High Court Division · Special Original Jurisdiction
Eti Rani Das v The Government of Bangladesh and others
Writ Petition 8174/2023 · Decided 14 December 2025
The petitioner's late husband was recognised as a freedom fighter of the 1971 liberation war by the Ministry of Liberation War Affairs and other authorities. His name was published in the civil gazette in 2005, and he received a state honorarium from July 2005 until his death in 2020, after which the petitioner received it. After a 2021 Upazila verification (jachai bachhai) committee report, the honorarium was stopped and a 2023 memo, following a Jatio Muktijoddha Council decision, cancelled his gazette entry. The Deputy Attorney General found it difficult to oppose the Rule. The High Court Division noted the many certificates recognising the husband and that the two committee reports were inconsistent. It found the cancellation was made without proper investigation and without cogent reasons, so it was arbitrary and not based on relevant factors. The Rule was made absolute, the cancellation memo was declared without lawful authority, and the respondents were directed to pay the monthly state honorarium to the petitioner as the wife of a deceased freedom fighter.
Rule made absolute; cancellation of freedom fighter gazette void
- Q1
Whether the cancellation of the gazette recognising the petitioner's deceased husband as a freedom fighter, without cogent reasons and on inconsistent verification reports, was made without lawful authority.
- Q2
Whether the state honorarium paid to a freedom fighter's family could be stopped without sufficient cause.
- The respondents cancelled the civil gazette of the petitioner's husband without proper investigation, without considering the certificates issued by many authorities including the Government, and without assigning cogent reasons.
- The two reports of the verification committee were inconsistent with each other, and no cogent reason appeared for the cancellation.
- An honorarium should not be cancelled without sufficient cause, and cancelling it arbitrarily would breach the implied or explicit agreement between payer and recipient.
- The impugned notification was not based on relevant factors and was arbitrary, mala fide and potentially discriminatory.
- The memo cancelling Gazette No. 442 so far as it related to the petitioner's husband was declared without lawful authority, and the respondents were directed to pay the petitioner the monthly state honorarium in accordance with law.
The law is by now well settled that an honorarium should not be canceled without sufficient cause, as this principle aligns with professional courtesy and contractual fairness.
In the court’s own words.
Writ Petition 8174/2023, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 18 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(SPECIAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION)
WRIT PETITION NO. 8174 of 2023
IN THE MATTER OF:
An application under Article 102 of the
Constitution of the People’s Republic of
Bangladesh.
IN THE MATTER OF:
Eti Rani Das.
………. Petitioner.
-Versus-
The Government of Bangladesh,
represented by Secretary, Ministry of
Liberation War Affairs and others.
………. Respondents
Mr. M.G. Mahmud with
Mr. Sohel Rana, Advocate.
………. For the petitioner.
Mr. Mohammad Mohsin Kabir, DAG with
Mr. A.K.M. Rezaul Karim Khandaker, D.A.G
Ms. Shaheen Sultana, AAG and
Mr. Md. Manowarul Islam Uzzal, A.A.G with
Mr. Md. Mukhlesur Rahman, A.A.G.
……… For the respondents.
Heard and Judgment on: 14.12.2025.
Present:
Mr. Justice Sheikh Abdul Awal
And
Mr. Justice S.M. Iftekhar Uddin Mahamud
Sheikh Abdul Awal, J.
1On an application under Article 102 of the Constitution , this Rule Nisi was issued calling upon the respondents to show cause as to why the Memo No. 48.02.0000.001.00.276.16-124 dated 07.02.2023 issued by the respondent No.3 cancelling the Gazette
No. 442 of the petitioner's husband as Freedom Fighter, so far it relates to serial No.5, (Annexure-J) pursuant to the decision taken on 17.01.2023 in 83rd meeting of Jatio Muktijoddha Council (JAMUKA) should not be declared to have been made without any lawful authority and is of no legal effect and/or such other or further order or orders passed as to this Court may seem fit and proper.
2The facts of the case as stated in the writ petition briefly are that the husband of petitioner, late Radhe Shyam Das as freedom fighter fought for this country in the liberation war, held in 1971. Due to his contribution in the liberation war Ministry of Liberation War Affairs issued a certificate in favour of Radhe Shyam Das, the husband of the petitioner, (Annexure-A) recognizing him as a freedom fighter and so many authorities including fellow freedom fighters also issued certificates in favour of Radhe Shyam Das, the deceased husband of the petitioner recognizing him as a freedom fighter (Annexure-L, L-1&L-2 to the supplementary affidavit). In this background his name was published in Civil Gazette dated 17.04.2005 being gazette No. 442 at page No. 1519 (Annexure- B) and his name also published in MIS of Ministry of Liberation War Affairs as Freedom Fighter (Annexure-D-2). Thereafter, the husband of the petitioner started to get state honorarium since July, 2005 by using the vata book issued in favour of late Radhe Shyam Das, the husband of the petitioner by the Government and it is on record that he got state honorarium till to his death on 04.04.2020 and thereafter the petitioner as wife of deceased freedom fighter ( Radhe Shyam Das) received state honorarium in favour of her husband. In this backdrop all on a sudden as per report of Upazilla Jacai Bachai Committee in the year 2021 the state honorarium of the petitioner’s husband was stopped as well as the respondents without assigning any reasons whatsoever abruptly canceled the
Civil Gazette of the petitioner’s husband as freedom fighter by the impugned decision being memo dated 07.02.2023 (Annexure-J) and gazette notification dated 06.08.2023 (as contained in “AnnexureN” to the supplementary affidavit). Thereafter, finding no other alternative the petitioner has come before this Court and obtained the present Rule.
3Mr. M.G. Mahmud, the learned Advocate appearing for the petitioner submits that the husband of the petitioner, late Radhe Shyam Das was a valiant freedom fighter, who fought for this country during the liberation war and due to his contribution in the liberation war so many authorities including Upazilla Muktijoddha Commander, Jhalkathi and other fellow freedom fighters and ministry of Liberation War Affairs issued certificates in favour of the petitioner’s husband recognizing him as a freedom fighter and accordingly his name was duly published in civil gazette on 17.04.2005 and he also got state honorarium since July, 2005 to till his death on 04.04.2020 and thereafter, Upazilla Muktijoddha Jachai Bachhai Committee submitted a report stating- “ভারেত িনং কেরেছন এ মেম কােনা ্ -মাণক পাওয়া যায়িন।” and thereupon, the respondent No.2 stopped the state honorarium of the petitioner’s husband without considering the documents of the petitioner’s husband although it is on record that in the year, 2004 Upazilla Muktijoddha Jachai Bachhai Committee submitted a report stating that- “ কৃ ত মুি েযা া িহসােব মািণত হল।” Finally, the learned Advocate submits that the husband of the petitioner as Freedom Fighter got so many certificates and it is on record that earlier jachai bachhai was held in 2004 and after thorough scrutiny into the matter the Muktijoddha Jachai Bachhai Committee submitted a report stating that the husband of the petitioner is an actual freedom fighter but
finally, at the behest of the then Awami League Government jachai bachhai committee submitted a perfunctory report which is in-fact baseless and untrue although the respondent No.2 relying on the said perfunctory so-called report of jachai bachhai committee most illegally stopped the state honorarium of the petitioner’s husband and subsequently cancelled the civil gazette of petitioner’s husband as freedom fighter and as such, the same is liable to be declared to have been made without any lawful authority and is of no legal effect
4Mr. A.K.M. Rezaul Karim Khandaker, the learned Deputy Attorney General, on the other hand, in the facts and circumstances of the case has ultimately found it difficult to oppose the Rule on the grounds upon which Rule was obtained.
5On a scrutiny of the record, it appears that in this case the husband of the petitioner as a Freedom Fighter fought in the liberation war, held in 1971 and thereafter, the Government of Bangladesh as well as so many authorities including his fellow freedom fighters issued certificates in his favour recognizing him as a Freedom Fighter as evidenced by Annexure-A to the writ petition and Annexure- K, L, L-1&L-2 to the supplementary affidavit and his name also published in the civil gazette as well as website of the Ministry of Liberation War Affairs (Annexure- B&D-2). It is also found that Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangshad, Central Command Council issued a testimonial recommending for the job of the petitioner’s husband and the name of the husband of the petitioner has been also published in the voter list of Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangshad (Annexure-E&E-2). It is further found that without any proper investigation or without considering the certificate issued by so many authorities including the Government of Bangladesh, the
respondents canceled the civil gazette of the petitioner’s husband without assigning any cogent reasons whatsoever.
6On going through the annexed documents, it appears that in this case 2 reports of jachai bachhai committee (Annexure-F-1& Annexure-G) are inconsistent with each other. It further appears that the husband of the petitioner got state honorarium since July, 2005 to till his death on 04.04.2020 and thereafter the petitioner as wife of deceased freedom fighter ( Radhe Shyam Das) received the said state honorarium.
7Considering all these facts and circumstances of the case as revealed from the materials on record, we find no cogent reason as to why by the respondents by the impugned notification dated 07.02.2023 (Annexure-J) canceled the civil gazette of deceased freedom fighter, Radhe Shyam Das, the husband of the petitioner. The law is by now well settled that an honorarium should not be canceled without sufficient cause, as this principle aligns with professional courtesy and contractual fairness. State honorarium is a payment for special or occasional work, and canceling it arbitrarily would be a breach of the implied or explicit agreement between the payer and the recipient. Therefore, we are of the view that the impugned notification is not based on relevant factors. The notification was issued without considering the proper, appropriate, and important considerations that should have guided its creation. This lack of basis in relevant factors indicates the notification was arbitrary, malafide, and potentially discriminatory, making it legally flawed and subject to being declared without lawful authority.
8In the result, the Rule Nisi is made absolute. The impugned Memo No. 48.02.0000.001.00.276.16-124 dated 07.02.2023 issued by the respondent No.3 cancelling the Gazette No. 442 of the petitioner's husband as Freedom Fighter, so far it relates to serial No.5, (Annexure-J) pursuant to the decision taken on 17.01.2023 in the 83rd meeting of Jatio Muktijoddha Council (JAMUKA) is declared to have been made without lawful authority and is of no legal effect and the respondents are directed to pay monthly sate honorarium to the petitioner as wife of a deceased Freedom Fighter in accordance with law.
9In the facts and circumstances of the case there will be no order as to costs.
10Communicate this order to the Respondents at once.
11S.M. Iftekhar Uddin Mahamud, J:
12I agree.
13IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
14HIGH COURT DIVISION
15(SPECIAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION)
16WRIT PETITION NO. 8174 of 2023
17IN THE MATTER OF:
18An application under Article 102 of the
19Constitution of the People’s Republic of
20Bangladesh.
21IN THE MATTER OF:
22Eti Rani Das.
23………. Petitioner.
24-Versus-
25The Government of Bangladesh,
26represented by Secretary, Ministry of
27Liberation War Affairs and others.
28………. Respondents
29Mr. M.G. Mahmud with
30Mr. Sohel Rana, Advocate.
31………. For the petitioner.
32Mr. Mohammad Mohsin Kabir, DAG with
33Mr. A.K.M. Rezaul Karim Khandaker, D.A.G
34Ms. Shaheen Sultana, AAG and
35Mr. Md. Manowarul Islam Uzzal, A.A.G with
36Mr. Md. Mukhlesur Rahman, A.A.G.
37……… For the respondents.
38Heard and Judgment on: 14.12.2025.
39Present:
40Mr. Justice Sheikh Abdul Awal
41And Mr. Justice S.M. Iftekhar Uddin Mahamud Sheikh Abdul Awal, J.
42On an application under Article 102 of the Constitution , this Rule Nisi was issued calling upon the respondents to show cause as to why the Memo No. 48.02.0000.001.00.276.16-124 dated 07.02.2023 issued by the respondent No.3 cancelling the Gazette
No. 442 of the petitioner's husband as Freedom Fighter, so far it relates to serial No.5, (Annexure-J) pursuant to the decision taken on 17.01.2023 in 83rd meeting of Jatio Muktijoddha Council (JAMUKA) should not be declared to have been made without any lawful authority and is of no legal effect and/or such other or further order or orders passed as to this Court may seem fit and proper.
43The facts of the case as stated in the writ petition briefly are that the husband of petitioner, late Radhe Shyam Das as freedom fighter fought for this country in the liberation war, held in 1971. Due to his contribution in the liberation war Ministry of Liberation War Affairs issued a certificate in favour of Radhe Shyam Das, the husband of the petitioner, (Annexure-A) recognizing him as a freedom fighter and so many authorities including fellow freedom fighters also issued certificates in favour of Radhe Shyam Das, the deceased husband of the petitioner recognizing him as a freedom fighter (Annexure-L, L-1&L-2 to the supplementary affidavit). In this background his name was published in Civil Gazette dated 17.04.2005 being gazette No. 442 at page No. 1519 (Annexure- B) and his name also published in MIS of Ministry of Liberation War Affairs as Freedom Fighter (Annexure-D-2). Thereafter, the husband of the petitioner started to get state honorarium since July, 2005 by using the vata book issued in favour of late Radhe Shyam Das, the husband of the petitioner by the Government and it is on record that he got state honorarium till to his death on 04.04.2020 and thereafter the petitioner as wife of deceased freedom fighter ( Radhe Shyam Das) received state honorarium in favour of her husband. In this backdrop all on a sudden as per report of Upazilla Jacai Bachai Committee in the year 2021 the state honorarium of the petitioner’s husband was stopped as well as the respondents without assigning any reasons whatsoever abruptly canceled the
Civil Gazette of the petitioner’s husband as freedom fighter by the impugned decision being memo dated 07.02.2023 (Annexure-J) and gazette notification dated 06.08.2023 (as contained in “AnnexureN” to the supplementary affidavit). Thereafter, finding no other alternative the petitioner has come before this Court and obtained the present Rule.
44Mr. M.G. Mahmud, the learned Advocate appearing for the petitioner submits that the husband of the petitioner, late Radhe Shyam Das was a valiant freedom fighter, who fought for this country during the liberation war and due to his contribution in the liberation war so many authorities including Upazilla Muktijoddha Commander, Jhalkathi and other fellow freedom fighters and ministry of Liberation War Affairs issued certificates in favour of the petitioner’s husband recognizing him as a freedom fighter and accordingly his name was duly published in civil gazette on 17.04.2005 and he also got state honorarium since July, 2005 to till his death on 04.04.2020 and thereafter, Upazilla Muktijoddha Jachai Bachhai Committee submitted a report stating- “ভারেত িনং কেরেছন এ মেম কােনা ্ -মাণক পাওয়া যায়িন।” and thereupon, the respondent No.2 stopped the state honorarium of the petitioner’s husband without considering the documents of the petitioner’s husband although it is on record that in the year, 2004 Upazilla Muktijoddha Jachai Bachhai Committee submitted a report stating that- “ কৃ ত মুি েযা া িহসােব মািণত হল।” Finally, the learned Advocate submits that the husband of the petitioner as Freedom Fighter got so many certificates and it is on record that earlier jachai bachhai was held in 2004 and after thorough scrutiny into the matter the Muktijoddha Jachai Bachhai Committee submitted a report stating that the husband of the petitioner is an actual freedom fighter but
finally, at the behest of the then Awami League Government jachai bachhai committee submitted a perfunctory report which is in-fact baseless and untrue although the respondent No.2 relying on the said perfunctory so-called report of jachai bachhai committee most illegally stopped the state honorarium of the petitioner’s husband and subsequently cancelled the civil gazette of petitioner’s husband as freedom fighter and as such, the same is liable to be declared to have been made without any lawful authority and is of no legal effect
45Mr. A.K.M. Rezaul Karim Khandaker, the learned Deputy Attorney General, on the other hand, in the facts and circumstances of the case has ultimately found it difficult to oppose the Rule on the grounds upon which Rule was obtained.
46On a scrutiny of the record, it appears that in this case the husband of the petitioner as a Freedom Fighter fought in the liberation war, held in 1971 and thereafter, the Government of Bangladesh as well as so many authorities including his fellow freedom fighters issued certificates in his favour recognizing him as a Freedom Fighter as evidenced by Annexure-A to the writ petition and Annexure- K, L, L-1&L-2 to the supplementary affidavit and his name also published in the civil gazette as well as website of the Ministry of Liberation War Affairs (Annexure- B&D-2). It is also found that Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangshad, Central Command Council issued a testimonial recommending for the job of the petitioner’s husband and the name of the husband of the petitioner has been also published in the voter list of Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangshad (Annexure-E&E-2). It is further found that without any proper investigation or without considering the certificate issued by so many authorities including the Government of Bangladesh, the
respondents canceled the civil gazette of the petitioner’s husband without assigning any cogent reasons whatsoever.
47On going through the annexed documents, it appears that in this case 2 reports of jachai bachhai committee (Annexure-F-1& Annexure-G) are inconsistent with each other. It further appears that the husband of the petitioner got state honorarium since July, 2005 to till his death on 04.04.2020 and thereafter the petitioner as wife of deceased freedom fighter ( Radhe Shyam Das) received the said state honorarium.
48Considering all these facts and circumstances of the case as revealed from the materials on record, we find no cogent reason as to why by the respondents by the impugned notification dated 07.02.2023 (Annexure-J) canceled the civil gazette of deceased freedom fighter, Radhe Shyam Das, the husband of the petitioner. The law is by now well settled that an honorarium should not be canceled without sufficient cause, as this principle aligns with professional courtesy and contractual fairness. State honorarium is a payment for special or occasional work, and canceling it arbitrarily would be a breach of the implied or explicit agreement between the payer and the recipient. Therefore, we are of the view that the impugned notification is not based on relevant factors. The notification was issued without considering the proper, appropriate, and important considerations that should have guided its creation. This lack of basis in relevant factors indicates the notification was arbitrary, malafide, and potentially discriminatory, making it legally flawed and subject to being declared without lawful authority.
49In the result, the Rule Nisi is made absolute. The impugned Memo No. 48.02.0000.001.00.276.16-124 dated 07.02.2023 issued by the respondent No.3 cancelling the Gazette No. 442 of the petitioner's husband as Freedom Fighter, so far it relates to serial No.5, (Annexure-J) pursuant to the decision taken on 17.01.2023 in the 83rd meeting of Jatio Muktijoddha Council (JAMUKA) is declared to have been made without lawful authority and is of no legal effect and the respondents are directed to pay monthly sate honorarium to the petitioner as wife of a deceased Freedom Fighter in accordance with law.
50In the facts and circumstances of the case there will be no order as to costs.
51Communicate this order to the Respondents at once.
52S.M. Iftekhar Uddin Mahamud, J:
53I agree.
54IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
55HIGH COURT DIVISION
56(SPECIAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION)
57WRIT PETITION NO. 8174 of 2023
58IN THE MATTER OF:
59An application under Article 102 of the
60Constitution of the People’s Republic of
61Bangladesh.
62IN THE MATTER OF:
63Eti Rani Das.
64………. Petitioner.
65-Versus-
66The Government of Bangladesh,
67represented by Secretary, Ministry of
68Liberation War Affairs and others.
69………. Respondents
70Mr. M.G. Mahmud with
71Mr. Sohel Rana, Advocate.
72………. For the petitioner.
73Mr. Mohammad Mohsin Kabir, DAG with
74Mr. A.K.M. Rezaul Karim Khandaker, D.A.G
75Ms. Shaheen Sultana, AAG and
76Mr. Md. Manowarul Islam Uzzal, A.A.G with
77Mr. Md. Mukhlesur Rahman, A.A.G.
78……… For the respondents.
79Heard and Judgment on: 14.12.2025.
80Present:
81Mr. Justice Sheikh Abdul Awal
82And Mr. Justice S.M. Iftekhar Uddin Mahamud Sheikh Abdul Awal, J.
83On an application under Article 102 of the Constitution , this Rule Nisi was issued calling upon the respondents to show cause as to why the Memo No. 48.02.0000.001.00.276.16-124 dated 07.02.2023 issued by the respondent No.3 cancelling the Gazette
No. 442 of the petitioner's husband as Freedom Fighter, so far it relates to serial No.5, (Annexure-J) pursuant to the decision taken on 17.01.2023 in 83rd meeting of Jatio Muktijoddha Council (JAMUKA) should not be declared to have been made without any lawful authority and is of no legal effect and/or such other or further order or orders passed as to this Court may seem fit and proper.
84The facts of the case as stated in the writ petition briefly are that the husband of petitioner, late Radhe Shyam Das as freedom fighter fought for this country in the liberation war, held in 1971. Due to his contribution in the liberation war Ministry of Liberation War Affairs issued a certificate in favour of Radhe Shyam Das, the husband of the petitioner, (Annexure-A) recognizing him as a freedom fighter and so many authorities including fellow freedom fighters also issued certificates in favour of Radhe Shyam Das, the deceased husband of the petitioner recognizing him as a freedom fighter (Annexure-L, L-1&L-2 to the supplementary affidavit). In this background his name was published in Civil Gazette dated 17.04.2005 being gazette No. 442 at page No. 1519 (Annexure- B) and his name also published in MIS of Ministry of Liberation War Affairs as Freedom Fighter (Annexure-D-2). Thereafter, the husband of the petitioner started to get state honorarium since July, 2005 by using the vata book issued in favour of late Radhe Shyam Das, the husband of the petitioner by the Government and it is on record that he got state honorarium till to his death on 04.04.2020 and thereafter the petitioner as wife of deceased freedom fighter ( Radhe Shyam Das) received state honorarium in favour of her husband. In this backdrop all on a sudden as per report of Upazilla Jacai Bachai Committee in the year 2021 the state honorarium of the petitioner’s husband was stopped as well as the respondents without assigning any reasons whatsoever abruptly canceled the
Civil Gazette of the petitioner’s husband as freedom fighter by the impugned decision being memo dated 07.02.2023 (Annexure-J) and gazette notification dated 06.08.2023 (as contained in “AnnexureN” to the supplementary affidavit). Thereafter, finding no other alternative the petitioner has come before this Court and obtained the present Rule.
85Mr. M.G. Mahmud, the learned Advocate appearing for the petitioner submits that the husband of the petitioner, late Radhe Shyam Das was a valiant freedom fighter, who fought for this country during the liberation war and due to his contribution in the liberation war so many authorities including Upazilla Muktijoddha Commander, Jhalkathi and other fellow freedom fighters and ministry of Liberation War Affairs issued certificates in favour of the petitioner’s husband recognizing him as a freedom fighter and accordingly his name was duly published in civil gazette on 17.04.2005 and he also got state honorarium since July, 2005 to till his death on 04.04.2020 and thereafter, Upazilla Muktijoddha Jachai Bachhai Committee submitted a report stating- “ভারেত িনং কেরেছন এ মেম কােনা ্ -মাণক পাওয়া যায়িন।” and thereupon, the respondent No.2 stopped the state honorarium of the petitioner’s husband without considering the documents of the petitioner’s husband although it is on record that in the year, 2004 Upazilla Muktijoddha Jachai Bachhai Committee submitted a report stating that- “ কৃ ত মুি েযা া িহসােব মািণত হল।” Finally, the learned Advocate submits that the husband of the petitioner as Freedom Fighter got so many certificates and it is on record that earlier jachai bachhai was held in 2004 and after thorough scrutiny into the matter the Muktijoddha Jachai Bachhai Committee submitted a report stating that the husband of the petitioner is an actual freedom fighter but
finally, at the behest of the then Awami League Government jachai bachhai committee submitted a perfunctory report which is in-fact baseless and untrue although the respondent No.2 relying on the said perfunctory so-called report of jachai bachhai committee most illegally stopped the state honorarium of the petitioner’s husband and subsequently cancelled the civil gazette of petitioner’s husband as freedom fighter and as such, the same is liable to be declared to have been made without any lawful authority and is of no legal effect
86Mr. A.K.M. Rezaul Karim Khandaker, the learned Deputy Attorney General, on the other hand, in the facts and circumstances of the case has ultimately found it difficult to oppose the Rule on the grounds upon which Rule was obtained.
87On a scrutiny of the record, it appears that in this case the husband of the petitioner as a Freedom Fighter fought in the liberation war, held in 1971 and thereafter, the Government of Bangladesh as well as so many authorities including his fellow freedom fighters issued certificates in his favour recognizing him as a Freedom Fighter as evidenced by Annexure-A to the writ petition and Annexure- K, L, L-1&L-2 to the supplementary affidavit and his name also published in the civil gazette as well as website of the Ministry of Liberation War Affairs (Annexure- B&D-2). It is also found that Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangshad, Central Command Council issued a testimonial recommending for the job of the petitioner’s husband and the name of the husband of the petitioner has been also published in the voter list of Bangladesh Muktijoddha Sangshad (Annexure-E&E-2). It is further found that without any proper investigation or without considering the certificate issued by so many authorities including the Government of Bangladesh, the
respondents canceled the civil gazette of the petitioner’s husband without assigning any cogent reasons whatsoever.
88On going through the annexed documents, it appears that in this case 2 reports of jachai bachhai committee (Annexure-F-1& Annexure-G) are inconsistent with each other. It further appears that the husband of the petitioner got state honorarium since July, 2005 to till his death on 04.04.2020 and thereafter the petitioner as wife of deceased freedom fighter ( Radhe Shyam Das) received the said state honorarium.
89Considering all these facts and circumstances of the case as revealed from the materials on record, we find no cogent reason as to why by the respondents by the impugned notification dated 07.02.2023 (Annexure-J) canceled the civil gazette of deceased freedom fighter, Radhe Shyam Das, the husband of the petitioner. The law is by now well settled that an honorarium should not be canceled without sufficient cause, as this principle aligns with professional courtesy and contractual fairness. State honorarium is a payment for special or occasional work, and canceling it arbitrarily would be a breach of the implied or explicit agreement between the payer and the recipient. Therefore, we are of the view that the impugned notification is not based on relevant factors. The notification was issued without considering the proper, appropriate, and important considerations that should have guided its creation. This lack of basis in relevant factors indicates the notification was arbitrary, malafide, and potentially discriminatory, making it legally flawed and subject to being declared without lawful authority.
90In the result, the Rule Nisi is made absolute. The impugned Memo No. 48.02.0000.001.00.276.16-124 dated 07.02.2023 issued by the respondent No.3 cancelling the Gazette No. 442 of the petitioner's husband as Freedom Fighter, so far it relates to serial No.5, (Annexure-J) pursuant to the decision taken on 17.01.2023 in the 83rd meeting of Jatio Muktijoddha Council (JAMUKA) is declared to have been made without lawful authority and is of no legal effect and the respondents are directed to pay monthly sate honorarium to the petitioner as wife of a deceased Freedom Fighter in accordance with law.
91In the facts and circumstances of the case there will be no order as to costs.
92Communicate this order to the Respondents at once.
93S.M. Iftekhar Uddin Mahamud, J:
94I agree.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











