Supreme Court Judgments, Summarised

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Nov 3, 2026

Summary

The petitioner, a Deputy Assistant Director of the Bangladesh Agriculture Development Corporation (BADC), was charged with misconduct, an inquiry officer found him guilty, and after a second show cause notice he was dismissed on 19.02.2015; his appeal to the Chairman was rejected and a later review application was never decided. He argued that the inquiry reports were submitted well beyond the time limit in rule 43(4) of the BADC Service Regulations, 1990. The High Court Division held that rule 43(4) prescribes no consequence for missing the time limit, so it is directory, not mandatory. Following earlier decisions, delay alone does not vitiate an inquiry where the other procedural steps are followed, and here charges were framed, notices issued, an inquiry officer appointed and the petitioner given ample opportunity to defend himself. Rule 48 allows a review only where the Chairman imposes the penalty, so there was no duty to decide his review. The Rule was discharged without costs.

Issues

  1. Q1

    Whether submission of the departmental inquiry report after the time limit in rule 43(4) of the BADC Service Regulations, 1990 vitiates a dismissal order where all other procedural requirements were followed.

  2. Q2

    Whether the BADC authority was bound to dispose of a review application filed after the Chairman rejected the petitioner's departmental appeal.

Key points

  • Rule 43(4) of the BADC Service Regulations, 1990 sets a time limit for the inquiry but prescribes no consequence for non-compliance, so the requirement is directory and not mandatory.
  • Following Abdur Rouf (MD) v Power Development Board (60 DLR 292) and S.M. Mozammel Hoque Talukder v State (68 DLR (AD) 370), the Court held that failure to complete an inquiry within the stipulated time does not by itself make the proceeding unlawful.
  • BADC complied with all other procedural requirements, including framing charges, issuing show cause notices, appointing an inquiry officer and giving the petitioner ample opportunity to defend himself, so he was not prejudiced and the dismissal was lawful.
  • Under rule 48 a review lies only where the penalty is imposed by the Chairman, so the petitioner, dismissed by the Secretary and with his appeal rejected by the Chairman, had no right of review and the respondents were not obliged to decide it.
  • The Rule was discharged without costs.

since all other procedural formalities have been followed by the authority while dismissing the petitioner, the mere failure to conduct the inquiry within the stipulated time would not vitiate the ultimate result

From the judgment, Justice Urmee Rahman
Law considered

BADC Service Regulations, 1990, rule 43(4)BADC Service Regulations, 1990, rule 48(4)BADC Service Regulations, 1990, rule 40Constitution of the People's Republic of Bangladesh, Article 102

The judgment

In the court’s own words.

Writ Petition 9258/2023, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 11 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.

PDF
Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp