High Court Division · Special Original Jurisdiction
Md. Nasir Uddin Akon v The Government of the People's Republic of Bangladesh and others
Writ Petition 3558/2023 · Decided 26 February 2026
The petitioner, an Upper Division Accounts Assistant with West Zone Power Distribution Company Limited (WZPDCL) on an extended contract, was charged with misconduct, threatening and assaulting a colleague. A single inquiry officer held the inquiry and he was removed from service in June 2022; his appeal was rejected in January 2023. WZPDCL argued that a writ did not lie against a company and that the Labour Court was the proper forum. Following Conforce Limited v Titas Gas, 9 BLD 429, the High Court Division held that WZPDCL, supervised by the Power Development Board, a public body, was amenable to writ jurisdiction, and that the Labour Appellate Tribunal had held its employees were not workers under the Labour Act, 2006. Rule 7.7(C) of the service rules, requiring an inquiry committee of two or three senior officers, was mandatory, and its breach vitiated the whole proceeding. The removal was declared unlawful and, his contract having expired, WZPDCL was directed to pay his benefits for the full contractual period within 30 days.
Rule made absolute; removal from service declared unlawful
- Q1
Whether a writ petition is maintainable against West Zone Power Distribution Company Limited, a company under the supervision of the Power Development Board.
- Q2
Whether the employee's remedy lay before the Labour Court rather than in writ jurisdiction.
- Q3
Whether a removal from service based on an inquiry by a single inquiry officer, contrary to rule 7.7(C) of the company's service rules requiring a committee of two or three senior officers, was lawful.
- Following Conforce Limited v Titas Gas Transmission and Distribution Co. Ltd., 9 BLD 429, WZPDCL, though a company, is by nature an enterprise of the Power Development Board under its complete supervision, so a writ petition against it is maintainable.
- The objection that the Labour Court was the proper forum failed because the Labour Appellate Tribunal had held that a WZPDCL employee is not a worker under the Labour Act, 2006.
- Rule 7.7(C) of the WZPDCL Employee Service Rules, 2016, requiring a committee of two or three senior officers to conduct an inquiry, is mandatory, and following Managing Director, Agrani Bank v Md. Serajuddin, 10 MLR (AD) 159, violation of such a provision vitiates the whole proceeding.
- Because only one inquiry officer was appointed, the inquiry, the report and the removal and rejection of appeal based on it had no legal effect, and the company failed to show the deviation was merely procedural or caused no prejudice.
- The removal was declared unlawful and, as the contract had expired, the respondents were directed to pay the petitioner all financial benefits for the complete contractual period within 30 days.
Considering that, the inquiry committee was formed in clear deviation of the mandatory provisions of the relevant service rules, the very foundation of the inquiry proceeding was vitiated.
In the court’s own words.
Writ Petition 3558/2023, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 12 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(SPECIAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION)
Writ Petition No. 3558 of 2023
IN THE MATTER OF:
An application under Article 102 of the
Constitution of the People’s Republic of
Bangladesh.
-AND-
IN THE MATTER OF:
Md. Nasir Uddin Akon
……Petitioner
-Versus-
Present:
Mr. Justice Sashanka Shekhar Sarkar The Government of the People’s Republic
And of Bangladesh, represented by the
Justice Urmee Rahman Secretary, Ministry of Power, Energy and
Mineral Resources and others
….. Respondents
Mr. Samarendra Nath Biswas, Advocate with
Mr. Md. Abul Kalam Khan (Daud), Advocate
…For the petitioner
Mr. Md. Sanwar Hossain, Advocate
…. For the respondent No. 4
Mr. Mohammad Waliul Islam Oli, D.A.G with
Mr. Md. Ershadul Bari Khandakar, D.A.G,
Ms. Nilufar Yesmin, A.A.G,
Mr. Md. Moshiur Rahman (Rahat), A.A.G,
Mr. Md. MotasinBillah Parvez, A.A.G and
Mr. Md. Faridul Islam, A.A.G
…. For the respondents
Heard on 27.01.2026, 03.02.2026 and 15.02.2026
Judgment on 26.02.2026
Urmee Rahman, J:
1In the instant matter a Rule Nisi was issued on an application
2under Article 102 of the Constitution of the People’s Republic of
3Bangladesh in the following terms:
4“Let a Rule Nisi be issued calling upon the
5respondents to show cause as to why the office order
6dated 10.01.2023 contained in Memo No. 27.22.4785.
7002.29.001.23.167 (Annexure-N) purported to have
8been issued under signature of the respondent No. 9
9dismissing the appeal thereby affirming the order
10dated 06.06.2022 vide Memo No. 27.22.4785.002.
1129.001.22.1098 removing the petitioner from his
12service as Upper Division Accounts Assistant in the
13West Zone Power Distribution Company Limited
14(WZPDCL), Sales and Distribution Department,
15Madaripur should not be declared to have been passed
16without lawful authority and is of no legal effect
17and/or pass such other or further order or orders as to
18this Court may seem fit and proper.”
19Necessary facts for disposal of the instant Rule, in brief, are that, the petitioner was absorbed as Junior Division Accounts Assistant on 26.06.1986 by the Power Development Board (PDB). Thereafter he was made permanent in his service on 13.09.1987. West Zone Power Distribution Company Limited (WZPDCL) was created under PDB in 2005 and on 23.03.2005 an agreement was executed between the PDB and WZPDCL. Following that agreement, the petitioner was appointed as Computer Operator Junior Accounts Assistant in this Company vide order dated 27.02.2008. He was promoted as Upper-Class Accounts Assistant
and his tenure of service has been extended from time to time by WZPDCL and lastly it was extended on 12.12.2017, which is to be expired on 15.12.2022.
20During service of the petitioner the respondent No. 13 namely, Md. Miraz Hossain made an allegation of misconduct against the petitioner to the authority and upon receiving the complaint, the WZPDCL vide memo dated 29.11.2021, issued show cause notice upon the petitioner, to which he replied on 02.12.2022 denying all the allegations brought against him. The reply not being found satisfactory, the authority issued a second show cause notice on 14.12.2021 as to why departmental proceeding should not be initiated against him. The petitioner replied to that notice on 22.12.2021.
21Thereafter charge was framed against him on 13.01.2022 for the offence of misconduct, threatening for life and assaulting the respondent No. 12. One enquiry officer was appointed, who asked the petitioner to submit written reply. Upon receiving the written reply, the petitioner was asked to appear in person for hearing with supporting documents. Finally, by the order dated 06.06.2022 the petitioner was removed from service.
22Being aggrieved, the petitioner filed an application on 11.06.2022 for reviewing the order of removal. The respondent authority treated the application as appeal under the provision of law and sent it to the concerned authority for disposal vide memo dated 14.06.2022. Since the authority did not dispose of the appeal,
the petitioner filed Writ Petition No. 12556 of 2022 and upon hearing a Division Bench of the High Court Division by the order dated 07.11.2022 directed the respondents to dispose of the petitioner's appeal within 15 days of receipt of the order. Upon receiving the order of his Court, the respondent No. 3 rejected the appeal on 10.01.2023 without hearing the petitioner. Being aggrieved thereby and there having no other equally efficacious alternative remedy available, the petitioner filed the instant writ petition and obtained the Rule.
23Mr. Samarendra Nath Biswas, learned Advocate with Mr. Md. Abul Kalam Khan (Daud), learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioner submitted that, the allegation brought against the petitioner is vague and mala fide and as such the order of removal is not sustainable in the eye of law.
24Mr. Biswas next submitted that, earlier on 02.11.2010 the Manager, HRM & D of WZPDCL issued a memo to all the Operation and Maintenance Circle that every discipline and enquiry must be held primarily by the local office and after completion of enquiry the allegation having been proved, the same should be sent to the Head Office for imposing punishment but in the instant case the enquiry was held by the Head Office in violation of that memo.
25Learned Advocate then argued that, according to Rule 7.7 (C) of the Service Rules of the WZPDCL, the authority shall constitute a committee consisting of two or three officer's seniors in rank to the accused to conduct the inquiry, which shall submit a report after
giving the employee a personal hearing if so desired by him, within two weeks (may be extended if so required) from the date of its constitution. But in the instant case inquiry committee was formed with one member only and report was submitted beyond the prescribed time period in clear contravention of the Rules and as such the enquiry report being quorum non judice, the order of removal on the basis thereof has no lawful basis.
26He further submitted that, the respondent No. 5 issued the letter removing the petitioner from his service but he had no power to pass the order of termination before the proposal for termination is approved by the Board of the WZPDCL and as such the impugned order is liable to be declared without any lawful authority.
27He finally submitted that, the removal order and the rejection of appeal having been made in an arbitrary manner and the enquiry being held in contravention of the service rules, the order of removal is liable to be set aside. In support of his submission, learned Advocate referred to the case of The Managing Director, Agrani Bank, Head Office, Dhaka and others Vs. Md. Serajuddin reported in 10 MLR (AD) 2005 at page 159 and Conforce Limited Vs. Titas Gas Transmission and Distribution Co. Ltd. And others reported in 9 BLD 429.
28On the other hand, learned Advocate Mr. Md. Sanwar Hossain, entered appearance on behalf of Respondent no. 4 by filing an affidavit in opposition and vehemently opposed the Rule.
29At the very outset he submitted that, the service of the petitioner with the WZPDCL is contractual in nature and therefore the appropriate forum to challenge the order of removal is before the Labour Court. Furthermore, WZPDCL not being a statutory body, no remedy can be sought for against it in writ jurisdiction. As such the instant writ petition is not maintainable.
30He next submitted that the enquiry committee was formed by one inquiry officer and one prosecutor and as such there was no severe deviation from the provision of the Rules. Moreover, the time frame suggested in the Service Rules is not mandatory rather directive and the petitioner was not prejudiced in any way as the departmental proceeding was held following due process upon giving the petitioner ample opportunity of being heard.
31He finally submitted that, the allegation of negligence, inefficiency, misconduct and corruption having been proved against the petitioner, the punishment was just and proportionate and as such the Rule is liable to be discharged.
32Heard the learned advocates for the respective parties and perused the writ petition, affidavit in opposition, supplementary affidavit and the documents annexed therewith.
33Let us first of all see whether the writ petition is maintainable or not since an argument has been raised by the respondent no. 4 that WZPDCL being a public limited company and not being a person performing any function in connection with
the affairs of the Republic is not a subject to the writ jurisdiction under Article 102 of the Constitution.
34In the case of Conforce Limited Vs. Titas GAS Transmission and Distribution Company Limited and others reported in 9 BLD 429 the same question was raised as to the Respondent no. 1 i.e.Titas Gas Limited being a public limited company, whether writ petition was maintainable against it or not. On this issue it was held in that case by this Division that:
35“16. It is, therefore, admitted that
36although the Respondent no. 1 was initially
37established as a limited company it now
38functions for the purpose of distribution, sale,
39etc. of gaseous substance under the direct
40control of a statutory corporation i.e. the
41Bangladesh Oil and Gas Corporation and also
42the Government acting through the ‘Ministry of
43Mineral, Oil and Gas Resources’. It is,
44therefore, apparent that the Respondent No. 1 is
45now a branch of a statutory Corporation.
4621. … The Bangladesh Oil and Gas Corporation
47having been established by Government under
48the Bangladesh Petroleum Act, 1974, is,
49therefore, a local authority. We have already
50seen that the Respondent No. 1 is a functionary
51under it. As such, this petition under Article 102
52of the Constitution is maintainable against it.”
53In the present case WZPDCL admittedly is a public limited company incorporated under the Company’s Act 1913. This Company entered into an agreement with the Power Development Board in 2005. Clause 11 to that agreement provides that:
54“The company shall exclusively be
55accountable for its entire work performance to
56the management of BPDB.”
57Though WZPDCL is a private limited company, by nature it is an enterprise of BPDB subject to its complete supervision. Since BPDB is a public body and WZPDCL is a branch of this body, remedy can well be sought for against it in writ jurisdiction following the principle laid down in the decision mentioned hereinabove.
58Besides, learned Advocate for the petitioner referred to the judgment passed in Writ Petition No. 10571 of 2007 wherein the service matter of an employee of WZPDCL was the subject matter and the issue of maintainability of the writ petition was not raised therein; moreover, learned Advocate for WZPDCL in that case argued that, “the company is virtually the company of the PDB.”
59With the aforesaid discussion, we therefore find that, the writ petition against West Zone Power Distribution Company Limited (WZPDCL) is maintainable.
60Learned Advocate for the Respondent no. 4 further argued that the appropriate remedy for the petitioner was before the Labour Court and in support thereof he annexed two judgments of the Labour Court and Labour Appellate Tribunal by filing a supplementary affidavit in opposition dated 26.02.2026 to establish that, employees of WPDCL file application before the Labour Court. In that particular case an employee of WZPDCL filed a
petition under Section 33(3) of the Labour Act, 2006 challenging his termination from service (Annexure-4). It appears that in this judgment the Labour Appellate Tribunal upon detail discussion held that the employee of WZPDCL is not a labour as per the definition of Labour Act, 2006 and the petition before the Labour Court is not maintainable. Hence, the argument put forwarded by the learned Advocate on this point is devoid of any substance.
61Now we shall determine whether the impugned order of removal was made without any lawful authority or not.
62The learned Advocate for the petitioner submitted that the enquiry committee was formed by only one enquiry officer in contravention of Rule 7.7(C) of the Employee Service Rules-2016 of WZPDCL. Rule 7.7(C) provides as follows:
63“The competent authority shall
64constitute a committee consisting of two
65or three officers senior in rank to the
66accused to conduct the inquiry which
67shall submit a report after giving the
68employee a personal hearing if so desired
69by him within two weeks (may be
70extended if so required) from the date of
71its constitution.”.
72The language of this provision makes it obvious that this is a mandatory provision of law and should be strictly adhered to by the authority without any deviation. In the case of, The Managing Director, Agrani Bank, Head Office, Dhaka and others Vs. Md. Serajuddin reported in 10 MLR (AD) 2005 at page 159 it has been
held by the apex court that, violation of mandatory provisions of the service rules by the inquiry committee has vitiated the whole proceedings.
73From Annexure-2 to the supplementary affidavit in opposition dated 01.02.2026 filed by the respondent No. 4, it transpires that, on 13.01.2022 one Mr. Md. Rokunuzzaman, Superintendent Engineer (Commercial), Head Office, WZPDCL, Khulna was appointed as inquiry officer in order to inquire into the allegations brought against the petitioner. It also appears from this memo that Mr. Md. Mominur Rahman, Assistant Manager (Security), WZPDCL, Head Office, Khulna was appointed as Prosecutor in order to represent the company in the departmental proceeding. It is therefore evident from this document that only one inquiry officer was appointed in clear contravention of the mandatory provision of the service rules.
74Besides, during the inquiry the only eye witness, meter reader Md. Gias Uddin Mollah in his deposition categorically stated that:
75“Se¡h ,
76Se¡h ®j¡x ¢jl¡S ®q¡−pe, EfpqL¡l£
77fÐ−L±nm£ Hl p¡−b A−n¡ie A¡QlZ L−le e¡C z
78g¡Cm ü¡rl ¢e−u Lb¡ q−u−Rz H−a A−n¡ie A¡QlZ
79h−m j−e qu e¡z
80Se¡h ®j¡x e¡¢pl E¢Ÿe A¡Le, EµQj¡e ¢qp¡h
81pqL¡l£ ®S¡lf§hÑL ü¡rl Ll−a k¡e e¡Cz S£he e¡−nl
82ýj¢L fÐc¡e L−le e¡Cz n¡¢ll£Li¡−h a¡−L m¡¢“a
83L−le e¡Cz”
84The rest of the eye witnesses were not called as witness before the inquiry committee. The sole inquiry officer based his finding mainly on the C.C.T.V. footage and the hearsay evidence of the higher officials. By filing a supplementary affidavit dated 26.01.2026 the learned Advocate for the petitioner submitted that an application was filed by the petitioner in order to get a copy of the C.C.T.V. footage but the authority has not made any reply thereto and that he has been prejudiced by the arbitrary exercise of power by the authority.
85Considering that, the inquiry committee was formed in clear deviation of the mandatory provisions of the relevant service rules, the very foundation of the inquiry proceeding was vitiated. Consequently, the inquiry report and all subsequent actions taken on the basis thereof have no legal effect. The impugned order of removal from service and rejection of appeal are therefore not sustainable.
86The Respondent no. 4 has failed to show that the said deviation is merely procedural or that no prejudice has been caused to the petitioner.
87In view of the facts and circumstances discussed hereinabove, we find that the Rule issued in the writ petition has merit.
88Accordingly, the Rule is made absolute.
89However, without any order as to cost.
90The removal of the petitioner from service by the impugned memo is hereby declared unlawful and without any lawful authority.
91From Annexure-E it appears that the service contract period of the petitioner has already expired by this time on 15.11.2022 and the order of removal was issued earlier on 06.06.2022. The respondents are therefore directed to provide the petitioner with all the financial facilities which he is entitled to get for the complete contractual period of service in accordance with the service rules within 30 (thirty) days from the date of receipt of this judgment and order.
92Let a copy of this judgment and order be communicated to the concerned authorities at once.
93Sashanka Shekhar Sarkar, J:
94I agree.
95Helal/ABO
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











