High Court Division
Sentara Begum and others v Zakir Hossain and others
First Appeal 402/2013 · Decided 14 December 2025
The plaintiff sued for recovery of khas possession (direct physical possession) of land, claiming that the original raiyat's (tenant's) interest in 116 decimals ended when the land was sold at a 1935 rent auction, and that his widow later took 59 decimals back under a 1937 Kabuliat (a deed accepting a tenancy settlement). The defendants, as heirs of the original raiyat, said the auction never happened and the Kabuliat was fabricated. The Joint District Judge, 2nd Court, Feni decreed the suit in 2013. On appeal, the High Court Division found the plaintiff's evidence contradictory on who the superior landlord was, with no document proving the auction and no Dakhalanama (possession certificate). The Kabuliat was not found in the registration volume produced, which was for the wrong year. The plaintiff's witnesses did not see any dispossession, and one confirmed the defendants' house, latrine and tubewell on the land. The trial court had failed to assess the evidence, so the appeal was allowed without costs and the decree set aside.
Appeal allowed; decree for the plaintiff set aside
- Decree (dikri)The formal order recording a civil court's final decision on the parties' rights in a suit, which can be appealed and is enforced by execution.Read the full explanation →
- Set asideTo cancel an earlier court order, decree, award, sale or conviction so that it no longer has legal effect, usually by a higher court or by the same court on a proper application.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether the plaintiff proved title to the suit land through a 1935 rent auction purchase and a 1937 Kabuliat.
- Q2
Whether the plaintiff proved possession and dispossession by the defendants so as to recover khas possession.
- The plaintiff's witness contradicted the plaint on the identity of the superior landlord, which struck at the root of the claimed chain of title and made the claim unreliable.
- No document showed that the superior interest was ever auctioned or acquired through an auction, and without a Dakhalanama the claimed transfer of title and possession by auction remained unproven.
- The attempt to prove a Kabuliat registered in 1937 by producing a 1936 volume, in which the witness admitted the document did not appear, made the Kabuliat (Exhibit 16) wholly unreliable.
- The plaintiff failed to prove possession or dispossession, as the witnesses gave vague and contradictory evidence, admitted they did not see any dispossession, and one confirmed the defendants' structures on the land.
- The trial court failed to assess the evidence adequately, so the appeal was allowed without costs and the judgment and decree of 26.08.2013 were set aside.
In the absence of a Dakhalanama, the alleged transfer of title and possession through auction remains legally unproven and wholly conjectural.
In the court’s own words.
First Appeal 402/2013, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 9 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
Present:
Mr. Justice Md. Iqbal Kabir
And
Mrs. Justice Jesmin Ara Begum
First Appeal No. 402 of 2013
Sentara Begum and others
….Appellants
Versus
Zakir Hossain, being dead, his heirs 1(Ka) Muzibul
Haque Bhuiyan and others
….Respondents
Mr. Uzzal Kumar Bhowmick, Advocate with
Mrs. Shahana Perveen, Advocate
….For the Appellants
Mr. Md. Munsurul Hoque Chowdhury, Senior
Advocate with
Mr. Md. Sarwar Hossain, Advocate and
Mr. Mohammad Shafikul Islam Ripon, Advocate
….For the Respondent Nos. 1(Ka)-1(Cha)
Judgment on 14.12.2025.
Md. Iqbal Kabir, J:
1At the instance of the defendants/ appellants, this First Appeal is directed against the judgment and decree dated 26.08.2013 (decree signed on 29.08.2013) passed by the learned Joint District Judge, 2nd Court, Feni in Suit/Civil Case No. 30 of 2008 decreeing the suit in favour of the plaintiffrespondent.
2Short facts leading to preferring this first appeal are that the Plaintiff is the rightful owner and occupier of the suit property, having acquired the raiyati title through a valid legal process. The cause of action arose when the raiyati title was extinguished, and subsequently when the Plaintiff or her predecessor was dispossessed by the defendants.
3The plaintiff’s case, in essence, is that Girish Chandra Dhupi was the original raiyat of 116 decimals of land recorded in Khatian No. 231. The raiyati interest of Girish Chandra Dhupi and his heirs stood duly extinguished when the property was sold in a rent auction owing to non-payment of arrears of rent. The land was auctioned in Rent Case No. 2319/34, corresponding to Execution
Case No. 1652/34, and was purchased on 19-01-1935 by Safarjan Bibi Gong, who thereby lawfully acquired raiyati title to the property.
4It is the further case of the plaintiff that Sarla Sundari @ Ayesha Khatun, the widow of Girish Chandra Dhupi, subsequently obtained 59 decimals of the auction-purchased land through a settlement acceptance (Kabuliat-Exhibit-16) executed on 04-01-1937. Following such settlement, she exercised full rights of ownership over the land, including executing valid deeds of sale (Exhibits 3 and
54) and undertaking other transactions, which clearly demonstrate her possession and title. Based on these facts, the plaintiff seeks recovery of khas possession of the suit property from the defendants along with appropriate declaratory reliefs and costs.
6The defendants categorically denied the plaintiff’s assertions and maintain that they are the lawful owners and possessors of the suit land as heirs of the original raiyat, Girish Chandra Dhupi. They asserted that upon the death of Girish Chandra Dhupi, the entire 116 decimals of land recorded in Khatian No. 231 devolved upon his heirs, including themselves and Sarla Sundari, by operation of law. They deny that the property was ever sold in a rent auction, contending instead that the Rent Case and Execution Case cited by the plaintiff are fictitious. In support of this contention, they rely upon the court search slips (Exhibit-E series), which allegedly confirm that no such proceedings are traceable in the official records. Consequently, they claim that the Sale Certificate (Exhibit-14) is invalid, non-existent, or fraudulently procured.
7The defendants further state that Sarla Sundari @ Ayesha Khatun never executed the alleged Kabuliat (Exhibit-16) in favour of Safarjan Bibi Gong and contend that the document is fabricated and not found in the concerned volume. They assert that they have been in uninterrupted, peaceful, and lawful possession of the suit land through inheritance, and the SA record correctly reflects the names of the heirs of Girish Chandra Dhupi. According to them, the plaintiff has wholly failed to prove possession or dispossession. Accordingly, the
defendants pray for dismissal of the suit with costs, affirming their inherited title and continuous possession.
8It is pertinent to note that during the course of the trial, the plaintiff examined 5 witnesses, the defendant examined three witnesses, and witnesses were cross-examined. Further plaintiff produced 16 exhibits, and the defendant produced exhibits Ka, Kka, Kha-1, Ga, Gha, Gha-1, Yanga, and Yanga-1.
9However, upon considering the evidence and materials on record, the trial Court decreed the suit by its judgment and decree dated 26.08.2013, passed in Title Suit No. 30 of 2008, in favour of the plaintiff respondents.
10Being aggrieved with the aforesaid judgment and decree, the defendants/ appellants preferred the instant First Appeal No. 95 of 2000 before this Court.
11Mr. Uzzal Kumar Bhowmick, the learned Advocate for the appellants argued that the defendants (appellants) inherited the property as the lawful heirs of the original owner, Girish Chandra Dhupi, and the plaintiffs-respondents failed to prove their convoluted chain of title, possession, or dispossession. According to him, the alleged auction and subsequent extinguishment of the heirs' raiyati title are not proven. The burden of proof was squarely on the plaintiffs to establish the validity and existence of the legal proceedings that allegedly extinguished the clear inherited title. In this context, it was brought to notice that the core claim of the auction is supported only by a certified copy of a Sales Certificate (Exhibit-14) and a Kabuliat (Exhibit-16). According to him, the defendants produced a search slip (Exhibit-E series) from the concerned court showing no record of the alleged Rent Case No. 2319/34 or Rent Execution Case No. 1652/34 in the roll book. The registered copy of the sales certificate (Exhibit-14) contains contradictory case numbers, and the trial court's dismissal of this as mere "negligence" is an insufficient justification when the record search denies the existence of the case.
12It has been contended that the plaintiffs have utterly failed to adduce any documentary evidence in support of their assertion that Saforjan Bibi acquired
title to the suit property by way of auction sale of the superior interest of the admittedly alleged superior landlord, Mokrom Billah, and others. On the contrary, the plaintiffs’ own case suffers from material inconsistency and contradiction as to the identity of the superior landlord. While the plaintiff categorically asserts the superior landlord to be “Mokrom Billah Chowdhury Gong,” PW-1, in his examination-in-chief, erroneously stated the landlord to be “Safarjan Gong” and only attempted to rectify such misstatement during crossexamination, thereby rendering his testimony unreliable and untrustworthy.
13He argued that the Kabuliat (Exhibit-16) is highly doubtful and cannot be relied upon. He claims Kabuliat is fundamentally vitiated, as it purports to derive its validity from an alleged Rent Suit and corresponding Execution Case, the very existence and legality of which have not been proved by the plaintiffs. In the absence of proof of the underlying auction proceedings, any instrument purportedly emanating therefrom is devoid of legal foundation and must necessarily be rejected.
14It has alleged sale certificate was not supported by a document evidencing that the delivery of possession had been made. Such omission strikes at the root of the plaintiffs’ claim of lawful acquisition and possession. According to him, the testimony of PW-2 is highly questionable and undermines the plaintiffs’ case. PW-2 attempted to prove a Kabuliat allegedly registered in the year 1937 by producing a registration volume of the year 1936, which clearly casts serious doubt on the genuineness and authenticity of the document. This discrepancy strongly suggests manipulation and renders the plaintiffs’ documentary evidence unsafe to rely upon. Further, it has been argued in view of the aforesaid infirmities, contradictions, and lack of credible proof, the plaintiffs have failed to establish their claimed title and the suit is liable to be dismissed.
15Mr. Md. Munsurul Hoque Chowdhury, the learned Senior Advocate for the respondents, supports the judgment and decree; according to him plaintiff witness (P.W-2), by its testimony, prove Kabuliat registered in 1937 and, in
support of his claim, presented the related volume to the Court. He claims the court below did not commit any illegality in passing the decree, and the same does not require any interference either by the Appellate Court or by this Court.
16We have considered the submissions made by the parties, perused the memorandum of appeal and impugned judgment annexed herewith, and also perused the documents so exhibited by the parties.
17It has claimed that the plaintiff’s case and oral evidence are inconsistent with the identity of the superior landlord, and a failure of proof regarding possession and dispossession, which also creates a significant doubt about their ownership claim.
18Therefore, the point for consideration is whether the impugned judgment calls for interference by this Court.
19In the above context, on scrutiny, it appears that the plaintiff by its plaint claims h¢ZÑa e¡¢mn£ 231 ew M¢au¡−el Ef¢lÙÛ ü−aÄ j¡¢mL ¢R−me jœ²j ¢hmÉ¡ ®Q±d¤l£ Nw though, P.W-1 in its initial deposition states that e¡x M¢au¡−el i¨¢j−a ¢N¢ln Q¾cÐ d¤f£ j¡¢mL cMm L¡l b¡L¡hÙÛ¡u Ù»£ plm¡ p¤¾cl£ J LeÉ¡ ¢fœ¡m−u j¡l¡ ®N−m h¡c£ L−ll c¡−u Ef¢lÙÛ ü−aÄl j¡¢mL ¢R−me RglS¡e ¢h¢h Nw h¡c£ q−u plm¡ p¤¾cl£ Nw ®L ¢hh¡c£ L−l ®ge£ 2u j¤−¾pg£ Bc¡m−a 2319/1934 ew Ll ®j¡LŸj¡ Beue L−lz 138-34 Cw a¡¢l−M ¢Xœ²£ fË¡ç quz by the alleged deposition incorrectly identifies the superior landlord as Safarjan Gong.
20In the plaint, the plaintiff asserts that Mokrom Billah Gong was the superior landlord of Khatian No. 231. However, P.W-1, in his witness, categorically deposed that Safarjan Gong was the superior landlord who acquired the property after the auction. This erroneous assertion was subsequently distorted by cross-examination, where P.W-1 expressly admitted that Mokrom Billah Gong was, in fact, the superior landlord. Such contradictory versions from the part of the plaintiff’s witness strike at the root of the alleged chain of title and render the plaintiff’s claim wholly unreliable.
21Even assuming that Safarjan Gong had any connection with the property, the plaintiff has failed to produce a single document to establish superior interest of Mokrom Billah Gong was ever put to auction, or Safarjan
Gong lawfully acquired such interest through any auction proceeding. P.W-1 candidly admitted that no documentary evidence exists to show that Safarjan Gong acquired the property by auction. More significantly, the plaintiff admitted that no Dakhalanama (possession certificate) was filed in support of the alleged auction purchase. In the absence of a Dakhalanama, the alleged transfer of title and possession through auction remains legally unproven and wholly conjectural.
22Further, it appears that the testimony of P.W-2 is highly questionable, as they attempted to prove a Kabuliat (deed of agreement) registered in 1937 by bringing a Volume of 1936. The witness himself admitted that the alleged Kabuliat does not appear in the relevant pages of the said volume. Alleged illogical and untenable attempt to prove a document from the wrong year fatally undermines the authenticity and admissibility of Ext. 16, rendering it wholly unreliable.
23The plaintiff’s evidence regarding possession and dispossession is vague, contradictory, speculative, and self-destructive, and it can be evident from the following context, as stated below.
24It has claimed in the plaint that e¡¢mn£ p¡−hL 231 ew M¢au¡−el i¨¢j ¢em¡j qJu¡u M¢au¡−el l¡ua ¢N¢ln Q−¾cÐl üaÄ ¢hm¤ç qCu¡ ¢Nu¡−Rz However, P.W-1 in his deposition clearly states that e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j−a h¡c£Ne ®i¡NcM−m b¡L¡hÙÛ¡u 1-5 ew ¢hh¡c£Ne e¡¢mn£ ¢h,Hp, M¢au¡−el j¡¢mL ¢N¢ln Q−¾cÐl Ju¡¢ln¡eNe e¡x i¨¢j−a üaÄ cMm a¡−cl hl¡h−l ®R−s ®cJu¡l SeÉ Bj¡l ®R¡V i¡C−cl h−mez From the above it appears that the plaint specifies a manner of possession but P.W-1's deposition offered no specific manner of possession. Further, P.W-1 in his deposition admitted there is a "Ghar" (house) on the land, but did not state specific measurements his statement was as follows: e¡¢mn£ c¡−N HL¢V Ol B−Rz a−h ®L¡e l¡æ¡l Ol h¡ ®m¢VÊe ®eCz f−l h−m e¡¢mn£ c¡−N ®L¡e hpaOl ®eCz ®pM¡−e öd¤ HL¢V Lr ®~al£ Ll¡ B−Rz Ol¢V ¢V−el Q¡mk¤š², a−h f¢lj¡e hm−a f¡lh e¡z HC O−l ®L b¡−L hm−a f¡lh e¡z and failed to provide other specifications wherein it states ®hcMmL«a i¨¢jl p¤¢e¢ŸÑø ®~cOÉ fËÙÛ La B¢j S¡¢e e¡z ®hcM−ml fl ¢L ¢R−m j−e ®eCz
25Further, it appears P.W-3, in his deposition, states B¢j ¢hh¡c£−L ®hcMm Ll¡l pju ®c¢M¢ez. By such deposition, it is clear that other P.Ws gave contradictory evidence on their dispossession. P.W-4 attempted to improvise the manner of possession by introducing new elements (nursery and two shops), going beyond both the Plaint and P.W-1's testimony. In cross-examination, P.W-4 admitted they only heard about the dispossession according to him Bjl¡ fl¢ce ®c¡L¡−e Q¡ ®M−a H−p Shl cM−ml ¢hou ö¢ez Eš² 1/2 naL hÉ¢aa AeÉ ®L¡e i¨¢j−a ¢hh¡c£−cl cMm ®eC Hhw f§hÑ 1/2 na−LJ cMm ¢Rm e¡z h¡c£l¡ fË¡u 40 hvpl k¡hv cMm L−lz and did not know the date of dispossession Ešl f¡−nÄÑ ¢i¢V J ®c¡L¡e, f¢ÕQj f¡−nÄÑ A−eÉl S¡uN¡z
26From the above, it transpired that the plaint vaguely asserts possession following the auction; P.W-1’s deposition fails to describe any definite or continuous manner of possession. P.W-1 admitted the existence of a “ghar” on the land but could not specify its measurements, its nature, who resided therein, or any boundaries or appurtenant structures. Such evasive testimony conclusively demonstrates that P.W-1 had no actual knowledge of possession.
27The P.W-3 unequivocally admitted that he did not witness any dispossession. It appears P.W-4 conceded in cross-examination that he merely heard about the alleged dispossession and did not know the date or manner thereof. P.W-5 also admitted that he never saw the dispossession. Knowing such, it has been asserted that the plaintiff’s witnesses utterly failed to prove dispossession; further hearsay evidence of dispossession, unsupported by any specific date, manner, or act, is legally insufficient.
28Further, it transpired that a testimony witness supported the defendant's possession of the land. It is alleged that P.W-4 inadvertently supported the defense by admitting the existence of a kitchen on the suit land. P.W-4 deposes paÉ eu ®k, ®Qea¡l¡ Nw e£Q¥ S¡uN¡u LQ−¥ra m¡N¡uz LQ¤−r−œl c¢re ¢c®L h¡c£, Ešl f¡−nÄÑ M¡m, f¢ÕQj f¡−nÄÑ f¤L¥l, f§hÑ f¡−nÄÑ h¡S¡lz ¢hh¡c£l cMm£ i¨¢jl Ešl ¢c−L M¡m, c¢r−e e¡pÑ¡l£, f¢ÕQ−j AeÉ c¡−Nl f¤L¥l, f§hÑ ¢c−L h¡S¡lz ®Qea¡l¡−cl cMm£u Ol (5 10/12) hNÑq¡a a¡l p¡−b Ešl ¢c−L HL¢V l¡æ¡Olz ¢hh¡c£−cl ¢VEhJ−um B−R ¢Le¡ S¡¢e e¡z ¢hh¡c£l cMm£u i¨¢jl h¡C−ll e¡pÑ¡l£l f§hÑ f¡−nÄÑ h¡S¡lz Ešl f¡−nÄÑ ¢i¢V J ®c¡L¡e, f¢ÕQj
f¡−nÄÑ A−eÉl S¡uN¡z ®L¡e h¡−l ®Qea¡l¡ cMm L−l−R S¡¢e e¡z Na Dc¤m ¢gal/Dc¤m Bkq¡ La a¡¢l−M q−u−R pÈle ®eCz
29P.W-5 in its deposition confirming the presence of the defendant's "Ghar," latrine, and tubewell over the suit land, he states e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j¡a ®L¡e ®hX¡ ®eCz e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j−a Ešl c¢r−e 15-16 q¡a, f§hÑ-f¢ÕQ−j 8-10 q¡a kb¡ ®Qea¡l¡ Ol¢Vz Ol ®b−L ¢VEhJ−um¢V 15 q¡a c§−lz ®Qea¡l¡l mÉ¡¢YÊe Ešl f¡−nÄÑ 5/7 q¡a c§−lz l¡æ¡Ol¢V hpaO−ll Ešl f¡−nÄÑ 5/7 q¡a mð¡, fËÙÛ 4/5 q¡a, c¢rej¤M£z B¢j 145 d¡l¡l j¡jm¡ c¡−u−ll 1/2 ¢ce f§−hÑC ¢hh¡c£l¡ j¡¢V il¡V L−l¢Rmz Bj¡l c¡−ul£ j¡jm¡ M¡¢lS q−u−R ¢Le¡ B¢j S¡¢e e¡z e¡¢mn£ h¡s£¢V ¢hh¡c£−cl ®j¡~ln£ h¡s£ ¢Le¡ B¢j S¡¢e e¡z. P.W-5 also did not see the dispossession e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j−a c¤¢V ®c¡L¡e, c¤¢VC HLQ¡m¡z.
30From the above, it transpires that the plaintiff’s side made vague and contradictory testimony. Their witnesses could not provide the definite date of dispossession or the specific boundary of the property. While the Plaint specified a manner of possession, P.W-1 offered no specific manner in its deposition. Furthermore, P.W-3 and P.W-5 admitted they did not witness the alleged dispossession. P.W-4 attempted to introduce new unsupported elements of possession (nursery and two shops), but admitted they only heard about the dispossession and did not know the date. However, damagingly, the plaintiffs' own witnesses inadvertently supported the defense's position. P.W-5 delivered a significant admission, confirming the presence of the defendants' "Ghar, latrine, and tubewell over the suit land." The alleged admission strongly suggests that the plaintiff was not in possession at the time of the alleged dispossession.
31It appears the plaintiffs’ case suffers from material inconsistency and contradiction as to the identity of the superior landlord. The plaint categorically asserts that the superior landlord, to be “Mokrom Billah Chowdhury Gong,” P.W-1, in his examination-in-chief, erroneously stated the landlord to be “Safarjan Gong” and only attempted to rectify such misstatement during crossexamination, thereby rendering his testimony unreliable and untrustworthy. In this context, the plaintiff failed to submit any documents supporting the claim that Safarjan Gong acquired the property by auctioning the superior interest of
Mokrom Billah Gong. The alleged auction purchase is not supported by any documentary evidence, including dakhalanama. The plaintiff also failed to prove his possession at any material time. The plaintiff’s own witnesses affirmatively establish the defendant’s possession. Indeed, the plaintiffs failed to establish a superior title, and the defendants' title is clearer and supported by public records. The suit is nothing but a misconceived attempt to dispossess a party in settled possession.
32In light of the above discussions and reasons, we are of the view that the learned Joint District Judge, 2nd Court, Feni has utterly failed to assess the evidence on record adequately and came to a wrong decision, thereby, decreeing the suit. In view of the above, the impugned Judgment suffers from legal infirmities which call for interference by this Court. Thus, the appeal having merit succeeds.
33In the result, the First Appeal is allowed without any order as to cost.
34The impugned judgment and decree dated 26.08.2013 (decree signed on 29.08.2013), passed by the learned Joint District Judge, 2nd Court, Feni, in Suit/Civil Case No. 30 of 2008, decreeing the suit in favour of the plaintiffrespondent, are thus set aside.
35Let a copy of this judgment, along with the lower Court records, be communicated to the Court concerned forthwith.
36Jesmin Ara Begum, J:
37I agree.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











