Mobile Court Legality in Bangladesh: The 2017 Verdict, the Stay and Challenging Fines

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Oct 23, 2026 | Disputes & Public Law, Insights | 0 comments

TRW Insight / Bangladesh

The High Court Division held in 2017 that executive magistrates running mobile courts exercise judicial power unconstitutionally. The Appellate Division stayed that ruling pending appeals that remain unheard, so mobile courts still operate, but individual orders can still be overturned when they break the Act's own limits.

Updated 23 October 2026Legal insightBangladesh13 min read

Mobile court legality: where the law stands in 2026

Mobile court legality has been an open constitutional question in Bangladesh since 11 May 2017, when the High Court Division declared that executive magistrates running mobile courts under the Mobile Court Act 2009 were exercising judicial power the Constitution reserves to the judiciary. The Appellate Division stayed that judgment, and mobile courts have continued to operate under the stay ever since: in February 2026 the government appointed 1,051 executive magistrates to run them during the national election. Businesses fined on the spot, individuals jailed after summary hearings and the lawyers advising them therefore work in an unusual space, where the governing Act has been held unconstitutional but remains in operation.

This guide explains how mobile courts work, what the High Court Division decided in 2017 and why, what the Appellate Division has and has not done since, how later decisions have limited mobile court powers, and how a person penalised by a mobile court can challenge the order through appeal, revision or a writ petition.

Mobile court legality in Bangladesh — market stalls inspected during a mobile court drive
Mobile courts are widely used in food and market enforcement

Summary: In Kamruzzaman Khan v Bangladesh the High Court Division declared sections 5, 6(1), 6(2), 6(4), 7, 8(1), 9, 10, 11, 13 and 15 of the Mobile Court Act 2009 unconstitutional for breaching the separation of powers and judicial independence. The Appellate Division granted leave and allowed executive magistrates to keep running mobile courts until the government's appeals are decided. Individual orders remain open to challenge where the magistrate exceeded the Act's limits.

Key point: The stay keeps the Act operating, but it does not cure defects in individual cases. A mobile court that tries an offence outside its schedule, convicts a child, or sentences without a genuine confession recorded in the manner section 7 requires is still acting unlawfully, and the High Court Division has set aside such convictions while the main appeal remains pending.

At a glance

01

The Act

The Mobile Court Act 2009 lets executive magistrates try listed offences committed in their presence and impose penalties on the spot.

02

2017 judgment

The High Court Division held eleven provisions unconstitutional on 11 May 2017 in three heard-together writ petitions.

03

Stay pending appeal

In January 2018 the Appellate Division allowed mobile courts to continue until the government's appeals are disposed of.

04

Children

In March 2020 the High Court Division declared the mobile court convictions of 121 children illegal.

05

2026 practice

1,051 executive magistrates were appointed under section 5 to run mobile courts during the February 2026 election.

Table of Contents

How mobile courts work

Mobile courts began under an ordinance in 2007 and were placed on a statutory footing when Parliament passed the Mobile Court Act on 4 October 2009.[7] Section 5 is the provision under which executive magistrates, who are officers of the administrative civil service rather than judges, are empowered to conduct mobile courts.[11] The magistrate who witnesses a scheduled offence takes cognizance, frames the charge and, on the accused's confession, convicts and sentences on the spot.[1] [8]

The section 7 procedure

Section 7 sets out the steps the magistrate must follow: witnessing the offence, detaining the offender, recording names, taking cognizance, recording the complaint, framing and reading out the charge, recording the confession and obtaining signatures.[8] These steps are not formalities. They are the only procedural protection in a process where the same official observes the offence, frames the charge and passes sentence.

Scope and scale

The schedule to the Act lists the laws whose offences mobile courts may try, which by 2019 covered 104 offences, from food adulteration and narcotics to illegal occupation and unlawful gathering.[9] Supporters point to their role in tackling food adulteration, market control, polythene use and illegal construction; one 2017 commentary cited almost 9 lakh cases disposed of and more than Tk 208 crore in revenue over seven years.[10] That practical utility is the main reason the question of mobile court legality has remained politically difficult to resolve.

The 2017 High Court Division judgment

Three writ petitions were heard together: Kamruzzaman Khan v Bangladesh (Writ Petition No 8437 of 2011), Md Mujibur Rahman v Bangladesh (Writ Petition No 10482 of 2011) and Md Saifullah v Bangladesh (Writ Petition No 4879 of 2012). A Division Bench of Justice Moyeenul Islam Chowdhury and Justice Ashish Ranjan Das delivered judgment on 11 May 2017.[1]

The petitioners

The petitioners included a property developer who had been sentenced to 30 days' imprisonment for building-law violations, a building owner who sought refund of a Tk 10 lakh fine, and 17 bakery owners who asked for directions that mobile courts dealing with food adulteration be supported by food experts and testing equipment.[3] The range of petitioners shows how widely mobile court orders affect ordinary commercial life.

What the Court declared

The Court held sections 5, 6(1), 6(2), 6(4), 7, 8(1), 9, 10, 11, 13 and 15 of the Act ultra vires the Constitution and described mobile courts run by the executive magistracy as coram non judice. It said mobile courts, if any, must be staffed by judicial or metropolitan magistrates.[1] It condoned past convictions and sentences other than those under challenge in higher courts, and directed refund of the Tk 10 lakh fine within 90 days.[2]

The reasoning

The central ground was separation of powers. Relying on the Appellate Division's directions in the Masdar Hossain case to separate the lower judiciary from the executive, the Court held that executive magistrates cannot take cognizance, convict and sentence, and described the conferral of those powers as "a frontal attack on the independence of the judiciary".[1] [2] It found the Act inconsistent with Articles 22, 31 and 35(3) of the Constitution and called the impugned provisions colourable legislation.[1]

Section-by-section findings

  • Section 6(1): a magistrate who witnessed the offence cannot also try it.
  • Section 6(2): offences cannot be created by delegated legislation.
  • Section 6(4): no criteria governed which cases go to the regular courts, which was discriminatory.
  • Section 7: there was no safeguard governing how confessions are obtained or recorded, so convictions based on them were unsafe.
  • Sections 8, 9 and 10: discriminatory, arbitrary or inconsistent with the double jeopardy protection in Article 35(2).
  • Sections 11 and 13: district magistrates, as executive officers, cannot supervise mobile courts or hear appeals from them.
  • Section 15: Parliament cannot delegate to the government its power to amend the schedule.[1]
Mobile court legality in Bangladesh — Supreme Court building in Dhaka
The High Court Division held eleven provisions unconstitutional in 2017

The Appellate Division stay and mobile court legality today

The question of mobile court legality moved to the Appellate Division almost immediately. A chamber judge stayed the High Court Division's judgment, and the stay was extended several times. On 9 January 2018 a five-member bench led by the acting Chief Justice ordered that executive magistrates could keep running mobile courts until the government's three appeals were settled.[4] On 16 January 2018 the Court allowed the leave petitions and extended the stay until the appeals are disposed of.[6]

Why the appeals have not been heard

A hearing was set for 13 February 2018 but did not take place because the appeals were not in the cause list. By January 2019 they were still unheard, and by October 2020 neither the government nor the petitioners had taken steps to have them listed.[5] [6] We have found no reported decision of the Appellate Division on the appeals since then.

Mobile courts in 2026

The Act continues to be used on a large scale. Ahead of the 12 February 2026 national election and referendum, the Ministry of Public Administration appointed 1,051 officers as executive magistrates to run mobile courts nationwide from 8 to 14 February under section 5 of the Act, working alongside election law enforcement.[11] In practical terms, mobile court legality in 2026 rests entirely on the Appellate Division's stay.

Limits the High Court Division has imposed since 2017

The stay preserved the Act, but it did not stop the High Court Division from enforcing the Act's own limits in individual cases.

The 121 children

On 11 March 2020 the High Court Division declared the mobile court convictions of 121 children illegal and directed their release, observing that section 6 conflicts with the Constitution, that the Act needs amendment and that executive magistrates require compulsory training.[7] In those suo motu proceedings the Court held that mobile courts cannot try children because the Children Act 2013 is the later special law, that section 57 of the Narcotics Control Act 2018 does not override section 6 of the Mobile Court Act, and that the section 7 steps could not have been completed in about 21 minutes for 11 children.[8]

Night raids and abuse of the format

The March 2020 sentencing of a journalist in Kurigram to a year's imprisonment after a night raid on his home drew sharp criticism from senior lawyers, who argued that a mobile court cannot operate at night or enter a home in that way, and noted that the mobile court acts as complainant, investigator and judge at once.[7] Cases of this kind are where challenges to mobile court orders are strongest.

Missed opportunities for compensation

Commentary on the children's case argued that the Court could also have awarded compensation and acted against the magistrates, citing CCB Foundation v Government of Bangladesh (2017) 5 CLR (HCD) 278 and BLAST v Bangladesh (2003) 55 DLR (HCD) 363 for the power to award compensation for clear violations of fundamental rights, including of the Court's own motion.[8] A petitioner challenging an unlawful mobile court sentence should plead compensation expressly.

Mobile court legality in Bangladesh — official writing a penalty order on a clipboard
The section 7 record is the foundation of every conviction

The arguments on both sides

The debate over mobile court legality is often presented as a contest between efficiency and principle. Both sides deserve to be stated accurately, because the Appellate Division will have to weigh them.

The case for mobile courts

Supporters argue that mobile courts deliver fast, visible enforcement in areas the regular courts cannot reach quickly: adulterated food during Ramadan, expired products, illegal construction, polythene and public transport. They point to a heavy and growing backlog in the regular criminal courts, where a contested prosecution for a minor regulatory offence can take years, and argue that closing mobile courts would leave markets and consumers without effective protection. Some have suggested that any constitutional difficulty could be cured by amendment.[10]

The case against

Critics answer that speed cannot justify executive officers convicting and sentencing citizens. The High Court Division's core finding was that the arrangement breaches the separation of powers and judicial independence.[1] Lawyers have stressed that the mobile court combines the roles of complainant, investigator and judge, and rights organisations have warned against extending judicial powers to executive officials while the appeals remain pending.[7] [9]

A possible middle course

The High Court Division itself pointed to one: mobile courts staffed by judicial or metropolitan magistrates.[1] That would preserve on-the-spot enforcement while placing the power to convict with judicial officers. Whether the Appellate Division endorses that view, or Parliament legislates for it first, is the question on which mobile court legality now turns.

Challenging a mobile court order

The 2017 judgment shows that a person penalised by a mobile court can go directly to the High Court Division by writ. The choice of route still matters, and the arguments that succeed are usually specific to the order rather than general attacks on mobile court legality.

Grounds that work in individual cases

  • Offence outside the schedule: the law relied on is not listed, or another statute excludes mobile court jurisdiction.
  • Offence not in the magistrate's presence: the Act requires the offence to be committed or revealed before the magistrate.
  • No genuine confession: the record does not show the section 7 steps, or the timing makes them impossible.
  • Protected persons: the accused was a child, to whom the Children Act 2013 applies.
  • Excess of penalty or procedure: a sentence or fine beyond what the scheduled law and the Act permit, or seizure without authority.
  • Mala fides: evidence that the drive targeted the accused for reasons unrelated to the offence.

Appeal, revision or writ

The Act provides its own appeal route, though the High Court Division held that route itself unconstitutional because it runs to executive officers.[1] Because the appellate forum is part of the same executive structure the Court criticised, and because the challenge often goes to jurisdiction, the writ jurisdiction remains available despite the existence of an appeal. Our sibling guide on the alternative remedy bar in writ explains when the High Court Division will entertain a petition despite another remedy. Criminal revision is another route where the order is treated as a conviction; see our guide to criminal revision in Bangladesh.

Recovering fines and seized goods

Fines paid under protest and goods seized during a drive can be recovered if the order is set aside. The 2017 judgment directed refund of a Tk 10 lakh fine within 90 days.[2] Businesses should pay under written protest where they must pay to avoid imprisonment or closure, keep the receipt and seizure list, and move promptly.

A practical sequence after a mobile court order

The record is created in minutes on site, so what happens in the first days usually decides the challenge. The steps below reflect our approach.

Step 01

Obtain the record

Ask for a certified copy of the mobile court order, charge, confession record and any seizure list.

Step 02

Note the timing

Record how long the drive lasted and how many people were dealt with, to test whether the section 7 steps were possible.

Step 03

Pay under protest

If payment is unavoidable to prevent imprisonment or closure, pay with a written protest and keep the receipt.

Step 04

Check jurisdiction

Confirm that the offence is in the schedule, was committed in the magistrate's presence, and is not excluded by another law.

Step 05

Secure liberty

Where imprisonment was imposed, seek release through the fastest available route first.

Step 06

Choose the route

Decide between statutory appeal, criminal revision and a writ petition, depending on the defect.

Step 07

File and seek interim relief

Ask the High Court Division to stay the order, sealing or seizure pending the rule.

Step 08

Claim refund and compensation

Plead return of fines and goods and, where rights were violated, compensation.

Where several people were dealt with in the same drive, coordinate with them. A joint petition, or separate petitions relying on the same record, can show the Court how quickly convictions were recorded and whether the section 7 steps were realistically possible.

Two cautions apply. Do not sign a confession or any statement you dispute merely to end the drive, because the confession is the foundation of the conviction. And where imprisonment has been imposed, secure liberty first through the fastest available route before pursuing the wider challenge.

Mobile court legality in Bangladesh — business owner reviewing a fine receipt with a lawyer
Pay under protest and keep every document

Compliance points for businesses

Most mobile court drives affecting businesses concern food, consumer goods, construction, environment and trade licences. Keeping licences, test reports, product labels and building approvals available on site reduces the risk of an on-the-spot conviction. Staff should be trained not to sign statements they do not understand and to call a manager or lawyer before any confession is recorded. Where a business is sealed or goods are seized, the sealing or seizure order is itself challengeable, and interim relief is often available within days. Questions of mobile court legality rarely help a business at the scene, but a properly documented record makes a later challenge far stronger.

Comparing the routes

The table below compares the main ways to challenge a mobile court order. On a phone, scroll it sideways.

Routes to challenge a mobile court order in Bangladesh
RouteForumBest forKey point
Statutory appealAppellate authority under the ActErrors of fact or sentenceRoute itself criticised by the High Court Division as executive
Criminal revisionSessions Judge or High Court DivisionIllegal conviction or sentenceTreats the order as a criminal conviction
Writ petitionHigh Court DivisionLack of jurisdiction, section 7 breaches, children, mala fidesCan include refund and compensation
Constitutional challengeAppellate Division (pending)The validity of the Act itself2017 judgment stayed pending appeal

For food businesses and manufacturers, which face mobile court drives more often than most, the sibling guide to the food safety writ covers the regulatory side. Our constitutional and writ litigation practice handles challenges to mobile court orders, and our overview of writ petitions in Bangladesh sets out procedure and timing.

What to watch on mobile court legality

Three things will decide the future of mobile courts. The first is whether the Appellate Division lists and decides the government's appeals, which would settle the core constitutional question one way or the other. The second is whether Parliament amends the Act to address the High Court Division's findings, for example by vesting mobile court powers in judicial magistrates, introducing confession safeguards or moving the appeal route into the judiciary, as the Court suggested in 2020.[7] The third is how the High Court Division continues to police individual orders while the stay lasts.

Until then, mobile court legality remains provisional. The Act operates, the stay holds, and every individual order must still satisfy the Act's own conditions. That is where most successful challenges are won.

Frequently asked questions

Are mobile courts legal in Bangladesh in 2026?

They operate lawfully under an Appellate Division order allowing executive magistrates to run them until the government's appeals against the 2017 High Court Division judgment are decided.[4] [6]

Which sections did the High Court Division strike down?

Sections 5, 6(1), 6(2), 6(4), 7, 8(1), 9, 10, 11, 13 and 15 of the Mobile Court Act 2009.[1]

Why did the Court find mobile courts unconstitutional?

Because executive magistrates, who are civil servants, were exercising judicial power in breach of the separation of powers and the Masdar Hossain directions.[1]

Has the Appellate Division decided the appeal?

Leave was granted in January 2018, but the appeals had not been heard by October 2020, and we have found no reported decision since.[6]

Can a mobile court convict a child?

No. In 2020 the High Court Division held that the Children Act 2013 excludes mobile court jurisdiction over children and declared 121 convictions illegal.[7] [8]

Can a mobile court convict without a confession?

The Act's summary procedure depends on a confession recorded through the section 7 steps. Where those steps were not followed, the conviction is open to challenge.[8]

Can I get my mobile court fine back?

If the order is set aside, yes. The 2017 judgment directed refund of a Tk 10 lakh fine within 90 days.[2]

Do I have to appeal before filing a writ?

Not necessarily. Where the challenge goes to jurisdiction or fundamental rights, the High Court Division can entertain a writ, as it did in the 2017 petitions.[1]

How many offences can mobile courts try?

The schedule covered 104 offences by 2019, across laws on food, narcotics, occupation of land and public order, among others.[9]

Are mobile courts still used for elections?

Yes. 1,051 executive magistrates were appointed under section 5 to run mobile courts from 8 to 14 February 2026 around the national election.[11]

Source register

Primary legal and regulatory sources

Materials checked on 23 October 2026. Confirm the current official text before relying on any provision.

  1. Supreme Court of Bangladesh — Kamruzzaman Khan v Bangladesh, Writ Petition No 8437 of 2011 (judgment of 11 May 2017)
  2. The Daily Star, 12 May 2017 — Executive magistrate-led mobile court illegal: HC
  3. The Daily Star, 7 June 2017 — Mobile court: HC releases full verdict
  4. Prothom Alo English, 9 January 2018 — Mobile court to continue until appeals' settlement: SC
  5. The Daily Star, 17 January 2019 — Legitimacy of mobile courts: SC decision stuck in limbo
  6. The Daily Star, 6 October 2020 — Magistrates running mobile courts: SC yet to decide if it's legal
  7. Dhaka Tribune, 14 March 2020 — Are mobile courts serving justice?
  8. Dhaka Law Review, 11 September 2020 — Mobile court convictions of children
  9. The Daily Star, 12 July 2019 — 'Running of mobile courts by executive magistrates unconstitutional'
  10. Daily Observer, 12 June 2017 — Mobile courts for the public interest (opinion)
  11. Daily Observer, 4 February 2026 — 1,051 magistrates appointed nationwide for mobile courts during polls

Related TRW assistance

Move from information to a defined next step

TRW challenges mobile court convictions, fines, sealing and seizure orders for businesses and individuals before the High Court Division. Explore our constitutional and writ litigation practice or contact TRW in Dhaka to discuss an order.

Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp