Supreme Court Judgments, Summarised

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Nov 3, 2026

Summary

The petitioners, 43rd BCS candidates who sat the viva voce examination but were not recommended to cadre posts, challenged the Public Service Commission's failure to publish a merit list of non-cadre candidates and sought further recommendations to vacant non-cadre posts. The Commission had invited non-cadre choices from all viva candidates before cadre nominations and without a merit list, then recommended only 642 candidates against 1,342 posts. It argued that results were confidential and the 44th BCS complete. The High Court Division held that the Non-Cadre Appointment Rules, 2023 applied to the 43rd BCS, that the confidentiality bar in Rule 12 of the BCS Service Rules, 2014 concerns cadre appointments only, and that Rule 5 obliges the Commission to publish a merit list for non-cadre recommendation. As the 2023 Rules set no validity period for the list, further recommendations were not barred. No vested right to appointment arises. The Rule was disposed of with a direction to publish the merit list within 60 days and start the selection process.

Issues

  1. Q1

    Whether the Public Service Commission followed due process in the 43rd BCS by inviting non-cadre choices without first publishing a merit list of successful non-cadre candidates.

  2. Q2

    Whether the Commission may still recommend 43rd BCS candidates to non-cadre posts after publication of the final result of the 44th BCS.

  3. Q3

    Whether the petitioners have a right to be recommended to non-cadre posts.

Key points

  • The Non-Cadre Appointment Rules, 2023, being procedural and not affecting substantive rights, apply to 43rd BCS candidates although the circular was published under the earlier Rules.
  • While the Commission is barred from disclosing written or viva voce results relating to cadre appointments, there is no corresponding bar on publishing a merit list for recommending candidates to non-cadre posts.
  • Inviting non-cadre choices from all viva candidates before cadre nominations and without publishing a merit list violated the non-cadre recruitment Rules and the circular, so due process was not followed.
  • Since the 2023 Rules prescribe no period of validity for the merit list, there is no bar to the Commission recommending 43rd BCS candidates to non-cadre posts after the 44th BCS result.
  • No vested right to appointment accrues from passing the examinations or appearing on a merit list; selection depends on requisition, qualifications, merit and the candidate's choice list.
  • The Commission was directed to publish the 43rd BCS non-cadre merit list under Rule 5 within 60 days and then initiate the selection process.

Our specific finding, therefore, is that while the PSC is barred from disclosing the written or viva voce results relating to cadre appointments, there is no corresponding bar on publishing a merit list for the purpose of recommending candidates to non-cadre posts.

From the judgment, Justice Urmee Rahman
Law considered

Non-Cadre Appointment Rules, 2023, Rule 5Non-Cadre Appointment Rules, 2023, Rules 4(3) and 9(3)BCS Service Rules, 2014, Rule 12Constitution of the People's Republic of Bangladesh, Article 102

The judgment

In the court’s own words.

Writ Petition (TN) 1147/2024, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 28 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.

PDF
Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp