High Court Division · Special Original Jurisdiction
Subhash Chandra Sikder v Bangladesh and others
Writ Petition 15517/2018 · Decided 28 January 2026
The petitioner joined a Bandarban high school as an Assistant Teacher in 1989, shortly before it was nationalised. He was absorbed into government service, completed the required B.Ed. degree within three years, and was regularised with effect from 04.11.1989. A 2015 gradation (seniority) list placed him at serial 309, and promotions were made on it. In 2018 the Ministry of Education decided that seniority of teachers who joined before the 1991 Rules would run from the date of acquiring the required degree, and juniors were then promoted over him. No one contested the Rule. The High Court Division held that the 2015 list had been acted on and created a vested right, that accrued rights cannot be taken away retrospectively except by legal mandate, and that administrative decisions are presumed prospective. Applying the Appellate Division's decision in Bakhrabad Gas System Limited, it made the Rule absolute and set aside decision No. 4.3 of the 2018 memo so far as it affected the petitioner.
Rule made absolute; seniority re-fixing decision set aside
- Rule absolute and Rule dischargedThe two final results of a Rule in the High Court Division: made absolute means the petitioner wins; discharged means the petition fails and the order below stands.Read the full explanation →
- Set asideTo cancel an earlier court order, decree, award, sale or conviction so that it no longer has legal effect, usually by a higher court or by the same court on a proper application.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether the Ministry of Education could, by a 2018 decision, re-fix the seniority of Government High School Assistant Teachers appointed before the 1991 Rules from the date of acquiring the required degree, to the detriment of a teacher whose seniority had been fixed from his date of regularisation in the 2015 gradation list.
- Q2
Whether an administrative decision can operate retrospectively to take away a vested right of seniority.
- The petitioner's service was regularised from 04.11.1989, and the 2015 gradation list counted his appointment from that date and had been acted on for several promotions, so the 2018 decision had no applicability to him.
- The 2015 gradation list created a vested right in the petitioner's favour, and a substantive right once accrued cannot be retrospectively taken away except by legal mandate.
- No retrospective effect can be given to administrative decisions, circulars or policies, which are presumed prospective, and a person who met all eligibility conditions under earlier rules is entitled to be guided by them.
- Applying Bakhrabad Gas System Limited v Al Masur-ar-noor, 66 DLR (AD) 187, the Court held that the right accrued on 04.11.1989 and acted upon on 25.03.2015 could not be taken away by the decision of 11.04.2018.
- The Rule was made absolute without costs, and decision No. 4.3 of the memo dated 11.04.2018, so far as it affected the petitioner, was declared unlawful and set aside.
No retrospective effect can be given to any administrative decision, circulars or policies, this type of decision has always been presumed to be prospective in nature.
In the court’s own words.
Writ Petition 15517/2018, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 10 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(SPECIAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION)
Writ Petition No. 15517 of 2018
IN THE MATTER OF:
An application under Article 102 of the
Constitution of the People‟s Republic of
Bangladesh.
-AND-
IN THE MATTER OF:
Subhash Chandra Sikder
……Petitioner
-Versus-
Present:
Mr. Justice Sashanka Shekhar Sarkar Bangladesh, represented by the Secretary,
And Ministry of Education, Bangladesh
Justice Urmee Rahman Secretariat, Ramna, Dhaka and others
….. Respondents
Mr. K. B. Shahriar Ahmad, Advocate
…For the petitioner
Mr. Mohammad Waliul Islam Oli, D.A.G with
Mr. Md. Ershadul Bari Khandakar, D.A.G,
Ms. Nilufar Yesmin, A.A.G,
Mr. Md. Moshiur Rahman (Rahat), A.A.G,
Mr. Md. Motasin Billah Parvez, A.A.G and
Mr. Md. Faridul Islam, A.A.G
…. For the respondents
Heard on 06.01.2026, 07.01.2026,15.01.2026,
21.01.2026 and Judgment on 28.01.2026
Urmee Rahman, J:
1In the instant writ petition Rule was issued in the following
2terms:
3“Let a Rule nisi be issued calling upon the
4Respondents show cause as to why the decision dated
511.04.2018 (Annexure-I) taken by the Ministry of
6Education, Secondary and Higher Secondary Division
7(Government Secondary-1) under the signature of the
8respondent Nos. 5-9 for re-fixing the seniority of the
9Assistant Teachers of the Government High Schools
10who got appointment before 07.02.1991
11discriminatory and violative to the fundamental rights
12guaranteed by the Constitution of the People‟s
13Republic of Bangladesh in derogation of the seniority
14list dated 25.03.2015 (Annexure-F) should not be
15passed without lawful authority and is of no legal
16effect and as to why the respondents should not be
17directed to give the petitioner financial benefit of the
18post of Assistant Headmaster/Assistant District
19Education officer as has been serving as „Current
20charge‟/ „PjwZ `vwqZ¡‟ of the same from 04.12.2016 and
21to remove all kinds of discrimination including
22payment as evident from Annexure-H being memo
23dated 17.09.2018 implementing and continuing the
24seniority list dated 25.03.2015 (annexure-F) and/or
25such other or further order or orders be passed as to
26this Court may seem fit and proper.”
27Relevant facts for disposal of the matter in brief are that, at present the petitioner is serving the post of Assistant Headmaster („Current Charge‟/Qm¢a c¡¢uaÅ) being Assistant Teacher at Sitakundo Government Ideal High School, Chattogram. Earlier he joined as an Assistant Teacher on 16.10.1989 in the Royangchori High School, Royangchori, Bandarban, Chittagong Hill Tracts. Soon after that the school was nationalized on 04.11.1989. The petitioner was temporarily absorbed in the same post on 25.03.1992 and he completed his B.Ed. degree on 25.10.1994 i.e. within 3 years as required by first proviso to sub rule 2 of Rule 4 of Teacher and
Non-teaching Staff of Nationalized High School (Directorate of Secondary and Higher Education) Absorption Rules, 1983. He was regularised on 03.02.1996 giving effect from the date of regularization.
28Until 1991 there was no recruitment rules for teachers. In this field the applicable law was Bangladesh Civil Service Recruitment Rules 1981. However; in that Rules there was no prescribed rule for promotion. By the S.R.O. No. 17-Ain/2010/05/030.0174.01.00.006. 2010 dated 18.01.2010, the Rule was amended by including the qualification for promotion as „Diploma in Education or B.Ed. or B.P.Ed. degree with 7 years‟ experience in the feeder post.
29In 1991 for the first time a service rule came into force for the teachers and staffs of schools: Kg©KZ©v I Kg©Pvix (gva¨wgK I D”P gva¨wgK wkÿv Awa`ßi) wb‡qvM wewagvjv, 1991. Rule 2 (uma) of this Rules denotes about the „required qualification‟ referring to the qualification as stated in the Schedule which is under the heading of „‡Rjv wkÿv Awdm I miKvix ¯‹zj‟ being serial no. 1 that, the recruitment of Assistant teacher would be carried out directly subject to obtaining 2 nd class Education Degree/Diploma within 5 years from the appointment. However, there was no rule on seniority and promotion for direct recruited teachers. As such on 03.05.2011 a Rule was made as „eeK¨vWvi Kg©KZ©v I Kg©Pvix †R¨ôZv I c‡`vbœwZ) wewagvjv, 2011‟ where Rule 4
30(2) provides that „wewfbœ c‡`i mgwš^Z †R¨ôZv wba©vi‡Yi †ÿ‡Î mswkøó †kÖYxi cÖviw¤¢K c‡` wbqwgZ †hvM`v‡bi Zvwi‡Li wfwˇZ mgwš^Z †R¨ôZv wba©vwiZ nB‡e|Ó
31Accordingly, on the basis of Absorption Rules of 1983, Bangladesh Civil Service Recruitment Rules, 1981 (As amended in 2010) and Rules of 2011 the seniority of the petitioner and others were fixed from their respective date of joining in the service and in 2015 a seniority list was prepared where the petitioner was placed in serial no. 309. Several promotions have been made on the basis of this seniority list.
32On 17.09.2018 the respondents gave promotion to some teachers, who are junior to the petitioner in terms of date of joining as well as in terms of receiving the B.Ed. degree.
33On query the petitioner came to learn that in the meeting dated 11.04.2018 the Ministry of Education took a decision in preparing a new seniority list in the light of judgment passed in W.P. no. 5667 of 2015 and the corresponding C.P. No. 2037 of 2016. In that meeting the decision No. 4.3 was taken by giving reference to two recommendations of Ministry of Education dated 16.08.1984 and of Bangladesh Public Service Commission dated 06.02.2003 where it was said to have decided that the seniority of the teachers, who joined before the Rules 1991 came into force, will be counted from the date of acquiring the required degree.
34The seniority of the petitioner having been breached as a consequence of the said decision, he has filed the instant writ petition as an aggrieved person and obtained the Rule.
35Mr. K. B. Shahriar Ahmad, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioner at the very outset submitted that seniority
means the length of service similarly situated with others in the same feeder post and is the primary criteria to be considered in promotion though not the only criteria but the impugned decision of the respondents has made the primary criteria questionable resulting in discrimination among the teachers‟ in the same feeder posts and as such the impugned decision is discriminatory, mala fide, without lawful authority and therefore is liable to be declared to have taken in violation of the petitioner‟s fundamental rights as guaranteed by Articles 27, 29, 31 and 32 of the Constitution.
36It has been further submitted by the learned Advocate that the petitioner has acquired vested and indefeasible right of seniority in the post of Assistant Headmaster as per the gradation list prepared in 2015 which cannot be taken away capriciously at the sweet will of the respondents and hence the impugned decision debarring the petitioner from promotion is liable to be set aside.
37Mr. Ahmad argued that as per the judgment of the Supreme Court, as mentioned in the impugned decision, the petitioner is entitled to get promotion from the date of his joining in the service, not from the date of obtaining B.Ed. degree as Bangladesh Civil Service Recruitment Rules 1981provides no such condition and as such the pre-1991 appointed teachers, like the petitioner, are entitled to get promotion preferably as per seniority and hence the impugned decision debarring the petitioner from promotion is liable to be declared to have been adopted without lawful authority.
38He next contended that the impugned decision of the Public Service Commission does not have any overriding effect over the existing law namely Teachers and Non-Teaching Staffs of Nationalized High School Absorption Rules, 1983, Bangladesh, Civil Service Recruitment Rules, 1981 (as amended in 2010) and 'নন-ক্যাডার ক্র্মক্র্মা J LjÑQ¡l£ ®SÉùa¡ J f-c¡æ¢a ¢h¢dj¡m¡, 2011' and thus the impugned decision is mala fide, discriminatory, arbitrary and therefore liable to be set aside.
39He finally submitted that the impugned decision amounts to downgrading the rank of the petitioner which is discriminatory and therefore, the same is liable to be declared without any lawful authority and is no legal effect.
40No one appears to contest the Rule.
41We have heard the learned Advocate for the petitioner and perused the writ petition and as well as all the documents annexed therewith.
42As we have already seen from the case of the petitioner as has been discussed hereinabove that, the petitioner joined the school on 16.10.1989. However, the school was nationalized thereafter on 04.11.1989 and as per the Absorption Rules of 1983 the petitioner was temporarily absorbed in the same post on 25.03.1992 with the condition to complete the required B.Ed. degree within 3 years. Accordingly, he obtained the required decree withing the stipulated time and obtained the result on 25.10.1994. Subsequently, he was regularized in his service by the memo dated
03.02.1996 giving effect from the date of regularization of the school i.e. from 04.11.1989, as evident from Annexure A series at page 43 in serial no. 67. The relevant portion of the memo dated 03.02.1996, by which the petitioner along with other teachers were regularized, is quoted below:
43“A¡aÈ£Lle ¢h¢d 1983Cw Ae¤k¡u£ Hhw pwÙÛ¡fe j¿»Z¡m-ul
445/09/89Cw a¡¢l-Ml ew pj/A¡l-1/33/89-224(450) pÈ¡l-L N¢Wa
45¢hi¡N£u h¡R¡C/¢ehÑ¡Qe L¢j¢Vl 27/1/96Cw a¡¢l-Ml pi¡l
46p¤f¡¢lnœ²j ¢nr¡Na ®k¡NÉa¡, f¤¢mn ®i¢l¢gLne J X¡š²¡l£ fl£r¡
47CaÉ¡¢c pwœ²¡¿¹ pec¡¢c fl£r¡-¿¹ p¡j¢uLi¡-h A¡aÈ£L«a ¢eÇj¢m¢Ma
48¢nrL/¢n¢rL¡ J LjÑQ¡l£-cl-L pw¢nÔø ¢hcÉ¡mu S¡a£uLl-el
49a¡¢lM/pw¢nÔø ¢nrL/¢n¢rL¡ J LjÑQ¡l£l p¡j¢uL A¡aÈ£Ll-el a¡¢lM
50qCa ay¡q¡cl e¡jl f¡nÄÑ h¢ZÑa ®haeœ²j Q¤s¡¿¹ A¡aÈ£LlZ J
51¢eu¢ja ¢e-u¡N fÐc¡e Ll¡ qCmz”
52It appears from the record that there was no recruitment Rules for teachers until 1991 and the only law applicable in this field was Bangladesh Civil Service Recruitment Rules, 1981. In 1991 for the first time a service rule came into force mainly: LjÑLaÑ¡ J LjÑQ¡l£ ¢e-u¡N ¢h¢dj¡m¡, 1991. However, this rule also did not contain any provision regarding seniority or promotion of the teachers. As such on 03.05.2011 another Rule was made, namely, ee-LÉ¡X¡l LjÑLaÑ¡ J LjÑQ¡l£ ®SÉùa¡ J f-c¡æ¢a ¢h¢dj¡m¡, 2011 wherein Rule 4(2) provided that “¢h¢iæ fcl pj¢eÄa ®SÉùa¡ ¢edÑ¡lZl ®rœ ¢pw¢nÔø ®nÐZ£l fСl¢ñL fc ¢eu¢ja ®k¡Nc¡el a¡¢lMl ¢i¢ša pj¢eÄa ®SÉùa¡ ¢edÑ¡¢la qChz”
53As we have already found in our previous discussion that the petitioner‟s service was regularized from the date 04.11.1989 and accordingly on 25.03.2015 a gradation list was prepared from
where it can be seen that the date of appointment of the petitioner was also considered to be from 04.11.1989 (Annexure-F) wherein the petitioner‟s name was posted in serial No. 309.
54By the impugned decision as annexed in (Annexure-I), the Ministry of Education took a decision, which has been placed in serial No. 4.3, wherein a reference has been made to a recommendation made by the Ministry of Education dated 16.08.1984 and also another recommendation made by the Bangladesh Public Service Commission dated 06.02.2003 and on the basis of these recommendations it was decided that the seniority of the teachers who joined before the Rules, 1991, will be counted from the date of acquiring the required degree.
55We have seen that in the gradation list prepared in 2015 there is no reference of the said recommendation made by the Bangladesh Public Service Commission dated 06.02.2003 and the gradation list has already been acted upon because promotions have been given in several occasions on the basis of that gradation list. Therefore, the subsequent decision taken by the respondents by the impugned memo does not have any applicability in case of the petitioner.
56The gradation list was prepared in 2015 and a vested right has already been created in favour of the petitioner. Earlier it has decided in many cases by this Honb‟le Court that a substantive right once accrued are not to be retrospectively taken away except by legal mandate. It has also been decided in many cases that a
substantive policy decision cannot operate to the detriment of a person who was appointed earlier under the different set of rules since the earlier rules had already conferred a right or benefit upon him.
57No retrospective effect can be given to any administrative decision, circulars or policies, this type of decision has always been presumed to be prospective in nature. As the petitioner had already fulfilled all the eligibility conditions for promotion under the previous rules, he is lawfully entitled to be guided by that rule as a matter of right.
58In this context a decision of the Appellate Division reported in 66 DLR (AD) 187 in the case of Bakhrabad Gas System Limited Vs. Al Masur-ar-noor and Ors. is quoted below:
59“To be more explicit, the appointing
60authority enjoys the power and the authority to
61frame new rules to regulate the service of its
62employees, but that in no way, can take away
63the accrued/vested rights of its employees, here
64the writ petitioners. We also make it very clear
65that an employee shall definitely be entitled to
66the new service benefits if given or created by
67the new rules, but no rules can be framed to his
68disadvantage or detriment or to the denial of his
69accrued/vested right as in the instant case
70sought to be taken away. The new rules adding
71new terms and conditions including the one as
72to the promotion to the next higher posts shall
73be effective and applicable to the employees,
74who will be appointed after the coming into
75effect or force of the same.” (per Md. Abdul
76Wahhab Miah, J.)
77On the basis of the principle laid down by the Appellate Division we hold that, since the petitioner accrued the right on 04.11.1989, which has also been acted upon by the respondents on 25.03.2015, the same right cannot be taken away by the subsequent decision, which has been taken by the impugned memo dated 11.04.2018.
78With the findings and discussion made hereinabove, we are of the opinion that there is substance in the Rule issued in the instant matter.
79In the result, the Rule is made absolute.
80There is no order as to cost.
81The impugned memo dated 11.04.2018 so far it relates to the decision No. 4.3 affecting the petitioner is hereby declared unlawful and without any lawful authority and hereby set aside.
82Communicate the judgment and order at once. Sashanka Shekhar Sarkar, J:
83I agree.
84Helal/ABO
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











