Commutation of sentence, explained

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Oct 24, 2026

60-second explainer

Commutation of sentence, step by step.

ExplainerCommutation of sentence in 60 seconds
What it means

Commutation means replacing a sentence with a less severe kind of punishment, most often death with imprisonment for life.

In plain English

In Bangladesh it happens in two ways.

In plain English

A higher court, while upholding the conviction, can reduce a death sentence in a death reference or appeal.

What to do · 01

Get the full judgment

Obtain the certified copy of the trial and High Court Division judgments as soon as they are pronounced.

What to do · 02

Check the appeal route and deadline

Find out whether an appeal lies as of right or needs leave, and file within the time allowed.

What to do · 03

Collect mitigation evidence

Gather proof of age, previous good record, health, family circumstances and conduct in prison.

What to do · 04

Track time in custody

Keep records of arrest and custody dates, which affect the deduction under section 35A.

Done

You have the basics.

Test yourself, then read the full explanation.

Test yourselfRead in full
1 / 9
In short

Commutation means replacing a sentence with a less severe kind of punishment, most often death with imprisonment for life. In Bangladesh it happens in two ways. A higher court, while upholding the conviction, can reduce a death sentence in a death reference or appeal. After the case ends, the President or the Government can commute a sentence as an act of mercy. Commutation does not cancel the conviction.

What commutation means

To commute a sentence is to exchange it for a punishment of a different and lighter kind. The Penal Code 1860 lists the punishments in section 53: death, imprisonment for life, rigorous or simple imprisonment, forfeiture of property and fine. Commutation moves a person down that list, for example from death to imprisonment for life, or from imprisonment for life to a fixed term.

The person remains convicted. Only the punishment changes. That makes commutation different from an acquittal, which finds the person not guilty, and from remission, which shortens the time to be served without changing the kind of punishment. Judgment summaries often say a court ‘commuted the death sentence to imprisonment for life’, and that is the most common use of the word.

Where the power comes from

Article 49 of the Constitution gives the President power to grant pardons, reprieves and respites and to remit, suspend or commute any sentence passed by any court, tribunal or other authority. Section 54 of the Penal Code lets the Government commute a death sentence for any other punishment in the Code without the offender’s consent, and section 55 lets it commute imprisonment for life to imprisonment of either kind for up to twenty years.

Section 402 of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898 also lets the Government, without consent, commute a sentence to one lower in the order death, imprisonment for life, rigorous imprisonment, simple imprisonment and fine. Section 401 deals separately with suspending or remitting sentences, with or without conditions. Section 55A of the Penal Code preserves the President’s prerogative of mercy alongside these powers.

Commutation by the courts

A death sentence passed by a Court of Session cannot be carried out until the High Court Division confirms it (section 374 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The case goes up as a death reference, usually heard with the convict’s appeal and jail appeal. Under section 376 the High Court Division may confirm the sentence, pass any other sentence warranted by law, convict of another offence, order a retrial or acquit.

In ordinary criminal appeals, section 423 lets the appellate court reduce a sentence or change its nature, but not increase it, unless the appeal is for enhancement. Courts weigh aggravating and mitigating factors. In a 2026 death reference the High Court Division, relying on Appellate Division authority, treated a young age at the time of the offence, no previous convictions or record, and more than eight years in the condemned cell as reasons to commute death to imprisonment for life. See the death reference process.

Commutation by the President or the Government

Once the courts have finished, including any appeal and review in the Appellate Division, a prisoner under sentence of death may submit a mercy petition to the President under article 49. The President may commute the sentence, grant a pardon or reject the petition. The Government also holds the statutory powers in the Penal Code and the Code of Criminal Procedure described above.

This is an executive decision, not a court hearing. There is no fixed timetable, and the prisoner’s consent is not required for commutation under section 54 of the Penal Code or section 402 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. A conditional pardon granted by the President is enforceable as if the conditions had been imposed by a court sentence (section 401(5A)).

What it means for the prisoner and what comes next

Imprisonment for life is rigorous under the Explanation to section 53 of the Penal Code. When a court sentences a person to a term of imprisonment, section 35A of the Code of Criminal Procedure requires the time already spent in custody for that offence to be deducted, except for offences punishable only with death. For calculating fractions of punishment, section 57 treats imprisonment for life as thirty years’ rigorous imprisonment. Fines and other parts of the sentence usually stay unless the court changes them.

Article 103(2)(b) gives an appeal to the Appellate Division as of right where the High Court Division has confirmed a death sentence or sentenced a person to death or imprisonment for life. Other challenges, such as a State petition to restore a commuted death sentence, need leave. Under Order XXIV of the Appellate Division Rules, a criminal leave petition must be lodged within thirty days, or sixty days for a law officer challenging an acquittal, and a death sentence is stayed while a leave petition is pending.

Commutation compared with similar terms

A pardon releases the person from the punishment altogether. A reprieve or respite postpones or delays the carrying out of a sentence. Remission reduces the length of a sentence without changing its kind. A reduction to the ‘period already undergone’ is a court ordering release because the time served is enough. Criminal revision is a separate route by which the High Court Division corrects errors in lower court orders.

Case story
Suppose a 20-year-old with no previous record is sentenced to death by a Court of Session for murder during a robbery. The case goes to the High Court Division as a death reference, heard with his appeal. The court finds the murder proved and upholds the conviction. Considering his age, his clean record and eight years in the condemned cell, it commutes the death sentence to imprisonment for life and keeps the fine. Either side can then consider going to the Appellate Division.
A hypothetical illustration, not a real case.

What to do if this affects you

  1. 01
    Get the full judgment

    Obtain the certified copy of the trial and High Court Division judgments as soon as they are pronounced.

  2. 02
    Check the appeal route and deadline

    Find out whether an appeal lies as of right or needs leave, and file within the time allowed.

  3. 03
    Collect mitigation evidence

    Gather proof of age, previous good record, health, family circumstances and conduct in prison.

  4. 04
    Track time in custody

    Keep records of arrest and custody dates, which affect the deduction under section 35A.

  5. 05
    Consider a mercy petition

    After the Appellate Division has finally decided the case, a petition may be made to the President under article 49.

Flashcards

Test yourself on Commutation of sentence

0 known · 0 to review
Question 1 of 6What does “Commutation of sentence” mean?Tap to reveal the answer
AnswerReplacing a sentence with a lighter kind of punishment, such as death with imprisonment for life, by a higher court or by the Government or President.
Question 2 of 6Does commutation mean the person is innocent?Tap to reveal the answer
AnswerNo. Commutation changes only the punishment. The conviction stands, and the person is still treated as guilty of the offence. If the person wants to establish innocence, that must be done through an appeal or review in the courts, not through commutation or a mercy petition.
Question 3 of 6Who can commute a death sentence in Bangladesh?Tap to reveal the answer
AnswerWhile the case is in court, the High Court Division can do so in a death reference or appeal by passing a lesser sentence, and the Appellate Division can do so on appeal. After the case ends, the President can commute under article 49 of the Constitution, and the Government has statutory powers under section 54 of the Penal Code and section 402 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
Question 4 of 6Does the prisoner have to agree to commutation?Tap to reveal the answer
AnswerNo. Section 54 of the Penal Code and section 402 of the Code of Criminal Procedure both allow the Government to commute a sentence without the consent of the person sentenced. Consent matters only for conditional suspension or remission under section 401, where the person must accept the conditions.
Question 5 of 6What is the difference between commutation and remission?Tap to reveal the answer
AnswerCommutation replaces one kind of punishment with another, lighter kind, for example death with imprisonment for life. Remission reduces the amount of a punishment without changing its kind, for example cutting the length of a prison term. Under section 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure the Government may remit all or part of a sentence, with or without conditions.
Question 6 of 6How long is imprisonment for life after commutation?Tap to reveal the answer
AnswerSection 57 of the Penal Code treats imprisonment for life as thirty years’ rigorous imprisonment when calculating fractions of punishment. How long a person actually serves can also depend on custody deductions, remission rules and Appellate Division case law, so the answer for a particular prisoner needs individual advice on the sentence and the prison record.
Deck complete.You knew 0 of 6.

Questions about Commutation of sentence

Does commutation mean the person is innocent?

No. Commutation changes only the punishment. The conviction stands, and the person is still treated as guilty of the offence. If the person wants to establish innocence, that must be done through an appeal or review in the courts, not through commutation or a mercy petition.

Who can commute a death sentence in Bangladesh?

While the case is in court, the High Court Division can do so in a death reference or appeal by passing a lesser sentence, and the Appellate Division can do so on appeal. After the case ends, the President can commute under article 49 of the Constitution, and the Government has statutory powers under section 54 of the Penal Code and section 402 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

Does the prisoner have to agree to commutation?

No. Section 54 of the Penal Code and section 402 of the Code of Criminal Procedure both allow the Government to commute a sentence without the consent of the person sentenced. Consent matters only for conditional suspension or remission under section 401, where the person must accept the conditions.

What is the difference between commutation and remission?

Commutation replaces one kind of punishment with another, lighter kind, for example death with imprisonment for life. Remission reduces the amount of a punishment without changing its kind, for example cutting the length of a prison term. Under section 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure the Government may remit all or part of a sentence, with or without conditions.

How long is imprisonment for life after commutation?

Section 57 of the Penal Code treats imprisonment for life as thirty years’ rigorous imprisonment when calculating fractions of punishment. How long a person actually serves can also depend on custody deductions, remission rules and Appellate Division case law, so the answer for a particular prisoner needs individual advice on the sentence and the prison record.

Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp