Supreme Court Judgments, Summarised

by Barrister Tahmidur Rahman | Nov 3, 2026

Summary

The plaintiffs claimed 1.60 acres in Dinajpur through purchasers who bought the land at a 1964 auction held in a certificate case for rent arrears against the C.S. recorded tenants, and through later registered sales. When the Assistant Custodian, Special Property (Jute) Cell claimed the land as enemy property and tried to auction it, the plaintiffs sued for a declaration of title. The Subordinate Judge dismissed the suit in 1991. Hearing the long-pending appeal on its merits, the High Court Division held that certified copies from the certificate case could not be disbelieved merely because the original record had been destroyed under Act 5 of 1917, and a 1973 order dropping a revenue challenge to the sale proved the auction. The later deeds, mutation, rent receipts, buildings and a saw-mill showed title and possession. The government's gazette notification identified no plot or khatian, and an earlier decree permanently restrained the Deputy Commissioner from interfering. The appeal was allowed and the suit decreed.

Issues

  1. Q1

    Whether certified copies of the order sheet, sale certificate and delivery of possession in a 1960 rent certificate case could prove an auction purchase where the original record had been destroyed.

  2. Q2

    Whether a gazette notification that gave no plot, khatian, map or mouza number proved that the suit land was enemy property.

  3. Q3

    Whether the plaintiffs proved title and possession of 1.60 acres so as to be entitled to a declaration of title.

Key points

  • Certified copies of the certificate case documents, issued long ago by the proper authority, cannot be disbelieved only because the original record was not produced, as it had been validly destroyed under Act 5 of 1917.
  • The 1973 order dropping a case against the auction sale, together with the exhibits and the evidence of the land office witness, proved that the land was sold at auction in Certificate Case 621 of 1960 and possession delivered to the purchasers.
  • The gazette notification relied on by the government bore no plot, khatian, map or mouza number and so did not cover the suit land, and an earlier permanent injunction against the Deputy Commissioner left no reason to list it as enemy property.
  • Rent receipts are evidence of possession and may be used as collateral evidence of title, and the Government, having taken rent from the plaintiffs, could not deny their title.
  • The trial court misdirected itself in assessing the evidence, so the appeal was allowed, the decree set aside and the suit for declaration of title decreed.

The aforesaid certified copies of the certificate case exhibits- 1-4 cannot be disbelieved only on the reason that original record was not produced in the Court.

From the judgment, Justice Bhishmadev Chakrabortty
Law considered

Destruction of Records Act, 1917

The judgment

In the court’s own words.

First Appeal 739/1991, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 13 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.

PDF
Call the Dhaka office+880 1708 000660WhatsApp · message usMessage our team
Message TRW on WhatsApp