High Court Division
Government of Bangladesh v Messers Madina Husking Mill
First Appeal 168/1997 · Decided 6 September 2026
The Government, through the District Controller of Food, contracted in 1983 with a husking mill to mill Government paddy and return rice. The mill delivered far less rice than the agreed ratio required. Clause 7 of the agreement made the miller liable for short delivery at double the market price and provided for forfeiture of the security deposit. The trial court decreed the money suit only in part for Tk. 342537.77, refusing the double rate because the miller had supposedly made efforts to pay under a later arrangement, deducting the security deposit, and allowing 12 monthly instalments. The Government appealed. Hearing the appeal ex parte (in the respondent's absence), the High Court Division found the miller had admitted the shortfall, had produced no document proving the alleged later contract, and that the security deposit was forfeitable. It corrected the shortfall to 50180 Kg, set aside the decree and decreed the suit in part for Tk. 7,57,589.84 with cost, payable within 90 days, failing which it could be executed.
Appeal allowed; decree increased to Tk. 7,57,589.84 with cost
- Q1
Whether the trial court was right to exempt the defendant miller from paying double the market price for undelivered rice under clause 7 of the milling agreement.
- Q2
Whether a statement by the plaintiff's witness in cross-examination, without any supporting document, proved the defendant's alleged subsequent contract with the Government.
- Q3
Whether the miller's security deposit could be deducted from the decretal amount when clause 7 provided for its forfeiture on default.
- The defendant's own deposition and his application to the Secretary of the Ministry of Food were admissions that he failed to perform the agreement, and the true rice shortfall was 50180 Kg, not 50189 Kg.
- Under clause 7 the miller was liable to pay double the market price for the rice short delivered, but only the single price for the gunny bags, as the trial court had rightly found on the bags.
- A statement by P.W. 1 in cross-examination could not by itself prove the defendant's alleged subsequent contract and deposit when the defendant produced no supporting document, so the trial court misappreciated the evidence.
- Since clause 7 provided for forfeiture of the security money on default, the trial court had no scope to deduct the security deposit from the amount due.
- The decree was set aside and the suit decreed in part for Tk. 7,57,589.84 with cost, to be deposited within 90 days, failing which the plaintiff may execute the decree.
such statement made by the P.W. 1 in cross examination could not, by itself, be treated as proof of the entire claim set up by the defendant
In the court’s own words.
First Appeal 168/1997, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 17 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
Present:-
Mr. Justice Md. Riaz Uddin Khan
And
Ms. Justice Urmee Rahman
First Appeal No. 168 of 1997
Government of Bangladesh, represented by
the District Controller of Food, on his behalf
Officer in Charge, Saidpur Thana Food
Department, District-Nilphamari
….Plaintiff- Appellant
-Versus-
Messers Madina Husking Mill, Saidpur,
represented by Proprietor, Md. Ibrahim
…. Defendant-Respondent
Mr. Md. Zahirul Islam, D.A.G.
…. For the appellant
No one appeared
… For the respondent
Heard on 30.08.2026 and 03.09.2026
Judgment on 6th September, 2026
Urmee Rahman, J.
1This First Appeal is directed against the judgment and decree dated 05.04.1995 (decree signed on 12.05.1995) passed by the learned Subordinate Judge, 2nd Court, Nilphamari in Money Suit No. 11 of 1994 (originally Money Suit No. 05 of 1989) decreeing the suit in part with a direction upon the defendant to make payment of the decretal amount in 12 (twelve) equal monthly installments.
2Being aggrieved by the judgment and decree, the defendantjudgment debtor as appellant preferred First Appeal No. 259 of 1995 whereas the plaintiff as appellant preferred the instant First Appeal No. 168 of 1997.
3It transpires from the record that the First Appeal No. 259 of 1995 was dismissed pursuant to the order dated 02.05.2006 by which 2(two) weeks time was allowed by this Division to file the appellant list, failing which the appeal would stand dismissed. Since the appellant list was not filed by the appellant despite repeated opportunities granted by this Court, the appeal was accordingly dismissed and it was recorded by the order dated 13.07.2006 as transpires from the order book of First Appeal No. 259 of 1995.
4In the instant First Appeal No. 168 of 1997 notice was duly served upon the sole respondent but no one appeared till date in order to contest the Appeal. It appears from the order book that this First Appeal was made ready for hearing on 09.02.2005; however no step has been taken by the appellant until 17.08.2026, when the matter was fixed for hearing before this Bench. Since no one appeared on behalf of the respondent, this Appeal has been heard and the judgment is being pronounced ex
parte as per the provision of Order 41 Rule 17(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
5The relevant facts of the case are that, the District Food Controller, on behalf of the Government, filed Money Suit No. 05 of 1989 in the Court of then Subordinate Judge, Nilphamari praying for a decree for an amount of Tk. 7,69,372.62/- against the sole defendant, namely, Messers Madina Husking Mill, Saidpur, represented by its Proprietor, Md. Ibrahim, of Upazilla-Saidpur, District-Nilphamari.
6The plaintiff’s case, in brief, is that, the Government, through the District Controller of Food, Rangpur, entered into a contract with the defendant on 29.08.1983 by which the defendant agreed to take delivery of paddy from the Government godown and after crushing the paddy would deliver the milled rice back to the Government as per the terms of the agreement. However, the defendant failed to deliver the total quantity of the milled rice within the stipulated time mentioned in the agreement. Clause 7 of the agreement stipulates that in case of default in delivering the rice, the Miller shall be liable to make payment double the market price of the rice. Hence, the suit.
7The defendant No. 1 contested the suit by filing a written statement denying all the material allegations made in the plaint and alleging inter alia that, the contract on the basis of which the plaintiff has filed the instant suit has been made with some unfair and unlawful terms against the defendant and as such it is not binding upon him. Moreover, the paddy which has been supplied to the defendant was of substandard quality and most of the gunny bags, in which the paddy was supplied, were torn. The godown Officer inspected the defendant’s Mill and refused to receive the rice on the ground that those were not up to the standard and directed the defendant to make delivery of the total quantity of rice within 5 (five) days. The defendant was able to crush only 7 tons of rice in the next 5 (five) days and went to deliver it to the plaintiff, who refused to receive the same stating that until the total quantity of rice is delivered, he will not receive the same. In the meantime, one criminal case was filed by the plaintiff against the defendant and he was taken to police custody. Later, when he was released from jail, the plaintiff offered him an opportunity by which he was asked to receive paddy directly from the plaintiff and crush them in his mill upon submitting a security bond to the Government for the total
amount and the crushing charge shall be adjusted with the payment which is due to the Government by the defendant. But recently the plaintiff stopped supplying the rice for which the defendant could not make full payment of the due amount. Had the Government continued to supply rice regularly, he would have been able to make payment of the due amount. In the plaint the plaintiff did not disclose the amount which the defendant already paid. Hence, the instant suit has been brought without any lawful basis and is liable to be dismissed.
8During the course of the trial, the plaintiff examined only 1(one) witness, who is the Thana Food Inspector, Saidpur and produced documentary evidence marked as Exhibit-1, which is the original copy of the agreement dated 29.08.1983 between the plaintiff and the defendant and Exhibits-2 to 2(Gha), which are the receipts by which the defendant received the paddy from the plaintiff ’s godown.
9On the other hand, the defendant also examined 1(one) witness in support of his case, who is the Proprietor of the defendant-mill and produced documentary evidence marked as Exhibit-Ka, which is the memo dated 12.06.1990 and an application made by him before the
Secretary Ministry of Food was exhibited as Exhibit-Kha. Both the defendant’s exhibits were produced with objection by the plaintiff.
10This Money Suit No. 05 of 1989 was decreed ex parte on 15.05.1991 granting the full claim of the plaintiff against the defendant and the decree was signed on 21.05.1991. Thereafter, the defendantjudgment-debtor field Miscellaneous Case No. 43 of 1991 on 11.06.1991 under Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure praying for setting aside the ex parte Judgment and decree. The miscellaneous case was renumbered as 14 of 1994 and ultimately the Money Suit was restored and was renumbered as Money Suit No. 11 of 1994.
11The learned Subordinate Judge framed as many as 5(five) issues in deciding the case, which are as follows:
121. Is there any cause of action to the suit?
132. Is the suit maintainable in its present form?
143. Is the suit barred by limitation?
154. Is the plaintiff entitled to the decree for the amount prayed for?
165. Is the plaintiff entitled to get any other remedy as per law and
17equity?
18On consideration of the material evidence on record adduced by the respective parties, the learned Judge of the trial court was pleased to decree the suit in part on contest in the following manner:
191. The plaintiff claims to recover the double price of the
20rice as well as of the gunny bags but as per the terms of
21Clause 7 of the agreement plaintiff can claim double
22price of the rice only.
232. Since it appears from the document on the record that
24the defendant made effort in order to make payment of
25the due amount, he is exempted from making double
26price of the rice.
273. Admittedly, the defendant failed to deliver 50.189 metric
28ton milled rice and 1528 pieces of empty gunny bags to
29the plaintiff. The price per quintal of rice being 723 taka,
30total price for the rice would be Tk. 362866.47/- and per
31piece gunny bag being 14.28 taka, total price would be
32Tk. 21819.84/-. The plaintiff is therefore entitled to get
33an amount of Tk. 384686.31/- in total.
344. Since the defendant made payment of Tk. 27148.54/- for
35the crushing charge and paid a security amount of
36Tk.15000/- therefore, an amount of Tk. 42148.54/- shall
37be deducted from the total amount. Hence, the plaintiff
38would be entitled to get a decree for an amount of Tk.
39342537.77/-.
405. Since the defendant prayed for installments in making
41payment of the amount, he is allowed to make the
42payment of the decretal amount in 12 (twelve) equal
43monthly installments.
44Being aggrieved by the judgment the plaintiff has preferred the instant First Appeal.
45Learned Deputy Attorney General Mr. Md. Zahirul Islam appeared on behalf of the Plaintiff-Appellant i.e. Government of Bangladesh, District Controller of Food, represented by Thana Food Officer, Saidpur, District-Nilphamari and submitted that, having regard to the fact that the plaintiff-appellant as per terms of the contract dated 29.08.1983 supplied 1,12000 Kg Irri paddy and 1805 pieces of bags to the defendant-respondent but in return he supplied only 20,754 Kg
husked paddy and 277 pieces of bags in violation of clause 7 of the agreement and as such the appellant is entitled to get back 50,189 Kg husked paddy along with 1528 pieces bags amounting to Tk. 769327.62/- but the learned court below without discussing the evidence decreed the suit in part for an amount of Tk. 342537.77/- which is liable to be set aside.
46He next submitted that, clause 7 of the agreement (Exhibit-1) stipulated that in case of failure to deliver the husked paddy in time the respondent is bound to pay compensation two times of the market value but the learned court below misconstruing the Exhibit-1 and on mere surmises held that the defendant-respondent is entitled to get exemption from making payment of compensation. As such the impugned judgment is liable to be set aside.
47He finally submitted that, the learned court below failed to apply judicial mind into the facts and circumstances of the case and partly decreed the suit on mere surmise and conjecture and not on the basis of the evidence on record. Hence the instant appeal is liable to be allowed setting aside the judgment and decree passed by the trial court.
48We have heard the learned Deputy Attorney General for the appellant and gone through the memo of appeal and the grounds set forth therein, the judgment and decree appealed against as well as the Lower Court Records (L.C.R.).
49None appeared for the Respondent.
50On meticulous examination of Lower Court Records we find that, on 29.08.1983 an agreement was entered into between the Government of People’s Republic of Bangladesh through the District Controller of Food, Rangpur and Messers Madina Husking Mill, represented by its Proprietor, Md. Ibrahim. It was stipulated in the agreement that on delivery of the paddy the Miller shall have to account for the paddy received and rice husked out of it in the 60:38 ratio for the Irri paddy (Exhibit-1) and from the Exhibits-2 to 2(Gha), it appears that a total amount of 1,12,000 Kilogram of Irri paddy was delivered to the Miller in 1805 gunny bags. The plaintiff claims that although as per the ratio mentioned in the agreement the Miller was supposed to deliver 70934 Kg of rice but he actually delivered only 20754 Kg. Therefore, there has been a deficit of 50189 Kg of rice. Upon deducting the amount of rice actually received by the plaintiff from the amount to be delivered by the
Miller we find that, the difference is 50180 Kg not 50189 Kg. There has been a clear miscalculation regarding the deficit amount of rice to be delivered by the defendant.
51In order to prove the case, the plaintiff produced the original copy of the agreement and the receipts by which the paddy was delivered to the defendant but did not produce any document in order to substantiate their claim as to the amount of rice delivered back by the defendant to the Government. However, the defendant in his cross-examination as D.W.1 admitted the fact that he could deliver only 20754 Kg of rice to the plaintiff. The relevant part of the deposition of the D.W.1 is quoted below:
52“A¡¢j fÐc¡−el
53,000/- C। ! " #
54pj−ul $ % f¡¢l−m &'% () * + $
55" । ,- . / : % +% 1 % । 2 3 45
56। + % () % 6 789 () 3 :/;.00 । 2
573 6 =./4 ।- >? % . 3
58/5.:= : %, 2 3 /:: । – % 8 50.189 :
59% 8 ।! 2 @% l¢qu¡−R /4 ।”
60It also appears from Exhibit-Kha produced by the defendant that an application was submitted by him before the Secretary of Ministry of Food in which he clearly admitted the plaintiff’s claim regarding the deficit amount of rice to be delivered by him.
61Hence, it is admitted by the defendant that he has failed to perform in accordance with the terms of the agreement.
62Clause 7 of the agreement dated 29.08.1983 (Exhibit-1) provides as follows:
63“7. That the value of any short delivery of rice
64beyond the permissible refraction allowance provided for in
65clause 6 shall be compensated by the Miller at double the
66market price of rice prevailing at the time during which the
67loss occurs or at double the ex-godown rate of the
68Government, whichever is higher, within 30 (thirty) days of
69detection of the shortage. If the Miller fails to compensate
70for the short delivery, the security deposit of the Miller shall
71be liable to forfeiture in part or in full and the Miller shall
72be liable to criminal prosecution on the charge of breach of
73trust.”
74Considering the terms of the clause we find that, for failure of performance as per the stipulated terms of the contract the defendant is liable to make payment of the rice at double the market price as has been
rightly claimed by the plaintiff, but since there is no stipulation of making double payment for the gunny bags, the plaintiff is only entitled to get the single price for the 1805 gunny bags at the rate of 14.28 Taka per piece. The trial court rightly came to the finding in this regard.
75However, from the judgment of the court below it appears that, the learned Subordinate Judge relied on the third case made out by the defendant and exempted him from making payment at the double rate of the market price for the rice considering that the defendant made effort in making payment of the due amount to the Government. While arriving at this finding the learned Judge relied on the application so made by the defendant before the Secretary of Ministry of Food (Exhibit-Kha) and a statement made by the P. W. 1 in his crossexamination. The learned Judge of the trial court held that the P.W. 1 admitted in his cross-examination regarding a further contract with the defendant by which he was allegedly given an opportunity to make payment of the due amount.
76On perusal of the deposition we find that the P.W. 1 in the last line of his examination-in-chief stated that:
77“……… B %. ®k, ¢hh¡c£l %> ( ) + % 1 @ C 8 DE % 6 F pjeÄu 8 G Q¤¢š² quz”
78And in the first line of the cross-examination he stated that:
79“ ¢hh¡c£ p’ufœ Sj¡ ¢cu¡ plL¡l£ d¡e œ²u L¢lu¡ Q¡Em Sj¡ ¢c−he J œ²¡¢nw j§mÉ h¡c£l f¡Je¡ qC−a pjeÄu Ll¡ qC−h j−jÑ 1¢V Q¤¢š² quz Eš² p’ufœN¤¢m ®Sm¡ M¡cÉ ¢eu¿»−Ll ¢eL−V Sj¡ A¡−Rz………”
80The trial court in his judgment held that:
81“………¢hh¡c£l c¡¢MmL«a HL¢S¢hV-M (A¡f¢š) ¢Q¢q²a clM¡Ù¹¢Vl
82heÑe¡ qC−a ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, ¢a¢e j¡ee£u p¢Qh M¡cÉ j¿»Z¡mu hl¡hl A¡−hce
83L¢lu¡−Re a¡q¡−a ¢a¢e 27148/54 V¡L¡ œ²¡¢nw Q¡SÑ j¡dÉ−j a¡q¡l f¡Je¡
84qC−a pjeÄu L¢lu¡−Re j−jÑ hÉš² L¢lu¡−Rez e¢b cª−ø fÐa£uj¡e qu ®k,
85¢hh¡c£fr Na 11.02.95 Cw a¡¢l−M qmge¡j¡pq h¡c£f−rl ¢eLV qC−a
86Q¡Em Sj¡ ¢ch¡l L¡NS fœ pj§q amh L−le Hhw A¡c¡ma h¡c£fr−L
87¢hh¡c£f−rl amhL«a L¡NS fœ 25-02-95 Cw a¡¢l−M c¡¢Mm L¢lh¡l
88A¡−cn ®cuz ¢L¿º h¡c£fr ®p pjÙ¹ ®L¡e am¢h L¡NS fœ c¡¢Mm L−l e¡C h¡
89amh£ L¡NS pÇf−LÑ ®L¡e hÉ¡MÉ¡ fÐc¡e L−l e¡Cz ®p L¡l−e ¢hh¡c£fr
90flha£Ñ−a d¡e NËqe L¢lu¡ œ²¡¢nw Q¡SÑ h¡h−c 27,148/54 V¡L¡ a¡q¡l f¡Je¡
91qC−a pjeÄu L¢lu¡−R j−jÑ ¢hnÄ¡p−k¡NÉ qC−a−Rz”
92On perusal of the corresponding application dated 11.05.1995 referred by the learned Judge of the trial court we find that, an application was made by the defendant on that date praying for production of certain document by the plaintiff on which he is relying to establish his case of entering into a further contract with the Government after getting out of the jail. In the schedule to that application it has been stated that:
93“amh£u L¡NS¡¢c (1) ®j¡x ChС¢qj, −fСfСCVl −jp¡pÑ j¢ce¡ q¡p¢Lw
94¢jm, ¯pucf¤−ll fÐcš p’ufœ, Q¤¢š²e¡j¡ J Q¡Em Sj¡ ¢ch¡l L¡NS¡¢c
95pj§qz”
96We find this application as unspecific and vague inasmuch as there is no description as to which security bond, agreement and receipts the defendant had mentioned. On the basis of such unspecific and vague application there was no scope for the plaintiff to produce any document before the court. Moreover, from the application made by the defendant before the Secretary of Ministry of Food, we find that there is no seal or signature showing that the application was actually received by the concerned office of the Secretary. There is no postal receipt showing that it was sent by post. The defendant could not produce a scrap of document in support of this claim.
97It appears that the learned trial court has placed reliance solely on the statement made by the P.W. 1 in his cross examination and held that the alleged subsequent contract was proved. When the defendant failed to produce any evidence whatsoever in order to prove the alleged third case made out by him, such statement made by the P.W. 1 in cross examination could not, by itself, be treated as proof of the entire claim set up by the defendant, particularly as regards the terms of the alleged contract and the alleged deposit so made by him. We therefore, find that the learned judge of the trial court has misappreciated the evidence.
98The learned judge of the trial court further deducted the amount of security deposit made by the defendant at the time of entering into the contract. However, we have already seen from Clause 7 that in case of default the security money shall be forfeited against the Miller. Therefore, there is no scope to deduct the amount.
99Hence, we find that the plaintiff has been able to prove it’s case so far as the price of the rice to be paid at a double rate of the market price by the defendant and for the due price of the gunny bags at a single rate.
100Therefore, the decretal amount stands as follows:
10150180 Kg or 501.89 quintal rice in total
102Price per quintal 723 taka, thus double price would be
103(723×2)=1446 taka per quintal.
104Hence, 501.89 X 1446 = 7,35,770.74 taka for rice; and
1051528 bags X 14.28 taka per piece = 21819.84 taka, for gunny
106bags.
107In total an amount of (7,35,770+21,819·84)=7,57,589.84/- taka with cost in favour of the plaintiff.
108In view of the fact and circumstances and the discussion made hereinabove, we find merit in this appeal. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment and decree dated 05.04.1995 (decree signed on 12.05.1995) passed by the learned Subordinate Judge, Second Court, Nilphamari in Money Suit No. 11 of 1994 is hereby set aside.
109Accordingly, the Money Suit No. 11 of 1994 be decreed in part against the defendant for an amount of 7,57,589.84/- taka with cost in favour of the plaintiff .
110The defendant-respondent is hereby directed to deposit the decretal amount before the concerned court within 90 (ninety) days from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment by the trial court. In default of such payment within the stipulated period, the plaintiff shall be at liberty to realize the decretal amount in accordance with law through the process of execution.
111Let the Lower Court Records (LCR) be sent down to the Court concerned forthwith along with a copy of this judgment and order. Md. Riaz Uddin Khan, J.
112I agree. Helal/Abo
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











