High Court Division
Prof. Md. Abdus Samad v The Government of Bangladesh and others
Writ Petition 6664/2014 · Decided 4 March 2026
A professor of Khulna University of Engineering & Technology (KUET) was accused of serving as a Dean at another university and drawing a monthly honorarium without KUET's approval. The Syndicate formed an inquiry committee, the Registrar issued a show cause notice giving 7 days to reply, and on 03.07.2014 the professor was compulsorily retired. He challenged the order by writ petition. The High Court Division found the allegation proved by his own written reply, which amounted to misconduct under the 2nd Statute of KUET. However, compulsory retirement was a major penalty, and the Statute required a formal charge, 10 days to reply and notice of the proposed punishment. None of this was done, and the inquiry committee was formed before the show cause notice. The objection that he should first have appealed was rejected, since the Syndicate itself had imposed the penalty. The Rule was made absolute. As he had since retired, no reinstatement was ordered, but he was held entitled to all financial benefits in accordance with law.
Rule made absolute; compulsory retirement declared unlawful
- Q1
Whether a KUET professor could be given the major penalty of compulsory retirement without a formal charge, a statement of the proposed punishment and the procedure required by Rule 19(11) of the 2nd Statute of KUET.
- Q2
Whether the writ petition was barred because the petitioner did not appeal to the Syndicate under Rule 20 of the 2nd Statute of KUET.
- The petitioner's own written reply proved that he served another university without KUET's approval in violation of Rule 18(3) of the 2nd Statute, which was misconduct.
- Compulsory retirement is a major penalty under Rule 19(7)(Kha)(2) of the 2nd Statute, and imposing it requires the procedure in Rule 19(11), including a formal charge, 10 days to reply and notice of the proposed punishment.
- As no formal charge was framed, only 7 days were given, the inquiry committee was formed before the show cause notice and the proposed punishment was not stated, the proceeding and penalty were without lawful authority and of no legal effect.
- Since the Syndicate itself took the final decision, an appeal to the same authority under Rule 20 was meaningless and the petitioner rightly invoked the writ jurisdiction.
- The order of 03.07.2014 was declared unlawful; no reinstatement was ordered because the petitioner had retired, but he was held entitled to all financial benefits in accordance with law.
The university Authority very casually proceeded with the inquiry against the petitioner and imposed major penalty upon him which cannot be sustained in law.
In the court’s own words.
Writ Petition 6664/2014, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 10 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1
Bench:
Mr. Justice Bhishmadev Chakrabortty
And
Mr. JusticeMurad-A-Mowla Sohel
Writ Petition No.6664 of 2014
Prof. Md. Abdus Samad …… petitioner
-Vs-
The Government of Bangladesh and others
…… respondents
Mr. Md. Mozammel Hossain with Ms. Shalina
Tazrin, Advocates ……for the petitioner
Ms. Tapati Ghosh, Advocate for Mr. Subrata
Chowdhury, learned Senior Advocate
…… for Respondents 2 and 3
Judgment on 04.3.2026.
Bhishmadev Chakrabortty, J:
1The Rule in the aforequoted writ petition was issued in the following terms:
2“Let a Rule Nisi issue calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to why the Notification issued by the Respondent No.3 under Memo No.
3dated 03.07.2014 (Annexure-C) in compulsory retiring the petitioner from service should not be declared to have been issued without any lawful authority and of no legal effect and/or such other or further order or orders passed to this Court may seem fit and proper.”
4At the time of issuing the Rule operation of the impugned notification as contained in annexure-C to the writ petition was stayed for a limited period which was subsequently extended from time to time and still subsists.
5The material facts as stated in the writ petition, in brief, are that the petitioner was appointed as Director of Bangladesh Institute of Technology (BIT), Khulna on 28.07.1991 for 4 years. After expiry of the tenure his directorship was extended. After establishment of Khulna University of Engineering & Technology (KUET) on 1st September, 2003 he was serving there as professor Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering (EEE). During his service there the Hon’ble President of Republic appointed him as Vice-Chancellor of Prime University, Dhaka for 4 years. The KUET authority approved his 4 years unpaid leave with lien. He joined in the Prime University on 11.04.2007 as Vice-Chancellor and after tenure of 4 years of service there he joined in the KUET on 12.04.2011 and till date of filing of the writ petition he was serving his professional responsibilities and obligations efficiently. All of a sudden the petitioner came to learn that the Syndicate of KUET in its 45th meeting formed a committee to investigate whether he served in the University of Science and Technology Chattogram (USTC) as a Dean and took salary of Taka 1 lac each month from January 2013 to July 2013. Subsequently, the Registrar of KUET, respondent 3 herein sent a letter to the petitioner asking him to explain the allegation denoting the said letter. The aforesaid letter shows that an inquiry committee was formed against him. He sent a reply of the same to respondent 3 on 06.03.2014. The committee requested him to appear before the Chairman of the committee at Dhaka to explain his position as to the allegation brought against him. The petitioner appeared before the Chairman of the Inquiry Committee on 24.05.2014 and on that day or afterwards the authority did not inform him that they are going to take major penalty against him. Respondent 3 suddenly without any further show cause notice upon him
issued a notification on 03.07.2014 compulsory retiring him from service of KUET under the provisions of Rule 19(7)(Kha)(2) of Khulna University of Engineering & Technology, 2nd Rules (2nd Statute) framed in 2005 read with Rule 4(3)(Kha) of the Government Servants (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1985 (the Rules, 1985). The impugned notice was issued by violating the mandatory provisions of law of the Rules 1985 and 2nd Statue of the University. In passing the order of compulsory retirement to the petitioner, the respondents violated the provisions of Article 135 of the Constitution without serving any show cause notice upon him and without framing any charge for imposing major penalty. The petitioner then through his learned Advocate sent a notice upon the respondents demanding justice. But the respondents did not inform anything to the petitioner which is nothing but denial of justice. The petitioner finally approached this Court with this writ petition and obtained this Rule with an interim order of stay.
6Respondents 2 and 3 filed affidavit-in-opposition to contest the Rule. There they denied the material facts as stated in the writ petition further contending that in 45th meeting of KUET Syndicate they took decision and constituted an Inquiry Committee to investigate into allegation brought against the petitioner of serving as Dean in USTC taking remuneration of Taka1 lac from January 2013 without taking approval of the KUET. In reply to the said notice the petitioner admitted the allegation brought against him. As a professor of KUET he cannot avail extra financial benefit by abusing professional ethics. But he joined in the USTC and took honorarium behind the back of the respondents which amounts to misconduct. The petitioner is a self-
declared doyen in the rank of Professor of KUET. He initially took assignment for 3 months service offered by USTC from 03.10.2010 as Advisor to the Vice Chancellor and Dean with monthly financial benefit of Taka 1 lac as a matter of contract dated 11.11.2010 and further extended 2 terms from 03.01.2011 to 02.01.2013 and 03.01.2013 to 02.01.2015 vide correspondence dated 22.01.2011 and 02.10.2013 keeping all other conditions unchanged behind the back of KUET Authority withholding information as to drawal of honorarium. The KUET Authority correctly took the decision of imposition of major penalty against him on holding inquiry by forming an inquiry committee, and as such the Rule would be discharged.
7Mr. Md. Mozammel Hossain, learned Advocate for the petitioner taking us through the writ petition, the annexures appended thereto and the law relating to taking disciplinary action against the employees of KUET submits that the Inquiry Committee was formed before issuance of show cause notice upon the petitioner. As per the provisions of Rule 19(7)(Kha)(2) of the second Statue of KUET, the compulsory retirement is a major penalty ( ) and to impose such penalty upon an employee, the inquiry should be as per the provisions of sub-rule 11 of Rule 19 of the Statute. As per the provisions of the aforesaid sub-rule charge is to be framed against an employee and proposed punishment, if the charge is proved, should be informed to him which was not at all done in the present case. Therefore, forming of the Inquiry Committee on 16.09.2013 in the 45th Syndicate meeting of KUET and imposing the penalty of compulsory retirement to the petition with all benefits through annexure-C has been issued in gross violation of the
provisions of 2nd Statue of KUET and Rules, 1985. By issuing such order the KUET authority has infringed the fundamental rights of the petitioner, and as such the Rule would be made absolute.
8Ms. Tapati Ghosh appearing for Mr. Subrata Chowdhury, learned Senior Advocate for respondents 2 and 3 on the other hand taking us through the annexures of the affidavit-in-opposition and supplementary affidavit-inopposition submits that by the strength of order of stay of the impugned order passed by this Division on 15.07.2014 the petitioner on completing his full tenure of service in the university went on retirement on 02.08.2016 after attaining the age of 65 years. Since the petitioner was given compulsory retirement with all benefits and in the meantime he has already relied from service, therefore, this Rule has virtually become infructuous. He then refers to the provisions of Rule 20 of the KUET, 2nd Statue and submits that against the impugned order of compulsory retirement, the petitioner ought to have preferred an appeal to the Syndicate but without doing so, he invoked writ jurisdiction of this Court directly. In that view of the matter, the instant writ petition is not maintainable. She lastly submits that the petitioner was a permanent teacher of KUET but by violating the laws and Rules he served in USTC and took salary therefrom which has been admitted by him in his written reply to the show cause notice. The aforesaid act of the petitioner is a misconduct within the meaning of Second Statue of KUET. The charge brought against him thus has been proved and as such there is nothing to interfere with the impugned order of imposing major penalty. The Rule, therefore, would be discharged.
9We have considered the submissions of both the sides, gone through the materials on record, the annexures appended with the writ petition, the affidavit-in-opposition and the law relating to take action against any employee of KUET known as 2nd Statue of KUET and Rules, 1985.
10It is admitted fact that the petitioner was a teacher of department of EEE of KUET. He was a permanent teacher and professor of the department. The Second Statue of KUET was framed in 2005 as per the provisions of section 20(2)(Ka) of Act 33 of 2003. Rule 18(3) of the aforesaid 2nd Statue provides that if he wants to serve any other university or any organization he has to take prior approval from the KUET Authority. The allegation was brought against him that he without taking permission from KUET served as a Dean in the USTC and drew regular salary therefrom as a teacher. On such allegation, the Syndicate in its minutes of meeting 45/39 dated 16.09.2013 through annexureA formed an Inquiry Committee consisting of 4(four) members to inquire into the allegation so brought against him. Respondent 3, Registrar of KUET under the purported authority of respondent 2 sent a show cause notice to him on 29.01.2014 (Annexure-A-1) asking him to submit a reply within 7 days to the allegation brought against him. The petitioner through annexure-B replied to the said show cause notice. In the reply he stated amongst other, “KUET-
11weekend Honorarium Honorarium
12KUET- EEE Dept- Course Load
13emphasis supplied
14The aforesaid written statement submitted by him proves that he provided service to the USTC while he was a full time professor of KUET without taking any approval or permission from KUET Authority in gross violation of Rule 18(3) of the 2nd Statue which comes within the meaning of misconduct defined in Rule 3(21)(Ga) of the same Statue. The petitioner was a professor of KUET and as such his aforesaid acts obviously do not go with his status and position. Therefore, we find that allegation so brought against the petitioner by the KUET authority is found proved. But the fact remains that to impose major penalty upon an employee of the aforesaid University, the Authority has to follow the procedure of law applicable at the material time, i.e., the 2nd Statue of KUET read with the relevant provisions of the Rules, 1985. Rule 19(7)(Ka) and (Kha) of the 2nd Statue classified the penalty may be imposed upon an employ of KUET in 2 categories as under-
15(Censure),
16(Reduction to a lower
17post or time-scale),
18(Compulsory retirement),
19(Removal)
20(Dismissal) (emphasis supplied)
21The penalty imposed upon the petitioner is found a major penalty as per Rule 19 (7) (Kha) (2) of the 2nd Statue of KUET. In case of imposition of major penalty, the procedure of Rule 19(11) of the Statue is to be followed which reads as follows:
22(Charge)
23(Statement of
24allegations)
25(Circumstances)
26(emphasis supplied)
27The aforequoted provisions of law provides that for taking disciplinary action against an employee formal charge/charges has to be brought and he has to be given 10 days time to submit its reply. But in the present case no formal
charge was brought against the petitioner, only allegation was brought against him. He was given only 7 days time to submit reply and Inquiry Committee was formed before issuance of show cause notice. But the petitioner submitted replay to the allegation brought against him. The aforesaid law also prescribes that in case of probability of inflicting major penalty the proposed punishment and the charge is to be mentioned in the show cause notice which is totally absent in this case. The university Authority very casually proceeded with the inquiry against the petitioner and imposed major penalty upon him which cannot be sustained in law. The whole proceeding and action taken against the petitioner is found to have been done in gross violation of law which are without lawful authority and are of no legal effect.
28We have gone through Rule 20 of the 2nd Statue of KUET where it is found that there is provision of appeal to the Syndicate against order passed against any employee alike the petitioner. We find that in the present case the KUET Syndicate took final decision to impose major penalty, therefore, the question of filing appeal to the same authority is found meaningless. The argument made by learned Advocate for respondents 2 and 3 on this point, therefore, bears no substance. Since the order has been passed in flagrant violation of law infringing the fundamental right of the petitioner guaranteed in the Constitution, the petitioner rightly invoked writ jurisdiction of this Court.
29In view of the discussion made hereinabove, we find merit in this Rule. Accordingly, the Rule is made absolute. The impugned order as contained in annexure-C to the writ petition dated 03.07.2014 compulsory retiring the petitioner from service is declared to have issued without lawful authority and
is no legal effect. Since the petitioner in the meantime has retired from service after completing his tenure of job attaining the age of retirement, therefore, no order is required to be passed for his reinstatement.
30However, the petitioner is entitled to get all financial benefits in accordance with law as he was entitled to as a regular teacher after his retirement.
31Communicate this judgment and order to the concerned.
32Murad-A-Mowla Sohel, J.
33I agree
34Sumon-B.O.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











