High Court Division
Zakir Hossain Rony v Monir Hossain Raju and others
Civil Revision 3209/2024 · Decided 17 June 2026
The plaintiff sued for partition of land and structures in Dhaka, stating the shares of himself and defendants 1 to 4 as heirs of their predecessor. The defendants admitted the plaintiff's case and the stated shares in full and applied for judgment on admission. The plaintiff, who was represented, raised no objection, and the Joint District Judge passed a preliminary decree under Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The plaintiff appealed and sought to amend the plaint to raise hotchpot and mortgage issues, but the appeal was dismissed. In revision, the High Court Division held that a litigant cannot approbate and reprobate: having obtained a decree on his own pleadings, he could not claim his suit was defective. The proposed matters were unnecessary to decide the suit and were the subject of another suit. Partition is not a transfer, so any encumbrance continues to attach. No fraud was alleged, and the Rule was discharged.
Rule discharged
- Q1
Whether a plaintiff who obtained a preliminary decree for partition on admission, exactly in terms of his own plaint, could challenge it in appeal and revision.
- Q2
Whether the appellate court erred in dismissing the appeal without separately disposing of the plaintiff's application to amend the plaint.
- Q3
Whether an alleged mortgage liability or the omission of other properties barred a preliminary decree for partition.
- Where defendants clearly admit the plaintiff's case and shares and the plaintiff raises no objection, the court may properly pass a preliminary decree for partition under Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
- A party cannot take one position before the trial court and, after obtaining a decree on that basis, take an inconsistent position on appeal or revision.
- The rule requiring inclusion of all joint properties in a partition suit is not inflexible, and whether omission is fatal depends on the facts of each case.
- An amendment raising matters not necessary to decide the controversy, and already the subject of a separate suit, neither advances justice nor assists the court.
- Partition is not a transfer of property; it demarcates pre-existing rights, so any lawful encumbrance continues to attach and is no ground to refuse a preliminary decree.
- A decree passed on admitted facts, with no allegation of fraud, misrepresentation, collusion or concealment, cannot be faulted.
A party cannot be permitted to assume one position before the trial Court and after obtaining a decree on that basis assume a completely inconsistent position before the appellate and revisional Courts merely because the outcome no longer suits his convenience.
In the court’s own words.
Civil Revision 3209/2024, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 12 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
Bench:
Mr. Justice Md. Ali Reza
Civil Revision No. 3209 of 2024
Zakir Hossain Rony
……petitioner
-Versus-
Monir Hossain Raju and others
……opposite parties
Mr. M. Ashraf Ali, Advocate
……for the petitioner
Mr. Ali Imam Khaled Rahim with
Mr. A.H.M. Obaydul Kabir, Advocates
……for the opposite parties
Heard on: 10.06.2026, 14.06.2026 and
16.06.2026
Judgment on: 17.06.2026
1In the instant revision Rule was issued calling upon the opposite parties 1-4 to show cause as to why the judgment and decree dated 01.04.2024 passed by the Additional District Judge, Court No. 8, Dhaka in Title Appeal Number 143 of 2023 dismissing the appeal thereby affirming the judgment and decree dated 08.11.2022 passed by the Joint District Judge, 3rd Court, Dhaka in Title Suit Number 171 of 2020 should not be set aside and/or such other or further order or orders be passed as to this Court may seem fit and proper.
2The petitioner as plaintiff filed Title Suit Number 171 of 2000 on 02.10.2020 in the Court of Joint District Judge, 3rd
Court, Dhaka seeking partition of the land measuring .1089 acres together with the structures standing thereon as described in the schedule to the plaint.
3The case of the plaintiff in short is that late Abdul Wahab alias Naushad acquired title to the suit property by six registered deeds executed on different dates and upon his death left the plaintiff and defendants 1-4 as his heirs. According to the plaintiff he became owner of 14/48 share equivalent to .0318 acres of the suit property and has been possessing the same jointly with the defendants. The plaintiff further stated that defendant 1 is entitled to 14/48 share equivalent to .0318 acres and defendants 2 and 3 are each entitled to 7/48 share equivalent to .0159 acres and defendant 4 is entitled to 1/8 share equivalent to .0136 acres of the suit property and the building standing thereon. Since the defendants allegedly refused to partition the property upon demand the plaintiff filed the suit.
4Defendants 1-4 entered appearance and filed a written statement. In the written statement the defendants admitted the entire case of the plaintiff. They specifically admitted the quantum of shares as stated in the plaint and further stated that they have no objection if a preliminary decree for partition is
passed according to the shares mentioned by the plaintiff. They also deposited the requisite court fees in respect of their sahams.
5Subsequently the defendants filed an application under Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure praying for judgment upon admission. The records further reveal that on the date when the said application was filed and on subsequent date the plaintiff was represented before the Court and had full notice of the proceedings. At no stage did the plaintiff dispute the admissions made by the defendants or object to the passing of a decree upon such admissions.
6Upon consideration of the pleadings and the clear admissions made by the defendants the Joint District Judge by judgment and decree dated 08.11.2022 decreed the suit under Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure and declared the respective shares of the parties.
7Being dissatisfied with the said judgment and decree the plaintiff preferred Title Appeal Number 143 of 2023 before the District Judge, Dhaka which was subsequently transferred to the Court of Additional District Judge, 8th Court, Dhaka. Upon hearing the parties the appellate Court by judgment and decree dated 01.04.2024 dismissed the appeal and affirmed the
judgment and decree passed by the trial Court. Challenging the concurrent decisions of the Courts below the plaintiff has obtained the present Rule.
8Learned Advocate Mr. M. Ashraf Ali appearing on behalf of the petitioner submits that both the Courts below committed error of law occasioning failure of justice in decreeing the suit without proper consideration of the relevant facts and circumstances. He submits that during pendency of the appeal the plaintiff filed an application for amendment of the plaint and the appellate Court failed to dispose of the same before deciding the appeal. According to him the appellate Court thus acted illegally in dismissing the appeal without first adjudicating upon the amendment petition. He further submits that partition is an equitable relief and before passing a decree in a partition suit the Court is required to examine the extent to which relief can legally and equitably be granted. He argues that a suit for partition involves equitable considerations and therefore before granting relief the Court is required to examine all surrounding circumstances affecting the property and the rights of the parties. He contends that the Courts below failed to undertake such exercise and thereby arrived at erroneous decisions.
9On the other hand Mr. Ali Imam Khaled Rahim along with Mr. A.H.M. Obaydul Kabir learned Advocates appearing on behalf of the opposite parties submits that the suit was decreed strictly in accordance with the plaintiff's own pleadings and prayers. He submits that the defendants admitted the plaintiff's claim in clear terms and therefore the trial Court rightly exercised its jurisdiction under Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code.
10He further submits that the plaintiff was present and represented before the Court when the application under Order 12 Rule 6 was filed. Despite having full opportunity the plaintiff neither disputed the admissions nor opposed the prayer for judgment upon admission. Having remained silent at the relevant stage and having obtained a decree exactly in terms of his own case the plaintiff is now estopped from challenging the same. He further submits that the proposed amendment neither sought alteration of the schedule of the suit property nor amendment of the prayer portion of the plaint. The plaintiff also did not implead any Bank or financial institution despite alleging mortgage liability. Therefore the proposed amendment did not raise any new issue necessary for adjudication of the real controversy involved in the suit. He
argues that had such amendment been allowed the suit would have suffered from misjoinder of causes of action and would have become vulnerable under the provisions of Order 2 Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure. He also submits that the plaintiff did not allege fraud in obtaining the decree. Consequently after obtaining a decree precisely in terms of his own pleadings and prayer the plaintiff cannot legitimately challenge the same in appeal and revision. The learned Advocate further points out that the plaintiff filed another suit being Title Suit Number 443 of 2020 concerning the very subject matter referred to in the amendment petition and the appellate Court upon calling for and examining the records of the said suit found no legal impediment in proceeding with the present suit. Therefore even though the appellate Court did not pass a separate order on the amendment application the substance of the matter was duly considered. He lastly submits that partition does not amount to transfer of property and therefore any mortgage liability if existing would continue to bind the respective shares even after partition. Such question is totally foreign to the present partition suit. In support of his submissions he refers to the case of Safaruddin Vs. Fazlul Haq reported in 49 DLR(AD) 151.
11I have heard the learned Advocates for the respective parties, perused the revisional application, the impugned judgments and decrees and the materials on record.
12The admitted facts of the case leave little room for controversy. The petitioner himself filed the suit seeking partition of the suit property. In the plaint he specifically disclosed the shares of all the co-sharers and prayed for partition accordingly. Defendants 1-4 entered appearance and filed a written statement clearly admitting the plaintiff's case. They admitted not only the status of co-sharership but also the exact quantum of shares as described in the plaint and expressly stated that they have no objection if a preliminary decree is passed in accordance therewith.
13On the basis of such admissions the defendants filed an application under Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The records reveal that the plaintiff was represented before the Court when the said application was filed and considered. Despite having full knowledge of the proceedings the plaintiff did not dispute the admissions and also did not seek framing of any issue and did not raise any objection against the proposed judgment upon admission.
14The trial Court therefore rightly proceeded to pronounce judgment under Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code and passed the preliminary decree declaring the shares of the parties.
15The plaintiff thereafter preferred an appeal and during pendency of the appeal filed an application for amendment of the plaint. Curiously enough by the said amendment petition the plaintiff attempted to introduce a case that the suit suffers from defect of hotchpot and certain matters relating to mortgage liability and other properties require consideration. The submissions advanced by the petitioner do not ring any bell. The most striking feature of the case is that the plaintiff having filed the suit himself and having pleaded the shares himself and having obtained a decree strictly in accordance with his own pleadings and prayers subsequently sought to challenge the very foundation of his own suit.
16The law does not encourage a litigant to approbate and reprobate in the same breath. A party cannot be permitted to assume one position before the trial Court and after obtaining a decree on that basis assume a completely inconsistent position before the appellate and revisional Courts merely because the outcome no longer suits his convenience.
17The proposed amendment itself shows the inherent contradiction in the petitioner's stand. On the one hand he sought partition of the suit property. On the other hand, he attempted to contend that the suit was defective for noninclusion of other properties and therefore should not have been decreed. Such a position is not only self-destructive but also indicative of a deliberate attempt to frustrate the lawful entitlement of the other co-sharers who admittedly possess shares in the property.
18It is well settled that the rule requiring inclusion of joint properties in a partition suit is not inflexible. Whether omission of a particular property is fatal depends upon the facts and circumstances of each case. More importantly a plaintiff who consciously institutes a suit on a particular cause of action cannot ordinarily be allowed after obtaining a decree in terms of his own pleadings to challenge that decree by asserting that his own suit was defective from its inception.
19The appellate Court rightly noticed that the matters sought to be introduced by amendment were not necessary for determination of the controversy involved in the present suit. It further appears that the plaintiff has already filed another Title Suit Number 443 of 2020 concerning the subject matter
sought to be incorporated by way of amendment. Therefore the proposed amendment neither advanced the cause of justice nor assisted the Court in determining the real questions in controversy between the parties.
20The argument regarding mortgage liability is equally misconceived. Partition is not a transfer of property. It merely demarcates and separates pre-existing rights of co-sharers. Consequently any lawful encumbrance if existing continues to remain attached to the property in accordance with law. Such question does not affect the maintainability of the present partition suit and does not constitute a ground for refusing a preliminary decree.
21It further transpires from the records that no allegation of fraud, misrepresentation, collusion or concealment was ever made against the defendants in obtaining the decree under Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The decree was passed on admitted facts. In the absence of any challenge to the validity of those admissions the decree cannot be faulted.
22The conduct of the plaintiff throughout the proceeding leaves little doubt that after obtaining a decree in accordance with his own pleadings he subsequently attempted to avoid the
consequences thereof by introducing totally inconsistent pleas. Such conduct cannot be encouraged by a Court of law.
23The Courts below concurrently found that there existed no disputed question requiring trial and the plaintiff was entitled to the relief claimed in the plaint. The findings are based upon the pleadings and admissions of the parties and do not suffer from any misreading of evidence or nonconsideration of material facts or error of law.
24I find no substance in the contention that the Courts below committed any error of law occasioning failure of justice.
25Accordingly the Rule is discharged.
26The judgment and decree dated 01.04.2024 passed by the Additional District Judge, 8th Court, Dhaka in Title Appeal Number 143 of 2023 dismissing the appeal thereby affirming the judgment and preliminary decree dated 08.11.2022 passed by the learned Joint District Judge, 3rd Court, Dhaka in Title Suit Number 171 of 2000 are hereby maintained.
27There shall be no order as to costs.
28Let a copy of this judgment be communicated to the Courts below forthwith and the Lower Courts' Records be sent down at once.
Md. Ali Reza, J:
29Naher, B.O.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











