High Court Division · Civil Revisional Jurisdiction
Legal heirs of Murari Mohon Roy Chowdhury and others v Chairman, Khulna Development Authority, Khulna and others
Civil Revision 2754/2014 · Decided 23 February 2026
The plaintiffs claimed that 0.1632 acres of their land, recorded in their names in a DP (draft publication) khatian after an objection case, had been wrongly included in plots Nos. 36 to 40 which the Khulna Development Authority (KDA) advertised for allotment. They sued for a permanent injunction. The trial court restrained allotment of those plots until demarcation, but the appellate court reversed, reasoning partly that individual interest must not prevail over the national interest. No one appeared for the petitioners in the High Court Division. The Court held that the plaintiffs' own witnesses admitted KDA was in possession, so possession was not proved; the plots were KDA's internal demarcations, not finally published survey plots with defined boundaries; and a DP khatian carries no presumptive value of title until final publication. The trial court had also wrongly shifted the burden of proof to KDA. Although the appellate court's findings were arguably irrelevant and contrary to law, its reversal was correct, so the Rule was discharged and the stay vacated.
Rule discharged; dismissal of injunction suit upheld
- Q1
Whether the plaintiffs were entitled to a permanent injunction restraining the Khulna Development Authority from allotting its internal plots Nos. 36 to 40, where they could not prove possession and relied on a draft publication khatian rather than finally published survey records.
- Q2
Whether the trial court wrongly shifted the burden of proof onto the defendant.
- The Court found that the plaintiffs' own witnesses admitted KDA was in possession of plots Nos. 36 to 40, so the plaintiffs could not prove possession, and following Ahsanul Haq v Md. Abdul Ahad, 11 ALR (AD) 82, they were not entitled to a permanent injunction.
- The Court held that a permanent injunction cannot be granted over property not defined by metes and bounds or recognised survey plots, such as an authority's internal administrative plots.
- The Court held that a khatian carries no presumptive value as to title until it has undergone final publication and is notified in the Gazette, so reliance on a DP khatian was misplaced.
- Following Sarhab Ali Molla v Md. Farid Master, 29 BLC (AD) 185, the Court held that the trial court committed a material irregularity by shifting the burden of proof onto the defendant.
- The Court held that the appellate court correctly reversed the trial court's decree, although on findings that were arguably irrelevant and contrary to law, and discharged the Rule without costs, vacating the stay.
Under established land laws, a khatian carries no presumptive value regarding title until it has undergone final publication and is officially notified vide Gazette.
In the court’s own words.
Civil Revision 2754/2014, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 8 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2HIGH COURT DIVISION
3(CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION)
4Present :
5Mr. Justice Dihider Masum Kabir
6CIVIL REVISION NO.2754 OF 2014
7IN THE MATTER OF:
8An application under Section 115(1) of the
9Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
10-AND-
11IN THE MATTER OF:
12Legal heirs of Murari Mohon Roy Chowdhury
13and others.
14…. Petitioners
15– Versus –
16Chairman, Khulna Development Authority,
17Khulna and others.
19No one appears
20.……….For the Petitioners
21Mr. Ahmed Nowshed Jamil , Advocate with
22Ms. Sayeda Shoukat Ara, Advocate
23……….For the Opposite Party No.1
24Heard on 18.01.2026, 08.02.2026 &
2510.02.2026 & Judgment on 23.02.2026
26The Rule was issued calling upon the opposite parties to show cause as to why the impugned judgment and decree dated 12.05.2014 (decree signed on 19.05.2014) passed by the learned Joint District Judge, 2nd Court, Khulna in Title Appeal No. 225 of 2011 allowing the said appeal and thereby reversing the judgment and decree dated 14.07.2011 (decree signed on 20.07.2011) passed by learned Senior Assistant Judge Sadar, Khulna in Title Suit No. 96 of 2005 decreeing
the suit should not be set aside and/or to pass such other or further order or orders as to this court may seem fit and proper.
27The facts relevant for the disposal of this Rule, as set out in the civil revisional application, in short, are that the petitioners as plaintiffs filed the above suit for permanent injunction alleging that 1.38 acres land under CS Khatian No. 2626 (Plot No. 50) and SA Khatian No. 2795 (Plot No. 49) belonged to Raj Kumar Dutta and Panchanan Dutta, sons of Naba Kumar Dutta. Out of above 1.38 acres, defendant No. 1 (Khulna Development Authority) acquired 0.64 acres vide LA Case No. 2/1976-1977, leaving a remainder of 0.74 acres. From the remaining 0.74 acres, 0.37 acres devolved to Shova Rani and her subsequent legal heirs (the Plaintiffs). This interest is currently reflected in RS Plot Nos. 5068 and 5067. During a recent survey, the defendants allegedly amalgamated a portion of the plaintiffs’ land specifically the western roadside strip into their own holdings. This was erroneously recorded under DP Khatian No. 44, Plot No. 5067. The plaintiffs successfully contested above entry by Objection Case No. 3666. As a result, the record was corrected to show 0.1632 acres within plot No. 5067 under the plaintiffs' exclusive Khatian No. 12268. On 01.06.2005, KDA published an advertisement for the allotment of plot Nos. 36 to 40. Plaintiffs contend that above designated plots unlawfully encompass their 0.1632 acres land. Consequently, the plaintiffs filed a suit for permanent injunction to protect their interest.
28Defendants (KDA) contested the suit by filing a written statement but failed to produce any evidence to support their claim that the land fell within the acquired 64 decimals.
29At trial, the plaintiffs examined four witnesses including Advocate Commissioner (PW 1 to PW 4). Documents produced and proved by the plaintiffs were marked as Exhibits 1 to 7 (series).
30On consideration of the facts, circumstances and evidence on record, the learned trial Court decreed the suit, restraining the defendants from allotting plot Nos. 36 to 40 (Schedule-Kha) until a formal demarcation of the suit land is conducted.
31Being aggrieved by above judgment and decree, defendant No.1 as appellant filed Title Appeal No. 225 of 2011 in the Court of the District Judge, Khulna which was transferred to the 2nd Court of the Joint District Judge, Khulna who allowed the appeal and set aside the judgment and decree of trial Court and dismissed the suit.
32Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and decree of Title Appeal No. 225 of 2011, the plaintiffs as the petitioners moved to this Court with this Revisional Application under section 115(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 and obtained the present Rule.
33No one appears on behalf of the petitioners, despite the matter being fixed for hearing and the names of the learned advocate appearing in the daily cause list for several consecutive days.
34On the other hand, the learned Advocate, Ms. Sayeda Shoukat Ara, appearing on behalf of the Opposite Party No.1, Chairman of the Khulna Development Authority (KDA), Khulna, submits that KDA
acquired 64 decimals land vide L.A. Case No.2/1976-1977 from the plaintiff’s predecessor and subsequently merged this land with other non-suited land to develop residential and commercial plots. She further asserted that being in peaceful possession KDA was allotting above plots through tender process and did not possess any land beyond what was legally acquired. She maintained that the land designated as plot Nos. 36 to 40 did not belong to the plaintiffs. Finally, she relied upon the judgment and decree passed by the Court of appeal below in Title Appeal No.225 of 2011.
35I have considered the submissions of the learned Advocate for the opposite parties and have carefully examined the impugned judgment and decree passed by the learned Joint District Judge, 2nd Court, Khulna as well as all other materials on record.
36The underlying suit seeks permanent injunction to restrain the defendants from transferring plot Nos. 36 to 40 (described in 'Schedule-Kha'). These plots are situated within the plaintiff’s larger landholding described in 'Schedule-Ka'. Plaintiffs contend that the defendants unlawfully amalgamated a western portion of the plaintiffs' land adjacent to the road side into their own acquired holdings. This encroachment was originally recorded under DP Khatian No. 44 (Plot No. 5067). Plaintiffs successfully challenged this erroneous entry in Objection Case No. 3666. Consequently, 0.1632 acres within Plot No. 5067 was extracted and recorded in the plaintiffs’ names under a separate and distinct Khatian No. 12268. It is admitted that the defendants hold title to 0.64 acres, while the plaintiffs hold absolute title to the 0.1632 acres.
37Plaintiff while giving evidence as PW 1 stated that while the Government acquired the land for the Khulna Development Authority (KDA), the KDA subsequently demarcated plot Nos. 36 to 40 on that acquired land. He admitted that they were in possession of this area previously; KDA currently maintains possession in above plots. PW 2, PW 3 & PW 4 corroborated the testimony of PW 1, admitting that KDA is in possession of the land of plot Nos. 36 to 40. PW 4 Mr. Pronob Kanto Golder, Advocate Commissioner provided technical evidence, stating unequivocally that plot Nos. 36 to 40 overlap with and are included within the 0.1632 acres of land under Khatian No.12268, which is fully owned by the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs could not prove their possession.
38In the case of Ahsanul Haq -vs- Md. Abdul Ahad reported in 11 ALR (AD) 82, held that “The plaintiff have admitted they are not in exclusive possession in entire suit land so they are not entitle to get decree of permanent injunction for the entire land.”
39Upon a thorough review of the facts and circumstances of the instant case, I am of the view that the learned Judge of the trial Court delivered the judgment and decree without a comprehensive examination of the plaint and the materials on record. Consequently, several "core facts" essential to the proper adjudication of the dispute were either ignored or overlooked. These include: The actual possession of the land at the time of the suit. The specific schedule of the property as delineated in the pleadings. The legal sanctity and conclusive value of the DP khatian, particularly those resulting from Objection Case No. 3666 or orders passed by the Settlement Officer.
40In Title Appeal No.225 of 2011, the Court of appeal below, despite being the final Court of fact reversed the judgment and decree without properly reviewing the plaint or the impugned judgment, thereby committing an error of law. Specifically, the learned Court of appeal below erred in holding that:
41"Since the KDA has included the plaintiff's 0.1632
42acres within Plots 36-40, granting a permanent
43injunction against the defendant’s Tender Notice
44would be contrary to the National Interest. In this
45instance, individual interest must not take
46precedence over the National Interest."
47This reasoning suggests that permanent injunction against KDA tender notification is "hostile" to the state, even if it concerns the rightful ownership of 0.1632 acres. Notably, the trial Court did not stay the entire tender notification; it merely restrained the defendants from allotting plot Nos.36 to 40 (as specified in Schedule-Kha) until the suit land could be properly demarcated.
48Plaintiffs, in their prayer for permanent injunction, erroneously included two distinct schedules without providing a singular, cohesive identification of the suit land. Crucially, plaintiffs failed to identify the property through a Gazette-published survey khatian or officially gazetted plot numbers with clearly defined boundaries. In this instance, schedule-kha describes the KDA’s internal plot Nos. 36 to
4940. These are administrative demarcations rather than "finally published" survey plots recognized by the government. A court cannot legally grant permanent injunction to restrain an authority from
allotting its own internal plots unless a "line in the sand" a precise boundary is established through recognized survey records.
50Plaintiffs’ reliance on a DP (Draft Publication) khatian or a khatian resulting from an Objection Case is legally misplaced. Under established land laws, a khatian carries no presumptive value regarding title until it has undergone final publication and is officially notified vide Gazette.
51No specific boundaries were provided to substantiate the plaintiffs' claim of possession. Instead of defining their own boundaries, the plaintiffs relied on the negative assertion that KDA had never conducted a formal demarcation of its internal plots.
52In the case of Sarhab Ali Molla -vs- Md. Farid Master reported in 29 BLC (AD) 185, held that “The plaintiff had to prove his case in order to get the decree prayed for, in no way the burden can be shifted over the defendants to do so.”
53The trial Court committed a material irregularity by shifting the burden of proof. Rather than requiring the plaintiffs to prove their prime facie title and possession, the court focused on identifying perceived "loopholes" in the defendants' (KDA) case.
54While the Court of appeal below correctly reversed the trial Court’s decree, it reached its conclusion based on findings that are arguably irrelevant and contrary to law. An injunction granted over internal administrative plots (Schedule-Kha) without a finally published khatian to support the plaintiffs' title, constitutes an illegal exercise of judicial discretion. An injunction cannot be granted over
property that is not defined by "metes and bounds" or recognized survey plots.
55The suit for permanent injunction is found to be improperly filed due to lack of description and proof of possession, demarcation, missing of boundaries in the plaints and reliance on non-finalized khatians.
56In above view of the facts and circumstances of the case and materials on record, I am unable to find any substance in this Civil Revision and the Rule issued in this behalf is liable to be discharged.
57Accordingly, the Rule is discharged. The order of stay granted earlier by this Court is hereby recalled and vacated.
58However, there is no order as to costs.
59Let a copy of this judgment, along with the Lower Court Records (LCR), be sent to the concerned court immediately.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











