High Court Division
Sobura Khatun and others v Bangladesh and others
Writ Petition 10557/2011 · Decided 3 May 2026
Six writ petitions, heard together, concerned land in one mouza acquired in Noakhali for a health complex. The petitioners challenged notices under section 7 of the Acquisition and Requisition of Immovable Property Ordinance, 1982, all dated 22.02.2010, which assessed compensation at Taka 5,700 per decimal, claiming this was far below market value, and four petitions also challenged the vires of the proviso to section 31. The High Court Division found no basis to hold section 31 ultra vires. Market value had to be assessed with reference to the date of the section 3 notice, served on 11.10.2006, whereas the petitioners relied on 2010 and 2011 prices, so undervaluation was not shown. As the acquisition was complete, the 2017 Ain's savings clause kept the Ordinance applicable. A dispute over compensation was to be dealt with under section 10 of the Ordinance, not in writ. The Rules were discharged, leaving the petitioners free to approach the Arbitration Tribunal without limitation as a bar.
- Q1
Whether a writ petition lies to challenge notices under section 7 of the Acquisition and Requisition of Immovable Property Ordinance, 1982 solely on the ground that the compensation assessed is below market value.
- Q2
Whether the proviso to section 31 of the Ordinance, 1982 is ultra vires the Constitution.
- Q3
Whether landowners who had not received compensation were entitled to three times the present market value under the 2017 Ain.
- The proviso to section 31 of the Acquisition and Requisition of Immovable Property Ordinance, 1982 was not found to be ultra vires the Constitution.
- Under section 8(1)(a) of the Ordinance, compensation is assessed by reference to market value at the date of publication of the notice under section 3, so later sale prices do not show undervaluation.
- Where acquisition was completed under the Ordinance, the savings clause in section 50(2)(Ga) of the 2017 Ain means the Ordinance governs compensation, not the higher rate under the new law.
- A dispute over payment of compensation for acquired land is to be dealt with under section 10 of the Ordinance, and a writ petition challenging section 7 notices only for inadequate compensation affords no scope for interference.
- The petitioners were left free to seek compensation according to law, and limitation would not bar an approach to the Arbitration Tribunal under the Ordinance.
Therefore, we find that since the petitioners disputed regarding payment of compensation, it shall dealt with in accordance with law, more particularly as per section 10 of the Ordinance, 1982.
In the court’s own words.
Writ Petition 10557/2011, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 13 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1Bench: Mr. Justice BhishmadevChakrabortty And Mr. Justice Abdur Rahman Writ Petition No.10557 of 2011 Sobura Khatun and others …… petitioners
2-Vs- Bangladesh and others …… respondents with Writ Petition No.10559 of 2011 Abul Bashar …… petitioner
3-Vs- Bangladesh and others …… respondents with Writ Petition No.10561 of 2011 Md. Mokhlesur Rahman being dead his heirs: 1(a) Angkurar Nessa and others …… petitioners
4-Vs- Bangladesh and others …… respondents with Writ Petition No.10562 of 2011 Abul Bashar …… petitioner
5-Vs- Bangladesh and others …… respondents with Writ Petition No.12770 of 2022 Md. Abul Hashem and others …… petitioners
6-Vs- Bangladesh and others …… respondents and Writ Petition No.12771 of 2022
Md. Siraj Uddoula …… petitioner
-Vs-
Bangladesh and others …… respondents
Mr. Muhammad Hemayet Kabir Khan, Advocate
……for the petitioners
(In all the writ petitions)
Mr. Syed Ejaz Kabir with Mr. Mohammad Imam
Hossain (Tarek), Deputy Attorney Generals with Ms.
Mahbuba Tasnim Akhi, Mr. Mustafizur Rahman
Mukul, Mr. Ashraful Alam and Mr. Ruhani Siddique,
Assistant Attorney Generals.
…..… for the respondents
(In all the writ petitions)
Judgment on 03.05.2026
7Bhishmadev Chakrabortty, J:
8Since in all the Rules the respondents are same and common question of fact and law in respect of acquisition of lands of same mouza are involved, these have been heard together and are being disposed of by this judgment.
9The Rule in Writ Petition 10557 of 2011 at the instance of 11 petitioners was issued in the following terms-
“The Rule Nisi be issued calling upon the Respondents to show cause
10as to why the Proviso of Section 31 of the Acquisition and Requisition of the
11Immovable Property Ordinance, 1982 should not be declared to be ultra vires
12with the Constitution as being violative of the fundamental rights of the
13petitioners as guaranteed by Articles 26, 27, 31 and 42 of the Constitution
14and as to why the impugned Notice vide Process No. 279(1)/L.A. dated
1522.02.2010 issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Noakhali under the
16signature of Land Acquisition Officer, Noakhali fixing the award of
compensation for the land (mentioned in the scheduled) owned by the
17petitioners should not be declared to have been issued without lawful
18authority and is of no legal effect and/or pass such other or further order or
19orders as to this Court may seem fit and proper.”
20The Rule in Writ Petition 10559 of 2011 at the instance of sole petitioner was issued in the following terms-
“The Rule Nisi be issued calling upon the Respondents to show cause
21as to why the Proviso of section 31 of the Acquisition and Requisition of the
22Immovable Property Ordinance, 1982 should not be declared to be ultra vires
23with the Constitution as being violative of the fundamental rights of the
24petitioners guaranteed by Articles 26, 27, 31 and 42 of the Constitution and
25as to why the impugned Notice vide Process No. 279(1)/L.A. dated
2622.02.2010 issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Noakhali under the
27signature of Land Acquisition Officer, Noakhali fixing award of
28compensation for the land (mentioned in the schedule) owned by the
29petitioner should not be declared to have been issued without lawful authority
30and is of no legal effect and/or pass such other or further order or orders as to
31this Court may seem fit and proper.”
32The Rule in Writ Petition 10561 of 2011 at the instance of sole petitioner was issued in the following terms-
“The Rule Nisi be issued calling upon the Respondents to show cause
33as to why the Proviso of section 31 of the Acquisition and Requisition of the
34Immovable Property Ordinance, 1982 should not be declared to be ultra vires
35with the Constitution as being violative of the fundamental rights of the
36petitioner guaranteed by Articles 26, 27, 31 and 42 of the Constitution and as
37to why the impugned Notice vide Process No. 279(1)/L.A. dated 22.02.2010
38issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Noakhali under the signature of Land
Acquisition Officer, Noakhali fixing the award of compensation for the land
39(mentioned in the scheduled) owned by the petitioners should not be declared
40to have been issued without lawful authority and is of no legal effect and/or
41pass such other or further order or orders as to this Court may seem fit and
proper.
42Subsequently, on an application filed by the petitioners supplementary Rule was issued in the following terms-
“Issue a supplementary Rule Nisi calling upon the respondents
of the writ petition to show cause as to why the notices vide process
Nos. 276(1)/LA, 269(1)/LA, 292(1)/LA, 286(1)/LA and 298(1)/LA all
dated 22.02.2010 issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Noakhali
under the signature of Land Acquisition Officer, Noakhali fixing the
award of compensation for the land (mentioned in the schedule)
owned by the petitioners should not be declared to have been issued
without lawful authority and is of no legal effect and/or pass such
other or further order or orders to this court may seem fit and proper.”
43The Rule in the Writ Petition 10562 of 2011 was issued at the instance of sole petitioner in the following terms-
“The Rule Nisi be issued calling upon the Respondents to show cause
44as to why the Proviso of section 31 of the Acquisition and Requisition of the
45Immovable Property Ordinance, 1982 should not be declared to be ultra vires
with the Constitution as being violative of the fundamental rights of the
46petitioners as guaranteed by Articles 26, 27, 31 and 42 of the Constitution
and also as to why the impugned Notice vide Process No. 285(1)/L.A. dated
22.02.2010 issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Noakhali under the
signature of Land Acquisition Officer, Noakhali fixing the award of
compensation for the land (mentioned in the schedule) owned by the
47petitioner should not be declared to have been issued without lawful authority
48and is of no legal effect and/or pass such other or further order or orders as to
this Court may seem fit and proper.”
49The Rule in Writ Petition 12770 of 2022 was issued at the instance of 4 petitioners in the following terms-
“The Rule Nisi be issued calling upon the respondents to show cause
as to why the impugned Notices vide Process No. 296(1)/L.A dated
22.02.2010, 270(1)/L.A dated 22.02.2010, 293(1)/L.A dated 22.02.2010 and
294(1)/L.A dated 22.02.2010 issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Noakhali
under the signature of Land Acquisition Officer, Noakhali, Annexures-B,
B(1), B(2) and B(3) fixing the award of compensation for the land
50(mentioned in the schedule) owned by the petitioners should not be declared
51to have been issued without lawful authority and is of no legal effect and/or
52pass such other or further order or orders as to this Court may seem fit and
proper.”
53The Rule in the Writ Petition 12771 of 2022 was issued at the instance of sole petitioner in the following terms-
“The Rule Nisi be issued calling upon the respondents to show cause
as to why the impugned Notice vide Process No. 288(1)/L.A dated
22.02.2010, Process No. 291(1)/L.A dated 22.02.2010 and Process No.
295(1)/L.A dated 22.02.2010 issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Noakhali
under the signature of Land Acquisition Officer, Noakhali Annexures-B,
B(1), B(2) fixing the award of compensation for the land (mentioned in the
54schedule) owned by the petitioner should not be declared to have been issued
55without lawful authority and is of no legal effect and/or pass such other or
further order or orders as to this Court may seem fit and proper.”
56Facts relevant for disposal of the Rule issued in Writ Petition 10557 of 2022, in brief, are that .45 acres of land of these petitioners was acquired by the Government for construction of a Health Complex of newly constituted Kabirhat Upazila within the District of Noakhali through LA Case 03/2006-7. Notices under sections 3 and 6 of Acquisition and Requisition of Immovable Property Ordinance, 1982 (the Ordinance, 1982) were served upon the petitioners and finally notices under section 7 of the same Ordinance were served upon them fixing compensation of neat amount at Taka 2,89,011/- after deduction of income tax. The petitioners alleged in the writ petition that the fixation of compensation was undervalued considering the market price of the lands at that time. According to the Government rate of Sub-Registry Office, value of each decimals of land was at 9500/-. Moreover, the deeds Annexures- D and D1 shows that there the price of each decimal of land was Taka 10,000/to 20,000/- but the Government fixed the rate of compensation at Taka 5,700/per decimal which was much lower than the actual price. The petitioners without receiving compensation filed this writ petition challenging the vires of law of proviso of section 31 of the Ordinance, 1982 and also challenging the notice dated 22.02.2022 issued by respondent 2 and obtained this Rule.
57In Writ Petition 10559 of 2011 sole petitioner in the similar way has challenged the vires of law of the proviso of the aforestated section as well as the notice under section 7 of the Ordinance, 1982 fixing compensation at Taka 48,902.69 for .09 acres of land of same mouza after deduction of income tax stating the facts as stated in the aforesaid Writ Petition 10557 of 2011.
58In Writ Petition 10561 of 2011 three petitioners have challenged the vires of law of the proviso of same section as stated hereinabove and notice under section 7 of the Ordinance fixing compensation at Taka 27,161.16 for .05 acres of land; Taka 67920.10 for .035 acres; Taka 43,469.06 for .08 acres; Taka 19,017.70 for .125 acres and Taka 13,0407.18 for .24 acres of land of same mouza after deduction of income tax.
59In Writ Petition 10562 of 2011 sole petitioner have challenged the vires of law as well as the notice under section 7 of the Ordinance of selfsame date fixing compensation at Taka 43,469.06 for .08 acres of land of same mouza after deduction of income tax.
60In Writ Petition 12770 of 2022 four petitioners have challenged the notice published under section 7 of the Ordinance through which compensation was fixed at Taka 48,902.69 for .12 acres of land; Taka 65,203.59 for another .12 acres; Taka 9,508.86 for .0775 acres and Taka 42,110.65 for .0125 acres of land of same mouza after deduction of income taxe.
61In Writ Petition 12771 of 2022 sole petitioner has challenged notice under section 7 of the Ordinance fixing compensation at Taka 10,867.20 for .04 acres of land; Taka 21,734.53 for .02 acres and Taka 1,52,14.71/- for .28 acres of land after deduction of income tax.
62In all the writ petitions as above it has been alleged that valuation of the land was assessed by the concerned authority at Taka 5700/- for each decimal where the value of land as per annexed deeds was from Taka 10,000/- to 20,000/-. In the 4 first writ petitions it has been stated that as per the
Government rate of Sub Registry Office per decimal land was valued at Taka 19,500/- wherein the Deputy Commissioner fixed compensation at Taka 5700/per decimal which is much lower than the Government rate. In the last two writ petitions, the petitioners claimed that as per Government rate value of each decimal land there was at Taka 66,638/- but the Deputy Commissioner fixed it at Taka 5,700/- which is much lower that the value of the land in that mouza at the material time.
63Mr. Muhammad Hemayet Kabir Khan, learned Advocate for the petitioners in all the Rules taking us through the annexures of the writ petitions submits that in determining compensation under section 8 of the Ordinance, 1982 to be awarded for any property, the Deputy Commissioner shall take into consideration the market price of the property at the material time but without following the statutory provisions of law, respondent 2 most arbitrarily fixed compensation bellow the price fixed by the Government. The deeds annexed with the writ petitions shows that price of the land is much higher than that of the price fixed by the Deputy Commissioner. He then submits that the respondents issued the impugned notices with mala fide intend under influence of vested quarter and as such the impugned orders are liable to be declared to have been passed without lawful authority and is of no legal effect. The compensation assessed by respondent 2 being much lower than that of the market rate, the same are liable to be declared without lawful authority and of no legal effect. He refers to the cases of Government of Bangladesh and others vs. Most. Nurjahan Begum, 16 BLT (AD) 190, Satish Sabharwal and others vs. State of Maharashtra and others, 2 SCC 362 and Hosne Ara Begum vs.
64Chairman Court of Settlement and another, 46 DLR (AD) 9 and relied on the ratio laid in those cases. He further submits that since the petitioners have not yet received compensation and as such they are entitled to the thrice of present market price of the land as per the provisions of “
65(the Ain, 2017).” The Rules issued, therefore, would be made absolute.
66Mr. Mohammad Imam Hossain (Tarek), learned Deputy Attorney General on the other hand refers to the case of Government of Bangladesh and others vs. Md. Hadisur Rahman and others, 26 BLC (AD) 294 and relying on the ratio laid therein advanced his argument solely on point of law. He submits that notices under sections 3 and 6 of the Ordinance upon the petitioners in all the writ petitions were served. The Deputy Commissioner assessed the compensation in respect of the acquired land and issued a notice upon them under section 7 of the Ordinance, 1982. If, any dispute arises regarding payment of compensation, it should be dealt in accordance with law more particularly as per provisions of section 10 of the Ordinance, 1982. The writ petitions challenging the notices issued under section 7 of the Ordinance, 1982 only on the ground of inadequate compensation are not maintainable. The Rules, therefore, would be discharged.
67We have considered the submissions of both sides, gone through the materials on record, the annexures appended with the writ petition, the provisions of law and ratio of the cases cited by the parties.
68It is admitted fact that the petitioners were the owners of the lands described in the schedules to the writ petitions. They were served with notices
under sections 3 and 6 of Ordinance, 1982 but they did not raise any objection thereto. But while the notices under section 7 of the Ordinance all dated 22.02.2010 were served upon them then they raised objection that compensation assessed by respondent 2 in respect of the lands were below the market price. They did not receive any compensation as per the notice issued under section 7 of the Ordinance, 1982. It is admitted by the petitioners that they did not raise any objection in the acquisition because it was for public purpose. It is also admitted by them that in the meantime the health complex has already been constructed over the suit land and the hospital is running.
69In the writ petitions they have only raised objection as to the assessment of compensation for lands being less to the market price. In support of their claim they have submitted and annexed the market price of some lands of the concerned Sub Registry office of same mouza which they collected for the year 2011. They claimed that the price of each decimals null land was found there at Taka 19,861/-. They also annexed in the first four writ petitions same documents showing the price of land was Taka 10000/- to 20000/- per decimal. In the last 2 writ petitions they have annexed the documents to show the Government value of the land as per Sub Registry Office of Kabirhat, Noakhali and some deeds as contained in Annexures-C and C1 to the writ petitions showing price of land of that area at Taka 66,631/- per decimal. Although the Rule issued in first 4 writ petitions the vires of section 31 of the Ordinance, 1982 was challenged but the learned Advocate for the petitioners did not make any submission on first part of the Rules. However, on going through the provisions of law of proviso of section 31 of the Ordinance, 1982 and the
provisions of section 33 of the Ain, 2017 we do not find that the provisions of section 31 of the Ordinance, 1982 was or is ultra vires the constitution.
70The petitioners submits that respondent 2 assessed the compensation by violating the provisions of section 8 of the Ordinance, 1982 because the price of the acquired land was much more higher than that the compensation assessed. As per the provisions of section 8(1)(a) of the Ordinance, the Deputy Commissioner in determining the compensation to be awarded, shall take into consideration the market value of the property at the date of publication of the notice under section 3 of the Ordinance, 1982. In the instant case, it is admitted fact that the notices under section 3 were sent upon the petitioners on 11.10.2006 and as such the compensation is to be assessed fixing price at the rate of preceeding 12 months to that date. In all the writ petitions, the petitioners annexed the documents to show the market price in respect of land of said mouza of 2010 and 2011. Therefore, it cannot be said that the compensation assessed by the Deputy Commissioner was not in accordance with law or it was much more less than the market price at the material time. The petitioner’s learned Counsel argued that subsequently, a new law has been enacted in 2017 for acquisition and requisition of the immovable property and section 9 therein provides for payment of compensation thrice to the market value. Since the petitioners have not yet received the compensation at least they are entitled to get thrice of the amount of the present market price.
71It is admitted that process of acquiring the land has been completed and reached its finality. The health complex has been constructed and it is in operation. Section 50(2)(Ga) of the Ain, 2017 (the savings clause) provides
that “ ” which clearly means that in respect of payment of compensation to the petitioners for the land so acquired the provisions of the Ordinance, 1982 shall apply. In the case of Government of Bangladesh and others vs. Md. Hadisur Rahman and others, 26 BLC (AD) 294 it has been held that the Government cannot pay compensation for the land acquired beyond the rate fixed for the same which was notified earlier by publication of gazette. It has been further held therein that writ petition was not maintainable because the dispute therein is regarding the payment of compensation of the acquired land. The procedure of payment of compensation of acquired land has been described in section 10 of the Ordinance, 1982. It has been provided therein, if the persons entitled to compensation do not receive it, the Deputy Commissioner shall keep the amount of compensation in a deposit account in the Public account of the Republic which shall be deemed payment for the purpose of taking over possession of the property without any prejudice to the claim of the parties to be determined by the Arbitrator.
72Therefore, we find that since the petitioners disputed regarding payment of compensation, it shall dealt with in accordance with law, more particularly as per section 10 of the Ordinance, 1982. In writ jurisdiction, we have no scope to interfere with the service of notice under section 7 of the Ordinance, 1982, if it is not found that the provisions under the Ordinance, 1982 as embodied in sections 31, 34 and section 8 of the Ordinance ultra vires the unconstution. We find no relevancy in the cases referred to by the learned Advocate for the
petitioners. Therefore, we find that these Rules having no merit would be discharged.
73In view of the discussion made hereinabove, the Rules are discharged. There will be order as to costs.
74However, the judgment passed in these writ petitions will not preclude the petitioners from taking legal steps to get their compensation in accordance with law. If the petitioners being dissatisfied with the award amount approach before the Arbitration Tribunal as per the provisions of the Ordinance, 1982 the limitation prescribed in the law shall not be stand as bar.
75Communicate this judgment and order to the respondents.
76Abdur Rahman, J.
I agree
77Sumon-B.O.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











