Appellate Division
Md. Abdur Rashid v A.B.M. Yousuf Abdullah and others
Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal 901/2018 · Decided 22 January 2023
Two petitions for leave to appeal reached the Appellate Division, one by respondents to the writ and one by third-party buyers of part of the land. The Zonal Settlement Officer had issued a notice dated 28.09.2014 directing the parties to appear on 14.10.2014 for an inquiry under rule 42A of the State Acquisition and Tenancy Rules, 1955, which allows a Revenue Officer to look into fraudulent entries in the record-of-rights before final publication. The writ petitioners did not appear and instead challenged the notice. The High Court Division made the Rule absolute on 16.10.2017 and directed final publication of the City Survey Khatians. The Appellate Division noted that the record-of-rights had not been finally published and fraud had been specifically alleged. It held that the officer acted within the rule and that the High Court Division erred in interfering while the writ petitioners could still appear and produce documents. Both petitions were disposed of and the High Court Division's judgment was set aside.
Petitions disposed of; High Court Division judgment set aside
- High Court Division (HCD)The lower of the two Divisions of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh, which hears writs, appeals, revisions, bail matters and some original cases.Read the full explanation →
- Set asideTo cancel an earlier court order, decree, award, sale or conviction so that it no longer has legal effect, usually by a higher court or by the same court on a proper application.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether the High Court Division could, in writ jurisdiction, strike down a Zonal Settlement Officer's notice calling the parties to appear in an inquiry into alleged fraud in the draft record-of-rights.
- The delay in filing Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No. 1466 of 2022 was condoned.
- The record-of-rights had admittedly not been finally published, and since a specific allegation of fraud had been made, the Zonal Settlement Officer could examine whether the earlier order was procured by fraud.
- The officer had merely issued a notice directing the parties to appear with their papers, and the writ petitioners filed the writ petition without appearing before him.
- Rule 42A of the State Acquisition and Tenancy Rules, 1955 authorises a Revenue Officer with additional designation of Settlement Officer to inquire into fraud before final publication, so the officer acted within his jurisdiction.
- The High Court Division erred in interfering at a stage when the writ petitioners had ample opportunity to appear and produce documents, and its judgment in Writ Petition No. 9876 of 2014 was set aside.
Zonal Settlement Officer simply issued a notice directing the parties to appear before him with their respective papers. The writ petitioners, without appearing before the said Officer, directly filed the instant writ petition
In the court’s own words.
Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal 901/2018, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 10 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2APPELLATE DIVISION
3PRESENT:
4Mr. Justice Hasan Foez Siddique
5Chief Justice
6Mr. Justice M. Enayetur Rahim
7Mr. Justice Jahangir Hossain CIVIL PETITION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL NOS.901 OF 2018 with C.P.1466 of 2022.
8(From the judgment and order dated 16.10.2017 passed by the High Court Division in Writ Petition No.9876 of 2014.)
9Md. Abdur Rashid and others : Petitioners.
10(In C.P.901/18) Syed Sohrawardi and another : Petitioners.
11(In C.P.1466/22)
12=Versus= A.B.M. Yousuf Abdullah and others : Respondents.
13(In both the cases) For the Petitioners : Mr.A.M. Aminuddin, Senior (In C.P. 901/2018) Advocate, instructed by Mr.
14Md. Helal Amin, Advocate-on-
15Record.
16For the Petitioners : Mr. Probir Neogi, Senior (In C.P. 1466/2022) Advocate, instructed by
17Mrs. Madhumaloti Chowdhury
18Barua, Advocate-on-Record. For the Respondent No.1-5: Mr. Mr. Abdul Wadud Bhuiya, (In C.P.901/18) Senior Advocate with Mr.
19Md. Nurul Amin, Senior
20Advocate and Mr. M. Qumrul
21Hoque Siddique, Advocate,
22instructed by Mr. Bivash
23Chandra Biswas,
24Advocate-on-Record. Respondent Nos.6-11: Not represented (In C.P.901/18)
25Respondents : Not represented (In C.P.1466/22)
26Date of hearing and judgment : 22-01-2023
27JUDGMENT Hasan Foez Siddique, C. J: The delay in filing in Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No.1466 of 2022 is condoned.
28These two civil petitions for leave to appeal have been filed against the common judgment and order dated 16.10.2017 passed by the High Court Division in Writ Petition No.9876 of 2014 making the Rule absolute and directing the Land Survey Department to make final publication of the City Survey Khatians in respect of case khatian.
29The respondent Nos.1-5, A.B.M.Yousuf Abdullah and others filed aforesaid writ petition challenging the notice issued under Memo No.31.03.2600.022.16.002.14 dated 28.09.2014 under the signature of the Charge Officer and Investigating Officer, Dhaka Zonal Settlement Office (writ respondent No.4) directing the parties of the Appeal Nos.4489644901 of 2001 to appear with the documents on 14.10.2014 before him. The contents of the said notification dated 28.09.2014 were as under:
30ÒMYcªRvZš¿x evsjv‡`k miKvi
31‡Rvbvj †m‡Uj‡g›U Awdmv‡ii Kvh©vjq, XvKv
3228, knx` ZvRDwÏb Avng` m¥ibx
33‡ZRMvuI, XvKv-1208|
34d¨v∙ -9125423
35email-zsodhaka@gmail.com m¥viK bs-31.03.2600.022.16.002.14 ZvwiLt 28/09/2014 wLªt
36‡bvwUk
‡Rvbvj †m‡Uj‡g›U Awdmvi XvKv g‡nv`‡qi 24/08/2014 wLªt Zvwi‡Li 3103.26.00.022.46.001.14-458 bs m¥viKv‡`k †gvZv‡eK ¸jkvb _vbvaxb 15bs fvUviv †gŠRvi 44896/2001 n‡Z 44910/2001bs Avcxj gvgjvi iv‡qi wei“‡× Rbve †gvt Avãyi iwk` Ms Gi `vwLjK…Z cybt ïbvbxi Av‡e`‡bi wel‡q Z`š— AvMvgx 14/10/2014 wLªt ZvwiL mKvj 11.00 NwUKvq wbg¥ ¯^v¶iKvixi Awdm K‡¶ AbywôZ n‡e| mswk ó mKj‡K cª‡qvRbxq KvMRcÎvw`mn h_vmg‡q Dcw¯nZ _vKvi Rb¨ Aby‡iva Kiv n‡jv|
37¯^vt
38(†gvt †gvwgbyi ikx`)
39PvR© Awdmvi
40I
41Z`š—Kvix Kg©KZ©v
42‡Rvbvj †m‡Uj‡g›U Awdm, XvKv |Ó
43Against said notification, the writ petitioners, filing the aforesaid writ petition, obtained Rule.
44The leave petitioners (respondent No.5) of Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No.901 of 2018 and writ respondent Nos.8-10 appeared in the said writ petition and filed Affidavit-inOpposition.
45The High Court Division, by the impugned judgment and order dated 16.10.2017, made the said Rule absolute.
46Then the writ respondent No.5 Md. Abdur Rashid and 3 others filed Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No.901 of 2018 and third party
namely, Syed Sohrawardi and another filed Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No.1466 of 2022 in this Division.
47Mr. A.M. Aminuddin, learned Senior Advocate appearing for the petitioners in Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No. 901 of 2018, submits that they purchased the disputed land by separate registered sale deeds and have been possessing the same upon mutating their names and paying rent to the Government regularly. He submits that C.S., S.A. and R.S. khatians were duly prepared in the names of their predecessors and that the writ petitionerrespondents obtained an order in appeal by practising fraud. He submits that since there was specific allegation of fraud in the applications, the High Court Division erred in law in making the Rule absolute and declaring the notification unlawful.
48Mr. Probir Neogi, learned Senior Advocate appearing for the third party leave petitioners in Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No.1466 of 2022, submits that leave petitioners of this petition purchased .38 acre of land from one Narayan by two sale deeds No.12500 and 12501
dated 24.09.2000 from C.S. and S.A. khatian No.105 and 115 respectively and plots No.2375, the High Court Division erroneously made the Rule absolute, consequently, these two petitioners have been prejudiced seriously. He submits that after purchasing the aforesaid land, the leave petitioners of this petition mutated their names in the khatian from the office of the Assistant Commissioner of Land, Tejgaon, Dhaka in Namjari O Jomabhagh Case No.10302 of 2001 on 22.07.2001 and they also mutated their names in the khatian in NamjariO- Jomabhagh Case No.18819 of 2005 dated 27.12.2005 and paid rent to the Government, the High Court Division erred in law in making the Rule absolute in respect of their portion of their land.
49Mr. Abdul Wadud Bhuiya, learned Senior Advocate appearing with Mr. Md. Nurul Amin, learned Senior Advocate and Mr. Qumrul Huq Siddique, learned Advocate for the respondents in both the petitions in their submissions supported the judgment and order of the High Court Division.
50From the impugned notice dated 28.09.2014 as quoted above, it appears that at the instance of Zonal Settlement Officer, Dhaka, Charge Officer and Investigating Officer, issued the aforesaid letter for further hearing and communicated the said letter for holding inquiry on 14.10.2014. The writ petitioner respondents challenged the same without appearing before the concerned office.
51It further appears from the materials on record that on the basis of the application dated 21.07.2014 Zonal Settlement Officer issued a notice for holding inquiry under the provision of Rule 42A of the State Acquisition and Tenancy Rules, 1955 to ascertain as to whether any fraud has been committed in making entry of draft record-of-rights or not. The contents of the said notice were as follows.
52ÒMYcªRvZš¿x evsjv‡`k miKvi
53‡Rvbvj †m‡Uj‡g›U Awdmv‡ii Kvh©vjq, XvKv
5428, knx` ZvRDwÏb Avng` m¥ibx
55‡ZRMvuI, XvKv-1208| m¥viK bs-31.03.2600.022.46.001.14-458 ZvwiLt 24/08/2014 wLªt welqt 1955 m‡bi cªRvZ¯^Z¡ wewagvjvi 42K wewai †Kvb Dcv`vb Av‡Q wKbv Zv hvuPvB A‡š— cªwZ‡e`b `vwLj| m~Ît Rbve ‡gvt Avãyi iwk` Gi 21/07/14 wLªt Zvwi‡Li `vwLjK…Z Av‡e`b|
56Dchy³ welq I m~‡Î cªvß Rbve †gvt Avãyi iwk`, mvs-12/O/1, k¨vgjx, moK02, XvKv Gi XvKv wmwU Rwi‡ci ¸jkvb avbvaxb 15bs fvUviv †gŠRvi 44896/2001
n‡Z 44901/2001 bs †gvU 06 wU Avwcj gvgjvi iv‡qi Amg¥wZ‡Z 1955 m‡bi cªRv¯^Z¡ wewagvjvi 42K wewa g‡Z ïbvbxi g~j Av‡e`bmn Avbymw½K KvMRcÎ G mv‡_ †cªiY Kiv n‡jv|
5702| gnvcwiPvjK, f~wg †iKW© I Rwic Awa`ßi g‡nv`‡qi 14/7/2010wLªt Zvwi‡Li f~t †i./75/2009/2001bs ¯^vi‡K cªRv¯^Z¡ wewagvjv-1955 Gi 42K I L wewai cª‡qvM m¤ú‡K© †m‡Uj‡g›U Awdmvi/†Rvbvj †m‡Uj‡g›U Awdmvi eivei RvixK…Z wb‡`©kbvi Av‡jv‡K Av‡e`bKvixi Av‡e`‡bi wel‡q 1955 m‡bi cªRv¯^Z¡ wewagvjv AbymiYiZ wbg¥ ewb©Z Z_¨mn my¯có gZvgZmn cªwZ‡e`b `vwL‡ji Rb¨ Aby‡iva Kiv n‡jv|
58K) mswk ó †gŠRvi wWwc, AvcwË I Avcxj ïbvbx Pjvi mgqKvj|
59L)`vexK…Z Rwgi gvwjKvbv cªvwßi Drm
601| ˆcwÎK
612| µqm~‡Î (g~j `wj‡ji d‡UvKwc) `wj‡ji ‡cªw¶‡Z wgD‡Uk‡bi
62Kwc|
633| Ab¨vb¨|
64M) nvj m‡bi f~wg Dbœqb Ki cwi‡kv‡ai Kwc|
65N) m‡iRwg‡b `Lj cªwZ‡e`b (PZzc©vk¡¯’ `vM D‡j L KiZ †¯‹Pg¨vcmn)|
6603| cªwZ‡e`‡bi mv‡_ g~j Av‡e`b I AvbymswMK KvMRcÎ cªZ¨c©Y‡hvM¨| mshy³t 144 d`©| ¯^vt A¯có
6724/8/14
68(gynvg¥` Iqvwn`y¾vgvb)
69‡Rvbvj †m‡Uj‡g›U Awdmvi (AwZt `vwqZ¡)
70XvKv|
71‡dvbt (02)9131573 Rbve †gvt †gvwgbyi ikx` PvR© Awdmvi ‡Rvbvj †m‡Uj‡g›U Awdm, XvKv|Ó
72Thereafter, by the impugned notice dated 28.09.2014, it was directed to the parties to appear before the Zonal Settlement Officer on 14.10.2014. Rule 41, 42A of the State
Acquisition and Tenancy Rules, 1955 authorized the Revenue Officer to hold enquiry to ascertain as to whether any fraud has been committed in making entry in record-of-right or not and such application should be filed before final publication of the record-of-rights. The said provision run as follows:
73“42A. Correction of fraudulent entry
74before final publication of record-of-
75rights- The Revenue Officer, with the
76additional designation of ‘Settlement
77Officer’ shall, on receipt of an
78application or on receipt of an official
79report for the correction of an entry that
80has been procured by fraud in record-of-
81rights before final publication thereof,
82after consulting relevant records and
83making such other enquiries as he deems
84necessary, direct excision of the
85fraudulent entry and his act in doing so
86shall not be open to appeal. At the same
87time, the Revenue-Officer shall make the
88correct entry after giving the parties
89concerned a hearing and recording his
90finding in a formal proceeding for the
91purpose of future reference.”
92Admittedly, record-of-right in the instant case, has not yet been published finally. Since petitioner Abdur Rashid brought specific allegations that the writ petitioners procured
the order by practising fraud, the Revenue Officer with the additional designation of Settlement Officer can examine as to whether such order has been procured by practising fraud or not.
93The instant case, it appears that the Zonal Settlement Officer simply issued a notice directing the parties to appear before him with their respective papers. The writ petitioners, without appearing before the said Officer, directly filed the instant writ petition and obtained Rule which was finally made absolute.
94Since the law authorizes the Revenue officer with additional designation of settlement officer to hold inquiry to ascertain as to whether any fraud had been committed in procuring entry for preparation of the recordof-rights before final publication or not, we are of the view, that the said Office acted in its jurisdiction as conferred under the Rule 42A of the State Acquisition Rules, 1955 rightly, the High Court Division erred in law in interfering with the matter at the stage when the writ petitioners have ample opportunity to appear before the Zonal
Settlement Officer and to produce documents to justify their claims.
95Accordingly, we find substance both the petitions.
96Thus, both the petitions are disposed of.
97The judgment and order dated 16.10.2017 passed by the High Court Division in Writ Petition No.9876 of 2014 is hereby set aside.
98C. J.
99J.
100J. The •22nd January, 2023.
101halim/ words-1625 /
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











