should be absorbed against the posts with effect
70from the date of their appointment. In absorbing the employees
71the persons who have the longest period of service and are in
72retirement, or are on the verge of retirement should be given
73preference so that they get retirement benefit on retirement
74under the President's Order No. 14 of 1972.
752. The person who have already retired since the promulgation of
76the President's Order No. 14 of 1972 should also be given the
77benefit of absorption into regular establishment by since of
78orders retrospectively and giving retirement benefits provided
79they had the prescribed length of service.
803. The Ministry of Finance has been consulted.
81M.M. Zaman.
82Secretary
83It was brought to our notice that the above two circulars have not been superseded by the circular dated 24.01.1996.
84The learned Advocate for the petitioners also placed before us a Government Circular dated 03.05.2003 and submits that under the said Circular, those who have at least completed a period of 3 years in their service, are eligible for regularization.
85We have also perused the Circular dated 03.05.2003 which has been issued by the Cabinet Division. The Circular is reproduced below:
86! "।
87– jf¢h/ / / /L -%%/ %-%%% " &, (, 3 )
88. %.%+% ,
89– . /0 1 23, l¡Sü" 4! 5 6, 78! 9 2:
90;" ÙÛ¡e¡¿¹l, < , fc 4 ! = > ! ?@ A – B5 0
91(%) 8 !/ / E F / f F / ; !G 4/ E 4 H I0 ;" 4! 56 J 78! 9 2: ;" 4 . K ! L 4 ! A :M NM B &( ) 1 3 M. 1 O < < ? " M
92! 2 ! 0
93( ) R < 2< P ! < 23Q R
943: 3: 3S= :
95(") !2 A2 U M-
96। A2 U M 0 4 ! A :M
97V /0 q−h;
98(N) ®L¡e fc HL e¡N¡−s 02(c¤C) hRl n§ZÉ b¡L−m pwÙÛ¡fe j¿»Z¡mu J AbÑ
99¢hi¡−Nl Ae¤−j¡ce R¡s¡ pwlrZ Ll¡ k¡−h e¡;
100(,) ! NM W c < .A-J , pwÙÛ¡fe
101! A : M ¢hi¡−N ®fËlZ Ll−a q−h;
102(P) Eæue fËL−Òfl fc l¡Sü h¡−S−V ÙÛ¡e¡¿¹−ll pju ®L¡−e¡ naÑ B−l¡¢fa q−u
103b¡L−m fËn¡p¢eL j¿»Z¡mu−L a¡ f¡me Ll−a q−hz
104(2) HC e£¢aj¡m¡ h¡Ù¹h¡u−el f§−hÑ AÙÛ¡u£i¡−h pªSeL«a fc pj§−ql j−dÉ ®k pLm
105f−cl ®ju¡c 03(¢ae) hRl f§ZÑ qu¢e, −p pLm fc fËn¡p¢eL j¿»Z¡mu (1)
106EfAe¤−µR−c h¢ZÑa naÑ Ae¤plZf§hÑL ¢ae hRl fkÑ¿¹ hRl ¢i¢šL pwlrZ
107Ll−a f¡l−hz
108(&) J= L ! ®L¡e 4! pªÖV R2
109X 4 ! Ll¡ pñh 0 , 4 ! A :M V Y
110! Z 1 K Eš² I0 < ।
111(4) E çl/ F /ü¡uaÄ 4 K! !/ 4! A
112[6 ! !G ! ! V !
1133 ।
114(() M ;" AÙÛ¡u£i¡−h 56 fc 5(fy¡Q) hRl Hhw Eæue fËLÒf 2:
115;" ÙÛ¡e¡¿¹¢la fc 3(¢ae) hRl fl ÙÛ¡u£ Ll¡l 23 E !1
1160 ;" 4! 56 J 78! 9 2: ;"
1174 . 7 !E = &( ) 1 4! 3 ।
118(\) 4 ! 56 N ! hRl < 4! ! 0
11923Q R 0 !, < 2 ! 7O M Ljf−r 6(1!)
120] M 4 ! L 2 । 7R L 4 j¿»e¡mu
121fl£r¡ L−l fË−u¡Se£u pwMÉL fc ÙÛ¡u£ Ll¡l p¤f¡¢ln Ll−hz
122(7) pwÙÛ¡fe j¿»Z¡m−ul p¤f¡¢ln f¡h¡l fl AbÑ ¢hi¡−Nl pÇj¢a ¢e−u fËn¡p¢eL
123j¿»Z¡mu AeÉ¡eÉ BhnÉL£u Be¤ÖW¡¢eLa¡ f¡me L−l pw¢nÔÖV j¿»£l Ae¤−c¡e¡−¿¹
124fc ÙÛ¡u£ Ll¡l B−cn S¡¢l Ll−h a−h naÑ b¡−L ®k, j¿»Z¡mu/¢hi¡−Nl fËbj
125®nËe£l/LjÑLaÑ¡l fc ÙÛ¡u£ Ll¡l ®r−œ fËd¡ej¿»£l Ae¤−j¡c−el fË−u¡Se£u
126q−hz
127(8) HC e£¢aj¡m¡ h¡Ù¹h¡u−el f§−hÑ AÙÛ¡u£i¡−h pªÖV fc Ef¡e¤−µRc 9(5), (6) J
128(7) Hl ¢hd¡e Ae¤plZ f§hÑL ÙÛ¡u£ Ll¡ k¡−hz
1292z Haà¡l¡ pw¢nÔÖV ¢ho−u ¢hcÉj¡e fË¡pw¢Na B−cn, e£¢a-fÜ¢a h¡¢am/pw−n¡de
130Ll¡ qmz
1313z HC B−cn Seü¡−bÑ S¡¢l Ll¡ qm Hhw A¢hm−ð L¡kÑLl q−hz
132ü¡r¢la
13303-05-03
134(h¢cEl lqj¡e)
135k¤NÀ-p¢Qh
136®g¡e 7165510 ¢halZx %) S /^"É p¢Qh/ p¢Qh/ F S , :M !/
137( ) / /7 – l HL¡¿¹ p¢Qh ——— !/
138(&) E _ M M , =`
139(4)Ef¢eu¿»L, h¡wm¡−cn gljp J fËL¡ne¡ A¢gp, ®aSNy¡J, Y¡L¡z
140The petitioners have been rendering unblemished service for more than 3 years and they have been continuing their service in their respective offices. Therefore, they have legitimate expectation that they would be absorbed against the permanent posts. In this connection we may refer the case of Bangladesh Biman Corporation vs-Rabeya Bashir Irene and others reported in 55 DLR (AD) 132.
141In the case referred to above, the Appellate Division has held that “In the background of the existing practice of absorbing the employee of the petitioner’s category on satisfactory completion of the initial period of employment under a contract, it can be said that there was a reasonable ground for the writ petitioners to expect for being absorbed permanently in the service of the corporation”
142Since the question of facts and point of law involved in the instant case have already been discussed and decided in earlier judgments on similar facts and laws, we do not feel it necessary to elaborate the judgment. The petitioners of earlier writ petitions succeeded in getting favourable orders. The same fate must follow here.
143In view of the discussions narrated above, we find merit in the rule.
144In the result, the Rule is made absolute.
145The respondents are directed to absorb/regularize the petitioners into revenue budget against vacant posts of Bangladesh Railway as per memo bearing No. / / / / dated 29.01.2020 (Annexure-K) issued from the office of respondent No. 7 as expeditiously as possible, if they are otherwise not disqualified.
146However, there shall be no order as to costs.
147Communicate the judgment and order, at once.
148Faysal Hasan Arif, J:
149I agree.
150Md. Imam Hossain Bench officer.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











