High Court Division · Admiralty Jurisdiction
Nahid Akhter v Eden Fisheries Ltd. and others
Admiralty Suit 22/2021 · Decided 7 December 2025
Two admiralty suits concerned the fishing vessel F.V. Ocean-3 (registration No. F-11127), which had replaced the imported F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29. Eden Fisheries Ltd., which held the vessel, claimed it under 2013 agreements with the then owner, who denied them. He was registered as owner in 2018 and sold it, through another buyer, to Nahid Akhter, registered on 26.11.2018. The High Court Division held that time ran against Eden from 07.11.2019, when it knew of the sale to a third party, so its 2021 suit for specific performance was out of time under the one-year limit in Article 113 of the Limitation Act, 1908. Its earlier suit, rejected for unpaid court fees, did not qualify for exclusion under section 14(1), and section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act applies only to immovable property. As the Register is conclusive evidence of ownership, Nahid was declared owner and Eden ordered to hand over the vessel within 30 days. Her money claim failed, and Eden's suit was dismissed.
Owner's suit decreed in part; Eden's suit time-barred
- Q1
Whether a suit to enforce a 2013 agreement to buy a fishing vessel, filed in 2021, was barred by the one-year limitation period under Article 113 of the Limitation Act, 1908.
- Q2
Whether time spent on an earlier civil suit rejected for non-payment of court fees can be excluded under section 14(1) of the Limitation Act, 1908.
- Q3
Whether the person entered in the Register of fishing vessels is entitled to a declaration of ownership and to recover possession from a company holding the vessel without any valid document.
- Suits claiming ownership and possession of a fishing vessel are maintainable under section 3(2)(a) of the Admiralty Court Act, 2000, and under rule 57 of the Admiralty Rules, 1912 the Court could act on the official registration records sent by the Registrar of Bangladesh Ships.
- As Eden gave no notice for performance, time under Article 113 ran from 07.11.2019, when it knew that the vessel had been sold to a third party, so its suit for specific performance was barred by the one-year limitation period.
- Following Vijay Kumar Rampal v Diwan Devi (AIR 1985 (SC) 1669), Eden was not entitled to exclude time under section 14(1) for its earlier suit, which was rejected for failure to pay court fees, not for any defect of jurisdiction.
- Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 on part performance applies only to immovable property and could not help Eden, so Admiralty Suit No. 26 of 2021 was dismissed as time-barred.
- Under section 389(1) of the Bangladesh Merchant Shipping Ordinance, 1983 the Register is conclusive evidence of ownership, so Nahid Akhter was declared owner and Eden, holding the vessel without any valid document, was ordered to hand it over within 30 days.
- Nahid's money claim against Eden failed because she had no interest in the vessel during the earlier owner's verbal arrangement with Eden and was not a party to it.
the doctrine of part performance incorporated in Section 53A of the T.P. Act applies only to immovable property, whereas the subject matter of the instant suit is movable property.
In the court’s own words.
Admiralty Suit 22/2021, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 29 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2HIGH COURT DIVISION
3(ADMIRALTY JURISDICTION)
4Present:
5Mr. Justice Zafar Ahmed
6ADMIRALTY SUIT NO. 22 OF 2021
7WITH
8ADMIRALTY SUIT NO. 26 OF 2021
9IN THE MATTER OF:
10Nahid Akhter
11….. Plaintiff in Admiralty Suit No. 22 of 2021
12Eden Fisheries Limited
13….. Plaintiff in Admiralty Suit No. 26 of 2021
14-VERSUS-
15Eden Fisheries Ltd. and others.
16…..…Defendants in Admiralty Suit No. 22 of 2021
17Gazi Belayet Hossain and others.
18…..…Defendants in Admiralty Suit No. 26 of 2021
19Mr. Muhammad Mijanur Rahman, Advocate
20….. For the plaintiff in Admiralty Suit No. 22 of 2021 and
21defendants in Admiralty Suit No. 26 of 2021
22Mr. Md. Monowar Hossain, Advocate
23… for the plaintiff in Admiralty Suit No. 26 of 2021
24and defendant in Admiralty Suit No. 22 of 2021
25Heard on: 29.10.2025, 06.11.2025, 16.11.2025 and 20.11.2025
26Judgment on: 07.12.2025
271. In both suits, the parties are same. Their claims primarily concern
28ownership of the fishing vessel F.V. Ocean-3 registration No. F-11127
29which has been replaced with another imported fishing vessel F.V.
30SINNUMCHAI-29. The suits were heard simultaneously and are
31disposed of by this common single judgment.
32:2:
33Identity of the relevant parties:
34Admiralty suit (A.S.) No. 22 of 2021:
352. Nahid Akhter (in short, ‘Nahid’) proprietor of M/S Bay Resources
36Fishing is the plaintiff.
37Eden Fisheries Ltd. (in short, ‘Eden’) represented by its Managing
38Director Sheikh Abdul Hye Bacchu through its constituted attorney is
39the principal defendant.
40A.S. No. 26 of 2021:
413. Eden Fisheries Ltd. is the plaintiff.
42Gazi Belayet Hossain, proprietor of M/S Belayet Navigation (in short,
43‘Belayet’) is the 1st defendant, and
44Nahid, wife of Gazi Belayet Hossain, is the 2nd defendant.
45Contesting parties:
464. A.S. No. 22 of 2021 is contested by the sole principal defendant Eden
47by filing written statement and additional written statement.
48A.S. No. 26 of 2021 is contested by the 1st defendant Belayet and the
492nd defendant Nahid by filing separate written statement and additional
50written statement.
51Witnesses:
52A.S. 22 of 2021:
535. Md. Quamruzzaman, constituted attorney of the plaintiff Nahid, gave
54statements of facts (examination-in-chief) as PW1 by way of affidavit
55dated 15.07.2025 as per provisions of the newly inserted rule 4A to
56Order XVIII of the Coded of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), [vide the
57:3:
58Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Ordinance, 2025, 8th May,
592025]. He was cross-examined by the contesting 1st defendant Eden.
60Documents tendered in evidence by the PW1 were marked as exhibit
61Nos. 1-10. The 1st defendant Eden did not examine any witness.
62A.S. 26 of 2021:
636. Abdul Bashar Gazi, constituted attorney of the plaintiff Eden, was
64examined as PW1. He was cross-examined by the contesting 1st
65defendant Belayet and the 2nd defendant Nahid. Documents tendered
66in evidence by the PW1 were marked as exhibit Nos. 1-7.
677. Md. Zia Uddin gave statements of facts (examination-in-chief) as
68DW1 on behalf of the 1st defendant Belayet by way of affidavit dated
6916.07.2025. He also filed a separate statement of facts (examination-
70in-chief) on behalf of the 2nd defendant Nahid by way of affidavit
71dated 13.08.2025. He was cross-examined by the plaintiff. Documents
72tendered in evidence by the DW1 on behalf of the 1st defendant were
73marked as exhibit Nos. A-L and on behalf of the 2nd defendant as
74exhibit Nos. A-H.
75Issues:
76A.S. No. 22 of 2021:
778. The following issues were framed on 24.04.2025 in A.S. No. 22 of
782021:
791. Is the suit maintainable under Admiralty Jurisdiction?
802. Whether there is any cause of action against the principal
81defendant for filing the instant suit?
82:4:
833. Whether the plaintiff has accrued any right, title and ownership of
84the suit vessel?
854. Whether the principal defendant is liable for any losses and
86damages sustained by the plaintiff?
875. Is the plaintiff entitled to the decree as prayed for?
88During the argument, the following additional issues were framed on
8916.11.2025 as per provisions of Order XIV, rule 5(1) of the CPC:
906. Is the suit barred by limitation?
917. Whether plaintiff is entitled to recover possession of the suit
92vessel from the defendants?
93A.S. No. 26 of 2021:
949. The following issues were framed on 13.03.2025 in A.S. No. 26 of
952021:
961. Whether the suit is maintainable under admiralty jurisdiction in
97its present form?
982. Whether the defendants are jointly and severally liable to make
99registration of the Fishing Vessel?
1003. Whether the plaintiff has any cause of action against the
101defendants for filing the instant admiralty suit?
1024. Whether the suit is barred under the principles of estoppel, waiver
103and acquiescence?
1045. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to declaration as to the ownership
105of the Fishing Vessel?
1066. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get compensation worth Tk.
10746,11,76,191.00?
1087. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get relief as prayed for?
109:5:
110During the argument, the following additional issue was framed
111on 16.11.2025:
1128. Is the suit barred by limitation?
113Maintainability:
11410. The instant suits claiming ownership of the fishing vessel in question,
115possession thereof and consequential reliefs are maintainable under
116Section 3(2)(a) of the Admiralty Court, 2000 which provides that the
117Admiralty Court has jurisdiction to hear and determine any claim as to
118the possession or ownership of a ship or for recovery of documents of
119title and ownership of a ship, including registration certificate, log
120book and such certificates as may be necessary for the operation or
121navigation of the ship.
122Applicable law; Bangladesh Merchant Shipping Ordinance, 1983:
12311. Chapter 32 of Part IX of the Ordinance, 1983 deals with matters
124relating to registration of fishing vessels etc. Section 388(3) requires
125the owner of the fishing vessel to make an application in the
126prescribed form to the Registrar to grant him a Certificate of Registry
127of the vessel. Registrar means Registrar of Bangladesh Ships (Section
12817). After conducting an inquiry under Section 388(4), the Registrar
129grants the applicant a Certificate of Registry in the prescribed form on
130payment of requisite fees [Section 388 (5)]. The Register is the
131conclusive evidence that the person entered therein is the owner of the
132vessel [Section 389(1)]. (emphasis supplied)
133:6:
13412. Section 391 deals with the matter relating to the change of name of a
135fishing vessel registered under Section 388.
13613. Section 392 provides that change of ownership of a registered vessel
137can be done with approval in writing of the Government. Every
138change of ownership shall be reported jointly by the registered owner
139and the new owner to the Registrar in the prescribed form who shall,
140upon an inquiry, enter the name of the new owner in the Fishing
141Vessels Register and endorse the Certificate of Registry accordingly.
14214. Section 394 states that when a fishing vessel is so altered as not to
143correspond with the particulars relating to her entered in the
144Certificate of Registry, the owner shall report such alteration to the
145Registrar who shall register the alteration or direct that the vessel be
146registered a new in accordance with such rules as may be made in this
147behalf. Section 403 empowers the Government to make rules to carry
148out the purpose of Chapter 32, but no rules have yet been made.
149Replacement of fishing vessels:
15015. Bangladesh Merchant Shipping Ordinance, 1983 does not lay down
151any provision for replacement of fishing vessels. Rule 5 of Marine
152Fisheries Rules, 2023, made under the Marine Fisheries Act, 2020
153repealing the Marine Fisheries Ordinance, 1983, provides specific
154provisions for replacement of fishing vessels. Rule 5(8) states,
1555। (৮) গভীর স ে মৎ আহরেণর জ অ প দািব কিরয়া এই িবিধর অধীন কােনা
156মািলেকর আেবদেনর ি েত কােনা মৎ নৗযােনর রিজে শন বািতল করা হইেল,
157বািণিজ ক লােরর ে উহার মািলক সংি নৗযান িত াপেন আ হী হইেল, অথবা
158:7:
159সরকার ক ক অ েমািদত িনিদ ত ন না অ সাের তন বািণিজ ক লার আমদািন বা
160িনমাণ করা হইেল, গভীর স ে মৎ আহরেণর জ একই মািলেকর নােম এবং
161সংি আমদািন ত বা িনমাণ ত বািণিজ ক লােরর িবপরীেত িন বিণত শেত
162লাইেস দান করা যাইেব, যথা:-
163(ক) আেবদনকারীেক িত াপনাধীন বািণিজ ক লােরর মািলক হইেত হইেব এবং তাহার,
164আইন ও এই িবিধমালার অধীন, হালনাগাদ ত লাইেস থািকেত হইেব;
165(খ) বািণিজ ক লার মৎ আহরেণর অ প হওয়ায় উহা ভা া হইয়ােছ মেম উপ
166ক পে র ত য়নপ দািখল কিরেত হইেব;
167(গ) য বািণিজ ক লােরর রিজে শন বািতল করা হইয়ােছ তাহার ল সনদ দািখল কিরেত
168হইেব।
16916. It appears that the prevalent practice and procedure followed by the
170concerned Government departments for replacement of fishing vessels
171have been incorporated in Rule 5 of the Rules, 2023. PW1, who gave
172evidence for the plaintiff Eden of A.S. No. 26 of 2021, stated in cross-
173examination, “Bj¡l S¡e¡ja f¤l¡e¡ ¢g¢mw VÊm¡l fË¢aØq¡fel SeÉ plL¡¢l cçl
174®bL Ae¤j¢a ¢eu VÊm¡l¢V scrap Lla qu Hhw ea¥e S¡q¡S Be¡l ®rœ fË¢aØq¡fel
175SeÉ Ae¤j¢a ¢ea qu”z
176Rule 57 of Admiralty Rules, 1912 and report and documents sent
177by Registrar of Bangladesh Ships:
17817. On 16.11.2025, this Court passed the following order in both A.S.
179Nos. 22 of 2021 and 26 of 2021:
180“Earlier, vide order dated 30.10.2025, this Court
181directed the Principal Officer & Registrar of Bangladesh Ships
182of Mercantile Marine Department to transmit the relevant
183original registration records of the Fishing Vessel F.V. Ocean-
1843 (former official No. F-7704, present official No. F-11127)
185which was replaced with the Fishing Vessel F.V. Sinnumchai-
18629) to this Court. In compliance of the order, the concerned
187:8:
188authorities sent the relevant records maintained by them.
189Copies of those records were supplied to the learned
190Advocates of the parties.
191Rule 57 of the Admiralty Rules, 1912 states, “The
192Judge shall be at liberty to receive, call for and act upon, such
193evidence, documentary or otherwise, whether legally
194admissible or not, as he may think fit”. The learned Advocates
195of both sides accept that Rule 57 has given ample power to the
196Judge of the Admiralty Court to consider the official records
197transmitted to this Court by the concerned authority as
198evidence. This Court gave an option to the learned Advocates
199to challenge the official records by way calling the relevant
200officers as witness and to cross-examine them. The learned
201Advocates replied that they would not do so and further that
202the official records can be treated as evidence”.
20318. The Registrar of Bangladesh Ships, vide memo dated 05.11.2025 sent
204the relevant documents to this Court. It is stated in the forwarding
205letter dated 05.11.2025, নং: ১৮.১৭.১৫০০,০০.০০১.২০১১/ তাং: ০৫-১১-২০২৫ ি : িবষয়: এফ,িভ, ওশান-৩( রিজে শন নং: এফ-১১১২৭) এর মািলকানা যাচাই সং া ত রণ সে ।
206উপ িবষেয় স§ া পে র বরােত আপনার অবগিতর জ জানােনা যাে য, অ দ েরর রকডপ
207যাচাই সােপে িনে এফ.িড. ওশান-৩ ( রিজে শন নং: এফ-১১১২৭) নৗযােনর মািলকানা ও চািহত
208ত িদ িনে দওয়া হেলা-
209িফিশং জাহােজর নাম : এফ.িভ. "ওশান-৩"
210রিজে শন না ার ও তািরখ : এফ-১১১২৭, ২৫-০২-২০১৮ি ঃ।
211বতমান মািলেকর নাম : জনাব নািহদা আ ার, ামী: গাজী বলােয়ত হাসাইন,
212া াইটর অব ব-িরেসাস িফিশং, ৪৫/৪৭ া রাড,
213এস, হক চ ার (৩য় তলা), মািঝরঘাট, চ াম।
214উে য, ২৬-১১-২০১৮ি : তািরখ হেত উ জাহােজর কান কায ম অ দ ের চলমান নই।
215:9:
216ইহা আপনার অবগিতর জ জানােনা হেলা।
217(ক াে ন শখ মা: জালাল উি ন গাজী)
218ি ি পাল অিফসার (অঃদাঃ)
219ও
220রিজ ার অব বাংলােদশ িশপ'স fË¢a, pqL¡¢l ®l¢SØVÊ¡l (A¢l¢Se¡m S¤¢lp¢XLne)
221p¤¢fËj ®L¡VÑ, h¡wm¡cn q¡CL¡VÑ ¢X¢ine, Y¡L¡z
22219. It appears from the documents sent by the Registrar of Bangladesh
223ships that the fishing vessel M.V. Ocean-3 was first registered under
224Section 388 of Bangladesh Merchant Shipping Ordinance, 1983 on
22514.06.2009 in the name of Mr. S.M. Al Mamun. Belayet’s name as the
226owner of the vessel was entered in the Register and Certificate of
227Registry was endorsed accordingly on 09.02.2011. Registration of the
228vessel was cancelled for replacement as per memo dated 06.10.2013
229issued by the Ministry of Fisheries & Livestock and the same was
230endorsed by the Registrar of Bangladesh Ships in the Register. On
23125.02.2018, the Registrar of Bangladesh Ships issued Certificate of
232Registration of F.V. Ocean-3 in the name of Belayet. Following sale
233of the vessel to Farhadul by Beayet on 25.02.2018, which is recorded
234in the Registry in presence of a official witness by putting signature
235and seal of the seller, buyer and witnesses, the name of the Farhadul as
236the new owner was entered in the Registry and the same was endorsed
237on 28.02.2018. When Farhadul sold the vessel to Nahid on
23820.11.2018, the same procedure was followed and the name of Nahid
239was entered and endorsed in the Registry on 26.11.2018.
240: 10 :
241Facts:
24220. Relevant facts stated hereinafter are based on pleadings of both suits,
243documentary evidence adduced by the parties which are not disputed
244save and except agreement for sale dated 05.03.2013 and sale
245agreement dated 13.03.2013, and report and documents submitted by
246the Registrar of Bangladesh Ships.
24721. On 09.02.2011, F.V. Ocean-3 was registered in the name of Belayet
248with the office of Mercantile Marine Department, Chattogram. In late,
2492011, Belayet imported the fishing vessel F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29 for
250replacement with F.V. Ocean-3.
25122. In October, 2011, F.V. Ocean-3 was kept in mortgage with BASIC
252Bank against the loan taken by Belayet and after repayment mortgage
253discharge certificate was issued on 02.09.2014.
25423. Marine Fisheries Department, Chattogram filed Kornophuli Police
255Station Case No. 3(1)12, G.R. No. 14/12 against Belayet in the Court
256of Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Chattogram under Section 20 (entry
257of foreign fishing vessel in Bangladesh fisheries water without a
258licence) and Section 22 (foreign vessels liable to fine and forfeiture if
259found in Bangladesh fisheries water illegally) of Marine Fisheries
260Ordinance, 1983 (since repealed by the Marine Fisheries Act, 2020).
261The investigating officer submitted final report and the learned
262Magistrate discharged the accused Belayet on 16.10.2014.
263: 11 :
26424. On 06.10.2013, Belayet obtained approval from the government for
265replacement of F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29 with F.V. Ocean-3, and also
266obtained approval of proforma invoice and specification. Registration
267of F.V. Ocean-3 was cancelled for replacement on 06.10.2013.
26825. On 25.01.2015, F.V. Ocean-3 was scrapped and the concerned
269government authority issued scrap certificate dated 25.01.2015. On
27007.07.2015, the Government issued fitness certificate of F.V.
271SINNUMCHAI-29 to Belayet.
27226. On 20.08.2017, Belayet made declaration of ownership of F.V. Ocean-
2733 in prescribed Form No. 2. On 21.08.2017, Belayet applied to the
274concerned authority for registration of F.V. Ocean-3 for replacement
275with F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29.
27627. On 24.02.2018, sale agreement was entered into between Belayet and
277Farhadul to sell F.V. Ocean-3 to Farhadul. On 25.02.2018, the
278Registrar of Bangladesh Ships issued Certificate of Registration of
279F.V. Ocean-3 in the name of Belayet. On 25.02.2018, Farhadul made
280Declaration of Ownership of F.V. Ocean-3 in prescribed Form No. 2.
281On 25.02.2018, Belayet declared Bill of Sale of F.V. Ocean-3 in
282prescribed Form No. 8A. On 28.02.2018, Belayet submitted ‘Notice of
283Name Proposed For a Bangladeshi Ship’ for F.V. Ocean-3 in
284prescribed Form No. 20 before the Registrar of Bangladesh Ships. On
28528.02.2018, Registrar of Bangladesh Ships, Mercantile Marine Office
286registered F.V. Ocean-3 in the name of Farhadul.
287: 12 :
28828. On 19.03.208, Farhadul and the plaintiff Nahid entered into a sale
289agreement to sell F.V. Ocean-3 to Nahid. On 19.11.2018, Farhadul
290declared Bill of Sale of F.V. Ocean-3 in prescribed Form No. 8A. On
29120.11.2018, Nahid made Declaration of Ownership of F.V. Ocean-3 in
292prescribed Form No. 2. On 26.11.2018, Registrar of Bangladesh Ships
293registered change of ownership of F.V. Ocean-3 in the name of Nahid.
29429. On 06.03.2019, Eden filed C.R. Case No. 324 of 2019 against Belayet
295and others. The vessel was seized in connection with the case and later
296on, was given in the custody of Eden on 15.04.2019. The PBI
297submitted enquiry report before the learned Magistrate on 21.07.2019.
298The criminal case was withdrawn on 30.12.2019.
29930. Eden filed Title Suit No. 482 of 2020 against Belayet and others on
30021.09.2020. The suit was rejected on 01.03.2021.
301A.S. No. 26 of 2021 (Eden vs. Belayet, Nahid and ors). Is the suit
302barred by limitation?
30331. Plaint of A.S. No. 26 of 2021 was amended several times. Plaint,
304referred to hereinafter, means the final plaint incorporating earlier
305amendments (entry No. 9930, dated 20.11.2025).
30632. The plaintiff Eden filed the suit praying for recovery of documents of
307title of the fishing vessel F.V. Ocean-3 [later on replaced with F.V.
308SINNUMCHAI-29] from the defendants; for a declaration of title and
309ownership of the same; for a direction upon the defendants to register
310the vessel in favour of the plaintiff; for compensation; and for a
311: 13 :
312declaration that the transfer of the fishing vessel to the 2nd defendant
313Nahid is illegal and void.
31433. The specific case of the Eden Fishing Ltd., as stated in para 5-9 of the
315plaint of A.S. No. 26 of 2021, is that in order to purchase F.V.
316SINNUMCHAI-29, they entered into an agreement for sale of the said
317fishing vessel with Belayet on 05.03.2013 for a price of BDT
31815,00,00,000 (fifteen crore). The relevant portions of the said
319agreement for sale is reproduced below:
320m¡Cp¾ppq pj¤âN¡j£ ¢g¢nw Smk¡e Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 Hl ¢hH²ul h¡ue¡ c¢mm
321CXe ¢g¢nw ¢m¢jVX, fr-nM Bhc¤m q¡C h¡µQ¥, ¢WL¡e¡-h¡s£ ew-2/2H, psL ew-4,
322¢XJHCQHp (f¤l¡ae), he¡e£, Y¡L¡, h¡wm¡cnz
323—-1j frz
324Se¡h N¡S£ ®hm¡ua ®q¡pe, ¢fa¡-jlýj Bhc¤m BEu¡m N¡S£, üš¡¢dL¡l£-®jp¡pÑ
325®hm¡ua ®e¢iNne, 175 nq£c eSl²m Cpm¡j pÈlZ£, ¢hSueNl, Y¡L¡, h¡wm¡cnz
326—-2u frz
3272u fr haÑj¡e ¢ejÀ ag¢pm h¢ZÑa Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 Smk¡el j¡¢mL J ®i¡N
328cMmc¡lz e¡e¡ L¡le B¢bÑL fËu¡Se ®cM¡ ®cJu¡u ¢a¢e Eš² pj¤âN¡j£ Smk¡e¢V
329(m¡Cp¾ppq) ¢hH²ul fËØa¡h L¢lm 1j fr ag¢pm h¢ZÑa S¡q¡S¢V H²ul BNËq fËL¡n
330Llez Aaxfl 1j J 2u frl jdÉ ¢hØa¡¢la Bm¡f-Bm¡Qe¡H²j ¢ejÀh¢ZÑa
331naÑp¡fr HC ¢hH²ul h¡ue¡ c¢mm p¢q ü¡r¢la quz
332naÑ¡hm£
3331) 1j J 2u fr phÑ pÇj¢aH²j ¢g¢nw S¡q¡S Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 Hl ¢hH²uj§mÉ
334¢edÑ¡lZ Lle 15,00,00,000/- (fel ®L¡¢V) V¡L¡z
3352) 2u fr ag¢pm h¢ZÑa Smk¡e¢V ¢hH²ul SeÉ h¡ue¡ h¡hc AcÉ 05/03/2013Cw
336a¡¢lM eNc 7,75,00,000/- (p¡a ®L¡¢V fyQ¡šl mr) V¡L¡ h¤¢Tu¡ f¡Cu¡ ag¢pm
337h¢ZÑa Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 pj¤âN¡j£ ¢g¢nw Smk¡e, ¢g¢nw m¡Cp¾p J Qm¡Qml
338Efk¤š² L¡NSfœpq ¢hH²ul h¡ue¡ c¢mm p¢q pÇf¡ce Llmez
339: 14 :
3403) 1j fr ag¢pm h¢ZÑa ¢g¢nw Smk¡e Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 Smk¡e¢Vl d¡kÑÉL«a
341j§mÉl jdÉ hLu¡ 7,25,00,000/- (p¡a ®L¡¢V fy¢Qn mr) V¡L¡ BN¡j£ 30 (¢œn)
342¢cel jdÉ fËc¡e Llhe HC jjÑ HC Q¥¢š²e¡j¡ p¢q p¡r¢la qm¡z
3434) 2u fr ag¢pm h¢ZÑa ¢g¢nw Smk¡e Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 Smk¡e¢Vl d¡kÑÉL«a
344¢hH²uj§mÉl jdÉ hLu¡ 7,25,00,000/- V¡L¡ h¤¢Tu¡ f¡Cu¡ Smk¡e¢V qØa¡¿¹ll
345k¡ha£u L¡NS¡c£ p¢q pÇf¡ce Llax Smk¡e¢V 1j fr hl¡hl h¤T¡Cu¡ ¢chez
3465) 2u fr ag¢p h¢ZÑa Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 Smk¡e¢V qØa¡¿¹ll f§hÑ a¡¢lM fkÑ¿¹
347e¡e¡¢hd ce¡/f¡Je¡ ®kje e¡¢hL/nË¢jL pwH²¡¿¹ ¢qp¡h ¢eØf¢špq f¢ln¡d Llhez
3486) 2u fr ag¢pm h¢ZÑa Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 Smk¡e¢V qØa¡¿¹ll f§hÑ a¡¢lM fkÑ¿¹
349S¡q¡S pwH²¡¿¹ ®k ®L¡e B¢bÑL c¡u-®ce¡, j¡jm¡, plL¡ll k¡ha£u Q¡SÑp CaÉ¡¢cl
350p¡¢hÑL c¡ui¡l NËqZ Llhe Hhw f¢ln¡d Llhez Hac¢hou 1j frl ®L¡e c¡u
351c¡¢uaÄ b¡¢Lh e¡z
3527) 2u fr Smk¡e¢V qØa¡¿¹ll f§hÑ Smk¡el p¤ÖWi¡h Qm¡Qml k¡ha£u j§m L¡NS¡c£
353Hhw Efk¤š² ®e¢iNneÉ¡m CL¥ÉCfj¾V Cei¾Vl£l j¡dÉj 1j fr hl¡hl h¤T¡Cu¡
354¢che h¡ h¡dÉ b¡¢Lhez
3558) 1j fr k¢c ag¢pm h¢ZÑa Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 Smk¡e¢Vl hLu¡ 7,25,00,000/-
356V¡L¡ BN¡j£ 30 (¢œn) ¢cel jdÉ f¢ln¡d hÉbÑ qe ah Aœ ¢hH²u h¡ue¡ c¢mm
357h¡¢am h¢mu¡ NZÉ qChz
3589) 2u fr AhnÉC hLu¡ V¡L¡ h¤¢Tu¡ f¡Cu¡ a¡l ¢eS MlQ ag¢pm h¢ZÑa Smk¡e¢Vl
359®l¢SÖVÊne, ¢g¢nw m¡Cp¾p J jvpÉ ¢nL¡ll Ae¤j¢apq pw¢nÔÖV cçll e¡e¡¢hd
360Ae¤j¢a pj§q q¡m-e¡N¡c L¢lu¡ Smk¡e¢V pÇf§ZÑ Q¡m¤ AhØq¡u 2u frl hl¡hl
361h¤T¡Cu¡ ¢chez
36210) Aœ c¢mml naÑ¡hm£ fràul AhaÑj¡e a¡q¡cl ®~hd Ju¡¢lnNZ j¡¢eu¡ Q¢ma h¡dÉ
363b¡¢Lhez
364ag¢pm
365…
366…
367…
36834. The further case of the Eden is that Eden and Belayet entered into the
369sale agreement for F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29 on 13.03.2013. The
370relevant portions of the said agreement is quoted below:
371: 15 :
372jvpÉ VÊm¡l Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 (m¡Cp¾ppq) Hl ¢hH²u c¢mm CXe ¢gn¡¢lS ¢mx Hl hÉhØq¡fe¡ f¢lQ¡mL Se¡h nM Bhc¤m q¡C h¡µQ¥, ¢fa¡-jlýj ®nM Bhc¤m q¡¢jc, j¡a¡-®nM Rhc¡ ®hNj, h¡s£ ew-2/2H, psL ew-4, ¢XJHCQHp (f¤l¡ae), he¡e£, Y¡L¡ LÉ¡¾Vej¾V, Y¡L¡, hup-60 hvpl, ®fn¡-hÉhp¡, djÑ-Cpm¡j, S¡a£ua¡h¡wm¡cn£z
373—-1j fr/c¢mm NËq£a¡ (H²a¡)z ®jp¡pÑ ®hm¡ua ®e¢iNne Hl üš¡¢dL¡l£ Se¡h N¡S£ ®hm¡ua ®q¡pe, ¢fa¡-jlýj Bhc¤m BEu¡m N¡S£, 175 nq£c eSl²m Cpm¡j pÈlZ£, ¢hSueNl, Y¡L¡, h¡wm¡cn, hup52 hvpl, ®fn¡-hÉhp¡, djÑ-Cpm¡j, S¡a£ua¡-h¡wm¡cn£z
374—-2u fr/c¢mm c¡a¡ (¢hH²a¡)z Aœ ¢hH²u c¢mm ¢ejÀ ag¢pml h¢ZÑa jvpÉ VÊm¡l Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 VÊm¡l (m¡Cp¾p pq) pÇf¤ZÑ Q¡m¤ J Ni£l pj¤â j¡R dl¡ AhØq¡u B¢j 2u fr üš¡¢dL¡l£ J ®~hd cMmc¡lz haÑj¡e Bj¡l hÉhp¡¢uL L¡lZ eNc V¡L¡l ¢hno fËu¡Se qJu¡u B¢j 2u fr ¢hH²a¡ Bj¡l cMm£u Eš² e¡j£u VÊm¡l (m¡Cp¾p pq) ¢hH²ul fËØa¡h L¢lm Bf¢e 1j fr ®H²a¡ a¡q¡ H²u L¢la pÇja qCm Eiul Bm¡Qe¡l j¡dÉj ¢e®jÀ h¢ZÑa n®aÑ Aœ ¢hH²u c¢mm pÇf¡ce L¢lm¡jz
375naÑ¡hm£
3761) 1j fr (®H²a¡) J 2u fr (¢hH²a¡) Eiul phÑ pÇj¢aH²j afn£m¡š² ¢g¢nw
377VÊm¡l Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 (m¡Cp¾p pq) Hl ¢hH²uj§mÉ 4,50,00,000/- (Q¡l
378®L¡¢V f•¡n mr) V¡L¡ ¢edÑ¡lZ quz
3792) agn£m h¢ZÑa ¢g¢nw VÊm¡l Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 (m¡Cp¾p pq) Hl d¡kÑL«a ¢hH²u
380j§mÉ 4,50,00,000/- (Q¡l ®L¡¢V f•¡n mr) V¡L¡ AcÉ 13/03/2013Cw a¡¢lM
381eNc j§mÉ pÇf§ZÑ V¡L¡ h¤¢Tu¡ f¡Cu¡ Eš² ¢hH²u c¢mm B¢j 2u fr (¢hH²a¡) J 1j
382fr (®H²a¡) p¢q pÇf¡ce Llm¡jz
3833) 2u fr ag¢pm h¢ZÑa ¢g¢nw VÊm¡l Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 (m¡Cp¾p pq) Bf¢e 1j
384fr (®H²a¡) L¡R qØa¡¿¹ll f§hÑ ®L¡e hÉ¢š² h¡ fË¢aÖW¡el ¢eLV hu ¢hH²u L¢l e¡C
385Hhw agn£m h¢ZÑa VÊm¡ll f§hÑl k¡ha£u c¡uce¡, hÉ¡wL GZ, h£j¡, h¾cll Q¡SÑ,
386VÊm¡ll nË¢jL J LjÑLaÑ¡l f¡Je¡ V¡L¡ Ju¡LÑnf ¢hm CaÉ¡¢c Af¢ln¡¢da c¡uce¡
387Bj¡l 2u frl/ ¢hH²a¡l ®ce¡ ¢qph NeÉ qCh Hhw Eš² c¡u ®ce¡ pÇf§ZÑ
388f¢ln¡d Lla B¢j phÑ¡hØq¡u h¡dÉ b¡¢Lhz
389: 16 :
3904) B¢j 2u fr h¡ ¢hH²a¡ A¡f¢e 1j frl L¡R Eš² VÊm¡l qØa¡¿¹ll f§hÑ ®L¡e
391hÉÉwL GZ, j¡R f¡¢VÑl c¡ce h¡ AeÉ ®L¡e fËL¡l c¡u ®ce¡ h¡ GZ CaÉ¡¢c e¡Cz k¢c
392L¢üeL¡m ®Lq c¡h£ Ll a¡q¡ B¢j 2u fr ¢hH²a¡ f¢ln¡d L¢lu¡ ¢ca h¡dÉ
393b¡¢Lhz
3945) B¢j 2u fr ¢hH²a¡ afn£m h¢ZÑa VÊm¡l¢V qØa¡¿¹ll f§hÑ VÊm¡l Øq£a pjØa
395j¡m¡j¡m Hhw VÊm¡l¢V pÇf§lÑ Q¡m¤ h¡ pQm AhØq¡u VÊm¡ll k¡ha£u plL¡l£ Ae¤j¢a
396fœ J c¢mm cØa¡hS Bf¢e 1j fr ®H²a¡l hl¡hl Cei¾Vl£ Ll h¤T¡Cu¡ ¢ca
397h¡dÉ b¡¢Lhz
3986) 2u fr AhnÉC afn£m h¢ZÑa VÊm¡l¢Vl l¢SÖVÊne, ¢g¢nw m¡Cp¾p, jvpÉ ¢nL¡ll
399Ae¤j¢apq pw¢nÔÖV cçl e¡e¡¢hd Ae¤j¢apj§q q¡me¡N¡c L¢lu¡ Eš² VÊm¡l¢V f¢lf§ZÑ
400m¡Cp¾p J ®l¢SÖVÊne pq Q¥¢š² pÇf¡cel 1(HL) j¡pl jdÉ h¤T¡Cu¡ ¢ca h¡dÉ
401b¡¢Lh Hhw Eš² L¡Sl k¡ha£u MlQ¡c£ AhnÉC 2u fr h¡ ¢hH²a¡ hqe L¢la
402h¡dÉ b¡¢Lhz
4037) agn£m h¢ZÑa ¢g¢nw VÊm¡l Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 (m¡Cp¾p pq) Hl ¢hH²u Q¥¢š²
404pÇf¡cel fl ¢hH²a¡ h¡ 2u frl ®L¡e ®~hd A¢m Ju¡¢lnNZ h¢ZÑa VÊm¡ll
405j¡¢mL¡e¡ h¡ m¡Cp¾p h¡ ®L¡e Awnl naÑ c¡¢h L¢la f¡¢lh e¡z L¢lm a¡
406phÑ¡c¡ma ANË¡qÉ qChz
4078) afn£m h¢ZÑa VÊm¡l Hg.¢i. ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 (m¡Cp¾p pq) Hl ®l¢SÖVÊne J ¢g¢nw
408m¡Cp¾p S¡l£ qJu¡ j¡œ a¡q¡ 2u fr (¢hH²a¡) 1j fr (®H²a¡) ®L¡Çf¡e£l e¡j
409Eš² VÊm¡ll j¡¢mL¡e¡ e¡j f¢lhaÑe Ll pw¢nÔÖV cçl 2u fr ¢hH²a¡ ¢eS MlQ
410L¢lu¡ ¢ca h¡dÉ b¡¢Lhz
411afn£m f¢lQu
412…
413…
414…
415HC Ll¡l Bjl¡ Eiu fràu afn£m h¢ZÑa VÊm¡ll ¢hH²u c¢mm f¡W L¢lu¡, h¤¢Tu¡,
416ü‘¡e, p¤Øq j¢Øaú, L¡q¡l¡ ¢he¡ fËl¡Qe¡u Eš² ¢hH²u c¢mm p¡r£NZll pÇj¤M
417ü¡rl Llm¡jz q~¢a-pe a¡¢lM-13-3-2013Cwz
41835. It is stated in para 9 of the plaint that the amount of Tk. 4,50,00,000
419mentioned in clause 1 of the agreement was a typographical error.
420Belayet actually received Tk. 15,00,000,00 from the Eden.
421: 17 :
42236. Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 (Belayet and Nahid) in their separate written
423statements categorically denied execution of the agreement for sale
424and the sale agreement. They adduced evidence in support of their
425case. Whether the agreements are genuine or false is a question of fact.
426The question is whether the plaintiff Eden’s suit, which is based on the
427sale agreement dated 13.03.2013, is barred by limitation.
428Criminal Case No. 324 of 2019:
42937. It is stated in the plaint of A.S. No. 26 of 2021 that on 06.03.2019, the
430plaintiff Eden filed C.R. Case No. 324 of 2019 under Sections 420,
431406, 405 of the Penal Code against the defendants. Police Bureau of
432Investigation (PBI) inquired into the case and submitted a report
433stating that F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29 had been registered in the name
434of the 1st defendant Belayet on 25.02.2018. The criminal case was
435withdrawn on 30.12.2019.
436PBI report dated 21.07.2019:
43738. It appears from ext. 3 series filed by the PW1 and ext. J(4) filed by the
438DW1 of A.S. No. 26 of 2021 that the PBI report dated 21.07.2019 was
439submitted before the learned Magistrate on 07.11.2019. The
440complainant (plaintiff Eden) filed a naraji petition. He was examined.
441The learned Magistrate directed the CID, Chattogram for further
442inquiry. The PBI stated in their report, “ac¿¹L¡m ¢g¢nw Smk¡e Hg,¢i
443¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 flhaÑ£a Jn¡e-3 Hl j¡¢mL¡e¡ k¡Q¡C Hl SeÉ Aœ¡¢gp pÈ¡lL… a¡¢lM-
44430/05/2019Cw j§m fœ ®fËlZ L¢lm… ¢fË¢¾pf¡m A¢gp¡l, ®e± h¡¢ZSÉ cçl… BNË¡h¡c,
445: 18 :
446Q–NË¡j Hl pÈ¡lL ew… a¡¢lMx 17/06/2019Cw j§m… ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, jvpÉ J fË¡¢Z pÇfc j¿»Z¡mul fœ ew… a¡¢lM 06/10/2013Cw Hl Ae¤j¢a fœ Ae¤k¡u£ S¡q¡S¢V Aœ cçl Na 25/02/2018Cw a¡¢lM Se¡h N¡S£ ®hm¡ua ®q¡pe…Hl e¡j ®l¢SÖVÊne Ll¡ quz flha£Ña Eš² Smk¡e¢V Hg.¢i Jn¡e-3 e¡j e¡jLlZ Ll¡l fl ¢a¢e S¡q¡S¢V Se¡h g¡lq¡c¤m qL … ¢eLV ¢hH²u Llez H²u ¢hH²ul d¡l¡h¡¢qLa¡u S¡q¡S¢Vl haÑj¡e j¡¢mL e¡¢qc Bš²¡l …z 13/03/13Cw a¡¢lM 3,00,00,000/- (¢ae ®L¡¢V) V¡L¡ pq phÑj¡V 15,00,00,000/(fel ®L¡¢V) V¡L¡ fËc¡e Lle jjÑ EõM L¢lmJ ac¿¹L¡m Eš² V¡L¡ f¢ln¡dl L¡e fËaÉr J fl¡r p¡rÉ fËj¡e f¡Ju¡ k¡u e¡C, Eš² ¢hou Aœ j¡jm¡l Bj-®j¡š²¡l j§m h¡c£ Bh¤m h¡p¡l N¡S£L Eš² V¡L¡ ®L¡e hÉ¡wL h¡ ®L¡e j¡dÉj fËc¡e L¢lu¡Re jjÑ ¢S‘¡p¡h¡c L¢lm ¢a¢e ®L¡e p¿¹¡oSeL Sh¡h ¢ca f¡le e¡C Hhw ®L¡e hÉ¡wL ®ØVVjÉ¡¾V h¡ c¡¢m¢mL p¡rÉ fËj¡e EfØq¡fe L¢la f¡le e¡Cz HC V¡L¡l ®mecel p¢qa Na 13/03/13Cw a¡¢lM 300/- V¡L¡l ØVÉ¡Çf ¢hH²u c¢mm Hhw 05/03/13Cw a¡¢lM 150/- V¡L¡l ØVÉ¡Çf fËØa¥aL«a h¡ue¡ c¢mml ®L¡e p¡j” f¡Ju¡ k¡u e¡Cz … fË¡ç L¡NSfœ fkÑ¡m¡Qe¡u Aœ j¡jm¡l h¡c£l CXe ¢gn¡l£S ¢mx fËL¡n CXe ¢g¢nw ¢mx Hl fr hÉhØq¡fe¡ f¢lQ¡mL ®nM Bhc¤m q¡C h¡µQ¥ ¢hh¡c£ N¡S£ ®hm¡ua ®q¡pe Hl ¢eLV qCa hÉ¡wL ®m¡e fËc¡el pju A¢m¢Ma M¡¢m ØVÉ¡Çf ü¡rl NËqZ L¢lu¡ ¢eS ®qg¡Sa l¡¢Mu¡ flha£Ña ¢hh¡c£l AS¡¿¹ h¡c£ ¢eSC Eš² M¡¢m ØVÉ¡Çf ¢hh¡c£l j¡¢mL¡e¡d£e pj¤â Smk¡e ¢hH²u Ll¡l c¢mm pªSe Lle Hhw ¢pe¤jQ¡C-29 haÑj¡e Jn¡e-3 S¡q¡S¢V h¡c£l ®qg¡SaC BR ¢hd¡u Eš² ¢hh¡c£l ¢hl²Ü h¡c£l Be£a A¢ik¡N cx ¢hx 406/420/506 d¡l¡l Afl¡d fË¡b¢jLi¡h fËj¡¢Za qu e¡Cz … h¡c£L j¡jm¡ ac¿¹l gm¡gm S¡e¡e¡ quRz
447: 19 :
448Eventually, the complainant filed an application for withdrawal of the
449complaint. The learned Magistrate accepted the withdrawal petition
450and disposed of the case on 30.12.2019.
451Title Suit No. 482 of 2020:
45239. It is further stated in the plaint that the plaintiff filed Title Suit No. 482
453of 2020 in the 1st Court of Joint District Judge, Dhaka for declaration
454of title of F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29 and for a direction upon the
455defendants to register the vessel in the name of the plaintiff and to
456return the documents of ownership. Since the suit was filed in the
457wrong forum, the same was withdrawn. The statements are not correct.
458The suit was filed on 21.09.2020 (ext. 5 filed by PW1 of A.S. No. 22
459of 2021). The plaintiff did not deposit the requisite Court fees and did
460not take any steps. Accordingly, the Court below rejected the suit, vide
461order No. 7 dated 01.03.2021, which was fixed for depositing the
462Court fees (ext. L filed by DW1 of A.S. No. 26 of 2021).
463Article 113 of the Limitation Act, 1908:
46440. Under Article 113 of the Limitation Act, as it stands now, the period
465of limitation for filing a suit for specific performance of contract is
4661(one) year which begins to run from the date fixed for the
467performance, or, if no such date is fixed, when the plaintiff has notice
468that performance is refused. Earlier, the period of limitation was
4693(three) years which was substituted by 1(one) year by the Limitation
470(Amendment) Act, 2004 [w.e.f. 01.07.2005].
471: 20 :
472Clauses 6 and 8 of the Sale Agreement dated 13.03.2013:
47341. Clause 6 of the sale agreement dated 13.03.2013 required the 1st
474defendant Belayet to update the registration, fishing licence, fishing
475permit and other related permits for F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29 from the
476concerned government office and to hand over those to the plaintiff
477Eden within a period of 1(one) month from the date of execution of
478the agreement.
479Clause 8 of the agreement dated 13.03.2013 required the 1st defendant
480Belayet to change the ownership of F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29 in favour
481of the plaintiff Eden once the registration and fishing licence of the
482said vessel are issued.
48342. 1st defendant Belayet imported F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29 in late 2011 to
484replace her with F.V. Ocean-3. When the sale agreement for F.V.
485SINNUMCHAI-29 was entered into on 13.03.2013, F.V. Ocean-3 was
486kept in mortgage with the BASIC bank of which Sheikh Abdul Hai
487Bachchu was the Chairman (cross-examination of PW1 by 2nd
488defendant). Mortgage discharge certificate was issued on 2.09.2014.
489Shiekh Abdul Hai Bachchu executed the sale agreement on behalf of
490the plaintiff Eden. As such, he was fixed with either actual or
491constructive/ imputed notice of the law that unless F.V. Ocean-3 is
492scrapped, F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29 cannot be registered. M.V. Ocean-3
493was scrapped on 25.01.2015. Therefore, there was factual and legal
494impediment to execute clause 6.
495: 21 :
49643. Clause 8 of the sale agreement dated 13.03.2013 did not fix any time
497for performance. In the PBI’s report dated 21.07.2019, it is
498categorically stated that the fishing vessel in question was registered in
499the name of the 1st defendant Belayet on 25.02.2018. Belayet then sold
500her to one Mr. Farhadul Huq who then sold the same to the 2nd
501defendant Nahid Akhter. The PBI report was given to the plaintiff
502Eden and the same was submitted before the learned Magistrate on
50307.11.2019. The report was based on documents supplied to the
504inquiry officer by the concerned government offices. The plaintiff
505Eden was aware of the report on or before 07.11.2019. The plaint is
506silent as to whether Eden gave any notice to the 1st defendant Belayet
507to execute and register the fishing vessel in their name as per clause 8.
508Rather, it is stated in para 17 of the plaint that the cause of action to
509file the suit arose on 08.06.2021 when the 2nd defendant Nahid sent a
510legal notice to the plaintiff Eden claiming ownership of the vessel and
511demanded hand over of the possession of the same to her. PW1 stated
512in examination-in-chief and in cross-examination that till 2020 the
513plaintiff Eden gave several notices, both verbally and in writing, to the
514defendants to transfer the ownership and register the vessel in their
515name. PW1 deposed that they sent a letter to the defendants in 2017 by
516post, but PW1 did not produce any evidence to corroborate his
517deposition. Moreover, PW1 introduced new facts which were not
518stated in the plaint and as such, those are not admissible in evidence.
519: 22 :
52044. Since the plaintiff Eden did not serve any notice to the defendants for
521performance of the sale agreement, the cause of action, in my view,
522arose on 21.07.2019 which is the date of the PIB’s report or on
52307.11.2019 when the report was submitted before the learned
524Magistrate. The plaintiff, by then, had not only notice that the
525defendants had refused to perform the sale agreement but also the fact
526that they had breached the agreement by selling the vessel to a third
527party. In Md. Ashiq vs. Tauqir Shahid, PLD 1998 Lah. 444, it was
528held that where no evidence was led to prove any actual date of refusal
529to execute the sale deed, defendants’ conduct of selling land in
530question in favour of the vendee (defendants) could be assumed to be
531refusal on their part.
53245. For the purpose of computing the limitation period under Article 113,
533I accept that the date of plaintiff Eden’s notice that performance was
534refused is 07.11.2019. The plaint was admitted for hearing on
53523.06.2021. The prescribed period of limitation under Article 113 is
5361(one) year. Meanwhile, the plaintiff filed Title Suit No. 482 of 2020
537on 21.09.2020 for the same cause of action which was rejected on
53801.03.2021. Now, the question is whether the plaintiff would get
539benefit of Section 14(1) of the Limitation Act. Section 14(1) is quoted
540below:
541“14. (1) In computing the period of limitation prescribed
542for any suit, the time during which the plaintiff has been
543prosecuting with due diligence another civil proceeding,
544whether in a Court of first instance or in a Court of appeal,
545: 23 :
546against the defendant, shall be excluded, where the
547proceeding is founded upon the same cause of action and is
548prosecuted in good faith in a Court which, from defect of
549jurisdiction, or other cause of a like nature, is unable to
550entertain it”. (emphasis supplied)
55146. The key words in Section 14 are- ‘due diligence’, ‘good faith’, ‘defect
552of jurisdiction or other cause of a like nature’. ‘Good faith’ includes,
553under Section 2(7) of the Limitation Act, ‘due care and attention’. The
554relevant order No. 7 dated 01.03.2021 passed by the Court below in
555Title Suit No. 482 of 2020 runs as follows:
556"07… 01/03/2021… AcÉ ®L¡VÑ ¢g c¡¢Mml SeÉ ¢ce d¡kÑÉ BRz h¡c£ fr [Eden
557Fisheries] ®L¡e ach£l NËqZ Ll e¡C h¡ ®L¡e ®L¡VÑ ¢g c¡¢Mm Ll e¡Cz
558c¢Mm¡jz
559Aœ ®j¡LŸj¡l BlS£ fkÑ¡m¡Qe¡ L¢lm¡jz AcÉ h¡c£fr ®L¡e ach£l NËqZ Ll e¡Cz h¡c£
560fËu¡Se£u ®L¡VÑ ¢g c¡¢Mm e¡ Ll¡u Aœ ®j¡LŸj¡¢V M¡¢lS ®k¡NÉz
561AaHh,
562Bcn qu ®k,
563h¡c£ Aœ ®j¡LŸj¡u ®L¡VÑ ¢g c¡¢Mm e¡ Ll¡u M¡¢lS Ll¡ qm¡"z
564In Vijay Kumar Rampal vs. Diwan Devi, AIR 1985 (SC) 1669, the
565Indian Supreme Court observed:
566“The expression “good faith” qualifies prosecuting the
567proceeding in the Court which ultimately is found to have
568no jurisdiction. Failure to pay the requisite Court fee
569found deficient which was ultimately found to have no
570jurisdiction has absolutely nothing to do with the question
571of good faith in prosecuting the suit as provided in
572Section 14 of the Limitation Act”.
57347. The above-quoted ratio squarely applies to the instant case. Therefore,
574the plaintiff Eden is not entitled to the benefit of Section 14(1) of the
575: 24 :
576Limitation Act. The plaintiff’s conduct should also be taken into consideration. They claim to have entered into the sale agreement on 13.03.2013 but the contesting defendants deny execution of the agreement and claim it to be forged and fabricated. The case of the defendants is not relevant to determine the question of limitation. The plaintiff’s case, taken in its entirety and as it is, reveals that when the agreement was made, it was not factually and legally possible for the 1st defendant Belayet to perform the agreement for the reason that F.V. Ocean-3, with which F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29 was to be replaced, was kept in mortgage with the bank. The plaintiff was aware of it. Until the plaintiff filed the criminal case in March, 2019, they did not take any steps to perform the agreement e.g., giving notice to the 1st defendant or applying to the concerned authorities for registration of fishing vessel etc., which they, as a matter of fact, never did. After obtaining the PBI’s report, which stated that no offence as alleged was committed and that the sale agreement was false and fabricated, the plaintiff withdrew the criminal case. They then filed a civil suit but the same was rejected on 01.03.2021 for not depositing the requisite Court fees. After receipt of the legal notice dated 08.06.2021 sent by the 2nd defendant Nahid and admission of A.S. No. 22 of 2021 on 16.06.2021 filed by Nahid, the plaintiff Eden filed the instant A.S. No. 26 of 2021 on 22.06.2021 which was admitted for hearing on 23.06.2021. The instant suit, so far as it relates to specific performance of the agreement, is clearly barred by limitation under Article 113 of the
577: 25 :
578Limitation Act which provides 1 year (before 01.07.2005 it was 3
579years) period of limitation to file the suit.
58048. According to the plaintiff Eden’s case, they did not acquire any title
581and ownership in the fishing vessel based on the sale agreement. They
582will acquire title only when their prayer for specific performance of
583contract is allowed and the vessel is registered in their name. Since
584their case for specific performance of the contract is time barred, the
585question of ownership and title of the vessel in their favour does not
586arise. The prayer for declaration of title and ownership is
587misconceived.
58849. Mr. Md. Monowar Hossain, learned Advocate appearing for the
589plaintiff, argues that since the 1st defendant Belayet paid the full
590consideration money and the plaintiff Eden got possession of F.V.
591SINNUMCHAI-29, the plaintiff is entitled to the protection of S.53A
592of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (T.P. Act) and Article 113 of the
593Limitation Act has no manner of application to the case. Learned
594Advocate refers to the cases reported in 14 DLR (1962) 663 and 38
595DLR (1986) 240. Suffice it to say that the doctrine of part performance
596incorporated in Section 53A of the T.P. Act applies only to immovable
597property, whereas the subject matter of the instant suit is movable
598property. Therefore, Section 53A of the T.P. Act and the reported
599cases have no manner of application to the plaintiff Eden’s case. A.S.
600No. 26 of 2021 is dismissed as being barred by limitation.
601: 26 :
602A.S. No. 22 of 2021 (Nahid Akhter vs. Eden Fisheries Ltd. and
603others) :
60450. The case of the plaintiff, as stated in the plaint, is that Belayet sold
605F.V. Ocean-3 to Farhadul Haque, proprietor of M/S Silver Coin
606Shipping. Plaintiff Nahid purchased it from Farhadul and became
607owner of the vessel. Earlier, the previous owner Belayet obtained loan
608facility from the bank and the Managing Director of the defendant
609Eden obtained signature of Belayet on blank non-judicial stamp papers
610and created two fabricated sale deeds showing sale of F.V. Ocean-3 to
611Eden [first deed was agreement for sale dated 05.03.2013 and second
612deed was sale agreement dated 13.03.2013]. On verbal understanding,
613Belayet allowed the defendant Eden to operate the vessel upon
614payment of money per month but the defendant did not pay any
615money to the previous owner as well as to the plaintiff and retained the
616possession of the vessel. Finally, the plaintiff served a legal notice
617dated 08.06.2021 to the defendant to handover the possession of the
618vessel and to pay the plaintiff money due to her but the defendant did
619not comply with the notice and hence, the suit.
62051. The principal defendant Eden in their written statement and additional
621written statement denied the plaintiff’s case. Their case is same as that
622of the plaint of A.S. No. 26 of 2021 filed by them.
623Prayers made in plaint:
62452. The plaintiff made the following prayers:
625: 27 :
626(i) declaration of title and ownership of the fishing vessel F.V.
627Ocean-3 (previously F.V. SINNUMCHAI-29);
628(ii) direction upon the 1st defendant Eden to pay BDT 4,00,000,00
629(four crore) and a sum of BDT 8,00,000 (eight lac) per month
630from July, 2021 with interest; and
631(iii) direction upon the 1st defendant Eden to handover the possession
632of F.V. Ocean-3 to the plaintiff.
63353. In respect of the prayer (i) i.e. declaration of title and ownership of the
634fishing vessel, Section 389(1) of the Merchant Shipping Ordinance,
6351983 is recalled which provides that the Register is the conclusive
636evidence that the person entered therein is the owner of the vessel
637(para 11). The Registrar of Bangladesh Ships has confirmed in writing
638that the name of the plaintiff Nahid has been entered in the Register as
639the owner of the vessel. The Register has sent relevant documents to
640this Court which corroborate the Registrar’s confirmation. The
641documents have been declared by this Court as admissible evidence
642under Rule 57 of the Admiralty Rules, 1912. The contesting defendant
643Eden did not challenge those documents (para 17-19). Documentary
644evidence have proved that the vessel replacement as well as change of
645ownership procedure of the vessel were followed and complied with in
646accordance with law. Therefore, the plaintiff Nahid is entitled to the
647declaration in terms of prayer (i).
64854. In respect of the prayer (iii) i.e. handover of possession of the vessel,
649admittedly, the defendant Eden is in possession of the same. They are
650: 28 :
651not owners of the vessel. The defendant did not produce any document
652to show that they have retained the possession of the vessel based on
653any valid document. Therefore, they are legally bound to handover the
654possession of the vessel to the plaintiff.
65555. In respect of the prayer (ii) i.e. claim of money from the defendant
656Eden, suffice it to say that the plaintiff Nahid purchased the vessel
657from Farhadul who purchased it from Belayet. Plaint case is that while
658Belayet was the registered owner of the vessel, he verbally allowed
659Eden to operate the vessel on payment of money. During the said
660verbal arrangement between Belayet and Eden, the plaintiff Nahid had
661no right, title and interest in the vessel. She was not even a party to the
662verbal arrangement. As far as claim of money is concerned, Nahid
663may claim money against Farhadul based on the sale contract entered
664into between them under clause 4 of which Farhadul was contractually
665obliged to handover the possession of the vessel to the buyer Nahid.
666Neither Farhadul nor Belayet has been made defendant in the suit.
667Therefore, the prayer (ii) fails.
668Orders:
66956. Admiralty Suit No. 22 of 2021 is allowed and decreed in part in terms
670of prayers (i) and (iii). It is declared that the plaintiff Nahid Akhter is
671the owner of the fishing vessel F.V. Ocean-3, registration No. F
67211127. She has the title to the said vessel. The principal defendant
673Eden Fisheries Ltd. is directed to handover the possession of the
674: 29 :
675vessel F.V. Ocean-3 to the plaintiff within a period of 30(thirty) days
676from the date of receipt of the judgment. The prayer (ii) is dismissed.
67757. Admiralty Suit No. 26 of 2021 is dismissed as being by limitation.
67858. No order as to costs.
679Mazhar, BO
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











