Alternative remedy rule
The principle that the High Court Division will not usually hear a writ petition when the law already gives an equally effective remedy, such as a statutory appeal.
Alternative remedy rule, step by step.
If you challenge a government decision by writ petition, the High Court Division will first ask whether the law already gives you another effective route, such as an appeal to a tribunal or a higher officer.
If it does, the court will usually send you there.
The rule has exceptions, including action without jurisdiction, breach of fundamental rights, bad faith and denial of a fair hearing, so check both routes and their deadlines early.
Read the statute
Check whether the law under which the decision was made provides an appeal, revision or tribunal case, and note its time limit and any deposit.
Diarise the deadline
Statutory remedies often have short limits. Protect your position by filing within time even while considering a writ.
Identify an exception
If you want to file a writ, set out why the other remedy is not equally efficacious: no jurisdiction, bad faith, no hearing, or breach of a fundamental right.
Raise it early if you are the respondent
Government and other respondents should take the objection in the affidavit-in-opposition, with the statutory provision cited.
If you challenge a government decision by writ petition, the High Court Division will first ask whether the law already gives you another effective route, such as an appeal to a tribunal or a higher officer. If it does, the court will usually send you there. The rule has exceptions, including action without jurisdiction, breach of fundamental rights, bad faith and denial of a fair hearing, so check both routes and their deadlines early.
What the alternative remedy rule means
A writ petition under article 102 of the Constitution is an extraordinary remedy. The High Court Division uses it to correct unlawful action by public bodies when ordinary routes cannot do the job. The alternative remedy rule, also called the rule of exhaustion of remedies, says that if a law already provides another remedy that is just as effective, such as an appeal, a revision or a tribunal case, the person should normally use that first.
The rule guides the court's discretion; it is not an absolute bar. The real question is whether the other remedy is "equally efficacious": can it give the same relief, as fully and in reasonable time, before a body able to decide the issue? A remedy that is illusory, very slow, before the same officer whose act is challenged, or unable to decide the legal point raised may not count.
Where the rule comes from in Bangladesh law
The rule is written into the Constitution. Article 102(2) lets the High Court Division make its other orders, including those of the mandamus, prohibition and certiorari kind, only "if satisfied that no other equally efficacious remedy is provided by law". Article 102(1), which deals with enforcing fundamental rights, contains no such words. That difference is one reason courts are readier to hear a writ that shows a real breach of a fundamental right.
Many statutes create their own remedies that the court expects people to use. Matters within the jurisdiction of an Administrative Tribunal set up under article 117, such as most terms of service of public servants, cannot be brought in any other court at all. Disputes about the final survey record of rights go to the Land Survey Tribunal under section 145A of the State Acquisition and Tenancy Act 1950. Tax, customs and revenue laws also provide appeals to their own tribunals.
How the rule is applied in court
The point is usually raised by the respondent, often a government office, in its affidavit-in-opposition or at the hearing. Sometimes the Bench raises it at the motion stage and refuses to issue a Rule, telling the petitioner to use the statutory route. More often a Rule is issued and the question of maintainability is argued at the final hearing together with the merits, which can come years later.
If the court upholds the objection, it usually discharges the Rule or summarily rejects the petition as not maintainable, without deciding who is right on the merits. The court may add an observation that the petitioner is free to pursue the other remedy. Whether time spent in the High Court Division can be excluded when that remedy is later pursued depends on the governing law and the court's order, so do not assume it.
The main exceptions
Courts in Bangladesh have long held that an alternative remedy does not stop a writ where the authority acted wholly without jurisdiction, where it acted mala fide (in bad faith), where it broke the rules of natural justice by deciding without a hearing, or where a fundamental right is being infringed. A writ may also be heard where the case turns on a pure question of law, such as the meaning or validity of a statute.
Another exception arises where the other remedy is no longer open for reasons outside the petitioner's control, or is plainly inadequate, for example where the appeal lies to the same authority that made the decision, or where the remedy cannot grant the relief needed. Courts look at the facts of each case. A petitioner who simply let an appeal deadline pass without good reason should not expect the writ court to rescue the claim.
What it means for each side and what to do next
For the person challenging a decision, the rule means checking the governing statute first. Find out whether it provides an appeal, revision or tribunal case, what the time limit is, and whether any deposit is required. If you file a writ instead, the petition should explain clearly why the statutory remedy is not equally efficacious or why an exception applies.
For the government office or other respondent, the rule is a common preliminary objection. It is strongest where the petitioner had a working statutory appeal and offers no reason for bypassing it. If the writ is rejected on this ground, the petitioner can usually still pursue the statutory remedy if it remains in time, or seek leave to appeal to the Appellate Division within 60 days of the High Court Division's judgment.
Common misunderstandings
The rule does not mean a writ is never possible when an appeal exists. It is a rule of practice and discretion, with well-known exceptions. Nor is it the same as laches, which is unreasonable delay in coming to court, or as lack of standing, which asks whether the petitioner is a person aggrieved. A petition can fail on any of these grounds separately. Finally, a writ dismissed for an alternative remedy is not a ruling that the decision was lawful.
Suppose a trader receives an order from a tax officer imposing a large penalty. The statute gives a right of appeal to a tribunal within a set time. Instead, the trader files a writ petition saying the order is wrong on the facts. The High Court Division is likely to reject the writ and point to the tribunal appeal. If, however, the officer had imposed the penalty without any notice or hearing, the trader could argue that the breach of natural justice justifies a writ.
What to do if this affects you
- 01Read the statute
Check whether the law under which the decision was made provides an appeal, revision or tribunal case, and note its time limit and any deposit.
- 02Diarise the deadline
Statutory remedies often have short limits. Protect your position by filing within time even while considering a writ.
- 03Identify an exception
If you want to file a writ, set out why the other remedy is not equally efficacious: no jurisdiction, bad faith, no hearing, or breach of a fundamental right.
- 04Raise it early if you are the respondent
Government and other respondents should take the objection in the affidavit-in-opposition, with the statutory provision cited.
- 05Act on the outcome
If the writ is rejected on this ground, move quickly to the statutory forum or seek leave to appeal within 60 days.
Test yourself on Alternative remedy rule
Alternative remedy rule in real judgments
Recent Supreme Court of Bangladesh judgments summarised on trw.co where the term appears.
Questions about Alternative remedy rule
Can I file a writ if I have a right of appeal?
Sometimes. The High Court Division normally expects you to use an equally effective statutory appeal first. A writ may still be heard if the authority acted without jurisdiction, in bad faith, without giving you a hearing, or in breach of a fundamental right, or if the appeal is not a real remedy in your situation.
Does the rule apply to fundamental rights cases?
Less strictly. Article 102(1), which covers enforcement of fundamental rights, does not contain the words about another equally efficacious remedy found in article 102(2). Courts are therefore more willing to hear a writ showing a genuine breach of a fundamental right, though they may still direct a person to an available statutory forum.
What happens if my writ is rejected because of an alternative remedy?
The court has not decided that the decision against you was lawful. It has said you should use the other route. You can usually go to the statutory forum if you are still within time, or seek leave to appeal to the Appellate Division within 60 days. Check the time limit for the statutory remedy immediately.
Is a remedy that has become time-barred still an alternative remedy?
It depends on why it lapsed. If you simply missed the deadline, the court may refuse to help. If the remedy was never realistically available, or the delay was not your fault, the court may treat the writ as the only effective route. Explain the history fully and honestly in the petition.
Who decides whether the other remedy is equally efficacious?
The High Court Division Bench hearing the writ. It looks at whether the other forum can grant the same relief, decide the legal issue raised, and act within a reasonable time. There is no fixed list, so the petition and the affidavit-in-opposition should each give concrete reasons on this point.
Can the court raise the point itself?
Yes. Even if the respondent does not object, the Bench may ask why the petitioner did not use the statutory remedy, at the motion hearing or at final hearing. Be ready to answer it from the start, citing the statute and the facts that make the other remedy inadequate in your case.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











