Supreme Court Judgments, Summarised

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Nov 3, 2026

Summary

Two rival title suits over 6.36 acres, each side claiming purchase from the original owner's heirs, were tried together by the Joint District Judge, 1st Court, Dhaka, who decreed the plaintiff's suit and dismissed the defendants' suit after finding the defendants' earlier deeds of 09.05.2000 forged. The defendants appealed. During the appeals, respondents Nos. 10 and 11 were added, claiming that the original owner had sold the whole 8.27 acres to their predecessor by a registered deed of 28.07.1965. The High Court Division held that the trial court wrongly relied on a handwriting expert's report from a criminal case, which was inadmissible in the suits, and wrongly admitted certified copies of deeds without explanation for non-production of the originals. As the plaintiff admitted dispossession but sought no relief for possession, the suit was hit by section 42 of the Specific Relief Act. The appeals were allowed, the decree set aside and the suits remanded for retrial within one year, with the added respondents to be impleaded as defendants.

Issues

  1. Q1

    Whether the trial court could find the defendants' registered sale deeds forged on the basis of a handwriting expert's report from a criminal case.

  2. Q2

    Whether certified copies of sale deeds were admissible without an explanation for non-production of the originals.

  3. Q3

    Whether a suit for declaration of title without a prayer for possession was maintainable where the plaintiff admitted dispossession.

Key points

  • Evidence given in a criminal case, including a handwriting expert's report submitted there, was inadmissible as evidence in the civil suits, so a finding of forgery based on it was not tenable.
  • Secondary evidence is admissible only when the party producing it explains the non-production of the primary evidence; the trial court erred in admitting certified copies of the deeds without such explanation.
  • A plaintiff who admits being dispossessed from part of the land but seeks only a declaration, without relief as to possession, is hit by section 42 of the Specific Relief Act, 1877.
  • Since the defendants' deeds were earlier in time, their separate suit for the same relief was misconceived and unnecessary.
  • Where a third party produces an earlier registered deed from the original owner which, if genuine, would defeat both sides, the suits should be remanded so that party can be added as a defendant and all parties may amend pleadings and adduce evidence.

A secondary evidence is admissible in evidence when the party producing above evidence provides an explanation for non production of the primary evidence.

From the judgment, Justice S M Kuddus Zaman
Law considered

Specific Relief Act, 1877, section 42Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, Order 1 rule 10

The judgment

In the court’s own words.

First Appeal 18/2015 with First Appeal 19/2015, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 12 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.

PDF
Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp