Supreme Court Judgments, Summarised

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Nov 3, 2026

Summary

The Government, through the District Controller of Food, contracted in 1983 with a husking mill to mill Government paddy and return rice. The mill delivered far less rice than the agreed ratio required. Clause 7 of the agreement made the miller liable for short delivery at double the market price and provided for forfeiture of the security deposit. The trial court decreed the money suit only in part for Tk. 342537.77, refusing the double rate because the miller had supposedly made efforts to pay under a later arrangement, deducting the security deposit, and allowing 12 monthly instalments. The Government appealed. Hearing the appeal ex parte (in the respondent's absence), the High Court Division found the miller had admitted the shortfall, had produced no document proving the alleged later contract, and that the security deposit was forfeitable. It corrected the shortfall to 50180 Kg, set aside the decree and decreed the suit in part for Tk. 7,57,589.84 with cost, payable within 90 days, failing which it could be executed.

Issues

  1. Q1

    Whether the trial court was right to exempt the defendant miller from paying double the market price for undelivered rice under clause 7 of the milling agreement.

  2. Q2

    Whether a statement by the plaintiff's witness in cross-examination, without any supporting document, proved the defendant's alleged subsequent contract with the Government.

  3. Q3

    Whether the miller's security deposit could be deducted from the decretal amount when clause 7 provided for its forfeiture on default.

Key points

  • The defendant's own deposition and his application to the Secretary of the Ministry of Food were admissions that he failed to perform the agreement, and the true rice shortfall was 50180 Kg, not 50189 Kg.
  • Under clause 7 the miller was liable to pay double the market price for the rice short delivered, but only the single price for the gunny bags, as the trial court had rightly found on the bags.
  • A statement by P.W. 1 in cross-examination could not by itself prove the defendant's alleged subsequent contract and deposit when the defendant produced no supporting document, so the trial court misappreciated the evidence.
  • Since clause 7 provided for forfeiture of the security money on default, the trial court had no scope to deduct the security deposit from the amount due.
  • The decree was set aside and the suit decreed in part for Tk. 7,57,589.84 with cost, to be deposited within 90 days, failing which the plaintiff may execute the decree.

such statement made by the P.W. 1 in cross examination could not, by itself, be treated as proof of the entire claim set up by the defendant

From the judgment, Justice Urmee Rahman
Law considered

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, Order XLI rule 17(2)

The judgment

In the court’s own words.

First Appeal 168/1997, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 17 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.

PDF
Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp