Supreme Court Judgments, Summarised

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Nov 3, 2026

Summary

The plaintiff sued for specific performance of an agreement for sale (bainapatra) of 5.54 acres in Satkhira, saying the vendor got title by gift from his father, who held a 1976 power of attorney from his brothers who had left for India. The Government said the land was vested (enemy) property and khas land, and some added defendants, landless freedom fighters, claimed a yearly settlement. The Subordinate Judge, First Court, Satkhira decreed the suit in 1998. The High Court Division found the power of attorney was on white paper, notarised and not authenticated by Bangladesh's High Commission in India, so it was inadmissible and passed no right. No deed of gift was produced, and the bainapatra appeared tampered with. As specific performance is equitable relief and the plaintiff relied on forged documents, the decree was set aside. The freedom fighters' appeal was dismissed for lack of standing, the Government's First Appeal No. 287 of 1999 was allowed and its duplicate First Appeal No. 59 of 2025 dismissed for non-prosecution.

Issues

  1. Q1

    Whether a decree for specific performance could stand when the vendor's title rested on a power of attorney executed abroad that was not duly authenticated, an unproduced deed of gift and a tampered agreement for sale.

  2. Q2

    Whether added defendants who were neither owners nor lessees of the land had standing to appeal against the decree.

Key points

  • The plaintiff's claim rested on the power of attorney of 16.12.1976, which was made on white paper and notarised, with no evidence of authentication by the High Commission of Bangladesh in India or payment of stamp duty in Bangladesh, so it had no legal value, was inadmissible and could transfer no right.
  • No deed of gift in favour of the vendor was produced or exhibited, so no right, title or interest passed to him and he had no legal basis to execute any bainanama.
  • The bainanama appeared tampered with at the date and the vendor's signatures were inconsistent, so it could not be treated as genuine.
  • As specific performance is an equitable relief and a person seeking equity must come with clean hands, the plaintiff, who relied on forged documents and committed fraud on the court, was not entitled to the decree, which was set aside.
  • First Appeal No. 209 of 1998 was dismissed because the appellants were neither owners nor lessees and had no locus standi, First Appeal No. 287 of 1999 was allowed, and First Appeal No. 59 of 2025 was dismissed for non-prosecution.

a decree for specific performance is an equitable relief, and under the settled principle of law, a person who seeks equity must come with clean hands.

From the judgment, Justice Md. Iqbal Kabir
The judgment

In the court’s own words.

First Appeal 209/1998, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 8 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.

PDF
Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp