Supreme Court Judgments, Summarised

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Nov 3, 2026

Summary

The plaintiffs, heirs of Syed Miron, sued in Moulvibazar for declaration of title by inheritance and by adverse possession over 6.01 acres, confirmation of possession, recovery of khas possession of 0.27 acre from which they said they were dispossessed in July 1987, and an injunction. The contesting defendants claimed through their predecessor Syed Ashraf Ali, who bought land from an auction purchaser in 1955. The Subordinate Judge decreed the suit in part, declaring title over the First Schedule land except 14 decimals, and the defendants appealed. The High Court Division rejected the maintainability objection, since adverse possession appeared only in the prayer clause, no issue was framed and the trial proceeded on inheritance. It found the plaintiffs' witnesses and municipal records credible and the defendants' witnesses unreliable. However, the plaintiffs had stated in an earlier writ petition that 3.15 acres were sold to Syed Ashraf Ali, and their counsel conceded 3.15 acres at the hearing. The decree was modified to declare title to 2.65 acres with a permanent injunction.

Issues

  1. Q1

    Whether a title suit is barred because the prayer clause seeks title both by inheritance and by adverse possession.

  2. Q2

    Whether the plaintiffs proved ancestral title and possession of the suit land against the defendants' claim through an auction purchaser.

  3. Q3

    To what extent the trial court's declaration of title should stand in light of the plaintiffs' earlier admission that 3.15 acres had been sold to the defendants' predecessor.

Key points

  • A reference to adverse possession in the prayer clause, without pleaded facts, a framed issue or evidence on it, does not make a suit founded on title by inheritance unmaintainable.
  • Mutation entries and revenue dakhilas do not confer title or establish actual physical occupancy, and at best prove symbolic possession for fiscal purposes.
  • For urban homestead property, municipal assessment records and tax receipts carry greater evidentiary weight on physical possession than survey-based land revenue receipts.
  • A plea of permissive occupancy requires cogent evidence of the licence's creation, terms and nature, and failure to call any neighbour or adjoining landowner to prove possession draws an adverse inference.
  • The plaintiffs' own statement in an earlier writ petition that 3.15 acres had been sold to the defendants' predecessor, together with their counsel's concession, limited their declared title to 2.65 acres.

a mere incongruity in the prayer clause, unsupported by foundational facts in the body of the plaint, cannot defeat the suit on technical maintainability grounds.

From the judgment, Justice A. K. M. Rabiul Hassan
The judgment

In the court’s own words.

First Appeal 200/1995, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 36 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.

PDF
Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp