High Court Division · Civil Revisional Jurisdiction
Md. Ekramul Haque v Mst. Majeda Begum and others
Civil Revision 3338/2015 · Decided 6 November 2024
The plaintiff, a tenant of a shop, bought it from the defendant owner by a registered sale deed dated 03.03.2009 for Taka 3,00,000. He sued for rectification of the deed, alleging that the defendant, with the help of the deed writer, had inserted a clause keeping the roof of the shop in the defendant's ownership and allowing him to build additional floors. The defendant said the deed reflected the parties' agreement. The trial court dismissed the suit and the Additional District Judge, Chapai Nawabgonj, dismissed the appeal. On revision, with no one appearing for the opposite parties, the High Court Division found that the deed was not an out and out sale and, read as a whole, the roof clause was not unusual or unreasonable. A party to a registered document can challenge its terms only on grounds of fraud or error, and the plaintiff neither pleaded nor proved either, nor called any witness to support his account. The Rule was discharged.
Rule discharged
- Q1
Whether a purchaser who is a party to a registered sale deed can have a clause reserving the roof of the sold shop to the seller rectified without proving fraud or error.
- A party to a registered document who admits its execution and registration can challenge a term of it only on the ground of fraud or error.
- The plaintiff made out no specific case of fraud or error, and did not allege that the clause was inserted fraudulently in collusion with the deed writer or witnesses, or by mistake.
- Read in its entirety, the deed was not an out and out sale, and the clause reserving ownership of the roof and the right to build further floors to the seller was not unusual or unreasonable.
- The plaintiff's uncorroborated claim that the roof clause was not agreed during negotiations could not succeed without supporting witnesses.
- The concurrent findings of the courts below disclosed no error calling for interference under section 115(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
It is well settled that a party to a registered document can challenge any tremor clause of the document and give evidence against above term clause of the document only on the grounds of fraud or error.
In the court’s own words.
Civil Revision 3338/2015, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 6 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION)
Present:
Mr. Justice S M Kuddus Zaman
CIVIL REVISION NO.3338 OF 2015
In the matter of:
An application under Section 115(1) of the Code of Civil
Procedure.
And
Md. Ekramul Haque
….Petitioner
-Versus-
Mst. Majeda Begum and others
….Opposite parties
Mr. Ahmed Nowshed Jamil with
Ms. Syeda Showkat Ara, Advocates
…. For the petitioner.
None appears
…. For the opposite parties.
Heard and Judgment on 06.11.2024
1This Rule was issued calling upon the opposite parties to show cause as to why the impugned judgment and decree dated 11.05.2015 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Chapai Nawabgonj in Title Appeal No.194 of 2012 dismissing the appeal and thereby affirming the judgment and decree dated 05.08.2012 passed by the learned Joint District Judge, 1st Court, Chapai Nawabgonj in Other Class Suit No.17 of 2010 should not be set aside and or pass such other or further order or orders as to this Court may seem fit and proper.
2Facts in short are that the opposite party as plaintiff instituted above suit for rectification of registered deed No.907 of 2009 executed
by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff for sale of a shop described in the schedule to the plaint.
3It has been alleged that defendant was the rightful owner and possessor of above shop and he declared to sale the same and the plaintiff who was the tenant of above shop agreed to purchase the same and on receipt of consideration of Taka 3,00,000/- defendant executed and registered above deed dated 03.03.2009. But the defendant illegally and unlawfully gained over the scribe of the deed and inserted term No.7 providing that the roof of the shop shall remain in the ownership and possession of the defendant and he would be entitled to construct additional floors over above roof.
4Defendant contested the suit by filing a written statement alleging that above deed was written on the basis of the agreement reached between the parties and the defendant did not insert anything in above document beyond the knowledge and consent of the plaintiff.
5At trial plaintiff and defendant examined 1 witness each. The documents produced and proved by the plaintiff were marked as Exhibit No.1 and 2 but defendant did not produce and prove any document.
6On consideration of facts and circumstances of the case and evidence on record the learned Senior Assistant Judge dismissed the suit.
7Being aggrieved by above judgment and decree plaintiff preferred Title Appeal No.194 of 2012 to the District Judge, Chapainabwabgoj which was heard by the learned Additional District Judge who dismissed the appeal and affirmed the judgment and decree of the trial Court.
8Being aggrieved by above judgment and decree of the Court of Appeal below above appellant as petitioner moved to this Court and obtained this Rule.
9Mr. Ahmed Nowshed Jamil, learned Advocate for the petitioner submits that the plaintiff purchased disputed shop from the defendant by registered deed of sale on 03.03.2009. Since the plaintiff became the absolute owner of above shop by virtue of above purchase the question of granting title and right of the defendant on the roof of above shop does not arise at all. The defendant inserted impugned clause in the above deed providing that the defendant shall have right and ownership over the roof and he would construct additional floors on the same with the aid of the scribe beyond the knowledge of the plaintiff. A plain reading of above clause shows that the same was unusual and against the spirit of transfer of immovable property by sale. But the learned Judges of the Courts below have miserably failed to appreciate above facts and relevant law properly and most illegally dismissed the suit and the appeal respectively which is not tenable in law.
10No one appears on behalf of the opposite parties when the Rule was taken up for hearing although this matter appeared in the list for hearing on several dates.
11I have considered the submissions of the learned Advocate for the petitioner and carefully examined all materials on record.
12It is admitted that defendant was the rightful owner of the disputed shop and plaintiff was his monthly tenant and the defendant wanted to reconstruct above shop but he had no money for the same and he executed the impugned deed of sale deed dated 03.03.2009 with the plaintiff.
13The plaintiff while giving evidence as PW1 produced and proved a certified copy of above deed of sale dated 03.03.2009 which was marked as Exhibit No.1. A plain reading of above document shows that the document was not a deed of out and out sale and there are some conditions attached to above transfer. The relevant part of above conditions are reproduced below:
""fËL¡n b¡−L ®k, EJ² ®c¡L¡e Ol¢Vl ¢ejÑ¡Z L¡S BN¡j£−a öl¦ q−h
Hhw c¡a¡ ®c¡L¡e Ol¢V ¢eS Ml−Q pÇfæ ®~a¢l L−l ¢c−he ®c¡L¡e
O−lll Ešl c¢rZ f§−hÑl ¢c−Ll Ju¡m J p¡j¡−el clS¡ Hhw Ef−ll
R¡c pÇf§ZÑi¡−h NË¢qa¡l Ae¤L¨−m ®qg¡Sa b¡¢L−hz H−a c¡a¡ h¡
c¡a¡l i¡h£ −L¡e fËL¡−l h¡d¡ ¢hOÀ pª¢ÖV L¢l−a f¡¢l−he e¡z E−õMÉ
b¡−L ®k, c¡a¡ R¡−cl Ef−l Ol ®~al£ L−l hÉhq¡l L¢l−h R¡−cl Efl
c¡a¡l pÇfªZÑ A¢dL¡l b¡−L ®k, H−a NË¢qa¡l ®L¡e c¡h£ c¡Ju¡
b¡¢L−h e¡ BlJ fËL¡n b¡−L ®k, ¢hH²£a ®c¡L¡e O−lll p¡j−el
¢c−L AbÑÉ¡a f¢ÕQj ¢c−L BV ¢gV S¡uN¡ gy¡L¡ l¢qmz HC S¡uN¡
gy¡L¡ l¢qmz HC S¡uN¡ öd¤ j¡œ l¡Ù¹¡l L¡−S hÉhq¡l q−h c¡a¡ h¡
NË¢qa¡l i¡h£ −L¡e Ju¡¢lnNZ ¢eS L¡−S hÉhq¡l L¢l−a f¡¢l−h e¡
öd¤j¡œ l¡Ù¹¡l L¡−S hÉhq¡l q−hz (3 f¡a¡) −j¡x −j¡S¡q¡l −q¡−pez''
14It appears that the defendant although sold above shop to the plaintiff but both parties agreed that reconstruction of above shop shall be done by the defendant not by the plaintiff who purchased the same. The plaintiff did not challenge the legality of above clause of the impugned deed.
15It has been further provided that the constructed shop shall remain in the ownership of the plaintiff but the roof of the shop shall remain in the ownership of the defendant and he shall have the right to construct additional floors on above roof. If above document is considered in its entirety then it does not appear that above clause as to ownership of the roof of the shop was unusual or unreasonable.
16The plaintiff is a party to above registered document and the plaintiff admits due execution and registration of the document. It is well settled that a party to a registered document can challenge any tremor clause of the document and give evidence against above term clause of the document only on the grounds of fraud or error. In the plaint or in his evidence as DW1 the plaintiff could not make out and prove a specific case of fraud or error. There is no allegation that the defendant fraudulently inserted above clause in above deed in collusion
with the scribe or witnesses nor there is any allegation that above clause was inserted erroneously.
17PW1 has stated that at the time of talk of above sale there was no agreement for inclusion of above clause as to ownership of the roof. But to substantiate above claim the plaintiff did not examine any witness who was present at the time of above talk of the sale or execution of the impugned deed. As such above claim of the plaintiff remains uncorroborated and unsubstantiated.
18In above view of the materials on record I hold that the learned Judges of the Courts below on correct appreciation of the materials on record rightly held that the defendant did not commit any fraud nor there was any error in the preparation, execution and registration of above deed of sale and the learned Judge of the Court of Appeal below rightly dismissed the appeal and affirmed lawful judgment of the trial Court which calls for no interference.
19I am unable to find any substance in this revisional application under Section 115(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure and the Rule issued in this connection is liable to be discharged.
20In the result, the Rule is hereby discharged.
21However, there is no order as to costs.
22Send down the lower Courts records immediately. MD. MASUDUR RAHMAN BENCH OFFICER
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











