High Court Division · Civil Revisional Jurisdiction
Hares Mia alias Hares Uddin and another v Mst. Saleha Khatun and others
Civil Revision 3777/2009 · Decided 26 February 2026
The plaintiffs, children of Kepu Shah, sued for declarations of title to 34 decimals of government land at Puthia, Rajshahi, and that its settlement in favour of the petitioners (defendants 3 and 4) was illegal. The government had settled the land on Kepu Shah for 99 years, but the kabuliyat (the registered settlement deed) was never executed, although he applied for it on 21.04.1995. In 2000 his settlement was cancelled without reasons and the land settled on the petitioners, one of whom is his daughter. The trial court dismissed the suit; the appellate court decreed it. In revision, the High Court Division held that a 1971 Board of Revenue circular relied on by the petitioners had been superseded by the Nitimala of 1997, under which the authority was bound to execute the kabuliyat for Kepu Shah. The cancellation and later settlement were therefore illegal. The Rule was discharged and the authorities were directed to execute the kabuliyat for his heirs and cancel the petitioners' kabuliyat.
Rule discharged; authorities directed to execute kabuliyat
- Q1
Whether the cancellation of a government land settlement in favour of a settlee who had applied for execution of the kabuliyat, and the later settlement of the same land on others, were lawful under the Nitimala of 1997.
- The 1971 Board of Revenue circular on settlement of agricultural khas land had been superseded by the Nitimala of 1997, so the non-execution of the kabuliyat did not extinguish Kepu Shah's interest in the land.
- Under the Nitimala as amended, the authority was bound to execute the kabuliyat in favour of Kepu Shah, who had applied for it on 21.04.1995, and the cancellation of his settlement was illegal.
- The later settlement of the land in favour of defendants 3 and 4 and the execution of the kabuliyat in their favour were illegal, and the appellate court's judgment was upheld on this ground also.
- The Rule was discharged and the Deputy Commissioner, the Additional Deputy Commissioner (Land) and the Assistant Commissioner (Land) were directed to execute and register the kabuliyat in favour of Kepu Shah's legal heirs and to cancel kabuliyat deed No. 2742 dated 13.06.2001 and the related settlement cases in accordance with law.
It follows that the settlement of land in favour of Kepu Shah was cancelled illegally and the authority is bound under the Nitimala to execute the kabuliyat in favour of Kepu Shah
In the court’s own words.
Civil Revision 3777/2009, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 6 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2HIGH COURT DIVISION
3(CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION)
4Present:
5Mr. Justice Zafar Ahmed
6Civil Revision No. 3777 of 2009
7In the matter of:
8Hares Mia alias Hares Uddin and another
9Defendant-respondent-petitioners
10-Versus-
11Mst. Saleha Khatun and others
12Plaintiff-Appellant-opposite parties
13Mr. Sherder Abul Hossain, Advocate
14…For the petitioners
15Mr. Kawsar Ahmed, with
16Mr. Md. Saleh Ahmed, Advocates
17… For the opposite party Nos. 1-3
18Heard on: 08.01.2026, 14.01.2026, 19.02.2026 and
1925.02.2026
20Judgment on: 26.02.2026
21The petitioners have filed this revisional application under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) challenging the judgment and decree dated 22.06.2009 (decree signed on 28.06.2009) passed by learned Joint District Judge, Rajshahi allowing the Title Appeal No. 167 of 2004 and thereby reversing the judgment and decree dated 23.02.2004 (decree signed on 29.02.2004) passed by
learned Assistant Judge, Puthia, Rajshahi dismissing the Title Suit No. 16 of 2002.
22Opposite party Nos. 1-3 as plaintiff filed the suit praying for declaration of title in respect of 34 decimals of land mentioned in the schedule of the plaint with further declaration that the settlement of the said land in favour of the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 (present petitioners) is illegal having no legal effect.
23The trial Court dismissed the suit on contest. The appellate Court below allowed the suit and decreed the same. Challenging the judgment and decree of the appellate Court below, defendant Nos. 3 and 4 filed the instant civil revision and obtained the Rule.
24Relevant facts are that the government was the owner of the suit land situated at Puthia, Rajshahi. The government settled the land in favour of Kepu Shah for 99 years, vide Permanent Settlement Case No. 1965/XII/67-68. However, the kabuliyat was not executed. Eventually, the settlement of land in favour of Kepu Shah was cancelled in 2000 and the land was settled in favour of defendant Nos. 3 and 4, vide Settlement Case Nos. 513/XII/2000 and 754/XII/2001 and the registered kabuliyat being No. 2742 dated 13.06.2001 was executed in favour of defendant Nos. 3 and 4. The permanent settlement of land in favour of defendant Nos. 3 and 4 and the kabuliyat dated 13.06.2001 have been challenged in the suit.
25Plaintiff Nos. 1, 3 and defendant No. 4 are daughters of Kepu Shah. Plaintiff No. 2 is the son of Kepu Shah. Defendant No. 3 is the husband of defendant No. 4.
26The appellate Court below categorically found that on 21.04.1995 Kepu Shah applied to the concerned authority for execution of registered kabuliyat in his favour (exhibit-5). It appears that no decision, whatsoever, was taken on the said application. The appellate Court further found that the concerned Upazilla Land Reforms and Execution Committee on 29.03.2000 cancelled the earlier settlement of land in favour of Kepu Shah without assigning any reason whatsoever. Thereafter, the land in question was settled in favour of defendant Nos. 3 and 4 and the registered kabuliyat was executed.
27Both the Courts below further found that Kepu Shah got his name mutated in respect of the land on payment of rents. The trial Court dismissed the suit on the ground that the plaintiff could not prove the case by producing adequate papers. The appellate Court below allowed the appeal on the ground that the settlement of the land in favour of Kepu Shah was cancelled without giving him any opportunity of being heard and without assigning any reason whatsoever.
28Mr. Kawsar Ahmed, learned Advocate appearing for the plaintiff-opposite party refers to clause 2 of “
29” published in the official gazette on 16.04.1997. Clause 2 of the said Nitimala is reproduced below:
30“
31”
32Mr. Ahmed also refers to the amendment made in the said Nitimala which was published in the official gazette on 18.05.2000 and came into effect on 30.04.2000. By the said amendment, clause 2( ) was substituted by the following paragraph:
33Mr. Sherder Abul Hossain, learned Advocate appearing for the defendant-petitioners refers to a circular under Memo No. 928(22)vii-76/71-L.S, dated 10.11.1971 issued by the Board of Revenue under the subject “Settlement of agriculture khas land, free of salami, with landless agriculturist families” and submits that since the kabuliyat was not executed in favour of Kepu Shah, his interest in the land has been extinguished. I do not find force in the argument for the reason that the circular of 1971 was subsequently superseded by the Nitimala 1997.
34As per clause of the Nitimala as amended, the concerned authority was bound to execute the kabuliyat in favour of Kepu Shah, who, on 21.04.1995, applied to the authority for execution of the registered kabuliyat. It follows that the settlement of land in favour of Kepu Shah was cancelled illegally and the authority is bound under the Nitimala to execute the kabuliyat in favour of Kepu Shah or alternatively after his demise, in favour of his legal successors in interest. In this regard, clause 7 of the Nitimala is relevant which is reproduced below:
35In view of the foregoing discussions, I hold that the subsequent settlement of the land in favour of defendant Nos. 3 and 4 (defendant No. 4 is one of the legal heirs of Kepu Shah) and execution of kabuliyat in their favour were done illegally. Accordingly, I uphold the judgment of the appellate Court below on this ground also.
36In the result, the Rule is discharged. The suit is allowed. Defendant No. 1 Deputy Commissioner, Rajshahi, defendant No. 2 Additional Deputy Commissioner (Land), Rajshahi and defendant No. 5 Assistant Commissioner (Land), Puthia, Rajshahi are directed to execute and register the kabuliyat in favour of the legal heirs of Kepu Shah as per clause of the Nitimala and to cancel the registered kabuliyat deed No. 2742 dated 13.06.2001 and Permanent Settlement Case Nos. 513/XII/2000 and 754/XII/2001 in favour of the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 in accordance with law.
37Send down the L.C.R.
38Arif, ABO
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











