Supreme Court Judgments, Summarised

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Nov 3, 2026

Summary

The plaintiffs filed a partition suit in 1970 claiming 135 decimals out of 215 decimals of land. The petitioners, who were defendants, sought a separate saham (allotted share in a partition) for 28 decimals, tracing title through a 1921 deed of gift (Exhibit-M) and later deeds. In 2011 the trial Court passed a partial preliminary decree giving the petitioners 28 decimals and the plaintiffs 57.1748 decimals. On the plaintiffs' appeal, the appellate Court disbelieved Exhibit-M and raised the plaintiffs' share to 116.88 decimals. The High Court Division found that the appellate Court had misread a witness's admission about Omeda Bibi's first marriage, attributed to the defendants admissions not found in the record, and inconsistently relied on a 1922 partition deed while rejecting Exhibit-M. The old registered deeds attracted the presumption of due execution under section 90 of the Evidence Act. The Court confirmed the petitioners' 28 decimals and, accepting a registered arbitration document for a limited purpose, fixed the plaintiffs' share at 92.6748 decimals. The Rule was made absolute.

Issues

  1. Q1

    Whether the appellate Court misread material evidence in disbelieving the 1921 deed of gift (Exhibit-M) and refusing the petitioner-defendants a separate saham for 28 decimals.

  2. Q2

    Whether old registered deeds produced from proper custody attracted the presumption of due execution under section 90 of the Evidence Act.

  3. Q3

    Whether documents marked by the appellate Court without compliance with Order 41 rules 27 and 29 of the Code of Civil Procedure could be considered, and to what extent.

Key points

  • The appellate Court misread PW-1's admission in cross-examination about Omeda Bibi's first marriage, and this misreading and non-consideration of material evidence occasioned failure of justice.
  • The appellate Court's statement that the defendants admitted their predecessor obtained land only in the non-suit mouza had no support in the record, and relying on Exhibit-Ga-17 while disbelieving Exhibit-M was contradictory and inconsistent.
  • Exhibits M, M-7 and M-1, being more than thirty years old and produced from proper custody, attracted the presumption under section 90 of the Evidence Act, which the plaintiffs did not rebut, so defendants 24-28 and 88 established title to 28 decimals.
  • Additional evidence cannot be admitted at the appellate stage as a matter of course, and the appellate Court's failure to record reasons under Order 41 rule 27 and to specify the point under rule 29 was a serious procedural irregularity.
  • The Court nevertheless considered Exhibit-4 for the limited purpose of the compromise with the heirs of defendant 37 and allotted the plaintiffs a further 25 decimals, subject to adjustment if defendants 37-Ka and 37-Gha later establish their lawful share.
  • The appellate decree was set aside, the trial Court's decree was modified so that the plaintiffs receive a total saham of 92.6748 decimals, and the petitioners' saham of 28 decimals was confirmed.

A bare assertion in the plaint cannot take the place of proof when the parentage of the alleged heir is specifically disputed.

From the judgment, Justice Md. Ali Reza
Law considered

Evidence Act, section 90Code of Civil Procedure, Order 41 rule 27Code of Civil Procedure, Order 41 rule 29

The judgment

In the court’s own words.

Civil Revision 2294/2017, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 28 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.

PDF
Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp