High Court Division · Special Original Jurisdiction
Md. Rubel Hossain v Bangladesh and others
Writ Petition 8750/2024 · Decided 5 May 2026
The petitioner was appointed a trainee police constable in 2010 under the freedom fighter quota on his father's provisional certificate. A criminal case was filed alleging the certificate was forged, the Ministry of Liberation War Affairs reported it as not genuine, and a departmental proceeding on the same allegation ended in his discharge from service on 09.08.2020, upheld on appeal. His father was later gazetted as a freedom fighter, the High Court Division quashed the criminal proceeding and the Sessions Judge, Jhenaidah discharged him. His application for reinstatement was rejected on the ground that the departmental order still stood. The High Court Division held that, as the criminal case on which the departmental proceeding was founded had ended in his favour and the allegation was negated, the penalty could not continue. Applying the principle of section 42(5) of the Public Servants Act, 2018, it found regulation 863 of the Police Regulations inconsistent with the Act, which prevails. Refusal was also discriminatory. Reinstatement with arrears was directed within 30 days.
Rule and supplementary Rule made absolute
- Rule NisiAn order of the High Court Division asking the other side to show cause why the relief sought should not be granted. It starts the full hearing; it is not a final decision.Read the full explanation →
- Rule absolute and Rule dischargedThe two final results of a Rule in the High Court Division: made absolute means the petitioner wins; discharged means the petition fails and the order below stands.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether a police constable discharged from service in a departmental proceeding founded on a criminal case must be reinstated once he is discharged from the criminal charge and the allegation is negated.
- Q2
Whether regulation 863 of the Police Regulations, 1943 can prevail over the principle in section 42 of the Public Servants Act, 2018.
- Q3
Whether refusing reinstatement while reinstating similarly placed employees was discriminatory.
- Where a departmental proceeding is founded merely on the filing of a criminal case and punishment is imposed before its outcome, the result of the criminal case affects that punishment.
- Once the criminal proceeding forming the foundation of the allegation ends in the employee's favour and the factual basis is negated, continuing the penalty of discharge from service is unsustainable in law.
- The principle of section 42(5) of the Public Servants Act, 2018, requiring reinstatement on acquittal, applies equally to proceedings under section 41(2).
- Regulation 863 of the Police Regulations, 1943 is inconsistent with the underlying principle of section 42 of the Public Servants Act, 2018, and where an Act and a regulation conflict, the Act prevails.
- Refusing to reinstate the petitioner while similarly situated police employees were reinstated amounted to discriminatory treatment.
- The discharge order, the appellate order and the refusal memo were set aside and the respondents were directed to reinstate the petitioner from 09.08.2020 with arrears within 30 days.
It is a well-established principle that in case of any inconsistency between an Act and a Regulation, the Act shall prevail.
In the court’s own words.
Writ Petition 8750/2024, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 13 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(SPECIAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION)
WRIT PETITION NO. 8750 OF 2024
IN THE MATTER OF:
An application under Article 102 of the Constitution
of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh.
AND
IN THE MATTER OF:
Md. Rubel Hossain
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS-
Bangladesh, represented by the Secretary, Ministry
of Home Affairs and others
..… Respondents
Mr. Md. Robiul Alam Budu, Senior Advocate, with
Mr. Md. Shahin Ali, Advocate
..…. For the Petitioner
Mr. Mohammad Waliul Islam Oli, D.A.G with
Mr. Md. Rashadul Hassan, D.A.G with
Ms. Nilufar Yesmin, A.A.G with
Mr. Md. Moshiur Rahman (Rahat), A.A.G with
Mr. Md. Motasin Billah Parvez, A.A.G with
Mr. Bishwanath Karmaker, A.A.G
……For the Respondents
Present:
Mr. Justice Sashanka Shekhar Sarkar
And
Justice Urmee Rahman
Heard on 03.03.2026 and 04.05.2026
Judgment on 05.05.2026
Urmee Rahman, J:
1In the instant matter a Rule Nisi was issued on an application under Article 102 of the Constitution of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh in the following terms:
“Let a Rule Nisi be issued calling upon the
2respondents to show cause as to why the Order No. 763
3dated 10.11.2020 passed by the respondent No.3 Deputy
4Inspector General (DIG) and Additional Inspector General
5of Police (In-Charge). Industrial Police dismissing the
6appeal vide Memo No. :/ 88 ( ) dated
710.11.2020 (Annexure-F-1) affirming the final order dated
809.08.2020 passed by the respondent No.4, Police Super,
9Industrial Police-2, Gazipur in Departmental Case No.04 of
102014 dated 28.08.2014 discharging the petitioner from his
11service (Annexure-E) should not be declared to have been
12done without lawful authority and is of no legal effect and/or
13such other or further order or order passed as to this court
14may seem fit and proper.” Subsequently by an order dated 10.03.2026 a supplementary Rule was issued in the following terms:
“ Let a supplementary Rule Nisi be issued calling upon
15the respondents to show cause as to why the letter vide
16Memo No. 768/(R.O) dated 13.05.2024 issued and signed by
17the respondent No. 4 refusing to consider the petitioner's
18application for reinstating him in his service in earlier post
19(Annexure-Q) should not be declared illegal and to have
20been passed without lawful authority and is of no legal effect
21and as to why a direction should not be given upon the
22respondents to reinstate the petitioner in his service with all
23arrears salary and other service benefits and/or pass such
other or further order or, orders as to this court may seem fit
and proper.”
24Necessary facts for disposal of the instant Writ Petition, in short, are that, in 2010 a number of trainee recruit constables were given appointment by Bangladesh Police. The petitioner applied for that post under freedom fighter quota submitting his father’s provisional certificate as a freedom fighter. On 24.05.2010 after examining physical fitness and scrutinizing all the documents, the appointment authority selected the petitioner and others for the post of trainee constable in freedom fighter quota and he was sent for taking basic training for 6 (six) months. After completing the training from Police Training Centre, Khulna, the petitioner was posted to Industrial Police Range, Bangladesh Police, Uttara, Dhaka and thereafter he was transferred to Industrial Police-2, Gazipur.
25The freedom fighter certificates submitted by the petitioner as well as others were sent for verification to the Ministry of Liberation War Affairs by the Police Headquarter vide memo dated 09.06.2010. The Ministry sent a report on 17.11.2013 to the Police Headquarter stating amongst others that the provisional certificate of petitioner’s father could not be found in the register and it is not a genuine one. On the basis of the said allegation on 26.07.2012 a Police Case being Jhenaidah P.S. Case No. 43 dated 26.07.2012 was filed in Jhenaidah Police Station under Sections 367/368/471/420 of the Penal Code against the petitioner and three others. Subsequently charge sheet was submitted in this case on
19.06.2014 and charge was framed against them on 10.05.2016. In the meantime, on the self-same allegation a departmental proceeding was initiated against the petitioner on 28.08.2014 being Departmental Case No. 04 of 2014 and during pendency of the departmental case the petitioner was suspended from his service on 08.06.2020. After concluding the departmental proceeding the petitioner was discharged from his service by the Police Super, Industrial Police-2, Gazipur by the order dated 09.08.2020. Challenging the order, the petitioner on 12.10.2020 filed an appeal before the Inspector General of Police and after concluding the appeal the DIG and Additional IGP, in charge, of Industrial Police, dismissed the appeal by the order dated 10.11.2020.
26Meanwhile, petitioner’s father made an application before the Secretary, Ministry of Liberation War Affairs to include his name in the Bangladesh Gazette and on the basis of his application Ministry inquired into the matter and finally by the Gazette Notification dated 30.01.2024 his name was published as a freedom fighter.
27Furthermore, the Criminal Case mentioned hereinabove was challenged in Criminal Miscellaneous Case No. 23524 of 2020 under Section 561A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 before the High Court Division and Rule was issued. After hearing, the Rule was made absolute by this Division by the judgment and order dated 30.05.2023 thereby quashing the entire criminal proceeding.
28As per the order of the High Court Division and on the basis of the Gazette notification submitted by the petitioner, the learned Sessions
Judge, Jhenaidah, discharged the petitioner from the charge on 28.02.2024. Having been discharged from the criminal proceeding the petitioner on 21.03.2024 filed an application before the Police Super Industrial Police-2, Gazipur for reinstatement in his service, who was pleased to reject the application on 13.05.2024.
29Being aggrieved thereby and there having no other alternative and equally efficacious remedy available, the petitioner has filed the instant writ petition and obtained the present Rule.
30Subsequently an application was filed by the petitioner for issuance of a Supplementary Rule challenging the abovementioned letter dated 13.05.2024, which was not initially challenged at the time of filing the writ petition. Accordingly, the Supplementary Rule was issued on 10.03.2026.
31Learned Senior Advocate Mr. Md. Robiul Alam Budu, appearing on behalf of the petitioner submits that, the respondent No. 3 and 4 without proper inquiry discharged the petitioner from his service, which is arbitrary in nature and was not in accordance with law and therefore the impugned order is liable to be declared to have been passed without any lawful authority.
32Learned Advocate further submits that the allegation brought against the petitioner as to the genuineness of the freedom fighter certificate of petitioner’s father was ultimately found to be untrue inasmuch as a Gazette was published including the petitioner’s father as a
freedom fighter and the criminal proceeding was also quashed by the High Court Division. As such the respondents ought to have considered the petitioner’s application for reinstatement in service but by rejecting the application the authority has acted mala fide and in an arbitrary and whimsical manner. Hence, the present Rule is liable to be made absolute.
33By referring to the supplementary affidavit dated 15.02.2026 learned Advocate for the petitioner submits that, 2(two) other employees of Bangladesh Police of different department being on the similar footing as of the petitioner, were reinstated in their service by the authority, as evidenced from Annexure-L and M. In the given circumstance the respondents are under a lawful obligation to reinstate the petitioner in his service.
34Lastly, he submits that, by the impugned memo dated 13.05.2024 the Police Super of Industrial Police-2, Gazipur opined that though the petitioner has been discharged from the allegation in a criminal Proceeding, they are not in a position to consider the reinstatement of the petitioner due to the fact that the order passed in the departmental proceeding is still in force. This opinion is misconceived and without any lawful basis, hence the Rule is liable to be made absolute.
35On the other hand, Mr. Waliul Islam Oli, the learned Deputy Attorney General entered appearance on behalf of the respondent no. 3 and contested the Rule by filing an affidavit in opposition.
36Learned Deputy Attorney General submits that, the criminal proceeding and departmental proceeding are separate and independent of each other and do not co-exist. Since the discharge order against the petitioner passed by a competent authority in a departmental proceeding was not set aside by Administrative Tribunal nordid the departmental order was reviewed pursuant to regulation 884 of PRB, 1943, the Rule issued in the instant matter is devoid of any substance.
37He further submits that, the petitioner was given reasonable opportunity of being heard and the departmental proceeding was held following due process of law. The competent authority rightly found him guilty of allegation for forging the freedom fighter certificate of his father and accordingly discharged him from service. The appellate authority on proper appreciation of the material evidence on record rejected the appeal. Hence the impugned order is very much lawful and therefore, the Rule is liable to be discharged.
38Heard the learned Advocates for the respective parties and perused the writ petition, supplementary affidavits thereto, the affidavit in opposition and all the documents annexed therewith.
39Facts need not be repeated for the purpose of brevity of the judgment. It is admitted that a criminal proceeding was initiated against the petitioner with the allegation of submitting forged freedom fighter certificate of his father in order to avail the freedom fighter quota and accordingly a departmental proceeding was initiated on the basis of the same allegation. The petitioner was ultimately discharged from the
allegation by the order dated 28.02.2024 (annexure-G). The allegation that the petitioner’s father is not a genuine Freedom fighter, was also proved to be untrue on publication of his name in the official Gazette notification dated 30.01.2024 as a genuine freedom fighter (Annexure-F).
40On meticulous perusal of Annexure-L and M, annexed to the supplementary affidavit, it transpires that, 2(two) other employees of Bangladesh Police, who were similarly convicted in a criminal case for submitting allegedly forged freedom fighter certificates, were subsequently reinstated in their services with the positive opinion from the Police Headquarters in this regard in a similar situation. In the office order dated 21.11.2023 (Annexure-M) it was stated that, “ , fË¡š²e LeØVhm/30301 , !"#$ % ¡- !(&)( )
' ( ) '* + , – -,
41' ( .'/ LjÑL¡m N−ZÉ Bangladesh Service Rules, Part-1Hl Rule – 01 . -2 – i¡a¡¢c 3 , ”।
42According to the provision of Section 41(2) of the Public Servants Act, 2018 the authority is empowered to initiate and dispose of a departmental proceeding against a delinquent employee on an allegation regarding which a criminal case is pending against him. However, this Section does not contain any provision as to the effect of the final outcome of the criminal case on the departmental proceeding. On the other hand, Section 42 (5) provides that, if any employee convicted in a criminal case, who has been removed from service by the employer on this ground, is subsequently acquitted on appeal, he shall be reinstated in
service. It can thus be construed that, the similar consequence as that of Section 42 (5) would follow in case of Section 41 (2).
43For better understanding Section 42 of the Public Servants Act, 2018 is quoted below:
42z “ z- ( )
( ) hvpl
!" #$ , %& '
() * + #$ a¡vr¢ZLi¡−h * , #$ z
(2) Ae§dÄÑ 1
44(HL) hvpl !+ %- #$ ,
. ' # / 0 1 ' ' ,
451+ :-
46( ) 2 ;
47(*) 3 4' 5 67 . 0;
48(.) / ' / 2 ! 0; !+
49(8) $ ( ! 4 0 !+ $9 :
50! # 0 !+ ;< =8> #$ 1 + '?&
@ 0 z
51(B) ' ( ' ) –
52( ) %'-" ( ) !" * ,: &, ' G '
53* ) H #$ # I # #$ ; =
54(*) %'-" (K) !" &, ' G '
55* ) H #$ , # %' ' () # #$ ।
56(L) * )H ,! . %' #$ !+
= M3 ' N H 8> , # I # 1$ ,
OPQ " + R " ) S #$ ”।
57In the present case the petitioner was not convicted of the alleged offence rather before completion of the trial the petitioner was discharged from the allegation. We find that in the given situation, the underlying purpose of the departmental proceeding initiated by Bangladesh Police no
longer survives. Once the criminal proceeding, which formed the foundation of the allegation brought against the petitioner has been terminated in favour of the petitioner and the factual aspect of the allegation has been negated, the continuation of the penalty of discharge from service in a departmental proceeding becomes wholly unsustainable in law.
58Moreover, the refusal to reinstate the petitioner, despite reinstatement being granted to other similarly situated employees of different departments amounts to discriminatory treatment towards the petitioner, which cannot be sustained in the eye of law.
59By the impugned memo dated 13.05.2024 (Annexure-Q/H-1) the respondent no. 4 rejected the petitioner’s application for reinstatement stating that, the criminal proceeding and the departmental proceeding are separate and independent of each other; since the order of removal given in the departmental proceeding has not been set aside either by the Administrative Tribunal or in any review under Regulation 884 of Police Regulation of 1943, they do not have the jurisdiction to consider the petitioner’s reinstatement application.
60Furthermore, by the memo dated 24.05.2025 (Annexure-O), the Police Super (Admin and Finance) Industrial Police Headquarters opined that, “ 4 – #। 6 (/ " ( ( -7"### 1 !$), !। 6 (/ 1 j¡qh¤h ( ( -$$###1&!0") Hhw 3z 6 (/442 ®nM ¢g−l¡S CLh¡m ( -$0###1&&"0) +8 9 – 1 (07)12 :;< 2 ( –
= , । , > +2- ( ?@ / 8 -z Police Regulations, 1943 Hl Regulation 862 and 863 fË¢hd¡e ®j¡a¡hL g±Sc¡l£ ( > +2- ( AB 3C – ( D gm¡gm AeÉ¢Vl E 3> 🙁 ।”
61In this context Regulation 863 of the Police Regulations, 1943 is quoted below:
“An order of discharge or acquittal of a Police
officer by a court shall not be a bar to the award of
departmental punishment to that officer in respect of the
same cause or matter.”
62It appears from Annexure L and M, already discussed hereinabove, that while reinstating the employees in a similar case, the Police Head Quarters relied on Section 42 (5) of the Public Servants Act, 2018 even though there was an order of removal in a departmental proceeding. As per the provision of Section 42 of the Act, a government servant can be awarded punishment by the employer without initiating a departmental proceeding if he is convicted in a criminal proceeding. However, regulation 863 of Police Regulations, 1943 is applicable in awarding punishment in a departmental proceeding irrespective of the fate of the criminal proceeding. In the present case, there is a punishment awarded in a departmental proceeding, which was initiated due to the filing of the criminal case on the self-same allegation.
63The basic provision of Section 42 (5) of the Public Servants Act is, if the employee is acquitted of the criminal conviction, the punishment awarded by the employer (without initiating departmental proceeding)
64shall be withdrawn. Considering the underlying reasoning of this provision we are of the view that, in a case where the basis of the departmental proceeding is merely filing of a criminal case, not the conviction, and punishment is awarded in the departmental proceeding prior to the final outcome of the criminal case, the result of the criminal case shall have effect on the punishment so awarded in the departmental proceeding. Because, the criminal proceeding, which formed the foundation of the departmental proceeding, has been terminated upon dismissing the factual aspect of the allegation. Hence the continuation of the punishment awarded in the departmental proceeding cannot subsists. The provision of regulation 863 of Police Regulations, 1943 thus appears to be inconsistent with the underlying principle of the provision of Section 42 of the Public Servants Act of 2018. It is a well-established principle that in case of any inconsistency between an Act and a Regulation, the Act shall prevail.
65With the foregoing discussions and findings we are inclined to hold that, the respondents are under a lawful obligation to reinstate the petitioner in service.
66In the given facts and circumstances, we find substance in the Rule and the supplementary Rule. In the result the both the Rule and the supplementary Rule are made absolute.
67The impugned order dated 09.08.2020 discharging the petitioner from service (Annexure-E), order dated 10.11.2020 dismissing the appeal
(Annexure F-1) and the memo dated 13.05.2024 (Annexure-K-1/Q) rejecting the petitioner’s application for reinstatement are hereby declared without any lawful effect and accordingly set aside.
68The respondents are hereby directed to reinstate the petitioner in his service giving effect from the date of discharge from service, that is, from 09.08.2020 and to provide him all the arrear salaries and benefits in accordance with law within 30 (thirty) days from receipt of this order.
69However, there is no order as to costs.
70Let a copy of this judgment and order be communicated to the concerned authorities at once. Justice Sashanka Shekhar Sarkar, J:
I agree.
71Farida B.O
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











