High Court Division · Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction
The State v Md. Kamrul Islam
Death Reference 111/2018 · Decided 14 January 2026
The Nari-O-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Tribunal, Tangail convicted the accused, a neighbour, of raping and killing an eight-year-old girl in 2014 under section 9(2) of the Nari-O-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Ain, 2000 and sentenced him to death. The reference was heard with his appeals. A child playmate saw him lead the victim away on the pretext of giving her litchis; he joined the search, falsely claimed she had been taken to Dhaka, later confessed, and her body was recovered where he showed. The High Court Division found the judicial confession voluntary, since the Magistrate proved all safeguards, and corroborated by the recovery, medical evidence of rape and homicidal death, and the last-seen evidence. Prior police custody without proof of coercion did not make it involuntary. The conviction was affirmed. Considering his youth, his long confinement in the condemned cell and the possibility of reform, the Court rejected the reference and commuted the death sentence to life imprisonment with a fine of Tk 100,000.
Reference rejected; conviction affirmed; death commuted to life
- Conviction and sentenceA conviction is a criminal court's finding that the accused is guilty; the sentence is the punishment it then imposes, such as imprisonment or a fine.Read the full explanation →
- Commutation of sentenceReplacing a sentence with a lighter kind of punishment, such as death with imprisonment for life, by a higher court or by the Government or President.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether the conviction for rape and murder of an eight-year-old child under section 9(2) of the Nari-O-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Ain, 2000 was proved by the judicial confession, recovery of the body, medical evidence and last-seen evidence.
- Q2
Whether alleged discrepancies in the inquest report and the accused's prior police custody undermined the conviction.
- Q3
Whether the sentence of death should be confirmed or commuted.
- The Court held that the judicial confession was voluntary and true, as the Magistrate proved compliance with all statutory safeguards, and that mere police custody before recording, without proof of threat or inducement, does not render a confession involuntary.
- The Court held that recovery of the dead body at the place pointed out by the accused was a highly incriminating circumstance that strongly corroborated the confession.
- The Court held that an inquest report is not substantive evidence and that its mention of a fractured neck was a minor variation that did not create reasonable doubt.
- The Court held that, once the victim was last seen in the accused's exclusive company and found dead, the burden shifted to him to explain how they parted, and his silence and false Dhaka story fortified the prosecution case.
- The Court affirmed the conviction under section 9(2) of the Ain, 2000 but, considering the accused's youth, his prolonged confinement in the condemned cell and the possibility of reformation, rejected the death reference and commuted the sentence to imprisonment for life with a fine of Tk 100,000.
Mere police custody prior to recording the confession, in the absence of any proof of threat or inducement, does not render a confession involuntary.
In the court’s own words.
Death Reference 111/2018, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 18 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1District: Tangail.
2In the Supreme Court of Bangladesh
3High Court Division (Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
4Present:
5Mr. Justice Md. Zakir Hossain
6And Mr. Justice Md. Toufiq Inam Death Reference No.111 of 2018.
7The State.
8-VersusMd. Kamrul Islam,
9—– Condemned-Prisoner.
10Mr. Mohammed Abdul Baset, DAG with Ms. Anjuman Ara Begum, A.A.G, Ms. Selina Parvin (Setu), A.A.G.
11Mr. Md. Syedur Rahman Mainul, A.A.G.
12Mr. Kazi Mohammad Moniruzzaman Dablu, A.A.G.
13Mr. Md. Mizanur Rahman, A.A.G. and Mr. Md. Shaikhul Islam, A.A.G.
14—– For the State. Mr. Md. Golam Nabi, Advocate, with Mr. Muhammad Ahsan Habib, Advocate and Mr. Muhammad Khairul Bashar, Advocate
15— For the Condemned-Prisoner.
16With Criminal Appeal No. 11154 of 2018.
17And Jail Appeal No. 280 of 2018.
18Md. Kamrul Islam,
19—– Condemned-Prisoner-Appellant.
20-VersusThe State.
21—– Respondent.
22Mr. Md. Golam Nabi, Advocate, with Mr. Muhammad Ahsan Habib, Advocate and
23Mr. Muhammad Khairul Bashar, Advocate
24—- For the Condemned-Prisoner-Appellant.
25Mr. Mohammed Abdul Baset, DAG with
26Ms. Anjuman Ara Begum, A.A.G,
27Ms. Selina Parvin (Setu), A.A.G.
28Mr. Md. Syedur Rahman Mainul, A.A.G.
29Mr. Kazi Mohammad Moniruzzaman Dablu, A.A.G.
30Mr. Md. Mizanur Rahman, A.A.G. and
31Mr. Md. Shaikhul Islam, A.A.G.
32—– For the Respondent.
33Heard On: 05.01.2026, 11.01.2026 and 13.01.2026
34And
35Judgment Delivered On: 14.01.2026.
36Md. Toufiq Inam, J:
37Pursuant to Section 374 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 [“the CrPC”] the instant Death Reference being no. 111 of 2018 has been made to this Court bythe Nari-O-ShishuNirjatan Daman Tribunal, Tangail, following pronouncement of its judgment dated 13.09.2018 in Nari-O-Shishu Case No. 415 of 2014. By the said judgment, the Tribunal convicted the sole accused, Md. Kamrul Islam, under section 9(2) of the Nari-O-ShishuNirjatan Daman Ain, 2000 (as amended in 2003) [“the Ain 2000] and sentenced him to death with a fine of Tk. 1,00,000 (one lac).
38The reference has been heard together with the above noted connected Criminal Appeal No. 11154 of 2018 and Jail Appeal No.
39280 of 2018 filed by the condemned prisoner challenging the same judgment. As all these proceedings arise out of the selfsame judgment, they have been heard together and are being disposed of by this common judgment.
40The prosecution case, in brief, is that the informant, Md. Abul Kalam of village Bhutia under Madhupur Police Station, Tangail, had an eight-year-old daughter named Bithi. On 19.05.2014 at about 5:00 p.m., while the victim was walking along a footpath near a place known as “Boyratala,” situated to the north-eastern side of the informant’s house, the accused, a neighbour, enticed her on the pretext of giving her litchis and took her away. When the victim did not return home by evening, the informant, along with relatives and local people, searched for her, during which the accused also participated. At about 7:30 p.m., three minor children informed the informant that they had seen the victim going towards Sujan’s banana garden at Boyratala in the company of the accused. The matter was immediately reported to the police. Upon arrival, the police detained and interrogated the accused, who falsely stated that he had handed over the victim to his brother-in-law, Ujjal, and another unknown person in a microbus, and that she had been taken
to Dhaka. Acting on this statement, the police, along with the informant and the accused, searched various places in Dhaka, but the victim could not be traced. On further interrogation in the morning of 20.05.2014, the accused confessed that he had taken the victim to a jungle beside the road near Akrachana ball field under Bhutia village, forcibly raped her, and, after she became unconscious, left her body in a drain beside the jungle after covering it with leaves.
41On the basis of the first information report, a case was registered at Madhupur Police Station under section 9(2) of the Ain, 2000. The accused subsequently made a judicial confession under section 164 of the CrPC, which was recorded by PW-9. During trial, the prosecution examined eleven witnesses. The accused was examined under section 342 of the CrPC on 05.08.2018, where he denied the allegations and declined to adduce any defence evidence. Upon conclusion of the trial, the learned Tribunal convicted the accused and sentenced him to death, giving rise to the present Death Reference and the connected appeals.
42Mr. Mohammed Abdul Baset, learned Deputy Attorney General appearing for the State, submits that the prosecution has been able
to prove the charge under section 9(2) of the Ain, 2000 beyond all reasonable doubt by cogent, consistent, and reliable evidence. He argues that the case is founded on unimpeachable circumstances, namely, the last-seen evidence of a natural child witness, the voluntary judicial confession of the accused, recovery of the dead body on the showing of the accused, and strong medical evidence conclusively proving rape followed by homicidal death. He further contends that the confessional statement recorded under section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure was made voluntarily after due compliance with all legal formalities, as proved by the Magistrate (PW-9), and that the same finds ample corroboration from independent evidence. He also submits that the conduct of the accused in deliberately misleading the family members of the victim by giving false information about taking the victim to Dhaka constitutes a strong incriminating circumstance pointing unmistakably to his guilt.
43With regard to sentence, Mr. Baset submits that the offence involves the rape and murder of an innocent eight-year-old child, committed in a brutal and barbaric manner, which has shaken the conscience of society. He argues that such a heinous crime squarely
falls within the category of the “rarest of rare” cases and that any leniency would undermine public confidence in the administration of criminal justice. He, therefore, prays for acceptance of the Death Reference, confirmation of the sentence of death, and dismissal of the Criminal Appeal and Jail Appeal.
44Per contra, Mr. Md. Golam Nabi, learned Advocate appearing with Mr. Muhammad Ahsan Habib and Muhammad Khairul Bashar, learned Advoctesfor the condemned accused, submits that both in the FIR and in his court deposition, PW-1 stated that the dead body was recovered in his presence and at the pointing out of the accused. In contrast, PW-2 to PW-5 deposed that the dead body was recovered at a time when the informant (PW-1) and the accused were in Dhaka. According to him, this material discrepancy strikes at the root of the prosecution case, and the benefit of such inconsistency must, therefore, go in favour of the accused.
45Mr. Nabi also argues that it has been mentioned in the inquest report that the victim’s neck was fractured, but neither in the confessional statement nor in the post-mortem report was any fracture of the neck found, and such discrepancy casts a serious
doubt on the prosecution case. Referring to the deposition of the Investigating Officer, he submits that the accused remained in police custody throughout and that the confessional statement was extracted under coercion, rendering it neither true nor voluntary. He further submits that the alleged recovery of the dead body on the showing of the accused has not been proved in accordance with law, as the evidence regarding the place, time, and presence of witnesses is contradictory and uncertain. Such recovery, therefore, cannot be treated as an incriminating circumstance of decisive value. He argues that the prosecution evidence, even if taken at its highest, does not form a complete and unbroken chain so as to exclude every hypothesis consistent with the innocence of the accused. He argues that the so-called “last-seen” evidence rests on the testimony of a solitary child witness, whose statement, according to him, suffers from inherent infirmities and lacks independent corroboration from any neutral witness. He adds that the medical evidence, far from conclusively supporting the prosecution story, leaves room for doubt regarding the exact manner and timing of death, and does not lend unqualified assurance to the alleged sequence of events narrated in the confession.
46Let us now meticulously reappraise the entire evidence on record, which is our bounden duty in a death reference, and, most importantly, examine with anxious scrutiny the confessional statement of the convicted accused recorded under section 164 of the CrPC by PW-9.
47PW-1 Md. Abul Kalam, the informant and father of the victim, has fully supported the prosecution case and reiterated the contents of the FIR in all material particulars. He stated that the accused enticed his minor daughter on the pretext of giving her litchis, actively participated in the night-long search, deliberately misled the family members by giving false information about Dhaka, and subsequently confessed before the assembled villagers that he had raped and killed the child and concealed her body in a drain. He proved the FIR and his signature thereon and further stated that the accused made a confessional statement before a Magistrate. In cross-examination, PW-1 categorically denied the defence suggestions of false implication, prior enmity, or fabrication. Being the father of the victim, his presence, conduct and testimony are natural and expected, and nothing has been elicited to discredit his credibility.
48PW-2 Anisur Rahman corroborated the sequence of events relating to the disappearance of the victim, the information supplied by the child witnesses, the detention of the accused, his false explanation regarding Dhaka, and his subsequent confession leading to the recovery of the dead body. PW-3 Anisur Rahman (son of Abdur Rashid) stated that the dead body was recovered from a drain in his pineapple garden as shown by the accused, and that the victim’s wearing apparels and blood-stained leaves were seized in his presence. His testimony directly corroborates the disclosure made by the accused and rules out any theory of planted recovery. PW-4 Rafiqul Islam consistently supported the prosecution case regarding the disappearance of the victim, the collective search, the information given by the child witnesses, the confession of the accused, and the recovery of the dead body. PW-5 Jahangir Hossain, an inquest witness, stated that blood stains were found on the private parts of the victim, lending contemporaneous corroboration to the allegation of sexual assault.
49PW-6 Lata Akter, a child witness and playmate of the victim, gave a clear, spontaneous and natural account that she saw the accused taking the victim towards Sujan’s banana garden on the pretext of
giving her litchis. Her testimony constitutes vital last-seen evidence. Despite searching cross-examination, her evidence remained consistent and unshaken. No motive for false implication or tutoring has been suggested or established. It is well settled that the testimony of a child witness, if found natural and trustworthy, can safely be relied upon. While PW-7 Alamgir was tendered by the prosecution.
50PW-8 Laskar Ali corroborated the preparation of the inquest report and seizure list and confirmed that the dead body was recovered on the showing of the accused. PW-9 A.B.M. Ashfaqul Haque, the learned Magistrate, proved the confessional statement recorded under section 164 CrPC and categorically stated that all statutory safeguards were strictly observed. He deposed that the accused was given sufficient time for reflection, was warned that he was not bound to confess, was kept free from police influence, and that the confession was made voluntarily. There is no material on record to suggest any departure from the mandatory legal requirements. PW-10 Dr. Profulla Kumar, who conducted the post-mortem examination, proved the post-mortem report and unequivocally opined that the victim was subjected to forcible sexual assault and
thereafter died a homicidal death. PW-11 SI Atikul Haque, the Investigating Officer, detailed the entire course of investigation, including GD entry, arrest, interrogation, recovery of the dead body on the showing of the accused, preparation of inquest and seizure lists, recording of statements and submission of the charge-sheet. His evidence remained consistent and inspires confidence. It is not disputed that the victim Mosammat Bithi, aged about eight years, went missing on the afternoon of 19.05.2014 and that her dead body was recovered on the following morning from a drain beside a jungle near Akrachana ball field. The post-mortem report and the testimony of PW-10, the medical officer, conclusively establish that the victim was subjected to forcible sexual assault and thereafter died a homicidal death. The extensive injuries found on her genital organs, along with swelling, bleeding and signs of violence, completely rule out any possibility of accidental or natural death. The evidence of the inquest witnesses (PW-5 and PW-8) lends further corroboration to the medical findings. The judicial confession of the accused is detailed, graphic, and unequivocally self-inculpatory; the relevant portion thereof reads as follows:
51""………..Avgvi eqm 20 eQi| Avwg Kvgjv †`B| Avwg 19/5/14 Bs ZvwiL
52Kvgjv w`‡q evox Avwm| evwo G‡m weKvj †ejv †Mvmj K‡i †`vKv‡bi w`‡K
53hvB| †`vKvb G hvIqvi Av‡MB Avgvi PvPv‡Zv †evb wew_i mv‡_ †`Lv nq|
54ZLb mgq wQj Abygvb weKvj 6.00 Uv| Gici Avwg wew_‡K †jPy LvIqvi K_v
55e‡j WvBKv wb‡q hvB| Gici Avwg wew_‡K AvKivPbv ejgv‡Vi cv‡k¡© R½‡ji
56w`‡K wb‡q hvB| H Lv‡b †KD wQj bv| wew_ †jPz LvIqvi †jv‡f Avgvi mv‡_
57hvq| R½‡j wb‡q hvIqvi ci Avwg wew_‡K Zvi mv‡jvqvi KvwgR Lyj‡Z ewj|
58wKš‘ wew_ †Lv‡j bv| Gici Avwg wew_‡K †kvqvBqv †Rvi K‡i Zvi cvqRvgv
59Lywj| Gici Avwg Avgvi †mvbv gv‡b †hUv w`‡q Avwg cªkve Kwi †mWv wew_i
60cªkve Gi RvqMvq WzwK‡q †`B| GB fv‡e wKQy¶b Kivi ci Avwg †`wL wew_
61wKQy e‡jbv ev wPrKvi K‡i| cª_‡g wew_ wPrKvi Ki‡ZwQj| Gici †`wL wew_
62AÁvb n‡q †M‡Q| ZLb Avwg fq cvB| Gici Avwg wew_‡K †Kv‡j K‡i wb‡q
63Avwm| †mLv‡b †KD wQj bv| ZLb AÜKvi wQj| Gici Avwg wew_‡K
64AvKivPbv ejgv‡Vi cv‡k¡© _vKv †Wª‡b †kvqvBqv ivwL| Gici Avwg Zv‡K H
65Lv‡b †i‡L evox P‡j Avwm| evwo Avmvi ci wew_i evev gv‡b Avgvi PvPv
66Avgv‡K wew_i wel‡q wRÁvmv K‡i| ZLb Avwg PvPv‡K ewj wew_ †Kv_vq †M‡Q
67Zv Rvwbbv| ………… '' This judicial confession of the accused is detailed, graphic, and replete with intrinsic particulars relating to the enticement of the minor victim, commission of rape, and subsequent disposal of the
dead body. Such minute and coherent details were within the exclusive knowledge of the perpetrator and could not have been fabricated or supplied by the police. The confession finds strong corroboration from independent evidence, including the medical findings and the recovery of the dead body at the place disclosed by the accused.
68PW-9, the Magistrate who recorded the confession, categorically testified that all statutory safeguards were strictly observed. He stated that the accused was given sufficient time for reflection and that the confession was made voluntarily, without any threat, inducement, or promise. The defence allegation of coercion is wholly unsubstantiated and stands squarely contradicted by the unimpeached testimony of the Magistrate. Mere police custody prior to recording the confession, in the absence of any proof of threat or inducement, does not render a confession involuntary. Pursuant to the disclosure made by the accused, the dead body of the victim was recovered from a drain in a pineapple field at the precise location pointed out by him. This recovery has been consistently proved by PW-1, PW-2, PW-3, PW-4, PW-8, and PW-
6911. Recovery of the dead body at the instance of the accused is a
highly incriminating circumstance and provides strong corroboration to the judicial confession.
70The defence contention regarding an alleged discrepancy in the inquest report mentioning a fractured neck is devoid of merit. An inquest report is not a substantive piece of evidence and merely notes the apparent external condition of the body. The medical evidence, which is decisive on the cause of death, conclusively establishes rape followed by homicidal death. Such minor variation neither strikes at the root of the prosecution case nor creates any reasonable doubt.
71The prosecution has successfully proved the circumstance that the accused was last seen in the company of the victim immediately prior to her disappearance. PW-6, a child witness and playmate of the victim, gave a clear, natural, and convincing account that she saw the accused taking the victim towards Sujan’s banana garden on the pretext of giving her litchis. Her testimony remained consistent and unshaken in cross-examination, and nothing has been elicited to suggest tutoring or fabrication. The evidence of PW-1, PW-2, and PW-4 materially corroborates this circumstance.
72Once the victim was last seen in the exclusive company of the accused and was thereafter found to have met an unnatural death, the burden shifted upon the accused to explain how they parted company. The accused has offered no explanation whatsoever, either during trial or in his examination under section 342 CrPC. His mere denial, coupled with complete silence in the face of such incriminating circumstances, further fortifies the prosecution case. The conduct of the accused is also highly incriminating. While ostensibly participating in the search, he deliberately misled the victim’s family by giving false information regarding her alleged presence in Dhaka. This false explanation, along with his shifting and inconsistent versions, clearly reflects a guilty conscience and constitutes an important link in the chain of circumstances. The medical evidence fully corroborates the prosecution case and is in complete consonance with the judicial confession. The grave injuries on the genital organs, accompanied by swelling, bleeding, and other clear signs of violence, as described by PW-10, are wholly consistent with the manner of assault admitted by the accused. The recovery of the naked body bearing such injuries completes the unbroken chain of circumstantial evidence.
73From the evidence of all eleven prosecution witnesses, it is evident that the informant, the last-seen child witness, the recovery witnesses, the medical officer, the Magistrate, and the Investigating Officer consistently supported the prosecution case. The prosecution relied upon last-seen evidence, extra-judicial and judicial confessions, recovery of the dead body at the instance of the accused, medical evidence, and other corroborative circumstances to establish the charge under section 9(2) of the Ain, 2000.
74It is our considered view that a conviction under section 9(2) of the Ain, 2000 is sustainable where a voluntary judicial confession, recorded in compliance with law and containing facts within the exclusive knowledge of the accused, is corroborated by recovery of the dead body at his instance, consistent medical evidence, credible last-seen testimony, and his failure to explain the incriminating circumstances. Minor discrepancies in the inquest report or prior police custody do not vitiate such conviction to its maker in the absence of proof of coercion.
75Upon a cumulative assessment of the entire evidence, we find that the prosecution has successfully proved each link in the chain of
circumstances beyond reasonable doubt. The evidence forms a complete and unbroken chain leading only to the conclusion that the accused Md. Kamrul Islam enticed the minor victim, subjected her to brutal rape, caused her death, and concealed her body. We find no illegality, infirmity, or perversity in the findings of the learned Tribunal in holding the accused guilty under section 9(2) of the Ain, 2000.Accordingly, the conviction of the accused is hereby affirmed.
76However, in deciding the scentence, we have taken into account that the accused was a young offender, that prolonged confinement in the condemned cell has itself inflicted extreme mental agony, and that there remains a possibility of his moral reformation and eventual reintegration into society. While the offence is undoubtedly heinous and has shaken the conscience of thesociety, the mitigating circumstances noted above persuade us to commute the sentence of death imposed upon the accused to imprisonment for life Consequently-
77i) The Death Reference No. 111 of 2018 is rejected. The
78conviction of the condemned convict is affirmed;
79however, the sentence of death is commuted to
80imprisonment for life together with a fine of Tk
81100,000. Consequently, the connected Criminal
82Appeal No. 11154 of 2018 and Jail Appeal No. 280 of
832018 are disposed of in the above terms.
84ii) The condemned prisoner Md. Kamrul Islam son of
85Md. Saban Ali @ Fazlul Haque shall be transferred
86from condemned cell to general prison at once. He
87shall remain in jail to serve out the sentence of
88imprisonment for life in accordance with law, subject
89to any remission or benefit of section 35A CrPC.
90iii) The Office is directed to transmit the lower court
91records forthwith and communicate this judgment to
92the tribunal and concerned authorities for immediate
93compliance.
94(Justice Md. Toufiq Inam) Md. Zakir Hossain, J:
95I agree.
96(Justice Md. Zakir Hossain) Ashraf/ABO.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











